Box dye Fail!!!

2024/11/16 Edited to

... Read moreI've been there countless times – standing in front of the mirror, fresh from a box dye session, only to find my roots a different shade than my ends, or patchy spots where the color just didn't take evenly. It's a classic box dye fail, and I know I'm not alone in this struggle. While I keep going back to my beloved Dark & Lovely 'Red Reality' (it’s just so convenient!), I’ve learned a lot about why these uneven results happen and what steps I can take to make them less disastrous. One of the biggest culprits for uneven hair color is existing hair porosity. My reddish-brown hair, especially towards the ends, tends to be more porous from previous coloring or heat styling. This means it soaks up color differently than my virgin roots, leading to that distinct two-tone effect. Application technique also plays a huge role; trying to cover all sections quickly can leave some areas oversaturated and others barely touched. Overlapping color onto previously dyed hair can also make those sections look much darker or duller. It’s a delicate balance trying to get it right at home! Beyond the unevenness, I've had my share of concerns about box dye hair damage. While modern formulas are better, regular box dyeing can still lead to dryness, breakage, and a loss of natural shine. I’ve noticed my hair feeling a bit more brittle after a particularly strong dye. To combat this, I swear by deep conditioning treatments once a week and always use a heat protectant when styling. Finding the least damaging box hair dye has been a journey; I often look for ammonia-free options or those enriched with oils and conditioners to minimize the harshness. Then there's the age-old question: is one box of hair dye enough? For my medium-length, voluminous hair, the answer is often no. If your hair is past your shoulders or particularly thick, one box is rarely sufficient to fully saturate every strand. This often leads to missed spots or an overall lighter, less vibrant color than intended. I learned this the hard way and now always buy two boxes, just in case. It ensures I have enough product for a thorough application, reducing the chances of another uneven hair dye result. When a box dye truly goes wrong, and I'm facing a serious hair dye disaster, I've had to consider how to fix box dyed hair. For minor unevenness, a color-depositing conditioner or glaze can sometimes blend the shades a bit. If the color is completely off, or too dark, removing box dye from hair is an option, but it's a harsh process. I've heard horror stories about color removers, so for anything significant, I've learned it's best to consult a professional stylist. They can assess the damage and suggest the safest way to correct it, whether that's through a gentle bleach bath, toning, or even a strategic haircut. It's all part of the box dye journey, and sometimes, you just have to laugh it off and try again next time!

54 comments

Rayn's images
Rayn

reasons why hairdressers exist

See more(6)
keeping it REAL's images
keeping it REAL

L’Oreal hi-color 30 developer

See more comments

Related posts

How to dye a 613 wig burgundy
Get into this color 😍 #613frontalwigs #burgundy #DIY #wiginfluencer #amazonfinds United States
Juhkneekuh

Juhkneekuh

1666 likes

The back of a person's head with long, wavy, multi-toned brown and blonde hair. Decorative flower icons are present, along with text overlayed that reads "Tips for removing box dye."
A plain light pink background with three white right-facing arrow symbols in the center, indicating to swipe or proceed to the next content.
A large blue bottle of dish soap with a yellow duckling on the label. The label also displays text including "DAWN ULTRA" and "50% LESS SCRUBBING."
Tips for removing box dye
New to Lemon8! Something I love: #hellolemon8 Wet hair apply a good amount of dawn dish soap to your head. Let it sit for 10 to 15 minutes wash and repeat over a couple of days and it’ll eventually pull most of the color out of your hair just make sure you use conditioner after! Dawn dis
Mady Mo ❤️

Mady Mo ❤️

127 likes

Blue CANDY Wig 🩵🍬💙 & DYE TUTORIAL, I absolutely 💙
Blue CANDY Wig 🩵🍬💙 & DYE TUTORIAL, I absolutely love this color! You turn into Elsa overnight 💋 #fyp #fy #viral #bluewig #tutorial
𝑩𝒆𝒏𝒊𝒉𝒂𝒏𝒂𝒂 ⋆𐙚

𝑩𝒆𝒏𝒊𝒉𝒂𝒏𝒂𝒂 ⋆𐙚

5346 likes

Hand Print Hair Dye Design!
Hand Print Hair Dye Design! #hair #hairtutorial #beauty #hairdye
Offbeatlook

