Vanilla protein ice cream sandwich

2025/8/6 Edited to

... Read moreHey sweet tooths! You know that feeling when you're desperately craving something sweet but don't want to derail your healthy eating goals? That's exactly why I had to share my new favorite dessert hack: these incredible 3-ingredient protein ice cream sandwiches! They're not just easy; they're genuinely delicious and so satisfying. I stumbled upon this recipe when I was looking for a quick post-workout treat, and it quickly became a staple. The best part? You probably have most of the ingredients already. All you need is some zero sugar whipped topping, your favorite protein powder (I love vanilla for this!), and a box of honey graham crackers. That’s it! Making them is a breeze. First, I grabbed my trusty clear rectangular glass baking dish. I found that a 9x13 inch dish works perfectly for a batch, but you can adjust based on how many you want to make. I started by layering those delicious graham crackers neatly at the bottom, making sure they covered the entire surface as much as possible. Don't worry if there are small gaps; the filling will take care of that. Next, for the 'ice cream' part, I combined the whipped topping and protein powder in a bowl. This is where you can get a little creative! While vanilla protein powder is my go-to for that classic ice cream sandwich vibe, I've also tried chocolate protein powder for a richer treat. Just fold them together gently with a pink spatula until it's well combined and has a smooth, creamy consistency. You want it fluffy but firm enough to spread. Once that's ready, I carefully spread a generous layer of the protein mixture over the graham cracker base. I try to make it as even as possible so each sandwich is packed with flavor. Then, I add another layer of graham crackers on top, pressing down gently to ensure everything is nicely compact. Now comes the hardest part: waiting! I usually pop a red lid over my baking dish and place it in the freezer for at least three hours, but honestly, overnight is even better. This allows everything to firm up perfectly, making it much easier to cut. When it's time to enjoy, I just take it out, separate the corners carefully, and then use a sharp knife to cut the frozen block into individual protein ice cream sandwiches. I usually aim for squares or rectangles, but you can get creative with shapes too! These little gems are perfect for satisfying those "kinder ice cream sandwich" cravings without all the extra sugar. They're a fantastic way to get some extra protein in, and because they use graham crackers, they have that classic, comforting taste. Plus, making them at home means you know exactly what's going into them. If you're looking for a simple, delicious, and healthier alternative to traditional store-bought treats or just a tasty "graham bar plain" style dessert, you absolutely have to give these a try. Let me know what protein powder flavors you experiment with!

Related posts

HEALTHY ICE CREAM SANDWICHES 🍨
Healthy Homemade Ice Cream Sandwiches Who else has some crazily nostalgia looking back at their childhood and eating ice cream sandwiches?! I don’t mean to toot my own horn, but these are literally most delicious ice cream sandwiches I’ve ever had and taste better than the store-bought junk!!
Katie 👩🏻‍🍳

Katie 👩🏻‍🍳

2375 likes

🍓HIGH PROTEIN STRAWBERRIES & CREAM JARS
This makes 2 servings at 195 calories, 31 grams protein a serving. You can make it into 3-4 servings if you prefer, too! This is great for a day you want a sweet treat without the sugar and blood sugar spikes. I used cottage cheese and Greek yogurt as the base, blended it with strawberries an
Shredhappens

Shredhappens

7306 likes

Honey 🍯 Vanilla Frozen Yogurt in the Ninja Creami
Honey is a perfect spring flavor and as the weather gets warmer, this will be my go-to! I used grocery store honey for this batch, but I’ll be trying it again with some different honey varieties. Honey can create such a unique flavor profile! Ingredients —— 1 & 1/8 cup (255g) Greek yogu
Murial

Murial

1672 likes

Chocolate covered strawberries protein Shake
Today’s protein shake was so good and only 250 calories!! Let me show you how to make it. Ingredients: -110g frozen strawberries -1 scoop chocolate protein powder or vanilla protein powder mixed with 2 tablespoons of cocoa powder -11g of semi sweet chocolate chips (optional for garnish) -1
IvannaCarolina

