Lemon8Lifestyle community
Beli App | Restaurant Lists
Beli App | Restaurant Lists

9420 followers

Follow
Follow
Follow
A close-up of soft-serve ice cream or gelato in a clear cup, topped with sauce and sliced fruit, garnished with a green leaf. Text overlay reads "top 14 ICE CREAM in NYC, ranked" and "as ranked by Beli members."
A map of New York City showing numerous ice cream cone icons with numerical ratings, indicating locations and scores. An overlay states "based on over 100 million ratings on beli."
A collage of six images featuring green and brown scoops of gelato in cups and cones, with "Triple gelato" text. A central overlay identifies it as "14. Eddie's Sweet Shop."
A collage of six images showcasing various ice cream flavors in cups, including "Captain crunch coo...", "Spongebob", and "Nutella Biscoff." A central overlay reads "13. Max & Mina's Ice Cream."
A collage of six images displaying matcha soft serve ice cream in cups and cones, with "Matcha soft serve" text. A central overlay identifies it as "12. Taku Parlor."
A collage of six images featuring various desserts like sundaes, affogato, and hot chocolate. A central overlay reads "11. Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain."
A collage of six images showing vanilla ice cream with various toppings or mix-ins, including "Vanilla with strawberr..." and "vanilla with speculoos...". A central overlay identifies it as "10. Julia Jean's."
A collage of six images featuring different gelato flavors in cups, such as "Pistachio e caramel c..." and "Hazelnut mousse." A central overlay reads "9. Anita La Mamma del Gelato."
A collage of six images showing ice cream in cups and cones, including "strawberry tres lec..." and "Honey lavender." One image shows a storefront. A central overlay identifies it as "8. Salt & Straw."
A collage of six images featuring green and brown scoops of gelato in cups and cones, with "Triple gelato" text. A central overlay identifies it as "7. Aoko Matcha."
1/11

You may also like

No content
See more on the app
See more on the app
See more on the app
2 saved

Top 14 ice cream and gelato shops in NYC, ranked

5/30 Edited to

... Read moreIf you're an ice cream lover visiting or living in New York City, this list of top-rated shops offers an amazing guide to some of the best places you can find authentic gelato and ice cream. Based on more than 100 million ratings on Beli, it provides a trusted community perspective. One highlight is the variety of unique flavors and specialties like "Triple Gelato" and "Matcha Soft Serve" at AOKO Matcha and Taku Parlor, offering a Japanese-inspired twist that is hard to find elsewhere. Meanwhile, classic favorites like Salt & Straw bring inventive flavors such as salted malted chocolate and honey lavender, satisfying those who love creative combinations. Many shops are also known for their nostalgic treats, such as Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain’s brownies and affogato, and Eddie's Sweet Shop's timeless scoops. From rich pistachio and caramel creations at Anita La Mamma del Gelato to playful options like the Captain Crunch cookie-topped sundaes, there’s something for every palate. Personally, exploring these shops gave me a wonderful way to experience NYC's diverse culinary scene. Instead of sticking to the usual flavors, I was thrilled to try exotic options like the cookie monster brownies sundae and homemade Nutella Biscoff scoops, which elevate ice cream beyond just a simple dessert. Also, these shops reflect NYC’s vibrant culture — from Chelsea to the East Channel — and each offers a unique ambiance that makes the ice cream tasting experience even better. Whether you prefer classic creamy vanilla or adventurous salted caramel with sea salt, the rankings help pinpoint spots that combine quality ingredients with excellent community feedback. If you’re hunting for ultimate ice cream or gelato experiences in the city, I recommend using this ranking as a starting checklist. Visiting a few top-ranked places can turn a casual sweet craving into a memorable outing. And don’t hesitate to share your own favorites online; with millions rating and sharing on Beli, the community’s voice helps uncover hidden gems and ensures the rankings stay fresh and helpful for all ice cream lovers.