Who Dunnit? Murder Mystery Book Recommendations

Who Dunnit? Let’s Read and Find Out in these Murder Mysteries

I love a good whodunnit and trying to solve the case as I read. Remember: Nothing Is As It Seems & Everybody Is A Suspect!!!!

📚Agatha Christie

And Then There Were None

A Haunting In Venice

Death On The Nile

📚Grady Hendrix

The Final Girl Support Group

📚Alexandra Benedict

The Christmas Murder Game

#books #murdermystery #bookrecommendations #lemon8books #fyp

2025/7/17 Edited to

... Read moreMurder mystery novels, especially whodunnit stories, have captivated readers for decades by inviting them to become detectives, solving puzzling crimes alongside the protagonists. Among the most celebrated authors in this genre is Agatha Christie, whose works like 'And Then There Were None' revolutionized mystery writing. In this particular novel, ten strangers are invited to a remote mansion, only to be picked off one by one — a classic setup that tests the reader’s deductive skills throughout. Another compelling addition to the genre is 'A Haunting in Venice,' featuring the famous Detective Hercule Poirot. Set during a Halloween party, the eerie atmosphere combined with Poirot’s sharp investigations create a captivating narrative where every guest could be a suspect. 'Death on the Nile,' soon to be a major motion picture, sets a gripping murder mystery aboard a cruise ship, showcasing Christie’s mastery of confined-space suspense. Contemporary authors also bring fresh twists to whodunnit tales. Grady Hendrix’s 'The Final Girl Support Group' explores the aftermath of horror movies, with final girls—survivors of slasher films—being targeted themselves. This novel cleverly blends slasher tropes with psychological thriller elements, crafting a unique mystery that keeps readers guessing. Alexandra Benedict’s 'The Christmas Murder Game' introduces holiday-themed suspense where family traditions mask deadly secrets. The protagonist, Lily, must navigate through ominous Christmas games to uncover the truth and survive. These titles collectively emphasize that in murder mysteries, "Nothing Is As It Seems" and "Everybody Is A Suspect," encouraging readers to scrutinize every clue and character detail. Exploring these works enhances your appreciation for intricate plotting, red herrings, and character development that define the whodunnit genre. For fans eager to delve deeper, engaging with online book communities tagged #murdermystery and #bookrecommendations can provide fresh insights and personalized suggestions. Whether you prefer classic detective stories or modern psychological thrillers, these murder mystery books offer suspense, intrigue, and the thrill of the chase.

Related posts

Who-dunnit Book Recs
New finds onto my TBR #kindlegirlie #lemon8challenge #lemon8bookclub #bookrecommendations #summer
Khannu💛

Khannu💛

32 likes

A window looking out onto a forest path, with an open book and a lamp on the windowsill. Red text overlays the image, stating 'THRILLERS THAT KEPT ME GUESSING UNTIL THE END'.
The book cover for 'The Sun Down Motel' by Simone St. James, set against a dark foliage background. Surrounding text highlights themes: 'PAST & PRESENT', 'ATMOSPHERIC SUSPENSE', 'LOCALS WITH SECRETS', and 'VINTAGE MOTEL'.
The book cover for 'Never Lie' by Freida McFadden, featuring a black couch, against a dark foliage background. Keywords like 'REMOTE MANOR', 'MISSING PERSON POV', 'WEB OF LIES', and 'COUPLES SECRETS' are displayed.
THRILLER 🔪 Book Recommendations 📚 Part I
Here are five thriller books that kept me guessing until the end. 📖 Each book follows its own set of tropes to provide a variety. 🌜Have you read any? 🌛 #thrillerbooks #Lemon8 #lemon8book #lemon8bookclub #booktok #bookaesthetic #mystery #reading #lemon8bookclubchallenge
DeLaney 🌞

DeLaney 🌞

5595 likes

Cozy Murder Mystery🔎
𝒫𝒾𝒸𝓉𝓊𝓇𝑒 𝒾𝓉 👀✨ You’re fired from your big girl job and now have to work at your parent’s noodle shop. 🍜 While on the job you go deliver a to go order to the landlord of the shop. You go about your night and the next day you’re being interviewed for the murder of the landlord. This was a cozy
Lupita

