“One by one”- Freida McFadden

2024/8/23 Edited to

... Read moreWhen I first picked up Freida McFadden's 'One by One,' I was genuinely excited. Her thrillers often promise nail-biting suspense and unexpected twists, and the striking cover – featuring that classic dark house aesthetic – definitely set a mood of eerie intrigue. People often wonder 'what is One by One by Freida McFadden about,' and for good reason! It's generally pitched as a psychological thriller that traps characters in a confined, tense situation, often with a killer lurking. You anticipate that signature Freida McFadden plot, where every character is a suspect and the secrets unravel slowly, leaving you guessing until the very last page. However, after diving into it, I found myself asking, 'was it worth the hype?' My honest take, as reflected in my two-star rating, is that it didn't quite hit the mark for me. While the premise sounded promising, with all the elements of a gripping 'one by one' style mystery, the execution felt a little flat. The plot, for all its potential, didn't quite build up the sustained tension I crave in a good thriller. I kept waiting for that jaw-dropping moment or that deeply unsettling revelation that Freida McFadden is known for, but it never fully materialized in a way that truly grabbed me. Many 'one by one Freida McFadden reviews' highlight her ability to craft unputdownable stories, but with this one, I struggled to stay engaged. There were certainly twists, as is typical for her work, but they felt somewhat predictable, lacking the depth and complexity that would have made them truly impactful. It felt like the characters were moving through the paces of a thriller rather than genuinely experiencing the escalating terror. For those looking for a comprehensive 'one by one book summary,' imagine a setup designed for maximum suspense – a group isolated, secrets surfacing, and danger closing in – but without the emotional payoff or the clever misdirection that makes a psychological thriller truly memorable. Even considering the 'freida mcfadden thriller book aesthetic' that draws so many readers in, the story behind the compelling dark house cover left me wanting more. I've enjoyed other books by her, so this was a bit of a surprise. If you're considering the 'one by one freida mcfadden audiobook,' I'd suggest checking out some more detailed reviews first to see if the pacing and narration might compensate for some of the plot's shortcomings, or if it might exacerbate them. Ultimately, while it has all the ingredients of a classic thriller, 'One by One' by Freida McFadden, in my personal opinion, just didn't deliver the intense, satisfying read I was hoping for. It's a quick read, but for me, it simply wasn't 'finished reading' with a sense of awe.

12 comments

Taylor💜's images
Taylor💜

This one wasn’t my favorite by here but I did enjoy it.

Happily Married 2024 ❤️'s images
Happily Married 2024 ❤️

Just finished it. Was definitely a good read!

Related posts

The book cover for Freida McFadden's novel 'One By One' features a dark, wooded scene with a house illuminated by a single glowing window. The title 'ONE BY ONE' is prominently displayed in white, with 'FREIDA McFADDEN' in yellow text below, along with 'NEW YORK TIMES BESTSELLING AUTHOR OF THE HOUSEMAID'.
ARC REVIEW 📚📚 One By One by Freida McFadden
I was granted the opportunity by Net Galley to read an advanced reader copy of Freida McFadden’s new book that released today! Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️.5 Okay, so first let’s say, who I thought was to blame WASNT the person to blame! 🤣 Ms. Freida sure knows how to make a reader point at every charact
_BrynnD

_BrynnD

7 likes

Freida Mcfadden Books I’ve Read
How many have you read?? #booktok #freidamcfadden #reading
noelle nugnes

noelle nugnes

137 likes

The book cover for 'One By One' by Freida McFadden is displayed, featuring a dark house with a glowing window. Overlays read 'Currently Reading' and a caption expressing excitement to start the book tonight, hoping it's unputdownable. A Lemon8 username is also visible.
CURRENTLY READING: ONE BY ONE FREIDA MCFADDEN ✨
I just finished The Locked Door by Freida Mcfadden about 20 minutes ago & on to the next hopefully unputdownable read!! I hear good things about this one & it sounds like an interesting plot, so we'll see how it goes. Starting it tonight after a quick snack break & hoping it's s
Sarah

