My spice rating scale for books

1/15 Edited to

... Read moreWhen it comes to picking out books, especially those with romantic or spicy elements, having a clear guideline on spice levels can truly enhance the reading experience. My spice rating scale breaks down books into categories ranging from no spice, focusing mostly on plot, to all spice with just a touch of storyline. For example, a rating of 1-2 indicates only a scene or two with some slow-burn spice—great for readers who prefer romantic tension without too much heat. Ratings of 3-4 include more frequent spicy scenes, often found in reverse harem or multifaceted romance novels where character dynamics play a big role. A balanced 50/50 spice-to-plot ratio appeals to those who want a strong storyline intertwined with romance. At the higher end of the scale, books are predominantly spicy with just a dash of plot to support the passionate scenes, catering to readers looking primarily for intense romance and chemistry. This system helps book lovers quickly find reads that match their comfort level and desired escapism. In my personal experience, having such a scale is invaluable, especially when recommending books to friends or selecting a novel during different moods. If I want a story that teases and builds romantic tension gradually, I stick to 1-2 ratings. But for those times when I crave a full-on steamy read with a side of plot, I dive into ratings 4 and above. Applying this approach not only makes picking books easier but also enriches my reading by aligning expectations and enjoyment. Overall, whether you're a fan of slow-burn romances or all-out spicy stories, using a personalized spice scale like this adds fun and clarity to your reading list. It’s all about finding the perfect recipe for your ideal book experience.

Related posts

A hand holds several books, with text overlay 'ENEMIES TO LOVERS BOOKS' and a chili pepper emoji, indicating a list of romance novels. The Lemon8 logo and username are visible at the bottom.
The book 'Powerless' by Lauren Roberts is shown, highlighted with keywords like 'FANTASY ROMANCE', 'FORBIDDEN LOVE', 'ENEMIES TO LOVERS', and 'SLOW BURN', along with a summary of its plot.
The book 'A Court of Mist and Fury' by Sarah J. Maas is displayed, featuring keywords such as 'SECOND CHANCE', 'FANTASY', 'TRAUMA BONDING', and 'EMOTIONAL', accompanied by a plot summary.
Rating Viral Enemies to Lovers Books 🥵
🔥Looking for books with the enemies to lovers trope, but they REALLY hate each other?! You’ve found just the right post 👀 1️⃣ Powerless by Lauren Roberts After being forced to work for her sworn enemy, the powerful and ruthless CEO, a strong-willed woman finds herself entangled in a dangerous g
irianna

irianna

1248 likes

Book and spice rating
Chat gbt for the win! Gonna start using this to rate my books! #chatgbt #bookratingscale
LifeWithShell💜

LifeWithShell💜

4 likes

An open book titled 'Crooked Kingdom' by Leigh Bardugo, with another book behind it, illustrating the theme of 'books with tons of spice but with a good plot'. The open pages display text from the novel.
The book 'Eyes on Me' by Sara Cate, featuring green gemstones on the cover, is described with tropes like enemies to lovers, step siblings, spicy, and millionaire trope.
The book 'Sinner' by Sierra Simone, with pink roses on a black cover, is highlighted for its spicy content, playboy, friends with benefits to lovers, age gap, and little sister tropes.
books with tons of spice but with good plot
trapped with mr walker broke my heart but it’s one of my favorite books ever plus the spice is iconic af😫 #lemon8bookchallenge #lemon8bookclub #lemon8bookworm #book #booktok #bookaesthetic #booksoflemon8 #bookrecommendations #bookrecs
Readers.archive

Readers.archive

2218 likes

Rating twisted series honestly
Book review💜💜 king of sins series nexttt #twisted lies #twisted love #twistedhate #twisted games #twistedseries
Luv.Jen

Luv.Jen

472 likes

Rating books so you don’t have to🫶🏽
#read📚 #books 🫶🏼 #reading📖 #a book 😭 #reader
Brook🌺