IvannaCarolina

7033 likes

Protein Wendy’s Frosty!! 🤍🤎
This was SO frickin good, here is how I made it with my ninja creami. In an empty creami container mix: •half chocolate milk •half vanilla core power 🤍 •tablespoon of sugar free jell-o mix use the “lite ice cream” setting. After, add a splash of chocolate milk and hit “re spin” I didn’t e
mya lina

mya lina

2543 likes

Protein ice cream sandwiches
Protein Ice Cream Sandwiches – the ultimate guilt-free treat! These creamy, protein-packed sandwiches are the perfect way to satisfy your sweet tooth while staying on track. Ingredients: Cool Whip 1/2 cup PB fit or two scoops protein powder Graham Crackers 1/2 cup chocolate chips #icecre
asipoftexas

asipoftexas

2157 likes

Banana Caramel Pecan Protein Shake
Ok.. my new obsession is making a different flavor protein shake every day so here’s today’s recipe! 😍 This protein shake reminded me of my favorite banana split from Basking Robbin’s let me show you how I made it. Ingredients: - 1 scoop of your favorite vanilla protein powder - 65g of non fa
IvannaCarolina

IvannaCarolina

2791 likes

High Protein Ninja Creami Oreo Blizzard
*approx 400 calories with 38 grams of protein for the entire pint* you can eat this WHOLE PINT guilt free and still reach your goals❤️ 🍦okios 20 grams protein yogurt 🍦1/2 scoop protein powder 🍦2 tbsp unsweetened almond milk 🍦mini oreos (i add them after blending my base) ENJOY ❤️
Makenna Gerres

Makenna Gerres

1084 likes

Protein “ice cream” yes please!
Protein Mint Oreo Ice Cream >>> 💚😮‍💨 Save this for later & follow @jfiteats for recipes I don’t know about yall, but I love ice cream and I love oreos. Some things you just can’t give upppp Here’s how to make it ⬇️ Cottage Cheese @oikos Plain Greek Yogurt Vanilla Hon
Jazmyhn Catlin

Jazmyhn Catlin

4254 likes

Protein Banana Cream Pudding!
Such a quick and easy protein dessert idea! Saw others mix in yogurt and protein powder and thought why not just use protein yogurt! Turned out fantastic! I bet if I popped a bowl of it into the freezer it would come out very well! I would have added some cool whip if I had any 😞, but it tastes awe
Pretzel

Pretzel

1617 likes

Healthy Cookie Dough Ice Cream Sandwiches 🍪🍪
Healthy Cookie Dough Ice Cream Sandwiches 🍪🍫 https://cookingkatielady.com/recipe/cookie-dough-ice-cream-sandwiches/ 👩🏻‍🍳INGREDIENTS: 👉Base: 3/4 cup creamy cashew butter 1/4 cup organic maple syrup 🍁 1/2 tsp vanilla extract 1 cup organic almond flour 1/8 tsp fine sea salt 🧂 45g organi
Katie 👩🏻‍🍳

Katie 👩🏻‍🍳

399 likes

Protein ice cream sandwiches
PROTEIN ICE CREAM SANDWICHES 2 cups almond flour 4 tbsp oat flour 1/2 cup sunflower seed butter 4 tbsp maple syrup 4 tbsp almond milk 2 tsp vanilla extract Pinch of salt 1/2 cup mini chocolate chips 1 tub coconut whip 1/2 cup birthday cake protein powder In a bowl, mix together
Victoria Tschopp

Victoria Tschopp

623 likes

Protein Birthday Cake Bliss Ice Cream🍦
This birthday cake ice cream is high in protein and low in calories, and it’s a perfect way to treat yourself without compromising your goals and it’s pure perfection 😋 Here’s what you need for a Deluxe Ninja Creami Pint 🍦 14oz vanilla Fairlife Core Protein shake 🍦 1 scoop CSE Birthday Cake p
Mykayla Braun