Lupita

101 likes

A stack of books on a white blanket, adorned with knitted pumpkins, a small pumpkin, and fall leaves. Text overlays read 'The ultimate FALL book guide' and list categories like Romance, Cozy fantasy, Cozy mystery, Witches, Vampires, Dark academia, Gothic, Dark romance, and Thriller.
A grid of 12 book covers under the heading 'Romance p1.' The covers feature various fall-themed romantic stories, including titles like 'The Cinnamon Bun Book Store,' 'The Pumpkin Spice Cafe,' and 'The Dead Romantics.'
A grid of 12 book covers under the heading 'Romance p2.' These book covers continue the fall and cozy romance theme, with titles such as 'The Fall of Bradley Reed,' 'Pumpkin Everything,' and 'Love at the Salted Pumpkin Caramel Cafe.'
Ultimate Fall Book Recommendations
#summervibes #lemon8contest #fallbookstack #notmypicture #fallvibes🍂
Samantha_ingold

Samantha_ingold

1974 likes

A person views a wall covered with notes and photos, illuminated by a light bulb, with text "5 murder mysteries that both scared and outsmarted me" overlayed.
A phone displays the book cover "LIES AND BONES" by TJ Law, featuring a silhouette in a dark alley. Text describes the plot: cracking a killer's code or becoming a target.
A phone displays the book cover "CAPITOL KILLER" by TJ Law, showing a silhouette before the Capitol building. Text describes solving a murder that hasn't happened yet.
Murder mystery books that outsmarted me
These murder mysteries scared and outsmarted me. If you’re looking for murder mystery books, these Booktok recommendations are perfect for ur TBR! #murdermysterybooks #mysterybookrecs #mysterybooks #bookseries #bookcommunity
Thriller Book Recs 2025

Thriller Book Recs 2025

148 likes

For those who need book recs...
Some of my favorite reads within the past year. I highly recommend Lock the Doors! Happy reading 📖 #bookrecommendations #bookwormsoflemon8 #booktok #booksoflemon8 #lemon8partner
Prophetess Alisa Elias

Prophetess Alisa Elias

1344 likes

Book series recommendations 📚
Sometimes I just want to read a quick series that doesn’t have a ton of books to invest in so here are some of my top picks ✨ plus all of these series are complete except the last one! 💭 What book series are you excited to read this year? #bookseries #bookrecommendations #books #book
sarahsbooks

sarahsbooks

651 likes

A dark, misty forest scene with a dilapidated cabin, featuring the text '5 murder mysteries that outsmarted me'. The image is framed like a film photo.
The book cover for 'For Your Own Good' by Samantha Downing, set against a dark forest background. Text overlay reads: 'Everyone's a suspect, including the narrator.'
The book cover for 'Lies and Bones' by TJ Law, showing a silhouette in a lit alley, against a dark forest. Text overlay: 'Very gripping and mysterious. Great book.'
These murder mystery books outsmarted me
If you love: 🕵️‍♂️ murder mystery books 🔪 psychological thriller books 📚 books with plot twists 😱 books with shocking endings 🧠 twisty thriller books 📖 detective mystery books 🖤 dark mystery thrillers 🔒 locked room mysteries 🚨 books with unreliable narrators 🔥 books like Gone Girl 👀 be
Chilling Book Recs

Chilling Book Recs

114 likes

A hand holds a closed book, showing its pages from the side, against a white textured background. The text overlay reads: 'CAN YOU SOLVE THE CASE BEFORE THEY DO?'
The cover of the book 'Murder in the Family' by Cara Hunter, featuring a house at night. Text overlays describe it as a 'COLD CASE THRILLER' with 'SECRETS,' 'MIXED MEDIA,' and 'TRUE CRIME DOCUMENTARY TELEPLAY' elements.
An open book displays a page with text messages between Amelie and Maura Honal, and another page titled 'Episode one' with the question 'WHO KILLED LUKE RYDER?'
TRUE CRIME THRILLER BOOK
If you like true crime tv shows and trying to solve cases yourself, you will LOVE this book! Murder in the Family is written in a tv show format and is so fun looking at the case, newspaper articles, text messages, etc. Did you solve the case before they did? #crimebooks #mysterybook
Jenna