Brook🌺

670 likes

Rating Murder Mystery Books
I recommend most of these books if you are looking for an entertaining but thrilling read! Follow me for more <3 #books #lemon8books #BookReview #booksoflemon8 #bookrecommendations #booklemon8
Florida_Girly

Florida_Girly

49 likes

Books I have read recently ! ✨
These are 9 books I have read recently. My favorite was : Beautiful Ugly ( I wish I could read it for the first time again ! ) Least Favorite : The Dead of Winter All were 3 stars or higher for me , on a rating scale 1-5 ⭐️ s. What are you currently reading ? #reading 📖 #📚book
👑💜

👑💜

6 likes

even more spicy books I need to read ASAP!!🌶️🖤
I am absolutely obsessed with a good, spicy, smutty, dark romance book and I keep buying more and more! The spicier, the better!!! 🌶️❤️‍🔥 My TBR is growing by the day and I seriously cannot get enough!! With that, here are a few more of the spiciest books on my physical to-be-read shelves and m
anika janelle🌿

anika janelle🌿

2013 likes

How I Rated Books Vs Goodreads
Here are my most recent reads : ) #booktok #goodreads #reading #bookrating
noelle nugnes

noelle nugnes

6 likes

A stack of books on a wooden surface with the pink and blue text overlay "ROMANCE BOOKS I WON'T STOP RECOMMENDING." Decorative stars and hearts are around the text, with the Lemon8 logo and username @mikalasreads at the bottom.
A hand holds the book "The Sun Is Also a Star" by Nicola Yoon. The cover features colorful abstract lines. Text overlays include "CREAT YA LOVE STORY" and "HE FALLS FIRST," highlighting its young adult romance theme.
A hand holds the book "Twisted Games" by Ana Huang. The white and gold cover shows the title and a crown. Text overlays read "PRINCESS/BODYGUARD LOVE STORY" and "CREAT SPICE!!!," indicating a spicy romance.
💗romance books I won't stop recommending💗
These are four romance books I will always be screaming from the rooftops for people to read! I have read so many books, and these love stories I cannot get out of my mind. The Sun is Also a Star: This is a young adult romance that has had my heart since the day I read it over a year ago! The tw
mikalasreads

mikalasreads

618 likes

Rating Books so YOU don’t have to | Sweet Romances
If you love stories that feel like healing and heartbreak all at once, these are for you. Four romances, each carrying a different heartbeat. Bridesmaid Undercover by Megan Quinn is sweet and sincere, proof that love can bloom where you least expect it. The Path to Loving Him, also by Megan
reagan westerly

reagan westerly

21 likes

A flat lay of four parenting books: How Toddlers Thrive, Raising Lions, The 5 Love Languages of Children, and Balanced and Barefoot, with the title "Rating parenting books From a second time mama."
The book "Balanced & Barefoot" by Angela J. Hanscom, rated 10/10, highlighting its focus on the importance of slow childhood and unrestricted outdoor play for children.
The book "Raising Lions: The Art of Compassionate Discipline" by Joe Newman, rated 8/10, emphasizing its real-life examples for disciplining strong-willed children.
Rating parenting books as a second time mom 🌟 ✨
I think it’s so easy to get lost in the sea of parenting books. There is a plethora of different styles and techniques of parenting. And sometimes it can be very overwhelming. So here is a few ratings on some popular parenting books. Balanced and barefoot 🌟 10/10 This is amazing for helping to
marycheyenne🕊️

marycheyenne🕊️

7 likes

A white bookshelf filled with various books, with pink text overlays reading "Rating my top 10 Books." A small decorated Christmas tree stands to the right.
The book cover for "Love on the Brain" by Ali Hazelwood, featuring an illustrated couple. Overlaid text describes it as a cute enemies-to-lovers story, rated #10.
The book cover for "The Cellar" by Natasha Preston, showing stairs with a pink flower. Overlaid text describes it as a good thriller/horror story with a good ending, rated #9.
Rating my top 10 books
My favorite books I’ve read! Book Review #books 🫶🏼 #favoriteread #lemon8bookclub #booklover
June

