🥀IF ONLY I HAD TOLD HER🥀 ✨Book Review✨

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️.75

The Story/Plot Was Really Good..

A YA Book About

Finny, Jack, Autumn; 3 Teenagers Navigating Life, Tragedy, Grief, Motherhood, Depression, Death, 1st Loves, Friendship, Maturity, College, Family, Appreciation…

It Was An Emotional Story . I Loved It. The Only Reason I Give It 4.75⭐️ Is Because Finny’s Story Was All About His Obsession With Autumn .. lol

#lemon8books #reading📖 #booklovers #lauranowlin

2025/12/9 Edited to

... Read moreAfter diving deep into Laura Nowlin's 'If Only I Had Told Her,' I wanted to share a few more insights, especially for those of you who, like me, often have questions beyond a quick review. This book left such an impression, and I've seen many readers curious about its details, from its place in the literary world to its suitability for different age groups. First off, a common question I get is: Is 'If Only I Had Told Her' part of a series? Technically, it's a standalone novel, but it's often considered a companion to Laura Nowlin's other beloved book, 'If He Had Been With Me.' While they tell a complete story independently, reading both offers a unique perspective on the same events and characters, particularly from Autumn's point of view in 'If He Had Been With Me.' So, you don't need to read one to understand the other, but they certainly enrich each other if you choose to explore both! For those wondering what the book is truly about, beyond the initial plot hints, 'If Only I Had Told Her' delves into the intricate lives of Finny, Jack, and Autumn. It's a story that masterfully explores the complexities of first love, friendship, loyalty, and the devastating impact of grief and loss. The characters navigate their adolescent years, facing profound challenges like depression, family struggles, and the daunting path to maturity and college. It’s a raw and honest portrayal of how past decisions ripple through future relationships and how unspoken feelings can shape destinies. The emotional depth is truly what makes this YA novel stand out. Speaking of standing out, many of you might be intrigued by the collector's edition. I've seen the stunning collector's edition cover of Laura Nowlin's YA book 'If Only I Had Told Her,' and it’s truly a work of art. The light blue cover often features beautiful illustrations – I particularly love how it depicts elements like windows, an open book, red roses, hearts, cleats, a soccer ball, and an umbrella, all resting on a patterned blanket. These visual cues subtly hint at the story's themes and characters, making it a wonderful piece for any book lover's shelf. Beyond the special editions, the book is widely available in paperback and digital formats, making it accessible for everyone. Finally, a crucial point for many parents and younger readers is the age rating and appropriateness for 13-year-olds. While it's a YA book, 'If Only I Had Told Her' tackles very mature and heavy themes including death, grief, depression, and complex romantic relationships. These are handled with sensitivity, but they can be intense. For a 13-year-old, it might be an emotional read, and some of the themes could be challenging. I'd personally recommend it more for mature teens (14+) or with parental guidance for younger readers, depending on their emotional readiness. It's definitely a book that sparks important conversations, which can be a valuable experience for families to share.

2 comments

ella:)'s images
ella:)

This sounds like such an emotional read! I'm adding it to my TBR list. What was your favorite part of Finny's story?

See more(1)

Related posts

A hand holds the book 'If Only I Had Told Her' by Laura Nowlin, featuring a red rose on the cover. Overlays include 'Book Review', 'His POV', 'Friends to lovers', and a three-star rating, all on a light-colored bedsheet background.
Book Review: If Only I Had Told Her
You guyssss! I randomly decided to read if he had been with me two weeks ago and zoomed through it in two days without knowing there was a second on the way! Obviously I had to grab it to read Finnys - I’m half way through and right now I’m preferring the first over this. Thoughts? 📖🥀 #Lemon8Di
MarySylvia Fain

MarySylvia Fain

220 likes

If Only I Had Told Her book review.
I read the first book which was good. Had to read the second book, which was really hard for me to pick up. I had this book for a month now and almost DNF. I pushed through and finish. It was okay. Too slow for me. Did you read this book? What’s your opinion #booktok #BookReview #laurano
DenisexoBueno

