The Book That Broke Me

"Oh Autumn."

On August 8‚ Phineas Smith died.

This is the book that got me back into reading but also broke me. I read the second one and Jacks POV broke me even more. I definitely recommend it but I am warning you that it will break you.

👍Pros:

Great Book about young love

🤔Cons:

It will absolutely Shatter your heart in a million different ways

it's a slow start but it gets better I promise

#ifhehadbeenwithme #tragiclovestory #ohfinny #booktok #reading #lastread #imwarningyou #youwillcry #2books

2024/10/27 Edited to

... Read moreIf you’re curious about the deep connection between Finny (Phineas Smith) and Autumn, this story truly captures the essence of youthful love and loss in a profoundly touching way. The narrative unfolds through perspectives that bring you closer to the characters' emotions, especially in the sequel where Jack's point of view adds another layer of depth. Learning that Finny died on August 8th adds a real sense of gravity and sorrow to the story, which is beautifully reflected in the writing and the heartfelt fanart shared by the community. What really stood out to me in my reading was how the author, Laura Nowlin, portrays Autumn’s unwavering presence and Finny’s devotion—this is not just romance, but a story about enduring admiration and the impact of love on our lives. For those wondering about Finny’s death and its impact, the book doesn't shy away from showing the shattering effects of grief and loss, making it a compelling read for anyone who has experienced heartbreak. I found that although it starts slow, the emotional payoff is worth it, and it kept me hooked through every twist and turn. If you want to dive deeper, exploring fanart of Finny and Autumn reveals how much this story resonates with readers worldwide, inspiring creative tributes that further express the themes of young love and tragedy. Whether you're a fan of tragic love stories or looking to get back into reading, this book offers a powerful experience that stays with you long after the last page.

14 comments

Lailah Sutler's images
Lailah Sutler

Oh my days, this book absolutely broke me. Chapter 84 I think it was “Finny?” “Oh autumn” that broke the shit out of me. I loved this book so much, if only they could have gotten more time together. For the second book I can not read it, I tried to read it and I really want to but I can not get into it

See more(3)

Related posts

A title card on a rainy cityscape background reads 'Books that broke me, then glued me back together!' from @that.bookish.mama on Lemon8, setting the theme for emotionally impactful book recommendations.
A book cover for 'Still Beating' by Jennifer Hartmann, showing chained hands, is presented on a rainy cityscape background. The text describes it as a dark, disturbing survival story that heals.
The book cover for 'Under Your Scars' by Ariel N. Anderson, featuring a gun with flowers, is displayed on a rainy cityscape. Text describes it as a raw journey through abuse, healing, and love.
Books that Broke me!
These books? Ruined me. Broke me in the best way possible. Had me questioning my morals and my standards. They are messy, emotional, and real. They’re not for the faint of heart — and that’s exactly why I’ll never stop recommending them. #sadbookrecs #booksthatchangedmylife #bookstha
✨🔥📚Kim📚🔥✨

✨🔥📚Kim📚🔥✨

403 likes

Sad book recs
Books that broke me💌 #booktok #bookrecs #bookish #sadbooks #bookrecommendations
MacK’s Books

MacK’s Books

8 likes

The Book That Broke The Internet | Book Summary
I kept seeing the book everywhere ! I usually don’t read trendy books (or atleast not often). But I had to see what the hype was about. I absolutely fell in love with it ! So if you are one of the few people who have not read it yet, PUT IT ON YOUR TBR. #booksummary 📚 Title & Author: Ho
Britttttttt✨

Britttttttt✨

34 likes

A book titled "Iron Flame" by Rebecca Yarros is on a shelf next to a plant. Overlay text reads: "A BOOK SO SMUTTY i HAD TO TAKE BREAKS."
Unhinged Book Read
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Spice Level: 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️ I don’t even know how to begin about this book. I’ve read a lot of books and I can confidently say that I have never read anything like this yet. The spice in this is unmatched and let me put it two words: THE CLAW.. ( iykyk 😉 ), and I think it bro
moodreadswithnicole 📚💭