June

648 likes

Rating books that I’ve read so far
Shatter me- I really enjoyed it and bc of Warner The housemaid- I absolutely loved this book!!! I finished the whole thing in one day because it got straight to the point and the plot twist OMG. The perfect marriage- eh it was ok i love anything true crime but we just kept getting suspects m
Jessica Nosenko

Jessica Nosenko

118 likes

rating romance books (again!!)
you can’t let me into a bookstore and *not* expect me to beeline it to the little table displays they make?? these videos are my kryptonite!! the table was looking *fiiineee* today and i found a few that i have some slightly unpopular opinions on… which i think makes things more fun! what genre boo
emmalouisebooks

emmalouisebooks

89 likes

A young woman smiles at the camera, with text overlay "My personal Rating Scale For Books" and the Lemon8 logo with username @cheyannereadsbooks. The background is a warm-toned wooden wall.
My personal rating scale for books
Hey guys! I rate books almost like everyday on my account and even though I always share my personal opinions of the book on the post, I figured you guys should still know how I rate books here. So let me break it down!! ~ #chyreads #currentlyreading #BookReview #reviews #ra
Chy 📚

Chy 📚

5 likes

An overhead shot shows two children on a carpeted floor, with a stack of books held in the foreground. The image has a text overlay that reads, 'RATING PARENTING BOOKS I'VE READ'.
A hand holds the book 'The Happiest Toddler on the Block' by Harvey Karp, M.D. An overlay rates it 3/5 stars, stating the advice is better for younger toddlers (1-2) and some tips didn't work.
A hand holds the book 'Toddler Discipline for Every Age and Stage' by Aubrey Hargis. An overlay rates it 4/5 stars, describing it as an easy read with age-specific strategies for handling tantrums.
Rating PARENTING BOOKS I’ve read 📚
If you’re in your gentle parenting era, these books are total must-reads for toddler moms.💛 “The Whole-Brain Child” & “Tiny Humans, Big Emotions” completely changed the way I respond to tantrums. Both are a 5/5 stars in my book for helping me stay calm & connected.⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ “Toddl
Dania Toddler Mom & UGC

Dania Toddler Mom & UGC

30 likes

Rating Popular books with yes no or maybe
#readersoflemon8 #booktok #books #booksoflemon8 #bookrecs #bookrecommendations
Kaylaelaine

Kaylaelaine

403 likes

A vintage camera and record player overlay an autumn street scene with colorful trees. Text reads 'FALL BOOKS ON MY TBR' and 'SWIPE' with an arrow.
Six book covers are displayed under the title 'Books for HALLOWEEN'. Titles include 'Halloween Season', 'We Have Always Lived in the Castle', and 'The Haunting of Aveline Jones'.
Nine book covers are shown under the 'COZY HORROR' heading. Titles include 'A House with Good Bones', 'The Saturday Night Ghost Club', and 'Cackle'.
FALL BOOKS ON MY TBR
Different genres for all of fall, spooky,romance,etc. Classics as well. ⭐️ Rating:5/5 My Current Read 📖 Name of the Book: the bell jar -Sylvia plath
Madi.brooke

Madi.brooke

43 likes

Rating books from tiktok
I’m back with more booktok reviews!!! 💗💗💗 ✨Better than the movies by Linn Painter: one of my fave YA books. It has 90’s romcom vibes and felt like the song “paper rings” by Taylor Swift. it follows the characters Liz Buxbaum and Wes Bennett!! Who are both high schoolers & next door neighbor
bianca.rose

bianca.rose

533 likes

Three books, 'Love Redesigned,' 'Powerless,' and 'Promises and Pomegranates,' are displayed on a white textured surface, with pink text overlay stating 'how I rate my books.'
my book rating scale 🌟
this is how I rate my books! I also do a lot of .5’s in goodreads, therefore those get rounded up. if I have something rated a 3.5 it will show as a 4 star, but at the beginning of my review it will say “3.5 ⭐️s rounded up.” #lemon8bookclub #lemon8bookchallenge #books #book #boo
kalees reads