Sarah

7 likes

A book review image featuring Freida McFadden's 'One By One' cover, depicting a dark cabin. Overlaid text highlights themes like marital troubles, lies, betrayal, anonymous POV, a huge plot twist, crazy ending, and a suspenseful read, with a Lemon8 watermark.
BOOk REVIEW: ONE BY ONE FREIDA MCFADDEN ✨
Y'all I honestly thought this would be your typical group of friends go to a cabin somewhere in the woods vibe, BUT...it was so much more!! There was marital troubles, cheating partners, people in the group constantly disappearing, occasional Anonymous POV. This one kept me guessing & secon
Sarah

Sarah

16 likes

The tenant by Freida McFadden
Book was ok I rate this3.5⭐️ It was interesting at first but idk how I feel about it. It took me so long to finish this.
C🩷

C🩷

52 likes

A cork board with photos, maps, and red string, resembling a detective's investigation board. Text overlays read 'FREIDA MCFADDEN Books' and 'For thriller fans'. A stack of thriller books by various authors, including Holly Jackson and Cara Hunter, is also visible.
A collage of four images featuring the book 'The Teacher' by Freida McFadden. The book is shown held by hands in different settings: by a pool, on an outdoor table, and alongside an apple and pencils.
A collage of four images showcasing the book 'The Ex' by Freida McFadden. The book is displayed in various arrangements, including with AirPods, eyeglasses, and on a wooden board with decorative beads and daisies.
Freida McFadden books for thriller fans 🩸
#thrillerbooks #freidamcfadden #thriller #murder mystery #book recommendations
Yami 📚🪱

Yami 📚🪱

120 likes

My Top 10 Freida McFadden Books 📚
not my usual content but this was highly requested for a while! 😁📚 #fyp #booktok #thriller
Michael🎀

Michael🎀

167 likes

A hand holds four books by author Freida McFadden: "The Housemaid," "The Teacher," "Never Lie," and "One By One." The image features text overlays "Freida McFadden" and "Is she worth the hype???", along with a Lemon8 watermark.
Ms. Freida McFadden!!! 📚✨
I’m excited to start reading her books!! I hear a good things about her! Which one should I start first???? Have you read her books??? are they worth the hype?!?! 📚 #books #book #booktok #bookwormsoflemon8 #BookReview #bookrecommendations #booksoflemon8 #blackgirlcreator #l
Dominique

Dominique

34 likes

Freida McFadden Did It AGAIN 👀
👀📚 Just finished The Intruder by Freida McFadden and… WOW. The twist?? The turns?? The absolute chaos?? I’m still picking my jaw up off the floor! 🤯 Every time I thought I had it figured out—nope, Freida threw me right back into panic mode. This book had me: 💀 side-eyeing every character 😱
jolieeggs_Books

jolieeggs_Books

161 likes

A promotional image for Freida McFadden's book 'The Divorce', featuring the book cover, a broken wedding ring, and text highlighting it as a psychological thriller with unexpected twists. It states, 'Some marriages end. This one starts a war.'
An image promoting 'The Divorce' with text about a seemingly perfect marriage, sudden divorce, and a secret. It shows a vase of pink flowers and a broken picture frame with a couple's silhouette, symbolizing a shattered relationship.
A promotional image for 'The Divorce' listing reasons to read it: shocking twists, unreliable narrators, high-stakes drama, and Freida McFadden at her best. A woman's silhouette is on the right against a pink background.
💔 BOOK REVIEW: The Divorce by Freida McFadden
💔 BOOK REVIEW: The Divorce by Freida McFadden Just when I thought I had everything figured out, Freida McFadden pulled the rug out from under me. What starts as a divorce quickly spirals into secrets, lies, and twists I genuinely didn’t see coming. Every time I thought I knew who to trust, th
Julie Jones

Julie Jones

1 like

A comprehensive checklist of Freida McFadden's books, categorized into Standalones, The Housemaid series, Dr. Jane McGill series, and Short stories. Many book covers feature green checkmarks, indicating they have been read.
✨Freida McFadden✨
Knocking out my Freida checklist! Dear Debbie is up next ! #freidamcfadden #booktok #bookrecs #books #suspensebook s
Amanduhhh

