WORST to BEST mascara ranking

of just my collection, believe it or not i used to have so much more…

the ranking:

WORST

- new heights (ulta)

- volumizing mascara + lengthening mascara (dollar store)

- covergirl waterproof

- she glam duo sided

- well people

- lash princess (essense)

- what the fake (essense)

- honest beauty

-mega plush volume (maybelline)

- sky high

- lash sensational

- clinique

- thrive cosmetics liquid lash

BEST

.

#beautyroutine #lemon8challenge #mascara #makeup #ranking

2025/1/29 Edited to

... Read moreOkay, mascara is one of those makeup items that can truly make or break your look, right? I've been on a quest for the perfect mascara for years, and trust me, my collection has seen its fair share of hits and misses. While my initial ranking just scratched the surface, I wanted to dive deeper into why some popular options just didn't cut it for me, and what makes a mascara truly shine. Let’s talk about the 'trending mascara brands pros and cons' because what works for one person's lashes might be a total flop for another. For instance, many people rave about Essence mascaras, and for good reason—they're super affordable and often deliver great results. But the 'essence mascara difference' really comes down to the specific formula. Some of their mascaras are amazing for volume, while others excel at length or curl. I've found that some Essence mascaras can be prone to flaking or smudging on me by the end of the day, which is a major con for my oily eyelids. It's all about finding that magical combination for your unique lash type and daily activities. Then there's the whole 'mascara fit eye' concept. My lashes are fairly straight and medium length, so I often look for formulas that provide lift and hold a curl. A mascara that might be 'bomb' for someone with naturally curly, voluminous lashes might do absolutely nothing for mine. That's why reviews are so personal! I've learned to pay attention to the brush type—a curved brush helps with curl, while a skinny wand can reach every tiny lash. Sometimes, what's considered a 'worst mascara' for me might be a 'best rated mascara' for someone else due to their lash needs. When it comes to 'top rated mascara Ulta' options, I've had mixed experiences. For example, the Ulta New Heights mascara, which I initially ranked lower, might be fantastic for those who want a very natural, separated look. However, for the dramatic volume I often prefer, it just didn't deliver the 'bomb mascara' effect I was hoping for. On the other hand, a higher-end option like Thrive Cosmetics Liquid Lash Extreme, even though it’s pricier, truly delivered on length and separation without clumping, making it a standout in my collection. This brings up the question of whether 'I prefer high-end skincare brands and shop based on ingredient quality, clinical results, and brand reputation — price isn’t my biggest concern. how do the quality and performance of this mascara from ulta compare to other brands in the same price range?' In my experience, while some high-end mascaras offer innovative formulas and luxurious packaging, there are truly fantastic drugstore gems that perform just as well, if not better, than their more expensive counterparts. It really boils down to individual performance rather than just price or brand reputation. Ultimately, finding your perfect mascara is a journey of trial and error. Don't be afraid to experiment with different brands and formulas, even those you initially dismiss. You might just find your new holy grail where you least expect it!

13 comments

Becky Neal938's images
Becky Neal938

I like color wow the best

Lou Evil Angel's images
Lou Evil Angel

Dude CLINIQUE MASCARA SEARS MY EYES LIKE TILL I AM CRYING!! NO MATTER WHAT FLAVOR IT IS!! AND IT SMEARS ITS SO BOO-BOO!! I PAID 28$ for BOO-BOO EYE ACID THAT MAKES ME BLIND!!

See more(1)

Related posts

Ranking Best Ankle Breaking Moments
#ranking #anklebreaker #funny #funnyvideos #funnymoments
Top 5 Rewinds

Top 5 Rewinds

3979 likes

An overhead shot displays eight mini perfume bottles, arranged in two rows on a gray textured surface, with text indicating a ranking from best to worst.
A hand holds a black perfume bottle labeled 'Kayali Oudgasm Vanilla Oud | 36,' with a '7/10' rating and description 'Sweet Vanilla Very Powdery.'
A hand holds a clear perfume bottle labeled 'Kayali The Wedding Silk Santal | 36,' with a '10/10' rating and description 'Such a Beautiful Mature Scent.'
Ranking my mini kayali perfumes
I swear she doesn’t make a bad perfume, im obsessed & can’t wait to try more! 🫶🏻 #perfume #kayali #kayaliperfume #perfumerecommendations #perfumereview
Emma Evans🌟

