I plan on posting a youtube video about it but here’s what I did:
Day 1:
1 cup of White Lily bread flour in a clean jar
1/2 if bottled water (i used a bit more. You’re looking for a thick pancake consistency so start with less and add more if you need to!)
Day 2:
discard half (i threw it away. Dont keep it right now, it contains bad bacteria)
1/2 of bread flour
1/4 cup of bottled water
I noticed it had already doubled in size here but it wasn’t yet active until it’s doubled in size twice in a row.
Day 3:
Same as day 2 and it rose within hours!
I plan on repeating the feeding process every day and keeping the discard for discard recipes since I can safely keep it now (it’s good in the fridge for up to a week.)
I’m so proud of Ellie (what I named my starter) and I can’t wait to start using her to make breads and other things!
2025/1/7 Edited to
... Read moreMaking your own sourdough starter, especially in just 3 days like I did, feels incredibly rewarding! If you're wondering about the best setup and how to truly know your starter is thriving, here are some extra tips based on my experience.
First off, let's talk about the sourdough starter jar and its home on your kitchen counter. I found a wide-mouth glass jar is perfect because you can easily mix ingredients and observe its progress. Placing it in a spot on your kitchen counter that maintains a relatively consistent temperature, away from direct sunlight or drafts, is key for happy microbes. I even used a hair tie around my jar to mark the initial level – it's super helpful to see just how much it grows!
When it comes to mixing flour and water on day 1, getting that initial consistency right is crucial. The original recipe mentions a 'thick pancake consistency,' and I can't stress enough how important it is to start with less water and gradually add more until you hit that sweet spot. You want it thick enough to hold some air bubbles, but not so thick it’s a paste. Use a spoon or spatula to thoroughly combine everything, making sure there are no dry pockets of flour. This initial pour of water and thorough mixing sets the stage for a healthy starter.
Now, for the big questions: how can you tell sourdough starter is ready and what does an active sourdough starter look like? In my 3-day journey, I learned to look for several key indicators. An active starter will consistently double or even triple in size after feeding within a few hours (typically 4-8 hours, depending on conditions). When you peek into the jar, you'll see a beautiful web of tiny bubbles throughout, not just on the surface. The surface itself might have a domed, bubbly appearance. Another great sign is the smell – it should be pleasantly yeasty, slightly tangy, and not at all unpleasant or like nail polish remover. If you gently jiggle the jar, it should have a jiggly, airy texture.
A definitive test for readiness is the float test. Take a small spoonful of your fed, active starter and gently drop it into a glass of water. If it floats, it's ready to bake with! This indicates it's full of carbon dioxide produced by the active wild yeast. The reason we get such amazing activity is due to the tiny sourdough bacteria and wild yeasts that are naturally present in flour and the air around us. In the early days, you might encounter some less desirable microbes, which is why discarding is so important. It helps promote the beneficial bacteria and yeast that give sourdough its distinct flavor and rise, ensuring your starter becomes robust and safe to use.
Following a sourdough starter day by day chart in your mind helps manage expectations. Day 1 is about initiation, Day 2 about first signs of life and discarding, and by Day 3, you're really aiming for that consistent doubling. Each day brings new observations, and it's a fascinating process of nurturing your own living culture. Happy baking!