rating my mascaras 🎇

i have sooo many mascaras so i figured i would rate them like the perfumes! 😚

i have super straight asian lashes so it’s very hard for my lashes to hold a curl! so it’s surprising that some of these work well for me.

honorable mention to the shiseido eyelash curler— it’s the absolute best, totally worth the money. 👍Pros :

remember the formulas act differently with everyone, this is just my experience :)

#makeup #mascara #makeuptips #glowup #makeupmusthaves

2025/2/15 Edited to

... Read moreHey everyone! We all love finding that perfect mascara, right? The one that gives us amazing length, volume, and for those of us with super straight lashes, actually holds a curl. But beyond performance, there's a really important topic we should talk about: mascara hygiene and why it's crucial for our eye health, especially if you're like me and want your eyes to look their best. I’ve heard people worry about “bugs in mascara” – and while it sounds scary, what we're usually talking about is bacterial contamination. Our eyes are super delicate, and old or improperly used mascara can become a breeding ground for bacteria, leading to annoying and sometimes painful eye infections like pink eye or styes. Nobody wants that to ruin their perfect lash day! So, how do we keep our mascaras clean and safe? First off, never, ever share your mascara. It might seem harmless, but it's a direct way to transfer bacteria from one person's eyes to another. Think of your mascara tube as a personal toothbrush for your lashes – you wouldn't share that, right? Also, try to avoid pumping the wand in and out of the tube. This pushes air into the container, drying out the formula faster and introducing more bacteria, which can make your favorite mascara clumpy even before its time. Instead, swirl the wand gently inside the tube to pick up product. Another huge factor is shelf life. Mascara isn't like other makeup that lasts for years. Its lifespan is surprisingly short, typically around three to six months after opening. Why so short? Because each time you use it, the wand touches your lashes and then goes back into the tube, potentially depositing bacteria. Over time, this bacteria builds up. If you notice your mascara starts to smell off (anything from a chemical odor to a sour scent), changes in texture (becomes dry, extra clumpy, or watery), or loses its effectiveness, it’s definitely time to toss it. Even if a waterproof mascara still seems to be performing, if it's past its prime, it's a risk. Using expired mascara, even if it’s a 10/10 for length and curl hold, can lead to serious irritation, redness, and even infections that require medical attention. Imagine finally finding that mascara that makes your lashes look like falsies, only for it to give you a nasty eye infection! Not worth it. Always seal the cap tightly after each use and store it in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight to keep it fresher for longer. In conclusion, while we're all on the hunt for the best performing mascara for our unique lashes – whether it’s for amazing length, volume, or that perfect curl hold for Asian lashes – let's remember that safety and hygiene are just as important. Regularly replacing your mascara and practicing good hygiene will ensure your eyes stay healthy while you achieve those stunning lash looks!

19 comments

MiniDietCoke's images
MiniDietCoke

What’s the difference between the two telescopic mascaras?

Makeupthepaige's images
Makeupthepaige

My go to mascara is Milani Anti Gravity

See more comments

Related posts

A collection of seven different mascara tubes standing upright on a patterned surface, with the title 'Rating my MASCARAS' overlaid.
A mascara tube with a green cap, rated 3/5. The review states it makes lashes long but can become crusty.
A gold mascara tube, rated 5/5. The review praises it as a favorite for being smudge-proof and providing perfect length.
Rating My Mascaras
Elf Lash Extender- 3/5 It works to extend lashes, but gets crusty on your lashes. L’Oreal Telescopic Mascara- 5/5 All time favorite mascara works so good, definitely worth the money! Essence Lash Princess- 3/5 Dried out really fast, but affordable and good for the price. Honest Beauty S
Gracie

Gracie

230 likes

Four close-up views of a person's eyes with mascara applied, showcasing different lash looks. The image is titled "My FAV Mascaras" and includes sparkle graphics.
A silver mascara tube and its brush are displayed, accompanied by text praising it as the "Best mascara!!!!" with a 10/10 rating.
A pink mascara tube and its brush are shown, with text indicating it is "Great for the Price!!!!" and rated 8/10.
My FAV Mascaras
And my eyelash type is a mix of curls and straight eyelashes and tend to fall after wearing most mascaras! So if your eyelashes are like mine, you might like these to! #mascaras #mascararecommendations #bestmascaras #makeupproducts #makeupmusts ⭐️Overall rating: /10:
that_grll_slabs