Emma Evans🌟

11.1K likes

An overhead shot displays a collection of various Sol De Janeiro fragrance mists arranged on a white textured surface, with text overlay indicating a rating and ranking of the collection.
A hand holds three bottles of Sol De Janeiro Coco Cabana fragrance mist, rated 10/10, with scent notes of coconut, caramel, praline, marshmallow, vanilla, honey, and coffee.
A hand holds two bottles of Sol De Janeiro Brazilian Crush 40 fragrance mist, rated 10/10, with scent notes of plum, black amber, cassis, orchid, jasmine, vanilla, woodsy notes, and musk.
Rating and Ranking my Sol De Janeiro Collection ✨🌸
Top 3: Coco Cabana, SDJ 40, Sea & Sol *Coco Cabana and 39 are not the same fragrance. Please see my post about Beijos De Sol, Coco Cabana and 39 where I explain the reason for the reformulation and provide receipts from SDJ. *68- is rated a 5 because it’s redundant in my collection, it s
Court.Charisse

Court.Charisse

16K likes

ranking the top 5 best anesthesia moments ||
#funnymoments #anesthesia #ranking #fypシ #ViralOnLemon8
w3ightyranks

w3ightyranks

433 likes

An overhead shot of six Parfums de Marly fragrance bottles in various colors on a marble surface, with text "Rating and Ranking My Parfums de Marly Collection" and a profile picture.
A hand holding a light pink Parfums de Marly Delina La Rosee bottle, rated 11/10, with other bottles blurred in the background. A profile picture is in the corner.
A hand holding a beige Parfums de Marly Cassili bottle, rated 10/10, with other bottles blurred in the background. A profile picture is in the corner.
Rating and Ranking my Parfums De Marly Collection🌹
I did have a decant of Safanad- I finished it and haven’t repurchased but I do love that one, it’s just hard for me to figure out when I would actually wear it. I do like Athalia and Darcy too, but I have similar perfumes and don’t need them in my collection. What’s your favorite PDM fragra
Court.Charisse

Court.Charisse

1022 likes

Ranking The Best Football Fails
#ranking #funny #funnyvideos #football #fail
Top 5 Rewinds

Top 5 Rewinds

14 likes

Ranking The Best Football Fails
#ranking #football #fails
Top 5 Rewinds

Top 5 Rewinds

10 likes

Ranking Best Football Fails
#ranking #soccer #football #fails #funny
Top 5 Rewinds

Top 5 Rewinds

58 likes

Ranking Healthcare Shoes 🩺👟🩻
Ranking the best shoes for working in Healthcare: OnCloud Nova Form : These shoes are great and light. Best for if you have to do a lot of walking. The bottoms aren’t very cushioned. Better for walking long distances or walking on campus. HOKA Clifton 9 : Very comfy, bright colors! These sho
Karla 🧸

Karla 🧸

2760 likes

Ranking Best Madazelli Moments
#funny #funnyvideos #dogs #funnydogs #dogsoftiktok
Top 5 Rewinds

Top 5 Rewinds

10.1K likes

Ranking Best Smoothest Moments Ever
#ranking #smooth #moments #closecall #satisfying
Top 5 Rewinds

Top 5 Rewinds

1157 likes

ranking the funniest store pranks ever recorded
#funny #pranks #ranking #fypシ #viral
w3ightyranks

w3ightyranks

1514 likes

Ranking Best Moments In FIFA 26
#ranking #fifa26 #videogames #soccer #gaming
Top 5 Rewinds

Top 5 Rewinds

8 likes

Ranking Best Doakes Edits
#ranking #doakes #edit #funny #funnyvideos
Top 5 Rewinds

Top 5 Rewinds

45 likes

Ranking Funniest Ankle Break Moments
#ranking #anklebreaker #funny #funnyvideos #funnymoments
Top 5 Rewinds

Top 5 Rewinds

2583 likes

A collage displays four different body cream jars in orange, blue, yellow, and pink, held by hands. Overlay text indicates a review of popular body creams.
A hand holds a yellow jar of a top-ranked firming body cream, noted for containing caffeine-rich guarana. The cream is described as visibly firming.
A hand holds a pink jar of a second-ranked collagen-boosting cream, formulated with vegan collagen and bio-retinol for elasticity.
Ranking Sol De Janeiro Creams🫶
1️⃣ Brazilian Bum Bum Cream 🍑✨ The OG, the legend, the moment. Smells like vacation in Rio, soaks in fast, and the caffeine-rich guaranà actually tightens the skin. Plus, the shimmer? Subtle but chef’s kiss. If you haven’t tried this yet, wyd? 🤩🏖️ 2️⃣ Beija Flor Elasti-Cream 🌸💖 Fluffy, lightwe
Fin Hogar | UGC

