Fall or Christmas?

Fall is in the air… but so is peppermint.

One aisle smells like pumpkin spice, the other screams “All I want for Christmas is YOUUU!” 🎃➡️🎄

Let’s settle this festive identity crisis:

Are you lighting fall candles or untangling Christmas lights?

Team “sweater weather and soup” or Team “Santa hats and sugar highs”?

👇Vote below and bring receipts!

2025/7/31 Edited to

... Read moreOkay, Lemon8 fam, I need your honest opinions because I am officially in a festive identity crisis! One minute I'm wrapped up in a cozy blanket, sipping a pumpkin spice latte, absolutely loving the scent of autumn in the air. The next, I spot the first twinkly lights in a neighbor's window, and suddenly, 'All I Want for Christmas Is You' starts playing in my head! How do you navigate this beautiful but confusing time of year? I mean, seriously, it feels like just yesterday the sidewalks were covered with fallen leaves, painted in those vibrant orange and yellow fall foliage hues, giving off that classic fall atmosphere. My home was decked out with gourds and warm, earthy tones. But then, almost overnight, the stores started playing Christmas music, and I saw a display of festive red bows and green garlands that just called my name. It makes me wonder, when is the right time to swap out my cozy fall wreaths for sparkly Christmas baubles? For me, the struggle is real. One part of me wants to savor every last moment of crisp autumn air, hayrides, and apple picking. There’s something so magical about watching the leaves change and enjoying comfort food. But then, there’s the undeniable pull of the holiday season. The thought of snow falling, the smell of fresh pine, and seeing small snow-covered Christmas trees pop up everywhere just fills me with so much joy. It's like my heart is pulled in two equally wonderful directions! I’ve tried to set a rule for myself – no Christmas decorations before Thanksgiving! But honestly, sometimes the temptation is just too strong. Do you wait until December 1st? Or are you one of those early birds who has their tree up right after Halloween? I've seen some incredible transformations on Lemon8, from stunning fall mantels to full-blown quintessential winter holiday and Christmas ambiance in the blink of an eye! What are your go-to traditions for welcoming the holiday season without completely rushing through fall? Do you try to blend the two, maybe with some transitional decor that works for both? Or do you go cold turkey, packing away every pumpkin before the first snowflake (or artificial snowflake, if you're like me and dreaming of a white Christmas in a warm climate!)? I’m curious to know your personal strategies. Do certain smells or songs trigger your Christmas spirit early, or do you cling to your autumn rituals until the very last moment? Let’s talk about it! I'm genuinely looking for tips, tricks, and commiseration on this ultimate festive season debate. Because honestly, while I love both equally, my decor closet (and my sanity!) can only handle so much seasonal overlap. Share your wisdom below – I need to know if I'm alone in this festive limbo!

103 comments

Kiara williams's images
Kiara williams

Both . Fall and Christmas both hit different in a good way. Fall makes everything feel calm and cozy, and Christmas just brings joy and warmth. I really enjoy both seasons for what they are.

imapaytreeoght's images
imapaytreeoght

That’s a toughie- I’d have to say fall. I’m old, the cold makes my bones hurt🫢 both look beautiful- but if I could experience one- it would be Fall. It’s the reprieve from the hot days of summer and filled with anticipation of winter.

See more comments

Related posts

Affordable Fall Fragrances ✨🍁
Looking for affordable fall fragrances to add to your collection? These cozy, warm scents will elevate your autumn vibe! • Sabrina Carpenter Sweet Tooth Caramel Dream - Indulge in a decadent caramel treat with hints of creamy sweetness. This one is perfect for those cozy fall evenings. • Soli
Paige 🍦💕

Paige 🍦💕

370 likes

Two fall-themed romance novels by Laurie Gilmore, "The Pumpkin Spice Cafe" and "The Cinnamon Bun Book Store," are displayed. The book covers feature charming storefronts decorated with autumn foliage and pumpkins.
The book "The Pumpkin Spice Cafe" by Laurie Gilmore is shown standing on a white surface. Its cover features an inviting cafe storefront adorned with autumn decorations, including pumpkins and fall leaves.
The book "The Cinnamon Bun Book Store" by Laurie Gilmore is displayed on a white surface. The cover illustrates a charming bookstore facade decorated with fall foliage and an outdoor bookshelf.
The CUTEST fall books EVER!
These books are the CUTEST!!!! Gives a small town feel, very Gilmore Girls vibes!! About to preorder the Christmas book ☺️ 💰Price: $18.99 each 👍Pros: Cute for fall and romancey! #fallbookhaul #fallbookinspo #book recommendations
Lizz