Jenna

1272 likes

Best authors for murder mysteries
These authors are known for writing some of the best murder mystery books. If you’re looking for book recommendations, try these murder mysteries! #murderbooks #murdermysterybooks #mysterybooks #murdermysteries #booksoflemon8
Chilling Book Recs

Chilling Book Recs

29 likes

A bookshelf filled with various mystery and thriller books, with a text overlay that reads 'Mystery/Crime Books recs'. Book titles like 'The Prince & The Apocalypse' and 'None Shall Sleep' are visible.
A hand holding the book 'The Mary Shelley Club' by Goldy Moldavsky, featuring a dark cover with a woman's profile and red text.
A hand holding the book 'We Were Warned' by Chelsea Ichaso, which has a dark cover depicting a flashlight and red, distressed text.
Mystery/Thriller Book recs
I love reading suspenseful mystery books. They make me really use my critical thinking skills unfortunately. But sometimes it’s just good to sit down with a good book and read the outcome. It’s always a plot twist. For all my mystery/crimes lovers, here are some recs. #mysterybooks #lemon8challe
Nehemiah

Nehemiah

348 likes

𝐹𝑜𝑜𝒹𝒾𝑒 𝑀𝓊𝓇𝒹𝑒𝓇 𝑀𝓎𝓈𝓉𝑒𝓇𝓎 🔎
The way I’m eating up these foodie mysteries!!! 😩☺️ This story follows Lila, who returns home to help at her family’s Filipino restaurant after a bad breakup with her fiancé. 😱 While working there, she ends up serving and assisting her ex, Derek, who is reviewing the restaurant for the *Shady
Lupita

Lupita

8 likes

Four colorful book covers from the 'Hamptons Murder Mystery' series by Carrie Doyle, including 'Death on Lily Pond Lane' and 'Death on Bull Path,' are displayed on a textured gray and white surface. An orange banner across the image reads 'COZY MYSTERY SERIES'.
Cozy Mystery Series 🧸🕯️🪵🍁
Super cute murder mystery series! They all take place in the East Hamptons with Antonia Bingham who is the owner and chef of an idyllic cozy inn. 💫 The books can be read in any order. #cozymystery #mysterybooks #bookrecommendations #murdermystery #bookwormsoflemon8
chelsea

chelsea

65 likes

Murder mystery thriller must read🖤
Love goes wrong🔥🖤 I LOVED this murder mystery! A must read ♥️🔥🖤 #murder mystery #thrillervibes #book recommendations #theperfectmarriage #jenevarose
that_girl_katelynnn

that_girl_katelynnn

13 likes

Summer Horror & Thriller Book Recommendations
Summer is supposed to feel carefree — beach trips, lake days, road trips, bonfires, and staying out way too late — but these books turn all of that into something terrifying. From cursed vacation houses and creepy summer camps to isolated islands, amusement parks, and deadly beach towns, these horr
Izzy

Izzy

117 likes

Murder mystery books
These murder mysteries were a lot of fun. #murdermysteries #murdermysterynovel #murdermysterybooks #booktokbooks #booksoflemon8
Chilling Book Recs

