Delmonico’s: NYC’s Oldest and Top-Rated Steakhouse Since 1827

Beli App | Restaurant Lists

9192 followers

Follow

Follow

Follow

1 saved

9

NYC’s oldest steakhouse, and it’s still one of the top rated in the city on Beli 📍 Delmonico’s (FiDi, Manhattan) #nycsteakhouse #steakhouserestaurant #nycrestaurantreviews #steakhouse #nycrestaurants

2025/11/10 Edited to

Delmonico’s stands out as a true historic gem in the world of steakhouses, combining nearly two centuries of rich tradition with consistently high-quality dining experiences. Opened in 1827, it’s recognized as America’s oldest fine dining steakhouse—a title that brings with it a legacy of culinary excellence and cultural significance. What makes Delmonico’s unique is not just its age but its commitment to preserving the classic steakhouse atmosphere while serving exceptional dishes like the signature Delmonico ribeye steak. The ribeye, known for its marbling and flavor, is often highlighted by diners and critics alike as a prime example of expertly aged and prepared beef. Beyond steaks, the menu features a thoughtful array of American cuisine that reflects both historic and modern influences, drawing locals and food enthusiasts from around the world. The location in the Financial District (FiDi) adds to its appeal, offering a sophisticated and welcoming setting that blends well with the bustling city environment. Diners often comment on the charming vintage décor that pays homage to its long history, making every visit feel like a step back in time without sacrificing modern comforts. Reviews consistently praise the attentive service and well-curated wine list, which complements the hearty flavors of the food. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, Delmonico’s offers an authentic New York steakhouse experience that respects its heritage while meeting contemporary dining standards. For those interested in exploring NYC steakhouses, Delmonico’s remains a must-try destination, standing head and shoulders above many newer competitors due to its remarkable history and reputation. Its recognition on platforms like Beli and inclusion in top NYC restaurant review lists attest to its ongoing popularity and relevance in the city's vibrant dining scene. If you’re seeking a blend of historic charm, expert culinary skill, and a true piece of New York dining history, Delmonico’s is sure to exceed expectations. Don’t miss out on trying the legendary Delmonico ribeye during your next visit to Manhattan’s Financial District.

Related posts

A close-up overhead shot of sliced steak served on a dish with red and green sauces, topped with white crumbles. The image has overlay text that reads "steak entrees I'm drooling over in NYC."

A close-up of a grilled steak topped with a pat of herb butter, served alongside a metal cup of golden french fries. Overlay text identifies it as "steak frites" from "boucherie."

A dish featuring sliced steak with a fried egg on top, accompanied by a generous portion of french fries. The plate has a savory sauce. Overlay text labels it "bife à cavalo" from "berimbau."

NYC Steak Entrees I’m Drooling Over

I live for a good hearty meat dish, so here are some of the the best steak entrees I've eaten recently in NYC (believe it or not, none of these are steakhouses!): 1. Boucherie Union Square - Union Square: Steak Frites ($52) 10 oz Grass-fed NY strip steak, herb butter, pommes frites 9/10 - B

206 likes

A close-up of a perfectly cooked, sliced steak with a fork, displaying a pink interior. Overlay text reads 'top 14 nyc STEAKHOUSES ranked'.

A map of New York City showing various locations marked with numerical ratings, indicating steakhouse rankings. Text states 'based on over 100 million rankings on Beli'.

A collage of six dishes from Lucky's Soho, including bone-in ribeye, lobster mac, mac and cheese, and a cocktail, representing the 14th ranked steakhouse.

Top 14 steakhouses in NYC, ranked

Based on over 100 million ratings on Beli. Let us know what you think should’ve made the list! #nycsteakhouse #steakhouse #nycfoodie #steakdinner #nyceats

21 likes

Interior view of Skirt Steak NYC, a dimly lit restaurant with a long bar, stools, and spherical pendant lights, highlighting the $45 unlimited steak, fries, and salad offer.

A close-up of a table setting at Skirt Steak NYC, featuring a napkin, cutlery, an amber glass, and a brown paper placemat with 'STEAK HOUR' menu details, emphasizing the dim and quiet ambiance.

An overhead view of a dining table with two plates of green salad, a long plate of sliced garlic bread, and two cocktails, with a person's hands holding a phone, praising the dressing and garlic bread.