moodreadswithnicole 📚💭

12.6K likes

A hand holds the book 'RED CITY' by Marie Lu, featuring a black lion design on a red cover, against a blurred city skyline. Text overlays read 'the newest trend in fantasy:' and 'ALCHEMY'.
An open book displays a quote about alchemy from 'The New Alchemist by Suzume Ito, 1996'. A red text overlay highlights 'alchemy is about that eternal ache in us for perfection.'
An open book shows a passage from 'RED CITY' discussing ambition and the feeling that 'everything suddenly feels less beautiful now'. A white text overlay repeats this quote.
✨ The Fantasy Book That BROKE Me ✨
I picked up Red City by Marie Lu and… I’m destroyed (in the best way). 🥹 From page nine I was already highlighting like crazy. This book is giving alchemy, power, corruption, love, grief, and the raw ache of wanting to be seen. Marie Lu weaves in history and science so seamlessly (gods as alchem
allee 📚🦠🤍

allee 📚🦠🤍

3 likes

A hand holds a sticker of Elsie Silver's books (Flawless, Heartless, Powerless, Reckless, Hopeless) over the cover of 'Heartless' by Elsie Silver. The book cover features a blue cowboy hat, guitar, and roses, with text 'A BOOK THAT BROKE ME' overlaid. Other books are visible on a shelf.
A book that broke me
I love Elsie silver and I promise it has a happy ending but wow it shattered me and put me back together lol #elsie silver #reading #books #romancebook #cowboy
Katie Jaine

Katie Jaine

99 likes

I hate this book
Look. This book broke my heart into a million pieces man. Like, stare at a wall for an hour because I needed to process everything. No spoilers. But lemme just say, if you want a book that’s gonna make your heart pound, whisper WTF to yourself every five seconds, make you cry, make you mad, sca
quinnireadssome

quinnireadssome

2217 likes

book lines that BROKE me❤️‍🩹❤️‍🩹❤️‍🩹
here are so books that caused me EXTREME emotional damage 🙂❤️‍🩹 there are other sad books, but these had lines that absolutely BROKE ME!!!! 1. daisy haites: the great undoing, jessa hastings 2. normal people, sally rooney 3. exodus, kate stewart 4. love and other words, christina lauren 5
Koko Kingston🩵

Koko Kingston🩵

20 likes

a poem that broke me —
📖: The Pain of Healing #heartbreak #lemon8books #poetrybook #poetry #poems
Samantha Camargo

Samantha Camargo

92 likes

BookTok says these thrillers broke readers’ brains
These thriller book recommendations had mind-blowing plots that made them popular topics on BookTok. Now they’re also getting noticed on BooksofLemon8! Some great thriller books for your TBR! #thrillerbooks #bookrecommendation #booksonlemon8 #thrillerbookrecs #booktok
Thriller Books Recs

Thriller Books Recs

126 likes

The Books That Broke Me 💔
#hauntingadeline #catandmouseduet #zademeadows #zadeandadiline #bookthatbrokemyheart
⊹.˚Jaedyn’s Booktok˚₊⊹

⊹.˚Jaedyn’s Booktok˚₊⊹

52 likes

2 book series that broke me
#lemon8bookclub #lemon8bookreview #books that made me cry
Hadley

Hadley

94 likes

A book that broke me🐦‍⬛🌧️😭
If you haven’t read the ravenhood series by Kate Stewart I definitely recommend reading 📖 you’ve been warned tho 😭 Looking for book recommendations that will take me on an emotional rollercoaster ride drop them below pleaseeeee📖 #theravenhoodseries #bookrecs #lemon8challenge #lemon8boo
MamaSelf

MamaSelf

5 likes

The book 'I Will Teach You To Be Rich' by Ramit Sethi, a New York Times Bestseller with over 1 million copies in print, is shown. The cover highlights it as a 6-week program with 'No Guilt. No Excuses. No BS.' Text overlay says 'This Book Simplified Money for Me!'
An open page from 'I Will Teach You To Be Rich' discusses 'Five Steps to Getting Rid of Credit Card Debt,' including prioritizing debt. An overlay states, 'Looking to get out of Debt? The Author Ramit Sethi breaks down simple plans on how and what ways this can be done.'
An open page from 'I Will Teach You To Be Rich' shows Chapter 3, 'GET READY TO INVEST,' explaining how to open 401(k) and Roth IRA accounts. An overlay reads, 'Breaks down what investing is and how to get the best outcome. Teaches your step by step how to get started!'
This Book Simplified Money for Me!
#moneybooks #iwillteachyoutoberich #booksonfinance #budgeting #budgetingforbeginners This book is like my BIBLE for finance! It has helped me so much during my financial journey and it helped me understand how the game of credit card works and how to avoid getting into debt. It teaches
Ana Benitez

