Scary Short Story Competition Round Two!

Over the weekend, I had the joy and challenge of brainstorming and writing round two's scary short story for #nycmidnightshortstorychallenge . I've participated in their contests for years. I can safely say this prompt was the most difficult. It took my wife and me over a day to nail down the story. Every word counts when you have a 400 word limit. Shout out to my wife for her efforts as a soundboard and editing machine.

#authorsoftiktok #writing #writingcommunity #writingchallenge

1/13 Edited to

... Read moreWow, what a rollercoaster that NYC Midnight Short Story Challenge was! I mentioned how tough Round Two's prompt was, and I really wasn't kidding. For our story, tentatively titled 'Silent Hours,' the initial brainstorming felt like hitting a brick wall. My wife and I spent over 24 hours just trying to crack the concept. You know that feeling when you're staring at a blank screen, the cursor blinking, and nothing comes? That was us for a solid day. We tried everything – mind maps, free writing, even just talking through absurd scenarios. Eventually, something clicked, and we started building on a creepy concept that felt both fresh and genuinely unsettling. The 400-word limit is a beast in itself. Every single word has to earn its place, especially in a scary story where atmosphere and tension are everything. There's no room for fluff. It really forces you to be precise with your language, choosing verbs and adjectives that pack the most punch. We went through countless drafts, pruning sentences, cutting unnecessary descriptions, and making sure every moment contributed to the overall dread. My wife, truly an editing machine, was invaluable in this. Having a second pair of eyes, especially someone who understands the nuances of horror, is a game-changer. I vividly remember those long hours, hunched over my laptop at our outdoor glass table, often with our black dog quietly resting nearby, offering that much-needed companionship. It's funny how those small comforts can ground you when your mind is deep in the dark corners of a scary narrative. The pressure was real, knowing that an 'Upload Success!' message was the goal, confirming our entry into the Scary Story Challenge 2025. It's more than just writing a story; it's about pushing your creative boundaries under a strict deadline. For anyone thinking about entering a similar writing challenge, my biggest advice would be: embrace the struggle. The most difficult prompts often lead to the most creative solutions. Don't be afraid to step away, let ideas marinate, and then come back with fresh eyes. And seriously, if you can, find a writing partner or a trusted reader. Their perspective can illuminate things you completely missed. The satisfaction of finally hitting that 'submit' button, knowing you poured your heart into it, is just incredible. It's a reminder of why I love being part of this vibrant writing community.

1 comment

Related posts

A laptop screen displays the nycmidnight.com website, showing "Upload Success!" and a message confirming the successful submission of a story for the "Scary Story Challenge 2025."
Scary Short Story Competition!
I didn't participate in any of the competitions last year because so much was happening in my personal life. This year, though, they created a competition for horror stories specifically. I've had 48 hours to write a 400 word horror story with a given topic, character, and subject. It was a
Christopher P Beckman|Author

Christopher P Beckman|Author

6 likes

The image displays the title 'Scary Roblox Games To play during Halloween' in orange text, with a Roblox logo on a screen below, framed by spider web designs.
A Roblox game page for 'The Mimic' is shown on a screen, featuring a dark, red-toned image of a demonic character with glowing eyes.
The Roblox game page for 'Dead Silence [Horror]' is displayed on a screen, featuring a grayscale, close-up image of a distorted face peering through slats.
Scary Roblox games
#halloween2024 #lemon8contest #letschat
MECII

MECII

289 likes

The cover of the manga "Shadows of Kyoto" by Yumeya, featuring a woman in a white kimono standing before red torii gates and numerous stone statues, with the title prominently displayed.
A manga panel showing a woman with long dark hair, one side of her face grotesquely veined, holding a doll with a single eye. The title "Episode 1: The Hour of the Ox" is visible.
Manga panels depict a male vlogger at a shrine, first offering a can, then hammering a straw effigy into a wooden structure, hoping to film something scary.
a short horror manga with big potential
Title: Shadows of Kyoto Creator: Yumeya 📄 Plot: Its a collection of short horror stories centered around historic Kyoto landmarks; An irreverent vlogger, a class angel with an ugly heart, a greedy thief....all meet gnarly ends at the hands of the demonic tour guide Kotone. 📖 Genre: Horror
Mel3ficent