Skirt Steak, NYC📍$45

def going back, date night w hubs! 💋 #nyc #nycrestaurants #nycdatenight #fyp #travelwithme2024 Skirt Steak

281 likes

AYCE Seafood Restaurant in NYC 🦀🤤

If you’re in the mood for seafood, steak — you have to check out the Crabhouse in Times Square. It just opened in New York City and this place is HUGE. It’s beautiful inside and the food is phenomenal. It’s all you can eat, so the dishes just keep coming. We had crab, lobster, ribeye, Wagyu, fried

1356 likes

OLDEST STEAKHOUSE IN AMERICA! 🇺🇸

OLDEST STEAKHOUSE IN AMERICA! Delmonico’s has been in business since 1837! 🇺🇸 Name: Delmonico’s in New York City 📍 Fact: originator of the Delmonico Steak 56 Beaver St, New York, NY 10004 #delmonicossteakhouse #delmonicos #nycsteakhouse #nycfood #nyc

10 likes

Cool & unique museums in NYC

Next time you’re traveling to New York , check out some of these unique museums! New York Transit Museum Located in Brooklyn at a defunct train station, you can see over a century of New York City’s trains on display here! It’s cool walking through the old trains and seeing ads from that

602 likes

Drool-Worthy Steak Entrees in NYC

I am a red meat girly - here are some good steaks I’ve eaten recently (not at traditional steakhouses!) 1️⃣ Cathédrale Restaurant filet mignon ‘banquiere’ $69 - 8/10 so delicious and rec starting with the salade verte $21 10/10 2️⃣ Medium Rare a one choice prix fixe menu $35 for 2 rounds of s

519 likes

A luxurious spread of raw beef cuts, possibly A5 Wagyu and Aged Ribeye, presented on a wooden tray with black stones and fresh herbs, surrounded by various Korean side dishes.

An elaborate presentation of a tasting menu featuring fresh Red Magic Shrimp, Blue Point Oysters, a caviar tin, raw beef, and aged duck breast, served in a decorative box with smoke.

Perfectly cooked, cubed steak, possibly A5 Wagyu or Aged Ribeye, served on a dark plate with a vibrant yellow sauce and fresh dill, showcasing the quality of the meat.

A Must-Visit for Seafood & Steak Lovers in NYC!

Finally, I got to try the fresh Red Magic Shrimp at Anto Korean Steak House in NYC, a place I’ve been wanting to visit for a while. They’ve updated their tasting menu, and it includes some incredible items like aged duck breast, A5 Wagyu, and caviar—all of which did not disappoint! Here’s a brea

31 likes

$35 Steak Dinner

✨ Sometimes, simplicity is the ultimate sophistication. ✨ Let me put you on to Medium Rare, where they’ve mastered the art of keeping it simple and delicious. For just $35, you get a pre-fixe menu that’s all about steak and fries done RIGHT. Here’s the breakdown: 🥖 Start with artisan rustic b

112 likes

Interior of Argosy Book Store, showing shelves of books, display racks with old prints, and green-shaded lamps. A sign indicates "Art Books Old Prints $20 each," reflecting the store's offerings of art pages for framing.

A close-up of wooden bookshelves inside Argosy Book Store, filled with numerous antique books, many featuring leather bindings. A "We Can Do It!" poster is displayed on a lower shelf, adding to the vintage atmosphere.

A room within Argosy Book Store, showcasing a collection of framed old prints, maps, and artworks leaning against walls and stacked on the floor, suggesting an area for browsing unique art pages.

Oldest Bookstore in NYC

Argosy Book Store located on E 59th St, is New York City’s oldest independent bookseller. The store just celebrated its 100th birthday and is still run by the family that started it. Argosy Book Store This place has a special place in my heart, since this is the first bookstore I went wit

6 likes

The interior of a New York City steakhouse with a large chandelier, dining tables, and patrons, accompanied by the text 'NYC Steakhouse That You Can Skip'.

A bread basket containing slices of baguette and two small rolls with dark toppings, served on a white napkin, illustrating the cold bread mentioned in the review.

Two pieces of steak on a white plate, one cut open to show a very rare, raw-looking interior with a burnt exterior, captioned 'the comparison here'.

NYC Steakhouse That You Can Skip🥩🚩

Mark this post before you decide where to splurge. your wallet deserves better, your steak should too! 🥖 to start: bread came out cold - my fav part turned out to be instant red flag💔 🥩 fillet mignon- ordered medium, came out burnt on the outside but still raw inside. 💸 service felt mid for th

11 likes

A top-down view of four Thai dishes: Black Panther Curry, Tom Kha Ramen, Uni Wagyu Don, and a plate of stir-fried noodles, arranged on a wooden table.