kalees reads

37 likes

A stack of horror books, including 'The September House', 'Leech', 'Dead Silence', 'The Troop', 'Parasite', 'Tender Is The Flesh', 'Where He Can't Find You', 'Uzumaki', and 'Mary', held by a person in a white sweater and black glove.
The book 'Where He Can't Find You' by Darcy Coates, rated 2.5/10 for body horror, with text indicating mostly intact bodies and the author's use of mannequins as horror.
The book 'Mary' by Nat Cassidy, rated 3/10 for body horror, with text describing some bodily unease and self-transformation, but nothing extreme.
VISCERAL HORROR:BODY HORROR INTENSITY SCALE📉➡️📈
⚠️The ratings are body horror based not overall for the book itself 🩸I keep forgetting Lemon8 only allows 10 photos. 🩸"The September House"...YOU be the judge. This one is personal for me. 🩸My scale maxes out at 9.5 rating. I know what a 10 would be and which book(genre). 🩸But I
⛓⛓YÉE⛓⛓

⛓⛓YÉE⛓⛓

80 likes

Rating books I’ve read recently✨
Just some of the books that I’ve read recently If you have any recs please drop them 👇 #readingrecommendations #lemondiary8challenge #favoriteread
Sanjile

Sanjile

33 likes

bookish star/spice rating system
heres my rating system! . . . #lemon8bookclub #lemon8bookclubchallenge #booktok #books #booksoflemon8 #BookReview #bookrecommendations #bookrecs #rating #stars
blimmi 🍂🤎📚

blimmi 🍂🤎📚

31 likes

Book recs based on my spice scale🌶️
Always check triggers before you read! As you can tell I prefer some spice in my books so I apologize there are not a ton of 1🌶️ recs Make sure you keep an eye out on my reviews I always include the 🌶️ ratings #lemon8bookclub #lemon8challenge #letschat #readersoflemon8 #spicesc
CanieshiaPowell

CanieshiaPowell

103 likes

Books I think you should read!!
#booktok #booksyoushouldread my ratings for each book/series: agggtm (a Good Girl's Guide To murder): RAVI IS MY HUSBAND. Loved the characters, story, and clues throughout the trilogy!⭐️Overall rating: 100000/10. five survive: I'll never forget that I read this all in one night. I
cloudy☁️

cloudy☁️

182 likes

The book cover for "The Killer Across the Table" by John Douglas and Mark Olshaker, an international bestseller about an ex-FBI agent interviewing serial killers. The cover features white and yellow text on a dark background, with a green chair and table visible.
The book cover for "Desperate Measures" by Katee Robert, featuring a golden snake design on a black background. The text describes it as a "Wicked Villains" series book, a reimagined Aladdin story where Jasmine ends up with a villain.
The book cover for "The Way I Used to Be" by Amber Smith, a New York Times bestseller. The cover features yellow dandelions and petals against a light blue background, with white text. The description mentions a girl's life changing after an event.
Books I've read and what they're about part 1
So I know these are very different books, but i was bored, and these were on my tbr. The first one is called The Killer Across the Table by John Douglas and Mark Olshaker: It was detailed, but sometimes I wish I knew EVERY detail ⭐️Overall rating: 3.5/5 The second one is called The Way I Use
Trinity 🫶🏼

Trinity 🫶🏼

9 likes

A vase of bright yellow sunflowers with the text overlay "Rating books I've read OUT OF 5 STARS (so far) in 2026" on a dark background, indicating a book review post.
A book cover for Mary Kubica's "It's Not Her" with a 5-star rating and bullet points describing it as fast-paced, with an unexpected twist, and multiple character perspectives.
A book cover for Freida McFadden's "The Gift" with a 3-star rating, noting it's a short story where characters aren't well-developed, but the plot twist was enjoyable.
Rating books I’ve read so far in 2026✨📖
Lots of Freida McFadden, I know. But I’ve read most of her books & I’m trying to expand my horizons. Comment good psychological thriller/mystery/horror recommendations for me to read! #BookReview #horrorbookrecommendations #thrillerbookrecommendations #bookrecommendations #booktok
Natalie