Mykayla Braun

1636 likes

Healthy Cookie Dough Ice Cream Sandwiches
Healthy Cookie Dough Ice Cream Sandwiches 🍪🍫 @Lemon8 Food https://cookingkatielady.com/recipe/cookie-dough-ice-cream-sandwiches/ 👩🏻‍🍳INGREDIENTS: 👉Base: 3/4 cup creamy cashew butter 1/4 cup organic maple syrup 🍁 1/2 tsp vanilla extract 1 cup organic almond flour 1/8 tsp fine sea
Katie 👩🏻‍🍳

Katie 👩🏻‍🍳

410 likes

On the go high protein low cal meals!
Are you trying to hit your protein goal but on the go? Don’t compromise your protein and calories , fast food low calorie high protein meals! #lowcaloriehighprotein #macros #protein #lowcaloriefood #fastfood #chickfila #panera #wendys #mcdonalds #pandaexpress
Tierrad3

Tierrad3

6243 likes

Protein Peanut Butter Ice Cream Recipe
Ingredients: 16 oz (453 g) cottage cheese 2 tablespoons (30 g) peanut butter 2 tablespoons (30 g) honey 1 teaspoon (5 g) vanilla extract Optional swaps: 1/2 to 1 cup fruit (about 75 to 150 g) instead of peanut butter and vanilla 2 tablespoons cocoa powder for chocolate version #cottagecheeseicec
Crave Times

Crave Times

74 likes

Protein Oreo ice cream sandwich🍦🍫
128cals & 3.6g protein #proteinideas #highproteinsweets #dessert #highproteinideas
Lainey

Lainey

309 likes

Cookies & Cream Pancake Donuts
You’re welcome 🍩 Macro friendly, high protein, and delicious! Lethal combo 🫦🤤 Ingredient breakdown - 116g of pancake mix - 1 scoop of protein powder - 2 eggs - 10 sandwich cookies - 1/2 cup of almond milk - 59 g of protein frosting - 2 tsp of vanilla paste Enjoy!💗 #foodier
chiamakafitbalance

chiamakafitbalance

17.8K likes

High Protein, Low Calorie Snacks ✨
Left to Right LEMON CHEESECAKE 🍋 - 299 calories 27.7g protein • Lemon Pudding Mix - 8g • Cheesecake Jello - 7g • Oikos Pro 23g Protein - 200g • Nilla Wafers - 21g BANANA PUDDING 🍌 - 214 calories 17g protein • Banana Crème Pudding Mix - 8g • Oikos Triple Zero 15g Protein : Banana Cre
Sav 🐥

Sav 🐥

3835 likes

High Protein Cake Batter Ice Cream
No matter the season, I will be enjoying a protein ice cream 🤣 Especially if I don’t have to feel guilty for eating the whole thing! This cake batter protein ice cream has 41g protein per pint & only 7g fat compared to store bought pints which are usually around 20g fat and 7g protein!
Lyss

Lyss

1427 likes

Birthday Cake Ice Cream in the Ninja Creami 🍦
Birthday Cake Ice Cream in the Ninja Cream🧁 Ingredients: 1 Vanilla Fairlife Protein Shake 2 tbsp Sugar Free Vanilla Pudding Mix 1/2 tsp Cake Batter Flavor Extract Instructions: 1. Add all to Ninja Creami Container 2. Mix to get out all of the clumps - I like to use a milk brother 3. Fr
Katherine Salom

Katherine Salom

2286 likes

Cookie Dough Ice Cream Sandwiches
Healthy Cookie Dough Ice Cream Sandwiches 🍪🍫 👩🏻‍🍳INGREDIENTS: 👉Base: 3/4 cup creamy cashew butter 1/4 cup organic maple syrup 🍁 1/2 tsp vanilla extract 1 cup organic almond flour 1/8 tsp fine sea salt 🧂 45g organic dark chocolate (roughly chopped) 1 scoop protein powder for high protei
Katie 👩🏻‍🍳

Katie 👩🏻‍🍳

54 likes

Protein Reese’s “ice cream” sandwich🤤
Recipe: (makes 8: 133cals & 8g protein) 101g cool whip 1 scoop vanilla protein powder 9 Reese’s minis 8 graham crackers total (4 for bottom & 4 for the top) #proteinsnacks #dessert #proteindessert #lowcal
Lainey