A close-up, top-down view of four Thai dishes: Black Panther Curry, Tom Kha Ramen, Uni Wagyu Don, and a plate of stir-fried noodles, on a wooden table.

A close-up of Uni Wagyu Don, featuring wagyu beef, uni, ikura, and an egg yolk, with a bowl of Tom Kha Ramen blurred in the background.

Uni Heaven – My Go-To Thai Spot in NYC! 🍣🥩

My go-to spot for uni lovers! 💛🍣 I’ve been here so many times, and every time I bring a new bestie, they love it just as much as I do! ✨ Must-order: 🍚 Uni Wagyu Don ($40) – Pricey but SO worth it! Creamy uni + tender wagyu = pure happiness. 🥩 Black Panther Curry – Juicy steak over rich, flavor

629 likes

Oldest and Best Dim Sum in the U.S. is in Vegas

Nom Wah Tea House is a classic NYC Chinatown dumpling staple, believed to be the oldest and best Dim Sum in the United States. The family owned, authentic recipes are now available in Las Vegas at Rampart Resort bringing their legendary, fresh affordable Chinese food to Summerlin. Add this to your

56 likes

Day in the Life NYC Suite Owner//College student🎀

Surviving Business, School, Personal Care & Relationships Wouldn’t be wanting to do anything different 🥂 Ruth's Chris Steak House Fashion Institute of Technology SiStudio Suites

5 likes

places to visit in nyc! ✨🎀

#placestovisit #lemon8challenge Central Park – Start your NYC adventure in the serene beauty of Central Park, where you can escape the city hustle for a moment of calm. Stroll through winding paths, marvel at iconic landmarks like Bethesda Terrace, or find a quiet bench to people-watch and

16 likes

Spots in NYC for history lovers

If you’re a history lover you’ll want to save these historic spots in New York to visit during your trip! Dine at Fraunces Tavern & Visit the Fraunces Tavern Museum This is one of my favorite places to take people when they visit! This is the oldest tavern in NYC and was a crucial

219 likes

Most Viral Steak Frites in NYC

one of NYC's most viral dishes is BACK!

24 likes

THE CHEAPEST UNLIMITED KBBQ in NYC✨

🥩 AYCE KBBQ under $30👇🏼 💛 follow @casserolebites for more good eats & food recs in nyc! 🔖 save this and share with someone you want to eat here with 😋 💰PRICING: mon-thurs: lunch $25.95; dinner $31.95 fri-sun: all day $31.95 late night (after 10pm daily): $35.95 premium menu +$20

1571 likes

NYC Parks | My top 3

I love a good park. Even though many people visit for our museums and night life. New York has so much more to offer. As the weather begins heating up ( 🤞🏾) i certainly plan to spend more time outside. Here are my favorite parks to visit ⬇️ Van Cortlandt Park Yes I know it’s far but i

23 likes

A plate of steak frites with green sauce, a red drink, and bread on a white table, highlighting the $38 steak frites in New York.

A hand holding a Shirley Temple drink with ice and a cherry, with a green salad visible on a white tablecloth.

A close-up of a green salad topped with nuts, served on a white plate with a fork and knife on a white tablecloth.

$38 Stteak frites in NYC!!

It’s my first time to try steak frites in nyc, good deal and server was so nice and friendly🤌🏼✨ We went on weekdays no line and no wait time! Highly recommend place in nyc⭐️ Le Relais de Venise L'Entrecôte #Lemon8Diary #nyc #nyceats #food #steak

3 likes

A woman with headphones sips a drink in front of a building at "119" in the East Village, adorned with festive autumn and Halloween decorations including pumpkins, orange leaves, and skeletons, reflecting the area's mystical energy.

A hand holds a glass jar labeled "LOVE POTION • 9," containing dried herbs. The label also features a potion bottle graphic and text, aligning with the witchy and mystical theme of the East Village shops.

Inside a shop, shelves display books like "The Shining Tribe Tarot" and "Thoth Tarot." Below, an old TV holds a stuffed bison and a stack of cult classic movies, showcasing vintage curiosities and witchy treasures.

Witchy District in NYC

I spent the day wandering through what I like to call the witchy district in the East Village 🖤✨ This little pocket of NYC has such a cool history — the area has been tied to counterculture, mysticism, and spirituality since the 1960s, when the East Village became a hub for free thinkers, artist

11 likes

Oldest diners in NYC 🗽

Bangers all of em #nyfood #nyc #newyork #newyorkcity

9 likes

A vibrant spread of Korean BBQ dishes on a table, featuring various cuts of raw beef, a grill with cooking meat, side dishes, corn cheese, and uni rice, all under the text 'Antoya Korean BBQ'.