Ana Benitez

36 likes

The book that broke my book buying ban
I couldn’t help myself…it’s so cute😭 Since this book is not on KU and I really want to read it, I decided to go to Barnes and noble to purchase it. I have heard so many good things about it from friends and mutuals and I just knew I had to have it. I can’t wait to get to it. Have you read th
Spookyrevioos

Spookyrevioos

31 likes

Books that broke me💔📚
POV: You’re still recovering from these romantasy books that shattered your heart 💔✨ Supernatural love hits different… Which one wrecked you the most? 👀 #RomantasyReads #BookTok #SupernaturalRomance #bookrecommendations #booklover
livdümer

livdümer

89 likes

A page from a poetry book titled "3/21/22," featuring a poem about wanting to destroy journals and evidence of absence for a single conversation, with the last four lines highlighted.
A page from a poetry book titled "The First Week of College," with a poem reflecting on college life and the highlighted lines about accepting sadness as temporary.
A page from a poetry book displaying four numbered verses, with the fourth verse highlighted, stating that someone writing about being saved wouldn't think things won't improve.
these book quotes broke me
this book broke me, then put me back together again 🥲 book: Holding the Moon With Lavender Hands by Kai McCarthy #bookquotes #poetry #poem #BookReview #quotes
chloe henkel

chloe henkel

205 likes

The book that broke me
Don’t know why I slept on this for so long! It’s so good, so sad but so good ♥️
Samiimarie

Samiimarie

0 likes

The book that ruined me (in the best way)
Alchemised by SenLinYu I don’t even know how to put into words what this book did to me. It completely unraveled me in the best and worst ways. Kaine has my whole heart…I’m not getting it back…and Helena? She is strength, resilience, and depth all wrapped into one unforgettable character.
Ash | Art & Life

Ash | Art & Life

15 likes

The book cover for Lucinda Berry's psychological thriller 'Phantom Limb' shows a dark pink teddy bear on a wet, dark ground with scattered leaves. An audio player interface below displays the book title and author.
The book that broke my brain 🤯
I’ve always loved Lucinda Berry’s books—her psychological thrillers never disappoint. Usually, the twists leave me unsettled but not completely shocked… but THIS ONE? 🤯 My head was spinning the whole time! The disorder featured in the story had me asking myself, can someone really live with this? I
Thrillville

Thrillville

7 likes

A book titled "To Bleed a Crystal Bloom" by Sarah A. Parker rests on a white bedspread, next to a wooden tray with decorative items. A pink text bubble overlays the image, stating "Book series I want to continue."
Three book covers are displayed: "Throne of Glass" by Sarah J. Maas, "To Bleed a Crystal Bloom" by Sarah A. Parker, and "It Happened One Summer" by Tessa Bailey. Each cover is accompanied by a text bubble describing the user's intent to continue reading the series.
Three book covers are shown: "Nightshade" by Keri Lake, "The Bridge Kingdom" by Danielle L. Jensen, and "Leaves May Fall" by Carissa Hardcastle. Each cover is paired with a text bubble explaining the user's desire to continue the series.
Book series I want to continue
Throne of glass I’ve read 3 books of this series but want to continue to see what all the hype is about. I don’t love it yet but I’ll continue it. To bleed a crystal bloom I’m currently reading book two from this series because I really enjoyed book one. There’s so much mystery to this romant
Spookyrevioos

Spookyrevioos

26 likes

Book Flights Without Going Broke,Thank Me later ✈️💚
Y’all still letting flight prices hold you hostage? Not on this side. ✊🏾💅🏽 It’s Juneteenth and I’m choosing freedom, flexibility, and Black-owned solutions. ✨ Airfordable lets you lock in your flight NOW and pay over time — with no credit check. But don’t get it twisted: you gotta pay it off bef
Ji’Rah 🎀

Ji’Rah 🎀

297 likes

A Book that will break your heart💔
A book that will leave your heart completely broken! This is the second book to If He Had Been With Me. I have been waiting for this book for so long to come out to get the second POV! I just started reading this book a couple of days ago and I already know this book is going to leave me in
Daniella Marie