Lainey

227 likes

Ice cream while in a calorie deficit?
If you’re on a weight loss journey and struggle with trying to control your sweet tooth, Then these are perfect sis! Plus, these are low-calorie to help you stay in a calorie deficit to still be able to lose weight. I’ve said it 1 million times before but Yasso and TruFru get alllllll of my coins.
Que

Que

2392 likes

Ninja Creami Reese’s PB Protein Ice Cream
I personally love the Ninja Creami and use it almost every day!! Here’s one of my favorite recipes!! ICE CREAM BASE: - 2 cups Unsweetened Vanilla Almond Milk - 2 scoops Peanut Cookie Herbalife Protein Drink Mix - 1 tsp vanilla extract *mix and freeze for 24 hours then blend MIX INS:
Haydipattonc12!

Haydipattonc12!

76 likes

Viral Ice Cream Sandwich Hack Appetizer
Serving these ice cream sandwiches will biggest ice cream hack that will impress your friends! You can make mini fried ice cream sandwiches to serve at your next party or get together with friends or family. I explain in the video how to make them, but the ingredients you need are: Vanilla
Safeezygal

Safeezygal

7217 likes

Healthy Ice Cream Sandwiches 🍫
Healthy Homemade Ice Cream Sandwiches @Lemon8 Food Who else has some crazily nostalgia looking back at their childhood and eating ice cream sandwiches?! I don’t mean to toot my own horn, but these are literally most delicious ice cream sandwiches I’ve ever had and taste better than the
Katie 👩🏻‍🍳

Katie 👩🏻‍🍳

193 likes

Super Easy Vanilla Protein Pudding Cups
A super creamy high protein vanilla pudding that makes a delicious multi-functional snack! These mini pudding cups are so simple to make – just 5 minutes to prep and you’ve got a nutritious treat with 16+ grams of protein. Full recipe and nutrition (or click link in bio): https://moderatel
Alex, MS, RD | Nutrition

Alex, MS, RD | Nutrition

180 likes

Healthy Ice Cream Sandwiches!
No bake, gluten free, vegan friendly ice cream sandwiches! Creamy vanilla protein ice cream, sandwiched between melt-in-your-mouth brownie dough squares, and perfectly complimented with a peanut butter chocolate drizzle 🤌🏻 #icecreamsandwich #summerdesserts #vegandesserts #glutenfreedes
Colleen Forton

Colleen Forton

317 likes

Healthier Oreo Protein Shake
An Oreo protein shake that tastes similar to a milkshake but without all the calories and sugar! It's creamy, thick and packed with Oreo flavor. Try this for a healthier snack or dessert. This recipe makes one 16-18 ounce shake. INGREDIENTS 3-4 Oreo sandwich cookies, plus more for garnish
Alex, MS, RD | Nutrition

Alex, MS, RD | Nutrition

120 likes

How To Hit 140g Protein Consistently 🍓💅
Finally a high protein roadmap that actually feels like a lifestyle. ✨ Hitting 140g of protein is the "secret sauce" for fat loss and hormone health, but nobody tells you how to do it without the burnout. We’ve mapped it out so you can look hot AND feel amazing in your body. 🦢 The Roa
Pretty Nourish

Pretty Nourish

108 likes

Soft Cake Sandwich
Ingredients Cake 50 g vegetable oil (1/4 cup) 50 g milk (1/4 cup) 55 g cake flour (1/2 cup & 1 tbsp) 5 eggs (each egg about 56g) 50 g granulated sugar (1/4 cup) 5 g lemon juice (1 tbsp) 5 g vanilla extract (1 tbsp) If you cannot find low-protein flour: 1/4 cup vegetable oil 1/4 cup m
Jessica | soft cake & u-taste