Chilling Book Recs

72 likes

A pile of young adult books, including Caraval, The Hunger Games, and A Good Girl's Guide to Murder, with the text 'YA BOOKS that are worth the hype' overlaid.
Three books from the Caraval Series by Stephanie Garber (Caraval, Legendary, Finale) held in a hand, with text highlighting magical realism, romance, magical games, mystery, and the need to read in order.
Three books from the Once Upon a Broken Heart Series by Stephanie Garber held in a hand, with text noting it's a Caraval spin-off, features magical realism, and requires reading in order after Caraval.
YA BOOK RECOMMENDATIONS 📚
Here are my favorite YA books/series!!! ✨ • CARAVAL 🪄 Stephanie Garber RATINGS: 4⭐️, 4.5⭐️, 5⭐️ — magical realism, magical games, LOTS of mystery, and the romance is AMAZING! — first book follows one couple, second follows another, and the third follows both couples • ONCE UPON A BROKEN H
Koko Kingston🩵

Koko Kingston🩵

1522 likes

5 mystery/ thriller books🔪
Here are 5 murder mystery/ thriller books! Have you read any or are they one your TBR? Happy reading📚 #thrillerbookrecommendations #mystery & thriller #murderbooks #bookrecommendations #bookwormsoflemon8
DBooks📚

DBooks📚

75 likes

COZY MYSTERY book rec✨
I just finished Shady Hollow and it was the cutest most charming little cozy mystery i’ve ever read. I haven’t been able to resist talking about it with anyone who will listen 🤭 This is the first in the series, and it’s about the grumpy old toad of the town who is found dead in the pond. We go
aubrei

aubrei

165 likes

Glory Be | Book Review
This is a great southern cozy mystery! It definitely is a tad bit predictable but nonetheless it kept me listening with quite a few chuckles throughout. That Glory is definitely quite the character and held her own throughout this entire book. Want to read something that's an in between reads m
Kandi R.

Kandi R.

1 like

For the thriller/mystery book girlies 🫶
#mystery & thriller #booktok #books #bookrecommendations #freidamcfaddenbooks
SheMyaReads

SheMyaReads

3 likes

Mystery Must Haves📚🫣
I’m in the middle of reading the “Good Girls Guide to Murder” series & it got me wanting to read more mystery/thriller books! So, of course I had to go over to Barnes and Noble to see what else I could add to my collection (as if i don’t already have enough books I’m reading🤣) What Myster
Ria🪴 | Books & Lifestyle

Ria🪴 | Books & Lifestyle

84 likes

thriller book recommendations 🖤
i’m a sucker for a good thriller book, so here are some of my favs! thrillers are always my go-to when i feel myself falling into a slump. #thrillerbooks #thrillervibes #thrillerbookrecs #bookrecommendations #BookReview #BookReviews
Koko Kingston🩵

Koko Kingston🩵

281 likes

A book mail package features three thriller novels: 'A Killer Getaway', 'The Dead Husband Cookbook', and 'Julie Tudor Is Not A Psychopath'. The box cover displays a skull and palm trees with the text 'Higher Body Counts Forecasted for a Killer Summer'.
🔪BOOK MAIL🔪
Ready for a k!ller summer? These books can help! Landmark is thrilled to spotlight our slightly psychotic leading ladies in JULIE TUDOR IS NOT A PSYCHOPATH by Jennifer Holdich (July 8),D€AD HUSBAND COOKBOOK by @daniellevalentinebooks (August 5), and A K!LLER GETAWAY by Sienna Sharpe (August 12).
The Twilight Bookworm

The Twilight Bookworm

132 likes

A light-colored page titled "Book Reccomendations" for Horror, Mystery, Thriller, Slasher, and Crime genres, dedicated to "quiet girls with stories in their heads."
The book cover for "You're Not Supposed to Die Tonight" by Kalynn Bayron, featuring a scared woman with blood on her face in a forest, with listed genres and content warnings.
The book cover for "The Cheerleaders" by Kara Thomas, showing a blood-splattered blue cheerleader skirt, with listed genres and content warnings.
Horror | Mystery | Thriller | Slasher | Crime
Book Recommendations for my Horror, Mystery, Thriller, Slasher and Crime, Guys and Gals! ———————————————————————————- You’re Not Supposed to Die Tonight By Kalynn Bayron At Camp Mirror Lake, terror is the name of the game... but can you survive the night? This heart-pounding slasher by N
W