that_grll_slabs

1503 likes

Rating My Mascaras
brands -wet n wild mega wear-$4 -sephora size up-$18 -maybeline sky high-$15 -essence lash princess-$6 -saie-$26 -benefit fan fest-$39 -too faced better then s*x waterproof-$39 -glossier lash slick-$27 -too faced better then s*x-$39 also i just got a new one after i edited this it’s the
tat

tat

141 likes

Mascaras
These are so good!! Have a great day💗
🫧

🫧

7420 likes

A store aisle displays various mascara products on shelves, with overlay text indicating a review of favorite mascaras and a star emoji.
A hand holds a pink packaged mascara, rated 8/10. The description notes that three coats are needed for great lashes.
A hand holds a purple packaged mascara, rated 7/10. The reviewer suggests it for casual outings.
Mascara Rating and Why? 👀
I love makeup and that’s why I created this page. I wanted to give you guys my favorite mascaras right now and why I love them. I have tried a lot of different mascaras and I know what I look for in my mascara. Let me know if you have tried these mascaras and is my rating fair? #letschat
Ty 😍✨✌🏽

Ty 😍✨✌🏽

1007 likes

A woman in a car smiles, surrounded by various mascara tubes and wands. The image has a text overlay "BEST DRUGSTORE MASCARA'S" and features several cosmetic products.
A gold mascara tube and wand are displayed. Text describes it as "SUPER lengthening & no clumping!" and expresses affection for the product.
A black mascara tube with pink accents and its wand are shown. Text highlights its ability to "bring the volume" and "mimics the look of waterproof" mascara.
best mascaras: drugstore edition
Ok it’s safe to say I’m obsessed with all things mascara and lashes.. if you know, you know 😏 I’ve done a lot of research and testing over the years to find the best mascaras. Here are just a FEW of the best drugstore mascaras I’ve found so far.. pt. 1: • Telescopic - L’Oréal Paris • Lash
Mia DeLuca

Mia DeLuca

570 likes

A young woman with long brown hair and blue eyes smiles at the camera, wearing a bright green vest. Overlay text reads "Rating Mascaras i've tried."
A gold mascara tube and wand are displayed, with a close-up of the brush. Text indicates a perfect rating and highlights its ability to hold curl and ease of removal.
A pink mascara tube and wand are shown. Text gives a high rating but notes that the product dries out quickly.
Rating Mascaras i’ve tried
I’m a big mascara girly and these are my most recent Mascaras i’ve tried and out of all of them Grande Lash Mascara takes the cake every time
Grace💖🌟🪩🎀

Grace💖🌟🪩🎀

1890 likes

A heart shape formed by seashells and starfish on a sandy beach, with text overlay asking about good mascaras and encouraging trust.
A black mascara tube and its wand are displayed on a white surface, with a lighted mirror in the background. Text describes it as lengthy and not needing many coats.
A black mascara tube with a pink-patterned cap and its wand are on a white surface, with a lighted mirror behind. Text describes it as nice and lightweight.
Want good mascaras? TRUST ME !!
👍Pros: all are easy to take off!! #tarte #mascara #trust #me #LoveYourself #preppy #easy #nottospendy #loveallofthem
☀️🤍Kiki🤍☀️

☀️🤍Kiki🤍☀️

935 likes

A hand holds three mascara tubes: a white and yellow Maybelline, a blue Tresluce Beauty, and a black and orange Rimmel London. The image has text overlays "Travel mascaras" and "Swipe," with decorative butterflies.
A close-up shows a white and yellow Maybelline mascara tube held in a hand. Text overlay reads "9/10" and describes its lengthening effect and applicator as excellent.
A close-up features a black and orange Rimmel London Scandaleyes mascara tube held in a hand. Text overlay reads "10/10" and praises it as an "old school classic."
Rating my travel mascaras💄
My favorite travel mascaras could not be missing from this rating, I love them. Tresluce: IPSY Maybelline and Rimmel London: CVS #lemon8challenge #lemon8beautycoupon #lemon8beautycrew #rating #letschat #lemon8beautycreator #mascaras
Roxy H