Offbeatlook

2252 likes

Hydration minus the added sugar + dye
#lemon8partner #Hydrating #naturesgatorade You can get the benefits of a Gatorade minus all the bad ingredients in it. I started making this drink when I was healing from my illnesses to make sure my body was up to speed in order to heal and detox. And then I never stopped consuming it
Madelinebhealth

Madelinebhealth

856 likes

A collage of nine photos showcasing a person with various split-dye hairstyles, including red/black, green/black, blue/purple, and silver/black, illustrating a four-year journey of coloring that eventually led to cutting off all hair.
A collage of six photos depicting the person's split-dye hair journey, highlighting the damage from bleaching over four years, culminating in a final black style with a white skunk stripe before giving up color.
A collage of nine close-up photos revealing the severe damage to the person's hair, showing thin, broken, and uneven strands, which hairdressers had to trim regularly due to bleach-induced damage.
SPLIT DYE RUINED MY HAIR! 😭💇🏻‍♀️BIG CHOP
my very first time putting real color in my hair was 2015. i was peak emo trinity. if you wanna jump ahead. recent split dye mention starts at this emoji 🦇 right after my mom got her br3ast augmentation, she was on some pretty heavy pain pills. and i mean right after. the day after lol. i asked
trinity wendt

trinity wendt

1241 likes

Attempt to remove 2 years of box dyed hair!
#hairdye #hairstyles #DIY #fyp #haircare Los Angeles
Red

Red

942 likes

Shamrock Pretzel Pops (Dye free!)
Shamrock Pretzel Pops! So easy and so fun to make with the kiddos! Skip the artificial dyes and use a pinch of matcha powder, or a dye free colorant brand like the one I shared below You'll need • Pretzels @quinnsnacks for gluten feee • White chocolate @paschachocolate for vegan organ
Colleen Forton

Colleen Forton

1080 likes

A woman with long, wavy, dark red hair, showcasing the cherry red hair dye result, with text overlay 'HAIR DYE RECIPE FOR CHERRY RED HAIR'.
A hand holding a box of L'Oréal Technique Excellence HiColor HiLights in Magenta, a hair dye product used for the cherry red hair.
A hand holding a box of L'Oréal Technique Excellence HiColor Violets in H19 True Violet, another hair dye product used for the cherry red hair.
Hair dye recipe for Cherry red hair 🍒
This year I chose to do something different, I have been wanting a change and for several years I have been dying my hair black and vowed to always have black hair 🙄 I seen an inspo pic on Pinterest of this color and decided I was gonna do it! And I'm glad I did 🥰 All color bought at Sally&
𝒜𝓂𝒶𝓇𝒾𝓈🍒

𝒜𝓂𝒶𝓇𝒾𝓈🍒

1717 likes

hair dye ideas
♤♤♤♤♤
☆𝖘𝖙𝖔𝖗𝖒𝖎𝖊☆

☆𝖘𝖙𝖔𝖗𝖒𝖎𝖊☆

12.8K likes

godefroy eyebrow dye > men’s beard dye!!!!
and it’s cheaper 🤭 #godefroyeyebrowdye #mensbearddye #eyebrowdye #diyeyebrows #eyebrowtint
jessica lauren 🌸🍓🎀♥️

jessica lauren 🌸🍓🎀♥️

292 likes

A person's long, straight deep red hair is shown from the side, with text overlay encouraging viewers to dye their hair deep red.
A person's long, voluminous deep red curly hair is captured from the back, illuminated by natural outdoor light.
A person's medium-length, layered deep red hair is styled and viewed from the side, with a hand near the face.
❥ signs to dye it red!💋
If you plan on or think of during your hair red..PLEASE DO!!!! trust me you will have no regrets in doing so!!i keep my hair red atleast every 3-4 months because of how beautiful the color is and the amount of compliments i get about it! ♡ | here’s some brands if you are interested! 💌 Brand:
ell 💐

ell 💐

177 likes

Black box dye Test Strand THIS is why we say that you cannot achieve a bright blonde in one session of removing box dye! Your best bet is to let it grow as long as you can and CHOP it if you want to be a clean bright blonde. • #hairbylima #trussprofessional #boxdyefail #teststrandfail
hairbylima

hairbylima

129 likes

hair dye inspo
I hope u like it
Brooklyn_pretty

Brooklyn_pretty

1678 likes

Black box dye Test Strand ❌ THIS is why we say that you cannot achieve a bright blonde in one session of removing box dye! Your best bet is to let it grow as long as you can and CHOP it💇🏻‍♀️ • #hairbylima #trussprofessional #boxdyefail #teststrandfail #teststrand
hairbylima

hairbylima

84 likes

Healthy dye free rainbow gummy strips!
These homemade gummy strips are so fun, wiggly, and tasty! No artificial colors, no refined sugars, and no artificial flavored jello packets needed! #noartificialcolors #healthysnacks #delicioussnacks #kidsnackideas #healthysnackideas
Colleen Forton

