"As It Was" by Elle Rivers masterfully explores the warmth and complexities that come with small-town romance, captivating readers who enjoy stories filled with rich emotional nuances. The grumpy/sunshine trope creates an engaging dynamic between characters, balancing tension and affection in a way that feels authentic and compelling. What sets this story apart is the found family element, which is beautifully portrayed through a protagonist who has taken on a paternal role, caring for his nephew and evolving into a single dad-like figure. Forced proximity – sharing a house – intensifies the relationship's development, offering ample opportunities for both conflict and tenderness, which contribute deeply to character growth. The narrative delicately touches on themes of loss and healing, particularly through the nephew's reflections on his parents, revealing how relationships of chosen family can provide support and belonging when biological ties falter. Readers will resonate with these heartfelt moments, especially the scenes where the protagonist is recognized by others as a parental figure, underscoring the impact of love and responsibility beyond traditional boundaries. This novel also highlights the importance of understanding and addressing emotional scars from childhood, fostering empathy and connection. For fans of contemporary romance with strong emotional layers and realistic portrayals of family dynamics, "As It Was" offers an enriching reading experience. By weaving together familiar romantic tropes with unique personal challenges, Elle Rivers invites readers to reflect on the meaning of family and the transformative power of love in everyday life.