... Read moreOkay, so let's dive a little deeper into the 19/99 Beauty Lash Tint Mascara, since I know so many of you are curious about it! When I first heard the buzz, I was genuinely excited. A lash tint that offers a natural, 'your lashes but better' look? Sign me up! I’m always on the hunt for mascaras that define without looking too heavy or clumpy, especially for my everyday makeup routine.
My experience, as you saw in my 'Bye' verdict, wasn't quite what I hoped for. The main issue for me was the consistency – it felt quite watery. This meant that each application didn't build much volume or length, and it took a while to dry down. For someone like me who often applies mascara quickly before heading out, waiting for it to set was a bit of a hassle. I found that if I blinked too soon, it would smudge slightly, which is definitely not ideal for a long-lasting look.
Another aspect that led to my 'Bye' decision was its performance on curling and longevity. My lashes tend to be fairly straight, so I rely on a good mascara to help hold a curl after I use an eyelash curler. Unfortunately, the 19/99 Lash Tint didn't provide much hold at all. Within an hour or two, my lashes had pretty much straightened out again, losing any lift they had. And throughout the day, I noticed it wasn't as long-lasting as some other formulas I’ve tried. I wasn't experiencing major flaking, but the definition and tint definitely seemed to fade, leaving my lashes looking less impactful than when I first applied it.
This makes me wonder: who is this mascara for? Perhaps it would work better for someone with naturally long and curly lashes who just wants a touch of color and definition without any added bulk. It might be perfect for those who prefer a truly minimalist look and have no issues with lash curl, or perhaps those who find traditional mascaras too heavy. If you have fine, short, or straight lashes like mine and are looking for a mascara to give a dramatic lift or significant volume, based on my experience, you might want to explore other options. The tiny bristles on the wand, similar to what I praised in the Maybelline Firework mascara, are designed for precision, but in this case, the formula just didn't back it up with performance.
For those still wanting a natural-looking lash tint effect, I’d strongly suggest looking into tubing mascaras. Brands like Thrive Causemetics or Caliray come to mind, as they often offer a similar defined, separated look but with much better longevity, curl hold, and virtually no smudging or flaking. Tubing mascaras encapsulate each lash in a polymer tube, which means they are usually much easier to remove with warm water and less prone to smudging throughout the day. While the 19/99 had beautiful, sleek packaging, and the concept was appealing, the execution for my lash type just didn't live up to the hype or its price point. It’s a reminder that what works for one person might not work for another, and sometimes, a viral product just isn't the right fit for your unique needs. Always check reviews from people with similar lash types to yours before committing! Don't forget there are so many amazing mascaras out there, so don't be afraid to keep experimenting until you find your perfect match!
I like that pink one better than the yellow one that brand has.