Lizz

550 likes

The image displays a person's feet wearing grey and yellow sneakers on a black surface, with the text "75 Soft Fall 2025 Edition" centered above, indicating the start of a wellness program.
This image outlines "Step 1: Diet" for the 75 Soft Fall 2025 Edition, focusing on mindful eating with healthy food swaps, alcohol balance tips, and fall-inspired nourishing meal ideas, set against a background of autumn foliage.
The image details "Step 2: Exercise" (45 minutes daily) with example workouts and active recovery ideas, and "Step 3: Hydration" (3 liters daily) with 10 practical hacks, against a backdrop of fitness gear.
Fall Wellness Blueprint: 75 Soft for Mind & Body 🍁
Diet: Nourish with Flexibility and Intelligence In my fall-edition of 75 Soft, mindful eating is about balance, not deprivation. I encourage you to choose nutrient-dense, satiating alternatives most days—and still enjoy social treats guilt-free. Swap starchy fries for baked sweet potato wedges l
Chalie_Baker

Chalie_Baker

2854 likes

Fall is coming! 👻🫀🧜🏻‍♀️🧚🏻‍♀️🍁🍂🏕️
#lemon8diarychallenge #falliscoming🍂🍁 #outside #shareyourthoughts Fall is coming!! So ready for Halloween 🎃,thanksgiving 🦃,Christmas 🎄. I love the end of the year just not the spending a lot of money. Comfy clothes, bonfires, dark vibes, food. Can’t go wrong. So what is your favorite sea
Heather Wehunt

Heather Wehunt

10 likes

A close-up of several homemade bath bombs, some topped with dried lavender and rose petals, with the text overlay "HOW TO MAKE Bath BOMBS" and sparkling graphics.
Various ingredients for bath bombs are displayed on a wooden surface, including bags of Epsom salt, citric acid, boxes of baking soda, corn starch, bottles of coconut oil, mica powder, and essential oils.
A four-panel collage illustrating the first steps of bath bomb making: mixing dry ingredients, mixing wet ingredients (water, oil, essential oil, coloring), slowly combining wet into dry, and thoroughly mixing the combined ingredients.
Make Your Own Bath Bombs for Christmas Gifts 🫶
Bath bombs are so fun and easier to make than I thought! They make great gifts that you can make in bulk and give to all your friends or family! They might seem a little pricey the first time you make them because you have to buy molds and all the ingredients. But I bought most of it in bulk so
Modern Mom | Shannon

Modern Mom | Shannon

113 likes

Fall Craft 🍂
✨ Easy & Fun DIY Coasters✨ I made some Halloween and fall-themed coasters, and I’m already planning Christmas ones next! These are such a simple and cute DIY, perfect for gifting or decorating your space. Here’s what you’ll need: 🪵 Tiles – I grabbed mine from Home Depot 🎀 Decorative nap
Em🦦

Em🦦

133 likes

Fall Decor At TJMAXX
#falldecor #lemon8challenge Run to your local @T.J.Maxx For all things fall and spooky. My favorite time of the year is this season and Christmas season 🙂 I absolutely love going and checking out all the fall blankets and garlands. what is your favorite Decor to use during spooky season? Are
Terr_Elane

Terr_Elane

4 likes

FALL BOOK SHOPPING🍁🍂
Sooo many options😩 I ended up narrowing it down to only 2 today lol Will definitely be back for the others at some point. Which one’s have you read or are on your Fall TBR list?🧡 #barnesandnoble #fallbooks #fallvibes #fallbookrecs #booklover
Aqiea🌿

Aqiea🌿

205 likes

Found Fall and christmas creamers 😂
#coffee #christmas #fall #creamer #starbucks #sugarcookies #pumpkin #target #targetfind #lemon8home @Lemon8 Home
Camila Patron✨

Camila Patron✨

380 likes

Cozy Fall Activities
Whether you do them by yourself, with a boo or with friends, here are some fun cozy fall activities that you can enjoy this season! #fallactivities #fallactivity #cozyfallvibes #cozyfall #falltime
Ber Months are the best!