Natalie

22 likes

Rating the top 4 books by my fav author! 📚✨
Katherine Center is definitely one of my top favorite authors. She’s an automatic buy author for me and I have read almost every one of her books including her back log. I love that her book have no spice. They always have great character development and while they are considered romance there
Ashlie

Ashlie

11 likes

A book titled "Honey & Spice" by Bolu Babalola, featuring two illustrated figures on the cover, lies on a fluffy white and grey rug. The image has text overlays "My Honest BOOK REVIEW" and a "Reese's Book Club" sticker, indicating a book review.
Honey & Spice Book Review
For the month of April my book club read “Honey & Spice” by Bolu Babalola. I have seen so many reviews on this book and I went in with very high expectations for it and it did not disappoint! I really enjoyed this book and it was a great read. To me this book reminds me of the shows “Gro
Denny Price

Denny Price

57 likes

A hand holds two Emily Henry books, "Beach Read" and "Book Lovers," against a light wall with sunbeams. Text reads "rating every Emily Henry book I've read." Icons for books and reading are in the top right corner.
A hand holds Emily Henry's "Book Lovers" with a 4.5-star rating. Text describes it as "my personal fav!" and highlights "enemies to lovers," "small town romance," and being "for fans of 'The Proposal'."
A hand holds Emily Henry's "Beach Read" with a 4-star rating. Text says "really enjoyed! would recommend still" and mentions "grumpy sunshine dynamic," "complicated parent-child relationship," and "second chance romance."
rating Emily Henry books
Emily Henry’s next book “Funny Story” comes out in April this year so I thought I’d give my ratings on her books I’ve read so far! I’m not normally a romance reader but I do really love the way she writes dialogue and her female characters. Have you read any of these books? #lemon8partner #le
bookrvws

bookrvws

35 likes

Books I read this week📚
Rating: 4/5: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ The last trip: Kiersten Modglin delivers a wild, twist-filled thriller with The Last Trip. # Calvin and Sadie plan a peaceful babymoon at a remote mountain cabin, but their getaway quickly spirals into a nightmare. Strange behavior from the homeowners and shocking revela
Maddy.walls

Maddy.walls

45 likes

Rating Books I’ve read
Rating Books I’ve Read !📖 #books 🫶🏼 #reading📖 #lemon8bookclub #booksbooksbooks📚 #betterthanthemovies #TheFaultInOurStars #fivefeetapart #theinheritancegames #theinheritancegamesreview #thehawthornelegacy
Baylee🎀

Baylee🎀

57 likes

Rating Books I Read On My Kindle
Some noteworthy reads I’ve gone through over the past year during babysitting hours lol. I could talk about horror novels all day but there are very few that have ever really stuck with me over the many years I’ve spent searching and reading and searching again and reading more. Usually I go throug
The Mayor

The Mayor

11 likes

Rating books i’ve read this week pt.1
#books 🫶🏼 #recentbook #recentread #augustreadreview ⭐️Overall rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️ 3.5/5: The Seven Year Slip This book was super cute and fun, I just wish there was more to it. But, if you love a YA book that feels very warm, this is it. ⭐️ 1/5: The Priest This one just wasnt it fo
shay🪐🎧 📚🌷

shay🪐🎧 📚🌷

106 likes

All 4 Books are byMiley_cutey1 on Wattpad!
All books bymiley_cutey1 on Wattpad If you have any questions at all just let me know down below! ⭐️Overall rating: 5/5 🌶️Spice Level: 4/5 #wattpad #stalkerromancebooks #mafiaromancebooks #viral #wattpadcommunity WattpadRecomend #romance #romancebooks #mafiaromance #books
Miley Jones