Amanduhhh

73 likes

Ward D by Freida McFadden
Honestly this is probably one of the best books I’ve read. If you like romance mixed with drama and mystery, this book is for you. This book is surrounds 1 night on a psych unit with two medical student and questionable patient and staff. I won’t spoil to much but this book with having you clinging
Kryssi b

Kryssi b

29 likes

A collage of Freida McFadden book covers with the text overlay "FREIDA MCFADDEN Book Ranking" in white, set against a dark background.
A hand holding Freida McFadden's book "The Teacher," rated 3.7 stars, with keywords including "Teacher & Student Relationship," "Cheating," and "A shoe obsession."
A hand holding Freida McFadden's book "The Locked Door," rated 3.9 stars, featuring keywords "Prominent Surgeon" and "Serial Killers."
Freida McFadden Book Rating 💡
Freida McFadden is literally my favorite Author! Her books are fast-paced and binge worthy 📚 #thecookbook #reading📖 #embracevulnerability #booksoflemon8 #books #reading #friedamcfadden #reading📚 #books #book
Katie May

Katie May

722 likes

The Boyfriend by Freida McFadden
finished The Boyfriend by Freida McFadden and honestly… every time i thought i almost figured it out, i was wrong 😵‍💫 fast paced, messy, suspicious men everywhere, and the ending had me staring at the wall for a minute! #freidamcfadden #theboyfriend #bookreview #thrillerbooks #book
MAK 🤍

MAK 🤍

46 likes

A book review image featuring the cover of 'One By One' by Freida McFadden, displayed on a wooden surface. The image includes 'BOOK REVIEW' text, five yellow stars, and a '10/10' rating, along with the Lemon8 logo and user handle.
One by One by Freida McFadden Review
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ OMG I read this book in 24 hrs it was so good and the storyline was jaw dropping. Another great book that had many jaw dropping moments and an ending that I never thought! Definitely a great read!! #BookReview #freidamcfadden #bookrecommendations #mustread #honestbookreview
Kara

Kara

3 likes

The Tenant by Freida McFadden
My next read, been really enjoying Freida McFadden lately one of my favorite . Stared this and I’m loving it.
C🩷

C🩷

11 likes

Freida McFadden Fan Club✨
I feel like I just hit the jackpot! Of course I decided to start off with The Housemaid series. But, the rest of them all sound so good! What other books from Freida I should read next? #thrillerbooks #freidamcfadden #booktok #lemon8bookclub #Lemon8Diary
Erica🌸

Erica🌸

89 likes

🔥 One of Freida McFadden’s Best Yet?
Freida McFadden did it again! Just when I thought I knew what was happening, another twist came out of nowhere. 😳💔 This book was impossible to put down—full of secrets, suspense, and characters that kept me guessing until the very end. I flew through it in one sitting and was left staring at the
BookmarksAndBodies

BookmarksAndBodies

11 likes

A red book titled "The Tenant" by Freida McFadden is displayed on a white fluffy blanket. The book cover features a hand holding a door slightly ajar with blood splatters. An overlay text reads "BOOK REVIEW" in a playful, outlined font.
Just finished The Tenant by Freida McFadden ⭐️⭐️⭐️/5
As someone who loves a good psychological thriller and was absolutely obsessed with The Housemaid, I had really high expectations for this one. It definitely had some twists and creepy moments, but overall it just didn’t hook me the same way. It took me a while to get through and I kept waiting for
emily🦋

emily🦋

10 likes

What’s YOUR favorite Freida McFadden book? 📚 👀
The twists, the chills, the jaw-drops... which one had you screaming?! #FreidaMcFadden #ThrillerBooks #booksoflemon8 #lemon8bookclub #viral
jolieeggs_Books

jolieeggs_Books

116 likes

Currently reading: ONE BY ONE by Freida McFadden
Isabel

Isabel

3 likes

Dear Debbie by Freida McFadden 🌸✂️
So far this book is really good . Almost done with it and I can’t put it down ⭐️Overall rating: 5/5
C🩷