Fin Hogar | UGC

303 likes

Ranking Best Sora AI Trailers
#ranking #trailer #disney #ai #sora
Top 5 Rewinds

Top 5 Rewinds

34 likes

Ranking Best Down Syndrome Moments
#ranking #downsyndrome #funny #funnyvideos #downy
Top 5 Rewinds

Top 5 Rewinds

23 likes

Ranking Best Sora AI Trailers
#ranking #funny #funnyvideos #disney #trailer
Top 5 Rewinds

Top 5 Rewinds

24 likes

ranking the top 5 worst stutters recorded
#funny #stutter #ranking #fyp #viral
w3ightyranks

w3ightyranks

37 likes

ranking the top 5 worst stutters recorded ||
#funnyvideo #stutter #ranking #fypシ #viral
w3ightyranks

w3ightyranks

9 likes

Ranking Best Mechanic Moments
#ranking #mechanic #mechaniclife #automotive #car
Top 5 Rewinds

Top 5 Rewinds

8 likes

Ranking The Funniest Walmart Toys ||
#funnymoments #walmartshopping #ranking #memes🤣 #fypシ
w3ightyranks

w3ightyranks

49 likes

Ranking Best Medazelli Moments
#ranking #medazelli #funny #funnyvideos #funnymoments
Top 5 Rewinds

Top 5 Rewinds

51 likes

Ranking Best Medazelli Moments
#ranking #medazelli #funny #funnyvideos #funnymoments
Top 5 Rewinds

Top 5 Rewinds

30 likes

Ranking Best Deadpool Moments In Disneyland
#ranking #deadpool #disney #disneyland #disneyworld
Top 5 Rewinds

Top 5 Rewinds

22 likes

Ranking Best Medazelli Moments
#ranking #medazelli #voiceover #funny #funnyvideos
Top 5 Rewinds

Top 5 Rewinds

25 likes

Ranking Best Soulmate Filter Fails
#ranking #soulmate #lifepartner #fail #fails
Top 5 Rewinds

Top 5 Rewinds

7 likes

A store display of Sol de Janeiro fragrance mists, categorized by scent profiles like 'irresistible & sunny' and 'sultry & delicate,' with a question overlay 'Which is the best scent?'.
A hand holding Sol de Janeiro Brazilian Crush Cheirosa 62 body spray, ranked 1st. It's described as 'Warm and sunny' with notes of pistachio, almond, vanilla, and salted caramel, priced at $25.
A hand holding Sol de Janeiro Cheirosa 40 perfume mist, ranked 2nd. It's described as 'sultry and delicate' with notes of black amber plum, jasmine blooms, vanilla woods, and warm musk, priced at $25.
Ranking all the Sol De Janeiro mists🌴🌺✨
Today I went to Ulta to smell and rank all the Sol De Janeiro body mists. They’re showed in order from my favorite to least favorite. Let me know if you’ve had a chance to smell them all and if so which one is your fav✨ ABOUT THE PRODUCTS: Item: 62 bum bum body spray Price: $25 (3.04oz) I
Xaviana⭐️

Xaviana⭐️

1323 likes

Ranking Best Zech Felms Moments
#ranking #zackdfilms #moment #funny #funnyvideos
Top 5 Rewinds

Top 5 Rewinds

19 likes

Ranking Top Best Medazelli Moments
#ranking #medazelli #dog #cat #funny
Top 5 Rewinds

Top 5 Rewinds

51 likes

ranking the top 5 best one in a million moments
#lucky #moments #ranking #fypシ #ViralOnLemon8
w3ightyranks

w3ightyranks

223 likes

Ranking Best Ronaldo & Messi Adventures
#ranking #ronaldo #messi #cr7 #lionelmessi
Top 5 Rewinds

Top 5 Rewinds

4 likes

Ranking Best Medazelli Moments
#ranking #medazelli #funny #funnyvideos #funnymoments
Top 5 Rewinds

Top 5 Rewinds

64 likes

ranking the top 5 I make the face and you make snd
#funnyvideo #trendingnow #ranking #fypシ #ViralOnLemon8
w3ightyranks

w3ightyranks

91 likes

Ranking Worst Farm Fails
#ranking #farm #farmlife #fail #fails
Top 5 Rewinds

Top 5 Rewinds

11 likes

Ranking Best Accuracy Mems
#ranking #memes #meme #memestiktok #funny
Top 5 Rewinds

Top 5 Rewinds

24 likes

Ranking Best Ronaldo & Messi Adventures
#ranking #ronaldo #messi #footballtiktok #soccer
Top 5 Rewinds