DenisexoBueno

2 likes

A hand holds the book 'If Only I Had Told Her' by Laura Nowlin, featuring a red rose on its cover, against a white hexagonal bookshelf filled with books. The image has a large orange 'BOOK REVIEW' overlay.
A book review graphic for 'If Only I Had Told Her' by Laura Nowlin, showing the book cover, title, author, and a positive review highlighting multiple character perspectives and emotional depth.
A book rating guide with five rows of stars, each corresponding to a different level of reader engagement, from 'unfinished' to 'occupies my thoughts long after reading'.
If Only I Had Told Her | ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Synopsis: If Only I Had Told Her revisits the story of If He Had Been With Me, this time through multiple perspectives. The novel gives readers Finn’s point of view leading up to the tragedy, followed by Autumn’s and Jack’s perspectives in the aftermath. Through these voices, the story explores gri
cerisevape

cerisevape

26 likes

A close-up of a book cover titled "if only i had told her" by Laura Nowlin, featuring a red rose with a stem and leaves. An overlay reads "My thought" and "lemon8 @lustunique", indicating a personal book review.
My Thoughts : “if only I had told her”
This book gives us everyone’s pov which is cool. I love how they brought in Jack. It is a pretty emotional story. (No crying, over here though 😂) The passion the characters have for each other is on par 🫶🏽. I’m sad how the main characters were oblivious😞. Because things could’ve took a different tu
neka lashay

neka lashay

9 likes

Book Review Pt. 1📖
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️.5 : I loved the plot line in this book! The overall story is VERY easy to follow! Lots of emotions, family/friend drama, high school journey, love and heartbreak. Short chapters (which I love) and it was hard to put this book down! I definitely recommend this book! Can’t wait to read the s
🩵Shelbs🩵

🩵Shelbs🩵

12 likes

A collage featuring the book cover for 'If Only I Had Told Her' by Laura Nowlin, which shows a red rose and stem. The collage also includes romantic and melancholic imagery, such as couples kissing, red roses, a ghost figure, and the quote 'sometimes sad things are beautiful' by Laura Nowlin, reflecting the book's themes of love and loss. The bottom left corner includes the Lemon8 logo and username @brittsbook_shelf.
If Only I Had Told Her- Review
Book Review: If Only I Had Told Her ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5) This book was an emotional whirlwind from start to finish. After reading the first installment, I spent days mourning and processing what had happened, so I knew that diving into Finn’s perspective would be nothing short of devastating—and it was,
Little Crow 🐦‍⬛

Little Crow 🐦‍⬛

4 likes

A hand holds the red cover of the book "If Only I Had Told Her" by Laura Nowlin, featuring a rose illustration and a "Barnes & Noble Exclusive" sticker. Text overlays indicate "My Thoughts: If Only I Had Told Her" and "Rating: 5/5". Bookshelves filled with various books are in the background.
My Thoughts on If Only I Had Told Her 💔📝
My Thoughts on If Only I Had Told Her by Laura Nowlin💓📝 📖 Name of the Book: If Only I had Told Her 📖 Genre: Young Adult, Romance 📄 My Favorite Quotes: “Whatever our souls are made of, hers and mine are the same.” 💭 My Thoughts: I’d recommend this duo-logy to everyone (both the first boo
nicole

nicole

7 likes

A book review graphic featuring the cover of "If Only I Had Told Her" by Laura Nowlin, which shows a red rose and stem. Text overlays read "MY HONEST", "Rating: 4/5", and "BOOK REVIEW", with a red background and white heart accents.
🍋Book Review🍋 If Only I Had Told Her
Short Summary: The sequel book to If He Had Been With Me starts at Finn's narrative three days before his death. He explores the progress of his unrequited love for best friend Autumn up until the day he finally expresses his feelings. Finn's story ends with his tragic death, which leaves h
Nancy Baten

Nancy Baten

6 likes

A book review featuring two books by Laura Nowlin: 'If He Had Been With Me' and 'If Only I Had Told Her'. A bouquet of red roses with gold crowns is next to them, labeled with 'School setting', 'Romance subplot', and 'Found family'. A Goodreads rating of 4.5/5 is also shown.
Book Review : If he had been with me
Book Review Book name: if he had been with me Author: Laura Nowlin Genre: young adult My rating: 4.5 /5 💰Price: 10.99 at Barnes and Noble My review: What I think about this book it’s good in point of view of Autumn one of the main characters. The setting is high school drama . It’s a fr
Ashley