Ber Months are the best!

149 likes

A scenic view from a car of a road lined with trees displaying autumn foliage under a cloudy sky, with the text "Fun fall Activities" overlaid.
A table set up for pumpkin painting, featuring three large pumpkins, various paint bottles, paintbrushes, and a bowl of candy on a plastic-covered surface.
A painted pumpkin with the phrase "LET'S GO GHOULS" in pink, adorned with two white ghosts wearing pink cowboy hats, surrounded by painting supplies.
Fun fall activities
Some fall events I’ve done lately #fallactivities #falltime #pumpkin #christmas #Halloween2024
Emily Grace

Emily Grace

17 likes

Recent Halloween & Fall Finds🎃🍂
I’m so excited for Fall and spooky season!! I’ve been picking up items here and there over the past few months.🖤 🦇🥀🐈‍⬛ #hallloween #fall #spookyseason #halloweenideas #beetlejuice #nightmarebeforechristmas #marshallsfinds #spookyvibes #fallvibes #Haul
Amanda Mello

Amanda Mello

561 likes

Cozy fall-winter combo
Sugared Crust is one of my favorite fall to winter scents because it’s so potent and cozy. It smells like a mix of sugar cookies and fresh pie crust. I normally pair it with a vanilla or coconut scrub but with the fireside s’mores scrub from Bodycology😳 She’s delicious! The sense complement each ot
Mack

Mack

56 likes

Fall Book Crafts🤎📚🍂
Book crafts from fall 🍂 Book/ kindle sleeves - I made some book & kindle sleeves as part of a book basket & for myself. I love them so much and can’t wait to make Christmas ones!!🎄 Magnetic bookmarks - seasonal everything 🤷‍♀️ I enjoyed making these & of course can’t wait to make Ch
Em🦦

Em🦦

43 likes

Christmas or Fall??
Liv Richardson

Liv Richardson

1 like

63 days until till Fall🍂
Can we just skip summer already😩 I live in the Central Valley in California, summers here are no joke. I love everything the fall brings, I love the vibe🧡 63 days left, the countdown begins🍂🎃🦃🎄 #fallvibes🍂 #fallaesthetic #Lemon8 #lemon8diarychallenge #thanksgiving #christmas
Destiny Ortega

Destiny Ortega

21 likes

We love a good Fall combo ✨🥰
Fragrance combo of the day❗️🥳 .. Very warm and gives cinnamon Christmas cookie or chai latte with vanilla 🎄 🍪 🍁 #perfumecollection #billieeilish #tjmaxxfinds #warm #vanilla
Franny

Franny

38 likes

5 MUST TRY Starbucks Drinks for This Fall!!🍂☕️
For all my Starbucks girls who are looking for a new order this season, try some of my go to's. I get these on repeat and they never miss😉 🍂 ~ 1. Caramel White Mocha Say: Hi, can I please get a (size) Iced White Chocolate Mocha with Sweet Cream Cold Foam with the cup lined with Caramel?
💌aubs💐

💌aubs💐

823 likes

Fall crafts to do with the kiddos 🧡
These are always so much fun to do with my little dude! I’ve made so many now that, instead of hanging them on my wall, I send them to family as surprise gifts throughout the year. I love thinking about how, one day, they might get pulled out of grandma’s basement or uncle’s garage, sparking
🍁 Autumn 🍁

🍁 Autumn 🍁

29 likes

Must visit Fall - Halloween Town near NYC 🎃
🎃 Spooky season is officially here! 👻 If you’re looking for a fun fall day trip, Wethersfield, Connecticut is about a 2.5-hour drive from NYC — and they completely transform the town for Halloween! 🎃✨ Think scarecrows on every corner, cozy cafés, and cute local shops — it’s definitely worth the vi
Savannah Vinson