Roxy H

23 likes

Four mascara tubes with black bodies and colorful heart-themed caps are held in a hand. A pink overlay states "rating the best mascaras."
A silver and purple mascara tube is shown next to an eyelash curler. A pink overlay displays "6.5/10."
A light green mascara tube, both closed and with its brush extended, is displayed. A pink overlay shows "4/10."
rating the best mascaras
#mascara #mascararecommendations #makeup
alaina

alaina

416 likes

A hand holds four black mascara tubes, each with a different colored heart and crown design on the cap. The image has text overlay indicating good mascaras.
A black mascara tube with a pink heart design and its wand are displayed. Text describes it as helping curl without a curler and giving good volume.
A black mascara tube with a light blue heart design and its wand are shown. Text describes it as giving good length, a false lash effect, and applying smoothly.
Best mascaras for cheap!!
Best mascaras for cheap!!🌸 #lemon8dairy #mascaras #beauty #trending #makeuptips
Ri_2

Ri_2

995 likes

This image shows a collection of various mascara tubes on a light surface, with a floral bag in the background. Text indicates a review of mascaras based on their ability to curl straight lashes.
This image displays three mascara tubes, two large and one small, with a "4/5" rating. Text describes the mascara holding a curl for 4-5 hours.
A hand holds a dark gray mascara tube, rated "4/5". Text states the mascara holds a curl for 6-7 hours, suitable for a date night.
✨ Rating My Mascaras ✨
I was unfortunately cursed with the straight Asian lashes gene 😭😭😭 And I’ve tried so many mascaras throughout my makeup journey trying to find my holy grail mascara —one that keeps my lashes curled! If you also have straight lashes, I 100% recommend trying out the curling iron mascara by JudyDol
Venus 🇹🇭

Venus 🇹🇭

41 likes

A white text overlay on a background of an open makeup drawer, featuring a line drawing of a mascara tube and wand. The text reads 'Must-have Mascaras My top 6'.
A black mascara tube with gold accents, highlighted against an open makeup drawer. Text rates it 10/10 for making lashes full and long, easy to remove, and long-lasting.
A brown and black mascara tube, highlighted against an open makeup drawer. Text rates it 8/10 for amazing lengthening, noting a desire for more volume.
Favorites mascaras as of right now
#mascara #drugstoremakeup #highendmakeup #lemon8badgehunt #makeup
HarlenReads

HarlenReads

1957 likes

A collection of various mascara tubes standing upright against a dark gray wall, with text overlay indicating mascara recommendations.
A black mascara tube with a pink, textured cap, highlighted for its lengthening, curl-keeping, and non-clumping properties.
A black mascara tube with a gold emblem, noted for its pretty color, thickening effect, and larger wand.
the best mascaras on the market 👸🏼
all my fave mascaras in one post !!!! #lemon8partner #mascararecommendations #mascarareview #mascararoutine #mascaratips
malaina 💫🫧🌷

malaina 💫🫧🌷

1125 likes

This image displays a comparative review of three mascaras: Maybelline (3/5), Barenbliss (4/5), and Somethinc (5/5). It shows close-ups of eyes with mascara and the product tubes, titled 'HONEST REVIEW RATE MY MASCARAS'.
This image reviews the Somethinc Hangover Mascara, rated 5/5. It shows the mascara tube, wand, and an eye with the product applied, highlighting its volumizing, lengthening, non-smudging, and curl-holding benefits.
This image reviews the Barenbliss Roll to Volume Mascara, rated 4/5. It features the mascara tube, wand, and an eye with the product, noting its lengthening, volumizing, affordability, and slight stickiness.
❗️RATING MY MASCARAS❗️HONEST REVIEW 😉
Here's are my honest opinions about some of the best selling mascaras 😉💖 💜SOMETHINC💜 This is the best mascara I've ever tried!! its so much better than alot of the high end mascaras I've tried 👀👀👀 its volumizing, lengthening, long lasting, and does NOT smudge at all!! and it's o
Carissa Faith

Carissa Faith

46 likes

The image displays various mascara products, including Essence Lash Princess, Clinique High Impact, and a pink Maybelline mascara, under the title 'DO'S AND DON'TS WITH MASCARAS,' with a red cross and green checkmark indicating good and bad practices.
This image illustrates mascara do's and don'ts, advising to replace mascara every 3-6 months and curl lashes before application, while warning against pumping the wand. It features Essence, Milk Makeup, and Wet n Wild eyelash primer with their wands.
The image provides mascara tips, recommending applying multiple coats after each dries and cautioning against applying too much at once to prevent clumping. It shows Essence Lash Princess mascara and a clear Wet n Wild product with a circled wand.
Do’s and Don’ts with Mascaras✅❌
✅Do's: 1. Do replace your mascara every three to six months to prevent bacterial buildup and ensure optimal performance.👆🏽 2. Do curl your lashes before applying mascara to enhance their natural curl and open up your eyes. 3. Do wiggle the mascara wand at the base of your lashes and then s
Alejandracsd