Ashley

8 likes

A book titled 'if only i had told her' by Laura Nowlin, featuring a red rose on its cover, is centered on a background of scattered book pages. A large number '5' and a yellow star are superimposed.
if only I had told her
#booklemon8 #booklemon #bookreview #sadbooks #yabooks #Lemon8Diary #readingjournal
Christina 🫶📚

Christina 🫶📚

2 likes

Book review : if he had been with me
Book Review Book name: If he had been with me Author: Laura Nowlin Genre: Fiction My rating: 5/5 ⭐️ #lemon8bookclub #honestbookreview #bookrrview #bookrecommendations #BookReview
Cynthia

Cynthia

17 likes

A book review for 'If Only I Had Told Her' by Laura Nowlin, featuring a 3-star rating and the comment 'Cute but didn't need it.' The book cover with a red rose is shown, alongside quotes like 'We're just being close one last time' and 'If only I'd told her that I loved her years ago.'
If only I had told her..
I could have went without reading this part of the story. I like reading Finns chapters, but should have stopped there. Kind of feel like i wasted a coiple days reading. Overall ⭐️⭐️⭐️ If only l'd told her that I loved her years ago, then I wouldn't be here now. Finn has always loved Aut
💜Wendy Nicole💛

💜Wendy Nicole💛

1 like

A book titled "If Only I Had Told Her" by Laura Nowlin, featuring a red rose on its cover, rests on a patterned fabric. Overlays describe it as "HEART BREAKING," covering "DEPRESSION/GRIEF" and "TRANSITION TO ADULTHOOD," with "LOVE IT!" and "sad" emojis.
my honest book review
if only i had told her is one of the very few books that made me cry. the first book is called “if he had been with me”, it is also a very sad book. but this book… this book makes u feel like the grief the characters are feeling are your own feelings too. it is a roller coaster but is one of the be
mwaiwaiole7

mwaiwaiole7

9 likes

A collage featuring a central image of a red rose with text 'if only i had told her', surrounded by romantic and melancholic scenes like a vintage car, a sleeping person, a 'Lovers Ln' street sign, and a couple.
A collage showing a couple in a forest, a woman looking at a soccer field, and text asking 'How is it possible that two people could simultaneously seem to be both destined and not destined to be together?'
A collage with images of children, a woman in a car, and rose petals on a book, alongside text expressing deep devotion: 'My love for her is the closest thing I have to religion.'
Unconventional book review pt. 2
have said this once and i will say it again Finny Smith is a character that you cant help but to fall so deeply in love with. This book definitely had me on a rollercoaster of emotions but overall it is a great read! #ifonlyihadtoldher #roses #finnyandautumn #finnysmith #autumndavis
Inthebookment

Inthebookment

13 likes

A hand holds the book 'If He Had Been with Me' by Laura Nowlin, featuring a dark cover with two broken lollipops forming a heart. A pink text overlay reads 'Book Review: 10/10'.
Book Review:
If He Had Been with Me by: Laura Nowlin Personally, I absolutely adored this book.🫶🫶 The character development in this book is amazing. I felt like I grew to personally know the characters. Your favorite character will be Finny! It is definitely an easy read. WARNING: the ending is truly heart b
MattieGrace🩷🫶

MattieGrace🩷🫶

13 likes

A black collector's edition of "If He Had Been With Me" by Laura Nowlin stands upright, topped with a golden tiara. It rests on two other books, including "If Only I Had Told Her." The cover features red and white illustrations of windows, hearts, and books.
If He Had Been With me Book review ❤️
Author: Laura Nowlin Overall rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️- 4/5 Spice: 🌶️ Favorite Quote💭: “This book is a treasure; I did not suspect it would be so good when I picked it up, but now I can feel the printed words seeping through my skin and into my veins, rushing to my heart and marking it forever.” I p
Lily Tavares