Daniella Marie

47 likes

a poem that broke me
📖: The Pain of Healing 💛 #grief #lemon8books #poetry #imissyou #poetrybook
Samantha Camargo

Samantha Camargo

9 likes

The book that broke me..
The things this book did to my brain.. I haven’t been able to function in over a month.. If you like emotional damage.. join me.. Start with Book 1- Falling In Reverse by @hazelgraceauthor #bookrecommendations #emotionaldamage #chaoskills #seduceanddestroy #hazelgrace
The_Page_Escape

The_Page_Escape

1 like

Black FMC Romance Book
Sis, if you’re into bad boys who end people for a living, are unpredictable and unhinged, and work for her dad as a contractor, you’re in for a wild ride. That’s exactly why they broke up the first time—when she found out what he really did. Want to know if she’s getting back with him or ready for
Inkitt Books 📚

Inkitt Books 📚

32 likes

Book that trip!!
Delusion is a travel hack actually #flightsnotfeels #travel #vacation #delulu #peru
Claire Hunter

Claire Hunter

13 likes

A purple binder with gold text and designs, featuring a crown, dollar signs, and floral patterns. The text on the cover reads "BROKE-ISH & BOUGIE".
A collage of various savings challenge sheets, including designs for $425, $3300, 100K, and 2K challenges. Text indicates "OVER 20+ SAVINGS CHALLENGES" and "INCLUDES CUSTOM CHALLENGES; CREATE YOUR OWN".
An open savings challenge book page with a "MWHA" theme, featuring lipstick and kiss mark designs. Various dollar amounts are listed, totaling $4250. Text reads "Savings Journey Starts Here ! SINGLE CHALLENGES, TWO PAGES".
Introducing Broke-ish & Bougie Challenge Book
💸 New savings challenge book ✨ Motivates you to save $500, $1,000, or even $10K 👜 For the girlies who need to save 💻 https://walletwhisperer.etsy.com/listing/4330856292 #BrokeishAndBougie #BudgetBabe #GlowUpGoals #SavingsChallengeBook #walletwhisperer
Wallet Whisperer

Wallet Whisperer

273 likes

Book quotes got me like…
Kai Azer… the man that you are. 🥰 That ending broke my heart. #bookquotes #book #books #booktok #booksoflemon8
Jess Read With Me 📖

Jess Read With Me 📖

2 likes

A bookshelf filled with books, featuring text overlays that read: "People are sharing the books that got them out of deep, deep, DEEP reading slumps. Here are the top 18."
A bookshelf background with six book covers displayed, including "The Housemaid," "The Martian," "The Butcher's Wife," "The Nightingale," "Verity," and "Rewind."
A bookshelf background with six book covers displayed, including "Lies and Bones," "The Lying Game," "The Sun Down Motel," "The Girl on the Train," "The Investigator," and "Drowned at Dawn."
People are sharing books that broke their readies
Break your reading slump with one of these thriller books—some great book recommendations from Booktok! #bookrecommendation #BookReview #bookrecs #booksoflemon8 #booktok
Great Thriller Reads

Great Thriller Reads

146 likes

I bought this vintage Louis Vuitton at BookOff
I bought this vintage Louis Vuitton at BookOff in Japan for about ¥30,000 (roughly $200 USD) while we were vintage designer bag shopping. I started using it immediately, and a few months later the strap broke… which forced a decision I didn’t expect to make. When you buy secondhand designer,
Salty Vagabonds

Salty Vagabonds

353 likes

Book ruined me before chapter 10 💞
#lemon8dairy I love a happy ending but I also love those books that really get me in my feelings, you know those books that break your heart and make you feel all the emotions: This book did that for me this book had me em ugly crying so bad I couldn’t put it down. This book broke my heart into a
Liliana | TBR Chaos CEO 📚

Liliana | TBR Chaos CEO 📚

76 likes

I already broke my book buying ban 🤫
I have books on my shelf that still need to be read but I couldn’t wait… - the ninth house has been on my tbr and when I saw it I just had to get it plus it is gorgeous omg - I’ve been waiting for Katee Robert to release this I’m already a few chapters in and I’m intrigued #shareyourthoughts
Itslyssa271

Itslyssa271

7 likes

SPRING BREAK BOOK RECS !!
Spring break = the perfect time to catch up on reading! Here are 5 recommendations for you this year 😌 1) Happy Place by Emily Henry A great story about navigating adult relationships and friendships, and connecting with those close to you. The book takes place on a vacation/trip, which is perf
cam !!

cam !!

