Crumbl Cookie 2024

Okay, so you've seen my quick ratings, but let me dive a little deeper into my recent Crumbl cookie haul! Getting that iconic pink box is always an experience, and this time, I was especially excited to try some of the newer flavors alongside a couple of classics. I even had my box ready for a quick photo op in the car! First up, that Snickerdoodle Cupcake cookie. Seriously, if you love snickerdoodles, you have to try this one. It’s not just a cookie; it genuinely has that moist, tender cupcake-like texture, topped with a creamy, perfectly spiced frosting. The cinnamon sugar coating on the cookie base is just right, not too overwhelming, and it perfectly complements the frosting. I often find snickerdoodle cookies can be a bit dry, but this one was incredibly soft and chewy. It’s definitely earned its 10/10 from me and is a strong contender for one of Crumbl's best creations. I usually pop mine in the microwave for 10-15 seconds to get that warm, gooey center, and it just elevates the whole experience. Then there was the Cinnamon Square. This one was interesting! It's essentially a soft, buttery cookie with a generous swirl of cinnamon filling and a sweet glaze on top. While it was good, it didn't quite hit the same highs as the Snickerdoodle Cupcake for me, hence the 5/10. It felt a bit simpler, almost like a really good cinnamon roll in cookie form, but I was looking for something a bit more complex. If you're a fan of classic cinnamon flavors without too many frills, you might enjoy it more than I did. It’s a comforting cookie, especially with a cup of coffee. The White Chocolate Raspberry Cheesecake was another one I was looking forward to. This cookie features a rich, dense base with a beautiful swirl of raspberry and a cheesecake-style frosting. The tartness of the raspberry cuts through the sweetness of the white chocolate and the cookie base really well. It's a solid choice if you're into fruity and creamy desserts, and the presentation with the distinct layers was lovely. My 6/10 rating for this one really comes down to personal preference; I prefer a more pronounced cheesecake tang, but it's undoubtedly a well-made cookie. Finally, the Holiday Confetti. This one was a bit of a wildcard for me. It's a sugar cookie base loaded with colorful sprinkles and a vanilla frosting. While festive and visually appealing in the box, I found it to be a pretty standard sugar cookie. There wasn't anything that truly made it stand out, which is why it landed at a 3/10 for me. It’s a fun, cheerful cookie, great for kids or if you just want something straightforward, but it didn't offer the unique flavor profile that Crumbl often excels at. Overall, my Crumbl cookie box experience this time around was a mixed bag, but those Snickerdoodle Cupcake cookies alone made the trip worth it! It’s always fun to see what new flavors they roll out each week. What are your favorite Crumbl cookies that I should try next?