C🩷

26 likes

The book cover for Freida McFadden's novel, 'Dear Debbie,' features a dark teal background. It shows two red poppy flowers and ornate gold scissors cutting a green stem. The author's name and book title are prominently displayed in white and bright green text.
Dear Debbie by Freida McFadden Review
Freida McFadden delivers yet another thrilling and addictive novel. From the very beginning, the story draws readers into the main character’s unreliable viewpoint. As the plot thickens with unexpected developments, the reader is left questioning which version of the truth to believe. Freida’s sign
Danielle Reedy

Danielle Reedy

59 likes

Newest obsession: Freida Mcfadden 📒💞
My newest obsession is Kindle Inserts! I have become a fan of Freida books. I have read like six and I am not stopping until I read all of them. But this kindle insert is perfect. Checklist of Freida Books 🤭 #kindleunlimited #kindleinsert #freidamcfaddenbooks #checklist #decor
Yessica🌱💕🐈‍⬛️🐕👧👧🧒

Yessica🌱💕🐈‍⬛️🐕👧👧🧒

32 likes

A hand holds the book 'Ward D' by USA Today Bestselling Author Freida McFadden, featuring a blue-toned tiled room with a chair on the cover. Text overlays read 'Current Read' and 'Goodreads Rating 4.02' with a star. The image also displays 'Lemon8 @thickthigh83'.
Ward D by Freida McFadden
I heard it’s good. -Val #reading #freidamcfadden #wardd #booktok #bookstagram #augusttbr
Holly Molly

Holly Molly

18 likes

My favorite book Freida McFadden⭐️
I read this books few months ago! This book was amazing !!! You would think you have it all figured out but you DONT! My favorite book from Freida ⭐️Overall rating: 5/5 #freidamcfadden #thrillerbooks #lemon8challenge #thrillerbookrecs #thrillerbookrecommendations
Thrillville

Thrillville

47 likes

A person holds the book 'Never Lie' by Freida McFadden, featuring a black tufted sofa against a white brick wall on its cover. A red heart-shaped bookmark is visible at the top, and a 'Currently Reading' text overlay is present. A Lemon8 watermark is at the bottom left.
Another Freida McFadden Read
I love her books, can put them down want to read one after another.-Val #currentlyreading #thrillerbooks #freidamcfadden #booktok #readingcommunity
Holly Molly

Holly Molly

46 likes

The Housemaid by Freida McFadden
This author is one of my top favs! This book definitely took some twist and turns. Beware: once you start you won’t be able to put it down! #pychologicalthrillers #BookTok #bookreview #freidamcfadden
jxcxlxns

jxcxlxns

14 likes

Got an ARC of The Intruder… by Freida McFadden🤯
🖤 The Intruder by Freida McFadden I don’t want to alarm you… but this book had me checking the locks. Twice. 😳 Freida McFadden does what she does best: drops you into chaos and dares you to stop reading. Spoiler alert: I didn’t. I’m fully locked in and can already tell this will be one of th
jolieeggs_Books

jolieeggs_Books

46 likes

A light green Tinkerbell mug with a beverage sits beside Freida McFadden's book, 'The Boyfriend.' The cover shows a red tie on a white background, with text asking 'Is he the man of your dreams or your worst nightmare?' A keyboard is visible in the background.
The Boyfriend by Freida McFadden
Everytime I swear off Freida I ended up reading another one. Here’s to hoping this one is ORIGINALLY good. 😉🫣👀 #iykyk #freidamcfadden #botm #readmorebooks #october #fall #lemon8bookclub
Maya Jay