Alejandracsd

3018 likes

Rating Mascaras!
This isn’t all I have tried out but I cleaned out recently. Let me know if there’s any suggestions you guys want to see/ any products you’d like me to review! I’ll try my best. #reviewing #rating #mascaras #ratingbeautyproducts #beautyfinds
elisa schmidt

elisa schmidt

1264 likes

Four mascara tubes of different colors (black with pink cap, white, black, teal) are displayed on a marble surface under the title "RATING VIRAL MASCARAS," indicating a review of these products.
A teal mascara tube is shown with text highlighting its features: "Doesn't smudge under your eyes," "Not super volumizing," "Doesn't make your lashes clumpy," and an "8/10" rating.
A black mascara tube with a pink cap is featured, noting it "Makes your lashes look full," "Smudges under eyes a little bit," "Could compare to a high end mascara," and has an "8/10" rating.
Rating Viral Mascaras
Here are my honest reviews on viral mascaras! Elf is my go-to affordable mascara for sure! It’s really grown on me. But my fav high end is definitely the ILIA mascara!! It gives everything I want in a mascara! What’s your fav mascara? 😍🫶 #beautyfinds #makeupreview #lemon8beauty @Lemon8 Be
dani :)

dani :)

114 likes

A flat lay of nine different mascara tubes in various colors, including gold, light blue, black, cream, and green, arranged on a white textured blanket, with the title 'Rating popular Mascaras' at the top.
A gold mascara tube with a black cap, rated 9/10, described as super volumizing but flakey.
A light blue mascara tube, rated 3/10, described as giving lots of volume but major panda eyes.
Rating Popular Mascaras
As someone who has a massive mascara collection, I decided to rate some of the mascaras I’ve been seeing on my for you page!! What’s ur fav mascara?👀 #lemon8beauty #lemon8beautycrew #lemon8beautyreviews #lemon8christmas #lemon8contest @Lemon8 Beauty
dani :)

dani :)

49 likes

A close-up of a person's eye and mouth with several mascara wands around the eye, featuring the text 'RATING ALL OF MY MASCARAS' and a social media handle.
RATING ALL OF MY MASCARAS
•1 Loreal Panorama😍😍😍 -My favorite -looks luxurious -lasts long -makes lashes thick & long -STAYS THE WHOLE DAY SWEAR BY IT •2 Maybelline Sky High (Brown) Pros: makes lashes very long, stays on long, beautiful brown color Cons: the tube doesn’t last long (a month maybe), the p
Ari🪽💌

Ari🪽💌

23 likes

A flat lay shows five mascara tubes with the title 'Rating Mascaras' and a 'Swipe' arrow. Mascaras include Essence Lash Princess, KVD, Benefit BADgal BANG!, Polite Society, and Benefit Fan Fest.
A hand holds a gold KVD Full Sleeve Long + Defined Tubing Mascara, rated 8/10. Text notes it's good for lengthening but can get clumpy.
A hand holds a black and pink Benefit Fan Fest Fanning & Volumizing Mascara, rated 7/10. Text indicates it fans out lashes and helps if lashes are already long.
Rating Mascaras✨
These are MY own opinions on these mascaras that I’ve used or have seen used on others. I’m a mascara junkie so I’ve tried a lot and this is my personal analysis lol Would love to know your opinion on these products and whether or not they’ve worked for you! Purchased from: Ulta Beauty #mascara
Kei_araa

Kei_araa

54 likes

Four different mascara tubes are displayed upright on a mirrored surface, with a purple and white checkered towel in the background. The image is titled 'Rating Mascaras' and suggests waiting until the end for a favorite.
An open mascara tube with a silver and blue design and its wand are shown. Text indicates a 9/10 rating, noting its applicator is perfect for lower lashes.
An open black mascara tube and its wand are displayed. The text gives an 8/10 rating, praising its lifting effect but noting excess product on the applicator.
Rating my mascara 🥰
My most sincere opinion about these mascaras, tell me what you think of them. #lemon8challenge #mascaras #lemon8beautycoupon #BackToSchool #lemon8beautycrew #rating #lemon8beautycreator
Roxy H