Colleen Forton

3294 likes

Under dye
#pinkhair #pinkhaircolor #underdye #underdyehair #underlights #underlight #kevinbeautysalon #phillysalon
Kevinhairsalon

Kevinhairsalon

95 likes

A sunset sky over a residential street with houses and cars, featuring the text 'CUTE/UNIQUE WAYS TO DYE YOUR HAIR Curly Edition!!' overlay.
Curly dark brown or black hair features vibrant pink highlights, creating a striking contrast and adding dimension.
A back view of curly dark hair with bright pink highlights, showcasing the color distribution throughout the curls.
Cute/Unique ways to dye your hair (Curly Edition)
#lemon8diarychallenge #Hair #dye #hairdye #curlyhairstyles #curlygirly #beautyfinds #neopolitanhair
🐼🐼🐼

🐼🐼🐼

649 likes

A vibrant sunset over a residential street with houses and cars, featuring the text "Unique ways to dye your hair! Swipe" and a pink heart with a smiley face, indicating a title slide for hair color ideas.
A close-up shot of hair styled with distinct streaks of bright pink, brown, and light blonde, labeled "Neopolatin Hair" with a red lips graphic in the corner.
A person with long, wavy hair showcasing prominent pink and blonde highlights, covering their face with one hand, with "Neopolatin Hair" text and a pink lily graphic.
Unique waysto dye your hair!
#lemon8diarychallenge #coloredhair #haircolorideas #funhaircolor #Lemon8Diary #beautyfinds #fashionfinds #2000s MY personal fav is the Neopolatin one.
🐼🐼🐼

🐼🐼🐼

1554 likes

Hair dye inspo
#black hair dye #fypシ゚
Kim💕

Kim💕

1149 likes

Three bottles of semi-permanent hair color are displayed. One large purple bottle is flanked by two smaller bottles, one pink and one silver. Text overlay indicates these are the hair dyes used.
A young woman with vibrant, wavy purple hair and bangs looks up and to the side. She wears dark clothing and makeup, showcasing the successful result of her hair coloring.
A young woman with vivid purple, wavy hair and bangs poses indoors, looking to the side with her hand near her chin. Her dark attire complements her newly dyed hair.
The hair dye I used vs. how it turned out! 💜😈
I have been dying to dye my hair purple, so I finally went through with it! 💜 #violet dream colored hair dye #purplehair #vividcolors #violethair #purplehaircolor
Lacy ✨🌙

Lacy ✨🌙

1730 likes

Box dying hair since I was 10 years old
#hair #hairstyles
Annie 💕

Annie 💕

1137 likes

Three glossy high-heeled shoes in pastel colors—lavender, mint green, and peach—are displayed on a reflective surface. The lavender and mint green shoes are pumps, while the peach shoe is a slingback, all featuring pointed toes and visible red soles, evoking an Easter aesthetic.
These pastels are to dye for!
I love these colors. it’s giving Easter Sunday honey 😍 #heels #shoesinspo #pastel #pastelaesthetic #pastelstyle
Hailey Michelle

Hailey Michelle

1385 likes

Handmade tie dye art 🎨
Something I love: #handmade #tiedye #icedye #artprocess
dyedbyher

dyedbyher

194 likes

Someone definitely switched the dye in the box! ;) #southernutah #hairdyefail #hairfail #wig #fyp
✺𝕸𝖆𝖊✺

✺𝕸𝖆𝖊✺

5 likes

Colors To Dye Your Hair💙🩵❤️🧡💗💜
#hairinspo #fyplemon8 #colors #coloredhair
MiyyMiyyDaBarbie