Mel3ficent

52 likes

Scary animated short👻👀
Reality Blurs: Monsters Escaped My VR Game! #shorts #scary #haunted #spooky #games
scarybio

scarybio

1 like

The image features a short scary story about a phone buzzing with "I SEE YOU" while being off, and a reflection moving. It includes "scary short story" and "HALLOWEEN" text with a pumpkin icon, set against a dark, cloudy sky with tree and house silhouettes.
scary short story
I love spooky, short stories, they keep so much in your imagination #halloween2024 #lemon8contest
Ashleigh 🫶🏻

Ashleigh 🫶🏻

8 likes

Scary animated short👻😱
Uncovering Memories: A Creepy TikTok Stunt From My Past! #horroranimation #scary #tiktokanimation #haunted #spooky
scarybio

scarybio

0 likes

Scary animated short👻👀
Found a Library Card, Uncovered a Dark Prediction... Run! #shorts #reels #scary #scarystories #haunted
scarybio

scarybio

3 likes

Journal: Amber episode 2 of 3
Chapter 1 — The Committee By Saturday afternoon, Ryan and Robbie had somehow convinced themselves that Amber’s invitation was their responsibility. I wasn’t sure how that happened. I definitely hadn’t asked for help. Yet there I was sitting in Robbie’s basement while the two of them pre
Kevin W. Simpson

Kevin W. Simpson

1 like

Three women, two in white dresses and one in a black dress, stand together against a light background. The title 'A Bond Broken' is overlaid in red text, symbolizing the story's theme of a fractured friendship.
A Bond Broken (short story)
#lemon8diarychallenge Chapter 1: The Perfect Competition Ava, Nina, and Jade had been inseparable since childhood. Their friendship had weathered high school crushes, college drama, and countless nights spent dreaming about their futures. When a high-profile wedding magazine announced a comp
Seize it

Seize it

20 likes

Scary Short Story
this is the title of a short story I wrote a couple years ago & made public today. visit Danika's Memory Box from the link in my bio & navigate to Short Stories from the menu up top to read! I look forward to hearing what you think ♡ #shortstory #scarystory #spookystories
Danika

Danika

0 likes

Scary animated short👻👀
Neighbors or nightmare?!!😱 #scary #horroranimation #haunted #spooky #hauntedplaces
scarybio

scarybio

1 like

Scary animated short👻😱
My Neighbor Looks Just Like Me... Until It Gets Creepy! #horrorstories #horroranimation #scary #haunted #creepy
scarybio

scarybio

9 likes

Scary short 👻👀
Haunted Music Box Reveals Dark Secrets from My Past! #shorts #reels #scary #scarystories #haunted
scarybio

scarybio

1 like

Scary animated short👻👀
Stranger's Sketchbook Reveals Dark Fate—Will I Be Next? #horroranimation #scary #haunted #spooky #spookyanimations
scarybio

scarybio

0 likes

Scary animated short👻👀
Grandpa’s Clock: A Countdown to My Dark Fate!! #scary #haunted #ghoststories #spooky #scarybio
scarybio

scarybio

0 likes

Romance short story rec
If you like sports, small town, low spice (with spicy banter), man in uniform, contemporary romance short stories, this one might be for you. 📖: Pinned #small town romance #romancebookrecs #kindleunlimitedromancebooks #contemporaryromance #sportsromancebooks
Kelly Renway | Author

Kelly Renway | Author

8 likes

Scary short👻👀
Online Friend or Stranger? My Terrifying Cafe Experience! 👻👀 #shorts #reels #scary #scarystories #haunted
scarybio

scarybio

1 like

Scary short 👀👻
Haunted by My Friendly Neighbor: A Chilling Encounter! #shorts #reels #scary #scarystories #neighborhood
scarybio

scarybio

2 likes

Scary animated short👻😱
Invited for Dinner: The Chilling Secret Behind Her Smiles! #horroranimation #scary #haunted #spooky #ghoststory
scarybio

scarybio

0 likes

Scary animation short👻👀
Meet Your Dark Doppelgänger: A Chilling Encounter Awaits! #horroranimation #scary #creepy #haunted #mystery
scarybio

scarybio

0 likes

Scary short👻👀
Are Numbers Warning Me? My Terrifying Countdown to Midnight! #reels #haunted #scarystories #storytime #shorts
scarybio

scarybio

1 like

True Scary Stalker Horror Story!
If you enjoyed check out the full video! #horrorstory #horrorstories #rcreepy #scary #truestory
Dexire

Dexire

13 likes

See more