Maya Jay

40 likes

A collage of autumn-themed images including fallen leaves, a bookshelf, a brick building, and a book, with the title 'Books by Freida McFadden that I LOVED.'
The book cover for 'The Teacher' by Freida McFadden, featuring a red apple with a knife stuck in it, against a dark background with a chalkboard effect.
The book cover for 'Never Lie' by Freida McFadden, showing a black tufted leather sofa against a white brick wall with the title in red letters.
Books by Freida McFadden that I LOVED.
1. The Teacher: I rate it ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️. It was everything and I read it in a day and a half! 2. Never Lie: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️. just trust me! Finished it in a day! 3. The Coworker: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️.5/⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️. I liked the suspense and psychological thriller part of it! I think it took me 3 d
Adriana

Adriana

63 likes

A stack of four Freida McFadden books, including 'Ward D', 'The Inmate', 'One by One', and 'The Perfect Son', displayed for a book review. The image has overlaid text 'My Honest BOOK REVIEW' and 'Lemon8 @a_velardi95'.
Freida McFadden Books 📕
I read these books earlier this year but I wanted to add them to my book reviews. The Perfect Son: it was almost clear it was not the son but for whatever reason I didn’t figure out who it really was even tho it was most likely blatantly obvious. Still, I liked the story. One by One: weirdly,
Ashley Velardi

Ashley Velardi

8 likes

The crash by Freida Mcfadden
I know alot of yall don't like Frieda but I DO! Sooo, for the one who like her and read her books, Is Freida gonna make me crash out or what?! Lmk bc i don't even think "The Teacher" wasn't even this thick. i actually believe “The Teacher” is just as thick! #damnthatsalotofb
Evy Evette🌙

Evy Evette🌙

24 likes

3 Books By Freida McFadden I Wouldn’t Recommend ❌
I love Freida! 📚💕! She rarely misses! But these weren’t it for me! 🥲 Have you read them? #lemon8bookclub #bookwormsoflemon8 #reading #bookrecommendations #freidamcfaddenbooks
Daneisha💕

Daneisha💕

71 likes

A close-up of an e-reader displaying the cover of Freida McFadden's new book, 'Dear Debbie.' The cover features a red poppy, ornate gold scissors cutting a green stem, and a vibrant green background. The author is noted as a #1 New York Times Bestselling Author.
New RELEASE Freida McFadden
Coming January 27, 2026 by Freida McFadden the title is called Dear Debbie!! It’s being called the revenge book! Let’s go! #freidamcfaddenbooks #newrelease #lemon8bookclub #thrillerbookrecommendations
Book_tude📚

Book_tude📚

180 likes

The Surrogate Mother by Freida McFadden✨🍋
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️Finished this book last night at 3:30 in the morning. It was really good. Just as the first book I ever read from her (the tenant) I was sucked in as soon as the plot twisted and I could not physically put the book down to save my ever loving life. I needed to know what happened. How it u
📚🖤Her🖤📚

📚🖤Her🖤📚

35 likes

Rating Freida McFadden thrillers
What is your favorite Freida McFadden book?? #thrillerreviews #freidamcfadden #bookreveiw
Yvonnie 🫶🏻

Yvonnie 🫶🏻

302 likes

Dear Debbie: by Freida McFadden
Dear Debbie by Freida McFadden is a sharp, emotionally charged thriller that pulled me in from the very first page. I really wanted to punch the daughter in the face, but I knew I had to keep reading , #thrillerbookreview The way my brain was constantly twisting terms and second-guessing every de
Lady Q 🧚

Lady Q 🧚

9 likes

A book cover for "The Wife Upstairs" by Freida McFadden, featuring a silhouette in a window. Overlaid text reads "Book Review," "Short Chapters," and "Shocking Plot Twist." The Lemon8 logo and username @fall_vibes_mama_tribes are visible at the bottom.
BOOK REVIEW: THE WIFE UPSTAIRS FREIDA MCFADDEN 📚
5/5 ⭐ I recently finished this book & y'all it was another great read by Freida Mcfadden. This book had me on edge from cover to cover, it was definitely unputdownable & kept me awake later than I should have been some nights haha. There were mostly short chapters & the shocking pl
Sarah