Lily Tavares

32 likes

A book titled 'if he had been with me' by Laura Nowlin, featuring a dark cover with two lollipops, one broken, on a white textured surface. Overlays read 'BOOK REVIEW' and 'SWIPE'.
The book 'if he had been with me' by Laura Nowlin, with four yellow stars indicating a rating. An overlay describes the book as good but slow, with an impactful ending.
A dark screen displaying a quote from the book 'if he had been with me', with the sentence 'If he had been with me, everything would have been different.' highlighted in purple.
BOOK REVIEW 📖
if he had been with me by Laura Nowlin ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Will definitely be reading if only I had told her! This book is so good, I only gave it 4 stars because it took me a hot minute to get into it. It was just enough to keep me reading but the ending had me like 😦😭 Also put a quote from the book
oliviablack

oliviablack

11 likes

A book review graphic for "If Only I Had Told Her" by Laura Nowlin, featuring the title in black text and a broken red rose. It includes a "Book Review: 10/10" rating and states "SUCH A GOOD/SAD READ".
If Only I Had Told Her💋
This book was most definitely a tear jerker🥲🥲 I absolutely love Finny as a character. I enjoyed this book a lot more than the first one. I highly recommend reading this one if you’ve read If He Had Been With Me. I most definitely cried through the whole book😭😭 I LOVE this series so much!
MattieGrace🩷🫶

MattieGrace🩷🫶

3 likes

The book cover for 'If He Had Been With Me' by Laura Nowlin, a #1 New York Times bestseller, is shown on a wooden surface. The dark cover features white text and two heart-shaped lollipops, one broken. A Lemon8 watermark is visible.
Book Review 📕 4.5 ⭐️
The ending was a stab to my heart 💔!!!!!! I need to read; If only I had told her 📖 if he had been with me: by Laura Nowlin ♥️ 1# New York best seller ✨ Plot: Childhood best friends Autumn and Finn grow apart in high school, but a tragic event in August forces Autumn to reflect on their rel
Soniia

Soniia

8 likes

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Psychological Thriller Book Review
I’m a Therapist and My Patient Is Going to Be the Next School Shooter is a gripping and unsettling read that pulls you directly into the psychological mindscape of both patient and therapist. The format—told through a series of therapy files—makes it feel raw and clinical, as though you’re peeking
Kae

Kae

473 likes

A collage of various book covers, predominantly in black and white with red accents, featuring text overlays that read "Books I Hated" and "Book Review."
A hand holding the spines of several books, with a dark tapestry featuring skull and moon designs in the background.
A hand holding the light blue cover of "The American Roommate Experiment" by Elena Armas, against a dark tapestry background.
BOOK REVIEW (books I hated)
Some of these books are well loved, but I practically forced myself to finish them because they were so overhyped. I was hoping they would get better. The one that really let me down was Punk 57. I fell in love with PD after reading Birthday Girl. Ugly Love was the first and last book by CH I will
𝓜𝓮𝓵𝓲𝓼𝓼𝓪 𝓢𝓸𝓵𝓲𝓼

𝓜𝓮𝓵𝓲𝓼𝓼𝓪 𝓢𝓸𝓵𝓲𝓼

7 likes

if only i had told her by Laura Nowlin 📖
We get to see Finn’s perspective on what happened in 𝙄𝙛 𝙝𝙚 𝙝𝙖𝙙 𝙗𝙚𝙚𝙣 𝙬𝙞𝙩𝙝 𝙢𝙚, but also the messy and emotional aftermath. Star rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ I think the layout was well thought out. The book starts with Finn’s perspective up until his untimely death, then shifts to Jack’s point of view, g
Marianna 🤎

Marianna 🤎

5 likes

A hand holds the book 'The Last Thing He Told Me' by Laura Dave, with text overlays indicating 'My Honest BOOK REVIEW' and a 'Rating: 4/5'. The book cover highlights it as a #1 New York Times Bestseller and a Reese's Book Club pick, also available to stream on Apple TV+.
A hand holds 'The Last Thing He Told Me' book, showing a Goodreads rating of 3.85 and a personal rating of 4. Overlays describe the book as 'fast-paced but a little far-fetched', aligning with the review's mixed feelings.
The back cover of 'The Last Thing He Told Me' is displayed, featuring a summary of the mystery novel and author information for Laura Dave. An overlay prompts readers to 'read the caption for my full review!'.
the last thing he told me book review
i have some mixed feelings about this book! overall, i really did like it. it was fast-paced and kept my attention. but it was a little TOO far-fetched at some points. i get it, it’s fiction! it doesn’t HAVE to be realistic. but i just feel like some parts could have been thought out a little b
megan | sahm