Miley Jones

49 likes

Rating the books I’ve read recently!!!
These are just some of the books I’ve read recently If you have any suggestions PLEASE drop them below!!! 💕 #booktok #reading #rating #readingaesthetic #BookReview #bookwormsoflemon8 #booksoflemon8 #readersoflemon8
💕Syrena💕

💕Syrena💕

52 likes

📚these books deserve more hype!
Closed Door romance for the girlies who don’t read spice!✨ #romance ✨ #bookrecommendations #closed door romance #christianreads #2024readinggoals
Remi Spell

Remi Spell

205 likes

A stack of five Riley Sager books on a wooden bookshelf, including 'Final Girls', 'The Only One Left', 'Survive the Night', 'The House Across the Lake', and 'Middle of the Night'.
A hand holds Riley Sager's 'Final Girls' book, rated five stars. An overlay describes it as emotionally investing with an imperfect victim.
A hand holds Riley Sager's 'The Only One Left' book, rated five stars. An overlay praises its whodunnit plot with amazing twists.
Rating Riley Sager books I own 📚🫆🔍
I haven’t had a chance to buy or read With a Vengeance yet, but thought I’d do a author highlight post for one of my fave thriller authors, Riley Sager! I’ve throughly enjoyed all of his books, and he’s an insta-read author for me! Have you read any of these? Did you like them?? - #lemon
carmen 📚

carmen 📚

62 likes

rating books I’ve read
Reminders of him 5/5 Mile high 5/5 King of Wrath 3/5 Regretting you 5/5 Things We Never Got Over 4/5 Icebreakers 5/5 #books #collenhooverbooks #reading #kindleaesthetic #kindlepaperwhite #foryou #foryoupage
brooke!

brooke!

30 likes

Mafia Books Recommendations 📚
👍Why I like it: There’re easy to read with a very good amount of spice and a good plot. ⭐️Overall rating: Lorenzo… you have to read it. Love after loss is difficult and this book did not disappoint. This is the third book of a series 🫣 however you can read it as a standalone. ⭐️Overall rating
Xymis <3

Xymis <3

41 likes

Book Rating Scale
These ratings are based on my own personal scale. Obviously if you see ♾️ it means I need a book trophy and it’s now my identity.😜 QOTD: Do you review DNF books? I do not! #lemon8diarychallenge #booksmut #darkromance #morallygreymen #lemon8bookclubchallenge #lemon8darkromance
CanieshiaPowell

CanieshiaPowell

13 likes

A book cover for 'Caught Up' by Liz Tomforde, featuring an illustration of a family (a woman, a man, and a child) baking in a kitchen, is displayed on a dark blanket. A plate with three chocolate chip cookies rests beside the book. The image includes a 'BOOK REVIEW' overlay.
𝑹𝒂𝒕𝒊𝒏𝒈: 5 ⭐️
“𝑀𝑖𝑙𝑙𝑒𝑟, 𝑖𝑓 𝑦𝑜𝑢 𝑒𝑣𝑒𝑟 𝑑𝑒𝑐𝑖𝑑𝑒 𝑡𝑜 𝑠𝑡𝑜𝑝 𝑟𝑢𝑛𝑛𝑖𝑛𝑔 𝑎𝑛𝑑 𝑚𝑎𝑘𝑒 𝑎 𝘩𝑜𝑚𝑒…𝑚𝑎𝑘𝑒 𝑖𝑡 𝑤𝑖𝑡𝘩 𝑚𝑒.”😩 🚨SPOILERS🚨 Kai, Miller, and Max have my heart! OMG! This is my favorite out of the series so far. I knew the instant Miller hit the page and started calling Kai "baseball daddy" that I was gonna love th
Chey🩵

Chey🩵

789 likes

RATING BOOKS IVE READ THIS MONTH
#recentread #this book had me bawling #book #booktok #BookReview #boysoftommen #neverlie #hauntingadeline
shay🪐🎧 📚🌷

shay🪐🎧 📚🌷

22 likes

See more