MiyyMiyyDaBarbie

1313 likes

How to dye chickpeas for SENSORY PLAY 🩷💜❤️
Let's dye chickpeas for a Valentine's Day themed sensory bin for my toddlers. WHAT YOU NEED: •2-4 bags dry chickpeas •Non-toxic paint •Hand sanitizer •ziplock bags •pan & wax paper for drying #valentinesday #lemon8contest #letschat #sensoryplay #toddlermom
Dania Toddler Mom & UGC

Dania Toddler Mom & UGC

361 likes

Rit Dye DIY ✨
Trying out a new Rit Dye color fomula! Let's DIY some chartreuse cargos 💚 #DIY #ritdye #upcycle #upcycledfashion #artistsoflemon8
Jade ✨️

Jade ✨️

792 likes

A pot containing fabric soaking in a natural dye bath, with a wooden spoon. The image features text overlay: 'HOW TO Change Up Your Wardrobe LIKE A QUEEN (NO FAST FASHION, NO BUDGET NEEDED)'. Dried berries are visible on the side.
Nine fabric swatches showcasing colors from natural dyes: yellow onion skins (yellow), blueberries (lavender), carrot tops (pale green), red cabbage (blue), used coffee grounds (beige), and strawberry tops (pink).
Nine fabric swatches displaying colors from natural dyes: avocado pits (dark brown), blackberries (dark grey), spinach (dark green), black beans (dark grey), used wine (burgundy), and raspberries (reddish-brown).
Cheap Fabric Dye Hack 🤎
Sometimes I get bored with my clothes pretty quickly, and I start craving something new. But instead of giving in to fast fashion trends, I try to get creative and breathe new life into the pieces I already own. It’s a fun way to refresh my style without constantly buying more. 🧺 What You’ll Nee
stephanie.knudsen

stephanie.knudsen

1553 likes

A black background with white speckles resembling stars, featuring a central grey rectangular box with the text "Hair dye idea's" in white, framed by decorative elements.
A back view of long, wavy hair featuring a mix of dark brown, blonde, and vibrant pink highlights, styled in layers.
A side view of a person with dark hair and bright pink highlights, styled in a high, messy ponytail.
Hair dye idea’sᰔᩚ
*ੈ✩‧₊˚༺☆༻*ੈ✩‧₊˚ ┊ Here is some hair dye ideas for the hair addicts! i always always always want to change my hair it might be a problem… i also have a part 2 if you would like, have many many more <𝟑 ┊ *ੈ✩‧₊˚༺☆༻*ੈ✩‧₊˚ ┊ #cutehairideas #hairdye #commentyourhaircolor #bodytransformati
kali ♰

kali ♰

165 likes

Dye My Hair with Me🥰
I’ve been dying my hair this exact way since 2020 and have never used bleach on my hair. This is the best way for me to achieve this color that I want. Products used: - L’Oreal HiColor Highlights (in red and magenta) - Developer 30v (I used 50v from what I already had) - mixing bowl #dy
Asia Simone

Asia Simone

404 likes

Adore Semi Permanent Hair Dye
#adoresemipermanent #colorhair #dyedhair #ginger
Muvalingling

Muvalingling

330 likes

Two colorful tie-dye cheesecake bars are stacked on top of other bars, showcasing vibrant swirls of pink, blue, purple, and yellow. The image features text overlays: 'TIE DYE CHEESECAKE BARS' and 'EASY STEP BY STEP INSTRUCTIONS'.
A close-up of a tie-dye cheesecake bar with a graham cracker crust. Text overlays list ingredients for the 'CRUST' (melted butter, graham cracker crumbs, sugar) and 'CHEESECAKE' (cream cheese, sugar, heavy cream, eggs, vanilla, food coloring).
A square baking pan lined with parchment paper, filled with a pressed graham cracker crust. Text instructions detail preheating the oven, lining the pan, mixing crust ingredients, and pressing and baking the crumb mix.
Tie Dye Cheesecake Bars🌈
#rainbow #dessert #Cheesecake #food #fyp
Lex

Lex

642 likes

A person's side profile shows natural curly hair dyed a light brown/caramel color, pulled into a high ponytail. The image introduces ways to dye natural hair.
Four images display 'Peakaboo' hair dye styles: black hair with hidden sections of bright pink, orange, blue, and light brown color underneath.
Four images illustrate 'Skunk stripe' hair dye styles: black hair with prominent stripes of light brown, red, and blue color on top or in front.
Ways to dye your hair
#dyefreekids #dying my natural hair #black hair dye #didmyownhair Blick Art Materials not mines 🦄
naraeisbrown

naraeisbrown

222 likes

Why I Dye My Dogs Tail.
#dogdye #servicedog #tailproblems #dogsafety #servicedogproblems
Britt & Bjorn

