ARE THESE A DUPE?

As a self-proclaimed beauty enthusiast always seeking the best value, I was SO excited to put these two lip products head-to-head: the much-hyped Fenty Gloss Bomb Stix in Icy Amethyst and the surprisingly affordable Wet N Wild x Spongebob lip oil in 'I Wumbo, You Wumbo'. With a significant price difference of $25 vs $6.50, the burning question is: is the Wet N Wild truly a dupe for the Fenty Gloss Bomb Stix? Let's dive into my honest findings! First, let's talk about the Fenty Gloss Bomb Stix. I picked up 'Icy Amethyst' because I adore a cool-toned, high-shine lip, and this shade delivers! It's a gorgeous, slightly iridescent lavender-pink that gives your lips a plump, juicy look without feeling sticky whatsoever. The stick format is super convenient for on-the-go application, and it glides on like a dream. The shimmer is subtle but catches the light beautifully, making it a fantastic statement piece that’s also versatile enough for everyday wear. The feel is cushiony and hydrating, making it comfortable for hours. Now, onto the contender: the Wet N Wild x Spongebob lip oil in 'I Wumbo, You Wumbo'. Straight away, the packaging is fun and playful. When I first swatched it, I was cautiously optimistic. The shade 'I Wumbo, You Wumbo' is a sheer, cool-toned pink with a delicate sparkle, very reminiscent of the Fenty 'Icy Amethyst'. The texture is definitely more of a traditional lip oil – it feels nourishing and slick, but not overly greasy. It also has that lovely high-shine gloss effect that I look for in a good lip product. I was impressed by how comfortable it felt on my lips right from the first application. So, how do they compare? Let's break it down: Shade & Shine: Both products offer a similar cool-toned, shimmery pink hue. The Fenty 'Icy Amethyst' might have slightly more noticeable sparkle, but the Wet N Wild 'I Wumbo, You Wumbo' still gives a beautiful, glossy finish with subtle shimmer. For a 'gloss bomb stix high-shine gloss stick' dupe, the Wet N Wild holds its own surprisingly well in terms of visual impact. Texture & Feel: This is where I noticed some differences. The Fenty Stix has a unique balm-like, cushiony feel – it's a solid stick that melts onto the lips. The Wet N Wild, being a lip oil, feels lighter and more liquid, but still very comfortable and hydrating. Neither is sticky, which is a huge win in my book! Longevity: I found the Fenty Stix to last a bit longer on my lips, probably due to its slightly thicker, balm-like consistency. The Wet N Wild lip oil, while lovely, required a bit more frequent reapplication, especially after eating or drinking. However, for a $6.50 product, its wear time is still respectable. Value: This is the big one! For less than a quarter of the price of the Fenty, the Wet N Wild offers a very compelling alternative. While not an exact 1:1 replica in terms of formula (one is a stick, the other an oil), the overall aesthetic and glossy, comfortable wear are remarkably similar. If you're looking for a 'Fenty Icy Amethyst dupe' or a general 'Fenty lip oil dupe' without breaking the bank, the Wet N Wild is an excellent contender. In conclusion, while the Fenty Gloss Bomb Stix in 'Icy Amethyst' remains a personal favorite for its unique texture and slightly longer wear, the Wet N Wild x Spongebob lip oil in 'I Wumbo, You Wumbo' is an incredible budget-friendly option. It captures the essence of the Fenty glow and cool-toned shimmer beautifully. If you want to save some cash but still achieve a similar high-shine, comfortable lip look, definitely give the Wet N Wild a try! It's a fantastic way to enjoy that trendy glossy lip without the premium price tag. For me, it's definitely a viable dupe for the overall look and feel, making it a smart choice for those prioritizing value.