... Read moreI recently hit pan (or rather, the end!) on my Maybelline SuperStay Ink Crayon, and I just had to share my thoughts in a full review. As you know from my quick rating, it scored an impressive 8/10 for me, and it's truly become one of my go-to lip products. If you're looking for a long-lasting lipstick crayon that delivers on its promises, keep reading!
What truly stands out about this product is the incredible pigment. The shade I owned, a beautiful dark red lipstick crayon, delivered rich, vibrant color in just one swipe. Seriously, the payoff is amazing! You don't need to layer it endlessly to get true-to-tube color. This deep pigment factor, coupled with its ease of application, makes it a winner in my book. The crayon format itself is fantastic – it allows for precise lining, almost like a lip liner, and then you can easily fill in your lips without needing a separate brush. It glides on smoothly, without tugging or skipping, which is a huge bonus, especially for a matte-finish product.
Speaking of finish, many of you might be wondering about the difference between the SuperStay Ink Crayon and the SuperStay Matte Ink Crayon. While both offer fantastic wear, the Ink Crayon tends to have a slightly more comfortable, less drying matte finish than its liquid counterpart. It’s still very much a matte, but I find it doesn't emphasize lip lines as much, and it feels lighter on the lips throughout the day. This comfort factor is a big part of why I keep reaching for it.
For those interested in swatches and finding the perfect shade, it’s worth noting that Maybelline offers a fantastic range. From nudes like 'Trust Your Gut' (which is a popular query!) to bolder shades and even the 'Lead The Way' swatch everyone talks about, there’s a color for every mood and occasion. My dark red shade, for instance, was perfect for both day and night, adding a touch of sophistication without being too overpowering. When trying to decide, I always recommend looking at online swatches but also trying to find in-store testers if possible, as lighting can make a big difference.
The 'SuperStay' claim isn't just marketing hype either. This lipstick crayon really does stay put for hours. I've worn it through meals and coffee, and while it might fade slightly in the very center of my lips after a greasy meal, the color largely remains intact. A quick touch-up is all you need, and because of its crayon shape, it’s super easy to reapply on the go without a mirror. The pointed tip helps maintain precision even after multiple uses, which is a clever design detail.
To get the best wear from your SuperStay Ink Crayon, I have a few personal tips. First, ensure your lips are well-exfoliated and moisturized before application. Even the smoothest matte can look patchy on dry lips. Second, for truly budge-proof wear, you can blot once after the first application and then apply a second thin layer. This technique often helps lock in the color even further. And if you want to experiment, you can even use a lighter shade in the center of your lips for a subtle ombre effect.
Overall, I heartily recommend the Maybelline SuperStay Ink Crayon line. It’s an affordable, high-performing lipstick crayon that delivers on color, comfort, and longevity. My 8/10 rating stands strong, and I'm definitely planning to repurchase and explore more shades!