Sarah

14 likes

The image displays the book cover for "Dead Med" by Freida McFadden, featuring a stethoscope on a dark background with the text "Enroll at your own risk...". Below, it states "Finished on August 11, 2025", with a 100% completion status and a five-star rating. Other book covers are partially visible in the background.
Freida McFadden
I absolutely love Freida McFadden , the twist and turns and omg the suspense of truly not knowing what’s gonna happen is so good. I just finished reading dead med this month and I figured I’d rate my Top 5 favorite books by her! Number 5: Never lie This one has me absolutely flabbergasted whe
Rebeka

Rebeka

2 likes

A collage resembling a detective's corkboard with photos, documents, and red strings, featuring the text 'FREIDA MCFADDEN Books For thriller fans PART 3' and various thriller book titles.
Multiple images of the book cover for 'The Housemaid Is Watching' by Freida McFadden, showing a keyhole with a blue eye looking through it, on a distressed white background.
Multiple images of the book cover for 'The Gift' by Freida McFadden, featuring a red background with a wrapped gift box tied with a gold ribbon.
Freida McFadden books for thriller fans Part 3 🔪
#thrillernovel #murderbythebook #thrillerbooks #freidamcfadden #freidamcfaddenbooks
Yami 📚🪱

Yami 📚🪱

25 likes

The book cover for 'Want to Know a Secret?' by Freida McFadden. A knife blade is positioned vertically over a person's mouth, with pink lips visible. The title and author are prominently displayed in white and red text, respectively. A Lemon8 watermark is in the bottom left corner.
Want to Know a Secret?-Freida Mcfadden Review
I previously read the original version of Do You Want to Know a Secret?, so I was really excited to see this story revisited. Freida McFadden always hits the nail on the head when it comes to fast-paced, addictive thrillers, and this one is packed with tension from the start. The idea alone is uns
Danielle Reedy

Danielle Reedy

22 likes

A book cover for Freida McFadden's 'Never Lie' rests on a leopard print blanket. The cover features a black tufted sofa against a white brick wall, with the title 'NEVER LIE' in red and black. Text overlays read 'Freidadaaaa Girrrrrrl!!!' and 'I AM SHOOK'.
Freida McFadden will always do it for you!!!
When I tell you this book had me confused up until the last page!!! I give it a 10/10, Fredia’s writing is so engaging.. I love it. She catches your attention very early on. It’s very hard to put her books down. I thought I knew who it was, I was actually 95% sure. I WAS SO WRONG. The ending was
Jamilexxxxxx🫶🏼

Jamilexxxxxx🫶🏼

25 likes

Freida McFadden books are so addictive!
Freida McFadden books are so addictive, I can’t pick a favorite! 😱 Each one has a twist that leaves you shook. 🔥 The Housemaid, Do not disturb, Never Lie… all absolute page-turners! 📚 So, tell me: which one had you on the edge of your seat? 👀 #lemon8bookclub #FreidaMcFadden #thrillerbook
jolieeggs_Books

jolieeggs_Books

20 likes

A book cover for 'THE TENANT' by Freida McFadden, featuring a hand with a ring and blood splatters reaching from a slightly open pink door. Below the cover is a review stating the book was decent but not a favorite, with a surprising twist and a 7/10 rating.
The Tenant by Freida McFadden
Rate✨: 7/10 #freidamcfadden #thrillerbookrecommendations #booktok #reading
Nique

Nique

10 likes

A hand with red nail polish holds Freida McFadden's thriller novel, 'One By One'. The dark cover depicts a house with a lit window in a wooded setting. An overlay reads 'New thriller'.
New Freida McFadden thriller book!!! 🤩
Plot: A night spent sleeping on dirt and leaves is not how Claire Matchett expected to spend her vacation. She thought this would be a break from the stresses of work and raising her young children. A chance to repair her damaged marriage. A week of hiking and hot tubs with two other couple fr
Call me Tania⭐️

Call me Tania⭐️

11 likes

The Tenant, By Freida McFadden
If you have read this what are your thoughts??! #books #freidamcfadden #bookrecs
Yvonnie 🫶🏻

Yvonnie 🫶🏻

10 likes

See more