W

30 likes

A book titled '14 Ways to Die' by Vincent Ralph, featuring a cover with dried rose petals, '1 Killer. 13 Victims. A Million Views.' and a 20% off sticker. It's presented as a thriller book review with a four-star rating and a cartoon book sticker on a textured blanket.
14 ways to die book review
In “14 Ways to Die,” the gripping narrative follows a young woman named Jess who becomes entangled in the chilling memories of her mother’s unsolved murder. As she navigates the complexities of grief and the pressure of social media fame, Jess decides to confront her past by investigating the circu
🍂🌵Shantel🌿🍄

🍂🌵Shantel🌿🍄

54 likes

A Murder Mystery Rooted in Family Ruin
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ In the middle of a fractured family and a murder investigation, brothers Evan and Russel Powder — both cops — are forced to work together to uncover who killed Chloe. But as the case unfolds, the Powder family’s darkest secrets begin surfacing one by one, unraveling shocking twists th
M a d i s o n

M a d i s o n

4 likes

Good murder mystery recs?? 😄
I’m struggling to find good murder mystery authors/books that are quality 😅. Help a girl out y’all 😅 #books #murdermystery #suspense #thriller #booktok #recs #reccommendations #fyp #bookrecommendations #lemon8bookclub
Lily Russell

Lily Russell

10 likes

The image displays the title "Mystery/Thriller book recs" in white text against a dark, dimly lit background featuring a street light and two benches, setting a mysterious tone.
The image shows the book cover for "You Shouldn't Have Come Here" with a dark forest, a small house, and a car on a road. A note reads "The Plot Twist!!!".
The image features the book title "NEVER LIE" in red text against a white brick wall, with a black leather couch below. A note says "Again with the plot twist!".
Mystery/Thriller book recs 📚🖤
I LOVE a good mystery/thriller! These got me right in the mood for spooky season and I’m still reading them afterwards. Jeneva Rose and Frieda McFadden have quickly became my favorite authors! The plot twists at the end of their books are next level. Definitely caught me off guard! If you need som
Cindy-Rae

Cindy-Rae

6 likes

A dark, stormy image with a hooded figure standing on books, featuring the text "NEW THRILLER, MYSTERY & SUSPENSE BOOKS" and "March 2025" in red, with the handle @HEARTSANDTHRILLERS.
Two book covers for March 4 releases: "Don't Tell Me How to Die" by Marshall Karp and "Count My Lies" by Sophie Stava (Debut). The image also features a "Debut" graphic.
Two book covers for March 11 releases: "Witness 8" by Steve Cavanagh and "Vanishing Daughters" by Cynthia Pelayo, set against a dark background.
15 new mystery & thriller books for your TBR
Most anticipated Mystery, Thriller, & Suspense books releasing in March: March 4: "Count My Lies" by Sophie Stava (Debut) "Don't Tell Me How to Die" by Marshall Karp March 11: "Witness 8" by Steve Cavanagh "Vanishing Daughters" by Cynthia
heartsandthrillers

heartsandthrillers

56 likes

Murder Most Puzzling Peril at Quandary Park |
#ChronicleBooks #StephanievonReiswitz #MurderMostPuzzlingPerilatQuandaryPark #NetGalley #Bookstagram #BookishCommunity #ReadersOfInstagram #BookReview #BookRecommendations
theintrovertedbookzone

theintrovertedbookzone

6 likes

A hand holds the book 'There Are 3 Women & 4 Men' by Jaden Payne, featuring a framed image with a bullet hole and blood on its cover. Autumn leaves and a small pumpkin decorate the scene, with a bookshelf in the background. The text overlay reads 'YOUR NEW FAVORITE FALL MYSTERY'.
The back cover of 'There Are 3 Women & 4 Men' is shown, detailing a murder mystery set in an art museum. Annotations point to 'art museum', 'whodunnit', 'kindle unlimited', and 'm*rder mystery', with a bookshelf and pumpkin in the background.
A digital display shows the book 'There Are 3 Women & 4 Men' available for purchase. Options include Kindle Unlimited and a Paperback version priced at $17.99, with text indicating availability on Amazon and Kindle Unlimited.
MUST BUY FALL MYSTERY!
Officially out of my reading slump thanks to this book >>> 📚 if you’re looking for a fun, cozy, murder mystery you have to checkout There Are 3 Women & Four Men. I saw this on TikTok and it has over 5M views and over a hundred thousand likes 🫢 the reviews were great and even if this i
blondegigi 🎀