megan | sahm

15 likes

A flat lay of multiple open books with Turkish text, featuring a central white overlay with "BOOK Review" and a downward arrow, indicating the start of a book review.
The book "if only i had told her" by Laura Nowlin, featuring a red rose on its cover, is displayed with text overlays indicating it's the second book, has 3 POVs, themes of death, suicide, car accident, teenage pregnancy, and provided closure, rated with two stars and two chili peppers.
A flat lay of open books with Turkish text, overlaid with quotes from the book: "Autumn- 'Finny was so proud of me,' I say." and "Jack- 'It's all done. Finn's Story is over.'".
Book Review
#ifhehadbeenwithme #ifonlyihadtoldher #lauranowlin #booksoflemon8 #books #reading #read #readersoflemon8 Overall this book was not that great. I fell in love with the first book. This book however didn’t really have the plot points the first book did. It was more for closure on
Aubrey

Aubrey

6 likes

A book titled "Powerless" by Lauren Roberts is displayed on a white quilted surface. Text overlays read "BOOK REVIEW!", "4.8/5", and "*page spoilers*". Decorative hearts and flowers are scattered around the book.
An open book shows the title page "POWERLESS" with colored tabs on the left page. The tabs are labeled with categories like "romance, love," "world building," "Kai," and "Paedyn." The text overlay says "My tab categories."
An open book displays pages 396 and 397 of "Powerless." Page 397 has a purple highlighted section and handwritten heart doodles in the margin, indicating a favorite passage.
Powerless Book Review! ✨🤍💚💜🏹🗡️🗝️
Author: Lauren Roberts Genre: romantasy My rating: 4.8/5 My review: Recently, I’ve only been reading romance, but I've been wanting to get into the fantasy world! My friend told me about how much she loved this book, because it was a mix of both genres, so I decided to give it a try. I am s
Abby

Abby

83 likes

Honest Book Review 🔮🌿✨
⭐️Overall rating: 4/5 I really enjoyed this book! It had a beautiful storyline, the characters were well thought out, the writing was poetic and immersive. I honestly don’t know why this book doesn’t get more hype because I thought it was really good! I wanted to give this book a 5 star rati
linds

linds

7 likes

The front cover of the book "Never Whistle at Night: An Indigenous Dark Fiction Anthology" features colorful, stylized illustrations of a snake, insects, and plants on a dark background. A pink banner with "Book Review!!!" is overlaid at the top.
Book Review!!!
Never Whistle at Night is an Indigenous Dark Fiction Anthology work by several Native American Authors. the settings of these stories are mostly modern with Native American lore. The book introduces ghosts, curses, hauntings, monstrous creatures, complex family legacies, desperate deeds and acts of
Kyodji2

Kyodji2

28 likes

Just Another Missing Person — BOOK REVIEW
I recently finished Just Another Missing Person by Gillian McAllister! This was my first book by this author. 🍋 A B O U T 🍋 The story, told from multiple POVs, follows a detective as they try to solve a missing person’s case. Only, the missing person walks into a dead end ally never to be seen
lexi :) :(

lexi :) :(

10 likes

Book review 5/5 stars
This may be her one of or her best book yet in her collection thus far 🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾 And if I didn’t have to work I probably would’ve finished in two and half days tops….. Even though the FMC in the book was getting on my nerves real bad 🙄🙄 I had a couple of theories at halfway to the finish l
💕✨TATIANA✨💕

💕✨TATIANA✨💕

5 likes

The book cover for Kristin Hannah's novel "Comfort & Joy" features a wreath of light-colored flowers and red berries. The title and author's name are centered on a white background, with "NEW YORK TIMES BESTSELLING AUTHOR" at the top. A Lemon8 watermark is at the bottom left.
Comfort & Joy Book Review
Comfort & Joy By: Kristen Hannah ⭐️Overall rating: 5/5: Kristen Hannah has done it again. The whole idea of this book is magical. I always thought that as a kid and for her to create a book about what I believed as a child is surreal. Highly recommend. “ in my mind and my memories, I ki
Marcel Morgen

Marcel Morgen

6 likes

See more