A close-up of pan-fried Strip Loin Yook-joen, garnished with green onions and sesame seeds, with chopsticks lifting a piece. Corn cheese is visible in the background.

Thinly sliced Korean Style Carpaccio, a raw beef dish, arranged on a white plate with microgreens, sesame seeds, and a side of pickled onions and wasabi.

Korean BBQ Meets Creative Bites✨ in NYC

Antoya is back with some amazing new Korean-inspired snacks, and they’re all must-tries! Here’s what we loved this time: ➡️ Korean Style Carpaccio Lightly seared beef slices that release a smoky aroma while staying tender inside. Wrap them with veggies and sauce for a fresh, crisp bite! ➡️ S

47 likes

The exterior of Great Jones Distilling Co., a dark brick building with gold accents, featuring the text 'NYC SPOTS great aesthetics & vibes to visit'.

The illuminated storefront of Nom Wah Tea Parlor at night, with two people standing outside, featuring the text 'Nom Wah Tea Parlor The oldest restaurant in Chinatown!'.

A person sitting in a serene garden courtyard with stone arches and columns at The Met Cloisters, featuring the text 'Met Cloisters You feel like you're in Europe, not in Upper Manhattan!'.

NYC spots with good vibes & aesthetics

Save these spots with a good ambiance, vibe, and aesthetics for your next New York trip! Nom Wah Tea Parlor This Chinatown institution opened in 1920 and is the oldest restaurant in the neighborhood! The Met Cloisters Wander around the medieval art like the famous Hunt of the Unic

285 likes

SPRING ACTIVITIES TO SO IN NYC 🌸

Places To Go New York Botanical Garden Cool places to go in NYC ✈️ 📍Location: New York Botenical Garden 📝Nice place for natives and visitors to escape the hustle and bustle of the city. 🚕🗽 Good Part: It’s a big space full of beautiful spring flower’s at the moment. It has gift shop, restaur

15 likes

nyc good eats (ep 1) - Skirt Steak

hi pookies, this is my first post on lemon8 i love the restaurant experience , especially in nyc ! my bestie and I tried “Skirt Steak” and it was so amazing we got there pretty early and there was a line outside but we got in (they only do walk ins) the menu is a pre fixe menu ( we paid

3 likes

Trying TikTok Popular Spots in NYC

I'm excited to start a new series where I rate TikTok's most hyped places in NYC (hyped = many viral videos taking about it). If you're visiting NYC, I'm doing you a favor and letting you know whether to visit these places so you can save some $! The other day, I went to get brunch

33 likes

A close-up of perfectly cooked, sliced steak with garlic and rosemary on a wooden board, highlighting New York City steak entrees not to be missed.

A medium-rare filet mignon steak, sliced, served with crispy fries in a metal cup and ketchup, representing Redeye Grill's offering.

Sliced steak with a side of golden fries and fresh greens, presented on a black pan, showcasing a dish from Legasea Bar & Grill.

✨ NYC Steak Entrees That Are Not To Be Missed 🥩💋

These steak entrees are too good to miss—perfect for your next indulgent night out: 🎭 Redeye Grill : Ideal pre-Broadway vibes! Their $55 filet mignon with fries is a showstopper. 🏟 Legasea Bar & Grill : Steps from Madison Square Garden! Sundays & Mondays mean unlimited salad, fries, a

29 likes

3 NYC attractions NOT TO MISS!

Traveling to New York and wondering what are a few things not to miss? These are the 3 things I take every visitor to when they come see me in NYC! Fraunces Tavern This historic tavern is the oldest in the city and has such a vibe. This is where George Washington gave his farewell address

20 likes

A cozy bar interior with a brown leather booth, a small table with snacks, and a colorful mural featuring whimsical animal characters, setting the scene for 'Places with Old New York Vibes'.

The interior of P.J. Clarke's, featuring a red brick wall, dark wood paneling, framed pictures, a large clock, and a table with a red and white checkered tablecloth, evoking its 1884 history.

Bemelmans Bar interior with a distinctive mural by Ludwig Bemelmans featuring whimsical scenes, and a small table with two chairs, highlighting its 1947 opening and artistic legacy.

Old School Places to visit in NYC

Next time you’re traveling to New York , don’t miss these classic, old-school establishments to feel like you’re in ‘Old New York.’ P.J. Clarke's on Third Avenue This spot dates back to 1884 and not only serves up a mean burger that Nat King Cole loved to order nicknamed the Cadillac,

85 likes

See more