36 likes

Barnes & Noble book shopping spree haul!
Ahhh I’m broke now😭 #bookhaul #barnes & noble #book shopping 🛒 #lovehypothesis #loveonthebrain #lovetheoretically #thedooverbook #likecatsanddogs #theneighborfavor #collide
Ava urban🪩

Ava urban🪩

1273 likes

An open book, "Stay Until Tomorrow" by Jacqueline Whitney, displaying text on the right page: "This is your sign to stay another day. Take it one tomorrow at a time. Peace is never as far as it feels. You deserve to see another tomorrow. Stay."
An open book, "Stay Until Tomorrow" by Jacqueline Whitney, showing text on the right page: "Even after everything you have been through, you are still here. You should be so proud of how far you have come."
An open book, "Stay Until Tomorrow" by Jacqueline Whitney, displaying a full page of text offering encouragement and hope for healing, emphasizing that things will get better with time and grace.
A book that heals
📚✨ "Stay Until Tomorrow" by Jacqueline Whitney is a journey of hope and healing. 🌅 With every page, we dive into the complexities of love, loss, and second chances. 💔💖 Join me as I unravel the emotions and insights this beautiful story offers! What were your thoughts on it? Let's ch
Jenna Weems

Jenna Weems

115 likes

My Honest Book Review!
The Fabric Of Our Souls by K.M. Moronova. ⚠️No Spoilers⚠️ I thought this book was really good. It’s a fast paced standalone (there is a spin off coming out soon) but I personally liked that even though it was fast paced it didn’t feel rushed. I truly could not put this book down and I think t
emy_h0pe

emy_h0pe

9 likes

book with their movies📖🎬
1. all the bright places~ really good very emotional both the book and the movie i cried a lot they’re both 10s but if i only had to choose one it would be the movie for me personally 2. if i stay~ i watched the movie first then i read the book but the movie is good and the book is also very good
kia🫧🎧📖

kia🫧🎧📖

230 likes

This Book Broke My Heart & I LOVED It 🥹🖤
Crying in H Mart by Michelle Zauner has been at the top of bestseller charts for what feels like ages, and it's well deserved. A memoir read and loved by so many, it's written by the musician behind Japanese Breakfast. Her entry into music and the beginnings of her performing career are tou
autumnintheoaks

autumnintheoaks

60 likes

A tablet displays the cover of "Tarnished Tyrant" by Nicole Fox, featuring a tattooed man in a suit. The tablet rests on dark fabric, surrounded by red flowers and small lit candles, creating a dark romance aesthetic for the book review.
𝑩𝒐𝒐𝒌 𝑹𝒆𝒗𝒊𝒆𝒘♥
𝑻𝒂𝒓𝒏𝒊𝒔𝒉𝒆𝒅 𝑻𝒚𝒓𝒂𝒏𝒕 & 𝑻𝒂𝒓𝒏𝒊𝒔𝒉𝒆𝒅 𝑸𝒖𝒆𝒆𝒏 ♥ By nicolefoxromance I loved these books and will not take any criticism on them what so ever. Nikolai and Belle have my heart. 𝑻𝒂𝒓𝒏𝒊𝒔𝒉𝒆𝒅 𝑻𝒚𝒓𝒂𝒏𝒕, Nikolai is part of the Bravata (not mafia, please respect his wishes 🤣) without giving anything truly aw
𝔅𝔯𝔦𝔱𝔱♡

𝔅𝔯𝔦𝔱𝔱♡

7 likes

A book titled 'They Both Die at the End' by Adam Silvera is displayed, featuring a night city skyline cover. The image includes 'Book Review' text, a pink heart, and a '5/5⭐️' rating, along with the Lemon8 username.
Book Review - they both die at the end
Book Review Book name: They Both Die at the end Author: Adam Silvera Genre: YA My rating: 5/5⭐️ My review: Honestly I had high expectations for this book and they did not disappoint. This is the most beautiful and heart breaking book I’ve read so far this year. I love the friendship between
Hasina

Hasina

24 likes

See more