The Five-Star Weekend 👒🥂🐚
book review | The Five-Star Weekend by Elin Hilderbrand ⛱️
my rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️✨
setting: Nantucket, Massachusetts🪻
The premise of this story is that a grieving widow invites four friends, each from a different stage of her life, to have a girls weekend.
Hollis Shaw’s life seems flawless. She is the creator of a very popular food blog and is married to a dreamy surgeon. One morning a tragic accident happens and leaving Hollis a widow. She hears about something called a “Five-Star Weekend” and decides to host one of her own. She invites four of her girlfriends, each from a different stage of her life, to Nantucket for a girls weekend. Each of the women brings along plenty of their own drama and scandals.
I love Elin Hilderbrand and have read 19 of her books. And maybe that’s the problem I had with this one? It just felt like the same redundant story with different characters.
While I still enjoyed reading this book, I just didn’t find it to be anything super special or exciting.
The ending felt very underwhelming.
Have you read The Five-Star Weekend? Let me know what you thought! 🫧
#elinhilderbrand #summerreads #summerbookrecs #booksoflemon8 #readersoflemon8
I've noticed many of you are curious about 'The Five-Star Weekend' by Elin Hilderbrand, especially beyond a simple rating. You're looking for deeper insights into the book's emotional impact, its specific elements, and how it measures up to other compelling dramas. Let’s dive a bit deeper into what makes this Nantucket story tick, based on my reading experience. First, let's talk about the cover! The book's captivating blue cover featuring people splashing in water immediately evokes that quintessential summer vibe. It perfectly sets the scene for a warm, beachy read, even if the underlying themes of 'tragic accident,' 'grieving widow,' and 'scandal & drama' add a layer of complexity not immediately visible. It’s a classic Hilderbrand visual, promising escape but hinting at more. One of the questions I often see is about the specific activities or events designed to evoke strong emotional responses. In 'The Five-Star Weekend,' the premise itself – a grieving widow, Hollis Shaw, bringing together four friends from different life stages for a 'girls weekend' in Nantucket – is ripe for emotional fireworks. While the book doesn't detail every single activity, the emotional responses are primarily driven by the interactions between these women. Old resentments resurface, new secrets are revealed, and Hollis grapples with her loss while attempting to curate a healing experience. The emotional depth comes from the clash of personalities and pasts, rather than grand events. It's the small, poignant moments of confession, confrontation, and tentative reconciliation that truly resonate, even if I felt they sometimes repeated familiar Hilderbrand tropes. Regarding Elin Hilderbrand's writing style, particularly the role of dialogue and description, she truly shines in her ability to paint a vivid picture of Nantucket. Her descriptions of the island, from its charming streets to its beautiful beaches, are as immersive as ever. You can almost feel the sea breeze and taste the salt in the air. The dialogue, while sometimes feeling a bit repetitive in character dynamics for long-time Hilderbrand readers like myself, effectively moves the plot forward and reveals the intricate relationships between the women. It’s through their conversations that the 'friendship,' 'scandal & drama' really come to life, allowing readers to understand their complex histories and motivations, even when the plot occasionally feels familiar. Finally, for those who love a good prestige drama or thriller on TV, you might be wondering how 'The Five-Star Weekend' compares in terms of emotional depth. I found that the book certainly has all the ingredients of a compelling drama. The 'grieving widow,' the 'girls weekend' setting, the inherent 'scandal & drama' among friends – it's all there. While it might not be a 'thriller' in the traditional sense, the unfolding of secrets and the emotional tension could easily translate into a buzzy TV series. The emotional impact, for me, was a mixed bag; some moments were genuinely touching, others felt a bit predictable. However, if you enjoy character-driven stories with a strong sense of place and plenty of juicy interpersonal conflict, this book provides a solid, if not groundbreaking, dramatic experience that parallels the escapism and emotional rollercoaster of a good network drama.

I love it I thought it was a great story. I love that every character had some type of baggage to unfold and even building their friendship.