Britt & Bjorn

3143 likes

Dye my eyelashes with me ✨
Warning, it says not to do this on the box but I have seen many people online doing this and I think it’s alright as long as you are careful not to get a bunch in your eye and are aware of it. This was my first time doing it and I’m happy with the results but the way they looked before I rinsed the
Daelyn07

Daelyn07

39 likes

Here are my top 3 worst test strand results 😮‍💨 Comment which of the 3 got you 🥴 👉🏼 Send this video to your bestie to get their reaction & follow for more Test strands can be life savers to make sure that your hair can handle the lightening process. We do test strands on clients who have visibl
hairbylima

hairbylima

1 like

Sock yarn dye
The sock yarn I dyed and am currently making a sock out of #wool yarn #yarn #handdyedyarn #tons of yarn to create with #uvreactive Great Falls
quirkyspools

quirkyspools

1983 likes

A 'before' image showing a person from behind with long, dark brown hair, indicating the starting point for an at-home box dye transformation to redhead.
An 'after' image showing a person from behind with long, wavy, vibrant red hair, showcasing the successful result of an at-home box dye transformation.
A close-up 'after' image of a person with long, straight, vibrant red hair, expressing satisfaction with the at-home box dye transformation.
Brunette to red (at home box dye)
#redhair #cherryredhair #hairdye #redhair #redhairinspo
Courtney

Courtney

11 likes

A young woman with long, bright red hair and dark roots takes a mirror selfie in a restroom. She wears a light blue crop top and dark pants, smiling while holding a phone with a white case. Her hair is styled with two small pigtails.
Well as i said… time for a Chop✂️ & Dye❤️
#fyp #hairstyles #red #haircare
Heaven🤍

Heaven🤍

648 likes

A person with long, layered black hair featuring vibrant red streaks, especially around the face. They are wearing a black mask, and the image has overlaid text asking "Should I Dye My Hair Guys?".
A person with long, wavy black hair styled with bright red face-framing streaks and layers. They have a nose piercing and are looking away from the camera.
A person with long, wavy black hair and striking red highlights, including face-framing pieces. They are wearing a black face mask and a necklace with a dark pendant.
Red and Black hair. Should I dye my black hair.
Curly black, with red streaks. I love this color. My hair would look so pretty. What are your guys ideas? #black hair dye #redhairblackgirl #dark hair #blackhaircolor #blackhairideas #red hair
Bea

Bea

145 likes

A person wearing blue gloves is applying bright pink dye to a long, wet wig, which is already vibrant pink. The image has text overlays "WATCH ME DYE MY HAIR PINK" and a "Swipe" arrow.
A person with bright pink wavy hair holds a phone to cover their face, while holding a large stack of money in their left hand, posing in front of a mirror.
Three bottles of KISS COLORS Semi-Permanent Tintation hair dye in shades Pink Petal, Pink Mania, and Hawaiian Fire are displayed on a surface, with a yellow bottle of got2b glued hairspray in the background.
Watch my dye my hair PINK🌸
New to Lemon8! Just found out about this app so let’s see how it goes😆 #hellolemon8 #pink hair #pinkhair #wiginfluencer #wigs #wiginstall #adorehairdye #pinkhairdye #beautyfinds
Aquarius Janay

Aquarius Janay

128 likes

DYE MY HAIR WITHOUT BLEACH 😳😻
#dyed hair #dyemyhairwithme #hairtips #redheadsdoitbetter #redhair
Smdsab

Smdsab

398 likes

A close-up of dark hair with vibrant blue highlights, styled in a half-up ponytail, showcasing a bold hair dye inspiration.
A person with long, voluminous, wavy light pink hair takes a mirror selfie, showing off a soft and colorful hair dye style.
The back view of a person's head, featuring dark hair with striking bright pink highlights styled in loose waves, offering a vivid hair dye idea.
Hair dye inspo I love to use
#lemon8diarychallenge Sometimes I get stumped with ideas so these help!!! ( from Pinterest )
Becca!!

Becca!!

312 likes

See more