blondegigi 🎀

69 likes

A hand holds several books fanned open on a colorful rug, with text overlay 'if you like this book then read this!' and a yellow arrow pointing downwards, indicating a book recommendation theme.
Two book covers are displayed on a colorful rug: 'A Good Girl's Guide to Murder' and 'Truly Devious'. Text highlights similarities like teen detectives and mystery series, with ratings of 4.5/5 and 4/5 respectively.
Two book covers are shown on a colorful rug: 'The Cruel Prince' and 'Kingdom of the Wicked'. Text lists similarities such as morally grey Prince, enemies to lovers, and romantasy, with both books rated 4.5/5.
If you like this… then read this! Book edition
Book game time!!! If you like this, then read this edition! 1. If you like A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder… read Truly Devious! - Both are YA mystery series - Both follow teen detectives delving into cases no one imagined would have a true conclusion. - Follow the main characters over several
emma privitera

emma privitera

715 likes

A person holds a Kindle e-reader displaying the cover of the murder mystery book "Last Day Alive" by Jeneva Rose, featuring two figures in a field. The image, set by a pool, is a book review for the Lemon8 Book Club, with "BOOK REVIEW" text overlaid.
MURDER MYSTERY BOOK REVIEW!
this book is a part two to another book I read last year! it involves a detective searching for a missing little girl in town and only a few days later does her only friend end up missing as well. little does the detective know that the ones closest and most important in the girls lives are the one
ganna sumar

ganna sumar

46 likes

A hand holds a Kindle displaying the cover of the psychological thriller "DON'T LET HER STAY" by Nicola Sanders, featuring a house under a dark sky. The image has overlay text "BOOK REVIEW" and "Lemon8 @gannasumar", with a plant in the background.
THRILLER BOOK REVIEW!
started this book a few weeks ago in hopes to finish it before february ended but I forgot my kindle in another state over the weekend & didn’t get it back until today! LOVED this book but the ending definitely throw me for a curve ball…let’s just say the tables had turned! this book is abou
ganna sumar

ganna sumar

98 likes

mystery novels i love!!
these are my favorite mystery novels and series ever!! holly jackson and karen m mcmanus are my absolute favorite authors ever if you cant tell #mysterymovies #mysterybooks #mysterybook #mysterygirl #bookrecommendations #bookrecs
Elizabeth

Elizabeth

17 likes

Thrillers/Mystery Books!😵‍💫🤫
These books had me on the edge of my seat, biting my nails, and lost in thought even after the ending!!! Cannot recommend these books enough! These definitely helped me out of any reading slump I was in!📚 I hope y’all enjoy!! 🙃☕️ #thrillerbookrecommendations #books 📚 #bookrecommendations
Elena’s Bookshelf📚☕️

Elena’s Bookshelf📚☕️

88 likes

A sepia-toned image of a person's silhouette in a forest, with text overlay "Six books so F*CKING clever they played the F*CK outta me" and Lemon8 branding.
The book cover for "The Bone Collector" by Jeffery Deaver, featuring a man and a car with bright lights, overlaid on a forest background, with text "Each discovery pulled me in deeper. Nice."
The book cover for "Lies and Bones" by TJ Law, depicting a woman's silhouette in a dark alley, overlaid on a forest background, with text "Every chapter made me lean in closer. So good."
Damn clever mystery books
I admit it, these murder mystery books outsmarted me, and I loved every moment! #mysterybooks #crimefiction #murdermysterybooks #bookrecommendations #booksoflemon
Great Thriller Reads

Great Thriller Reads

4 likes

See more