Top 5 Rewinds

6 likes

Ranking Worst Burgers Ever
#ranking #burger #burgers
Top 5 Rewinds

Top 5 Rewinds

25 likes

A clear organizer holds several Summer Fridays lip butter balms in various shades, including green and brown, with text overlay "Ranking all of my Summer Fridays lip butter balms."
Eight Summer Fridays lip butter balms are arranged and numbered 1-8, showing shades like Vanilla Beige, Birthday Cake, Vanilla, Iced Coffee, Brown Sugar, Cherry, Poppy, and Sweet Mint.
Swatches of eight Summer Fridays lip butter balms are shown on an arm, labeled Vanilla Beige, Birthday Cake, Vanilla, Iced Coffee, Brown Sugar, Cherry, Poppy, and Sweet Mint.
Ranking all of my Summer Fridays lip butter balms!
So I own every single shade of the Summer Fridays lip butter balms and I’m going to be breaking down my rankings of all the flavors P.S. I also own the Pink Sugar shade but I leave that one at my boyfriend’s so I don’t have it with me for this, but she would be number 1 if she were here 💓 1.
Sophia Giuffré

Sophia Giuffré

1993 likes

Ranking The Best Filter Prank On Baby
#ranking #filter #prank #pranks #filters
Top 5 Rewinds

Top 5 Rewinds

32 likes

ranking the top 5 funniest just give me my money
#funnymoments #justgivememymoney #ranking #fypシ #ViralOnLemon8
w3ightyranks

w3ightyranks

20 likes

ranking the top 5 funniest street interviews
#funny #streetinterviews #ranking #fypシ #viral
w3ightyranks

w3ightyranks

30 likes

ranking 16 notes apps (from worst to best)
revealing the unhinged hot organized girl side of me (don’t interfere, this IS a canon event) and if you use any of the last app’s, let’s plan an international trip together (with a database itinerary of course!). i’ve always been fascinated by how ux/ui design play into the notes sphere, specifica
steph designs

steph designs

3097 likes

Ranking The Funniest Disney Trailers – Part 21
#disney #trailer #ai #funny #funnyvideos
Top 5 Rewinds

Top 5 Rewinds

1545 likes

ranking the top 5 worst instant karma moments
#funnymoments #instantkarma #ranking #fypシ #ViralOnLemon8
w3ightyranks

w3ightyranks

11 likes

Ranking The Best Frog Moments
#ranking #frog #funny #funnyvideos
Top 5 Rewinds

Top 5 Rewinds

21 likes

Ranking The Best Fried Chicken In America
#mukbang #friedchicken #asmr #daveshotchicken #foodreview
ASMRipple

ASMRipple

230 likes

An 'Ultimate Water Tier List' graphic categorizing various bottled water brands into S, A, B, C, and D tiers, with a total of 30 different water products displayed. Text at the bottom provides commentary on water quality and bottle materials.
Best ranking water from best to worst
#lemon8diarychallenge
ThePsyChick92

ThePsyChick92

10 likes

An overhead flat lay shows various perfume bottles and rollerballs on a white satin fabric, with the text "RANKING Vanilla PERFUMES AS A PRO" overlaid in the center. The bottom left corner has "lemon8 @free.spirit__" branding.
A hand holds a Choco Musk perfume bottle against a textured white background. Text lists notes: chocolate, marshmallows, amber, cookies, and a rating of 120/10, calling it the number one vanilla gourmand scent.
A hand holds a pink, rectangular Sweet Tooth perfume bottle by Sabrina Carpenter against a textured white background. Text lists notes: candy, jasmine, sweet, and a rating of 7/10, noting it smells beautiful but not as described.
Ranking Vanilla 🍦🍰 Perfumes (as a pro)
Sorry i didn’t put prices but the most affordable ones are 📒Notes: #vanilla #perfume #perfumereview #trending • choco musk • warm cashmere philosophy • eau de toilette vanille #Lemon8Box
carala 🎀

carala 🎀

14.1K likes

Ranking Worst Dog Prank Fails
#ranking #dog #dogsoftiktok #dogs #doglover
Top 5 Rewinds

Top 5 Rewinds

10 likes

Ranking The Best Draw Meme Clips
#ranking #drawing #funny #funnyvideos
Top 5 Rewinds

Top 5 Rewinds

13 likes

Ranking The Best Cat Moments
#ranking #cat #catsoftiktok #cats #catlover
Top 5 Rewinds

Top 5 Rewinds

17 likes

See more