Jessica | soft cake & u-taste

1945 likes

Cookie Butter Ninja Creami protein ice cream
i have been having so much fun experimenting with different Ninja Creami recipes, and this one is my favorite yet. 🤭 Ingredients • 1.5 tbsp of sugar free butterscotch jello pudding mix (this is key! i will be adding a sugar free jello mix into all of my future recipes.) • 3/4 of a fairlife cor
avavescovi

avavescovi

1025 likes

Protein Ice Cream Recipes
Ever since getting a Ninja Creami Machine, I have become obsessed with creating different protein ice cream recipes. These recipes have anywhere from 25-40g protein. Super helpful when trying to hit your protein intake! My typical base for the Creamis is: ~ 240ml Almond Milk ~ 1 scoop of Van
Madison Johnson

Madison Johnson

1046 likes

Healthier Ice-cream Picks
Craving ice cream but want a healthier option? These low calorie, high protein and dairy free choices lets you enjoy your sweet treat guilt free. Here are some of the best healthy ice-creams you can grab on your next grocery run. Halo Top (Low-Cal, High-Protein) Around 280-360 calories per pin
Beauty

Beauty

1784 likes

HIGH PROTEIN LOW CAL ICE CREAM
do you love ice cream??🍦 i know i do!!! if there is one thing i learned in my fitness journey it’s that there is a healthy alternative to anything out there!! i use to be someone (and still am) who needs a sweet before i go to bed!! as soon as i found out about this ice cream i was amazed!! f
madifore

madifore

584 likes

PROTEIN PEACH ICE CREAM 🍦 🍑
#proteinicecreamrecipe #ninja creami #highproteinicecream #more protein w lots of flavor #proteindip Peach cobbler protein ice cream recipe: Overall rating: ⭐️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 1. Blend together, cottage cheese, heavy cream, vanilla, cinnamon, nutmeg, and the canned peach juice. 2. A
Livy🪐✨

Livy🪐✨

57 likes

Animal Cookies protein ice cream
INGREDIENTS • Vanilla Fairlife Core Power Shake • 1 Tbsp Sugar Free Vanilla Pudding • 1 tsp Almond Extract • 28g of Frosted Animal Cookies Let me know if you give this one a try!!! #ninjacreami #ninjacreamirecipe #proteinicecream #fairlifeproteinshakes #highproteindessert #high
Britni Wukasch

Britni Wukasch

17 likes

protein CAKE BATTER ICE CREAM!🧁
the cold stone cake batter ice cream is TOP TIER and I tried my best to copy that but make it protein version! I wish I had bites of vanilla cake to toss in which would have elevated this ice cream so much more!! ingredients: 🧁vanilla fairlife protein shake (24g of protein) 🧁2 tablespoons cake
ganna sumar

ganna sumar

464 likes

Cookies & Cream Protein Shake
Creamy, indulgent, and packed with protein — a smooth vanilla base blended with crushed cookies for a dessert-style shake that supports recovery while satisfying sweet cravings. #quickrecipes #fyp #food #protein #healthy
FitBiteNutrition

FitBiteNutrition

365 likes

Sea Salt + Honey Protein Ice Cream 🍯
Low Calorie, High Protein Sea Salt & Honey Ice Cream 🍨 🍯 @Lemon8 Food https://cookingkatielady.com/recipe/honey-sea-salt-protein-ice-cream-ninja-creami/ Low Calorie, High Protein Sea Salt & Honey Ice Cream 🍨 🍯 👩🏻‍🍳INGREDIENTS: 16 oz low fat cottage cheese 1/4 cup organic ho
Katie 👩🏻‍🍳

Katie 👩🏻‍🍳

400 likes

S’more Ice Cream Sandwich Recipe🍫
That s’more everyone loves, but make it cold.😋 This is an easy no bake dessert for you and yours to enjoy on these hot summer days! Let’s make it!👇 🤍YOU NEED: 2 sleeves of Graham crackers Regular size tub of vanilla ice cream, sat out for a bit to soften. Ice cream fudge, or chocolate crackle📝
Emerald.💗

Emerald.💗

733 likes

vanilla sweet cream protein coffee
what are your favorite protein coffee recipes? :) #proteincoffee #proteinicedcoffee #proteinideas #glp1 #coffee
𝚍𝚊𝚗𝚊 ☆ミ

𝚍𝚊𝚗𝚊 ☆ミ

587 likes

See more