Savannah Vinson

69 likes

A burgundy sherpa crossbody bag with a top handle and a wide strap featuring the brand name. The bag has a textured, fluffy appearance and a small tag hanging from the handle.
A tan sherpa crossbody bag with a top handle and a wide strap. The bag features a textured, fluffy material and a small tag hanging from the handle, identified as the Mirella Extra-Small Sherpa Crossbody Bag.
A tan faux shearling boot with a thick, ridged sole. The boot has a soft, textured exterior and is described as the Winnie Faux Shearling Boot, noted as being in demand.
Michael Kors snapped for Fall/ Winter 🍂❄️🥶😍
#christmaslistinspo #MICHAEL KORS #michael kors bag #WinterOutfit #healthylifestyle2024
Mss. Kekee

Mss. Kekee

37 likes

Fall decor inspired🍂🍁diy
Hey everyone! 🍁 Fall is officially here, and it’s time to bring out all the cozy, autumnal vibes into our homes. Today, I want to share with you an amazing find from the Dollar Store that will elevate your fall decor game – a transparent pumpkin! 🎃✨ This little gem is not just any pumpkin; it’s
DMLR 🌷🧁💌🎀

DMLR 🌷🧁💌🎀

192 likes

Fall is Approaching🫶🏽
Anybody else excited for Hallothanksmas?🎃🦇🦃🧡🎄🎁 #fallvibes🍂 #fall #halloween #thanksgiving #christmas #autumn #autumnvibes🍁 #coldweather #pumpkin #fyp
Faith Marii

Faith Marii

1936 likes

Three smiling young women are sitting together on a couch with festive Christmas lights in the background. The image serves as an introduction to a list of holiday romantic comedies, with text overlay "Holiday Rom-Coms to Watch with Friends or By Yourself Swipe for List Part 1."
A movie poster for "The Holiday" features headshots of Cameron Diaz, Kate Winslet, Jude Law, and Jack Black. The text indicates it's a film by Nancy Meyers and is available on Prime.
The movie poster for "Love Actually" displays a grid of its ensemble cast, including Hugh Grant, Liam Neeson, Colin Firth, Laura Linney, Emma Thompson, Alan Rickman, Keira Knightley, Martine McCutcheon, Bill Nighy, and Rowan Atkinson. It's labeled "THE ULTIMATE ROMANTIC COMEDY" and available on Prime.
Christmas Rom-Coms to Make You Fall in Love 🎬 🌲
Looking for a movie to warm your heart and make you laugh? Here’s a list of the best rom-coms, from iconic classics to feel-good new releases! Grab some popcorn, get cozy, and prepare to swoon. 🍿✨ #RomComs #MovieNight #FeelGoodFilms
KELLEE S

KELLEE S

3 likes

Fall Magazines finds
The fall issues are all just beautiful I’m still on the looker for 3 more fall magazines I’m trying not to get the Halloween ones I’ll probably get only two with hosting ,cookies, baking & crafts. Fall Magnolia magazine- love a seasonal magazine with the ins and outs for the fresh new seaso
Chinue Doll

Chinue Doll

2 likes

Hobby Lobby Finds You’ll Fall In Love With 🛍️
I love a good HL shopping trip ! I'm bound to come across special finds every time . It’s truly a creative goldmine . Here are the gems I came across on my latest visit : 💎 Parent Section : Cups , mugs , tumblers , keychains — you name it ! As a first-time parent (10 months strong 🙌🏾) , I
BrownBlondies

BrownBlondies

407 likes

An overhead shot of a small pot filled with a fall stovetop potpourri blend, featuring apple peels, orange peels, cinnamon sticks, anise stars, and cloves simmering in water. Whole fruits and spices are scattered on a white cloth around the pot.
Fall Stovetop Potpourri Blend
Fall Stovetop Potpourri Blend! It smells incredible and fills the entire house with the cozy scent of fall! Fall scented potpourri Simmer Peels from one apple Peels from one orange One teaspoon of ground cloves 4 cinnamon sticks 6 Anise Stars Water Christmas Blend One sliced orang
Simply Home

Simply Home

9 likes

See more