This is my first time trying Oakcha, and will be my last time. Or I just don’t like Dupes. But it does not spell good at all and Valentino born in Roma is one of my faves SO NOPE
3/24 Edited to
... Read moreMy first encounter with Oakcha Love in Rome was, to put it mildly, a significant letdown. As someone who absolutely adores Valentino Born in Roma, I went into this hoping for a budget-friendly alternative that could capture even a fraction of what I love about the original. Unfortunately, that wasn't my experience at all.
When you're searching for a 'dupe,' there's a certain expectation – you want something that closely mimics the original's scent profile, its longevity, and its overall feel. For me, the Valentino Born in Roma is a masterpiece: a beautiful blend of jasmine, bourbon vanilla, and woody notes, giving it a modern, elegant, and slightly edgy vibe. It's sophisticated, warm, and lasts beautifully on my skin. I was really hoping the OAKCHA LOVE IN ROME EXTRAIT DE PARFUM 50 ML would deliver something similar.
However, from the very first spray, Oakcha Love in Rome just didn't hit the mark for me. Instead of the rich, nuanced layers I adore in Born in Roma, I found it to be quite different. It lacked the depth and the smooth blend that makes the original so captivating. To my nose, it smelled… off. It didn't have that sparkling quality or the warm, inviting dry-down I’ve come to cherish. I noticed a distinct artificialness that sadly overshadowed any potential resemblance to the fragrance it was inspired by. It didn't "smell good at all" to me, and it definitely didn't have the same magical effect.
It’s truly fascinating how subjective fragrance can be. While my personal experience with Oakcha Love in Rome was disappointing, I've actually seen that this product boasts an impressive 4.6-star rating based on 3307 reviews! This really highlights that what doesn't resonate with one person can be a beloved scent for thousands of others. Perhaps it's a matter of skin chemistry, or maybe my expectations, as a devoted fan of Valentino Born in Roma, were simply too high. When you have such a strong connection to an original scent, finding a dupe that truly satisfies can be incredibly challenging.
For those considering the OAKCHA LOVE IN ROME EXTRAIT DE PARFUM, I'd suggest keeping an open mind. My advice for anyone looking into dupes is always to try them on your own skin if possible. What smells one way on a testing strip or on someone else, can evolve completely differently with your body chemistry. Read a variety of reviews, not just the glowing ones or the scathing ones, to get a balanced perspective. Understand that sometimes, the intricate balance and quality ingredients of a designer fragrance are incredibly difficult to replicate perfectly at a lower price point.
Ultimately, while I was hoping to find a new go-to, Oakcha Love in Rome just wasn't for me. If you're a die-hard fan of Valentino Born in Roma like I am, you might find yourself in a similar boat. But if you're curious and approach it as its own scent rather than a direct replacement, you might have a completely different and much more positive experience, just like those 3300+ reviewers did! For now, I'll stick to my beloved original.
I have three scents from Oakcha… they’re decent. I don’t own Love in Rome though.🤷🏽♀️