Roxy H

14 likes

Three mascara tubes, one dark purple with snakeskin texture, one bright pink, and one metallic purple, are displayed on a white countertop. The image has text overlays indicating "MY FAVORITE MASCARAS" and navigation cues.
A pink mascara tube and its wand with a pink brush are shown. Text describes it as a deep black mascara providing excellent lash separation, with a tip for light, multiple layers.
A dark purple mascara tube with a snakeskin texture and its wand with a brown brush are featured. Text highlights it as a volumizing and separating mascara that does not flake and is long-lasting.
my FAV mascaras for every look 🌸✨🤍
🎀 Maybelline Lash Sensational Firework Mascara This is my favorite mascara of ALL time! It gives the perfect spikey look to my lashes, kind of how they look when they are wet. The separation with this mascara is genuinely crazy, with the wand reaching and separating every lash. It also lasts all d
may

may

60 likes

An aesthetic flat lay featuring decorative items, a makeup palette, and a gold mirror, with the text overlay "Rating mascaras i've tried" as the article title.
A black mascara tube with purple accents is shown, with text overlay rating it as the worst mascara tried due to clumping.
A gold mascara tube and its wand are displayed, with text overlay rating it 1000/10 and calling it a holy grail product.
Rating mascaras i've tried
1.I don't like it because it's so freaking clump like i mean CLUMPY and chunky you get what you pay for with it being only 5$ 2.Its perfect for separate natural looking lashes while keeping up ALL day and doesn't flake at all it definitely doesn't get as much hype as it should 3.
Becky

Becky

72 likes

rating mascaras✨🎀
#mascara #grwm #makeup #makeupforbeginner #ratemyempties #lashes #TutorialMakeup #makeuptips #makeupinspo #makeuptutorial
lexie rose

lexie rose

7 likes

A person with freckles and makeup looks at the camera, with text overlay "rating the different mascaras i've tried." The person is in a car, wearing a light-colored top.
A mascara tube and wand are shown, with a close-up of the brush. Text rates it 7.5/10, noting pros like thickness and no clumping, and cons like heaviness and thick consistency.
A mascara tube and wand are displayed, with a close-up of the brush. Text rates it 8/10, highlighting pros like not too thick and lengthening, and a con of smudging after wear.
rating diff mascaras!
i’ve tried so many different mascaras in the past, but these are the ones I have used most often and my thoughts on them :)
alovéya

alovéya

17 likes

A title image featuring text "My favorite mascaras" and "For length + volume," surrounded by several white pearl-like spheres, mascara wands, a mascara tube, and an eyelash curler on a white background.
A silver mascara tube with prominent text indicating its purpose for volume, resting on a soft, light-colored textured surface. Accompanying text provides a personal review of the product's lifting capabilities.
A hand holds a white mascara tube, identified for its lengthening properties, against a blurred background of window blinds. Text describes the product as a necessity for lengthening lashes, often paired with a volumizing product.
My favorite mascaras 🫶
For length + volume ✨⚡️💫 🛍Brand: Ilia, L’Oréal, Sephora Ilia Limitless Lash + Sephora Size Up are available at Sephora L’Oréal Telescopic Lift + L’Oréal Voluminous Original are available at Ulta or drug stores 💰Price: Range of $8 to $28 #mascaras #makeuptips #loreal #sephora
peyton annie

peyton annie

2354 likes

A person wearing glasses and a pink and red star-patterned sweater is shown in a car, with text overlay "Rating Mascaras i've tried" and a social media handle.
A gold mascara tube and its wand are displayed, with text indicating a high rating and positive feedback for lifting lashes.
A pink mascara tube and its wand are shown against a textured background, with text praising its appearance on lashes and a high rating.
Rating Mascaras i’ve tried
Kaylee Hines

Kaylee Hines

4 likes

A graphic with the text "THE BEST MASCARAS EVER" surrounded by various mascara tubes and wands in black, red, gold, and brown colors.
A gold mascara tube and wand are displayed, with text indicating it provides significant length.
A teal mascara tube is shown with a large black mascara smudge, accompanied by text praising its length and easy removal.
Best mascaras in my opinion 🫶
I love all of these so much my mascara routine is the butterfly one and the malani mascara love these so much!! let me know what ur fav mascara is !!!
ellie . 🤍🎱🐆

ellie . 🤍🎱🐆

957 likes

The image displays four different mascara tubes arranged vertically on a patterned fabric surface. From left to right, the tubes are rose gold, gold, black with green accents, and pink. Each tube has descriptive text below it.
Best mascaras (my opinion)
Best mascaras for cheap $ (my opinion) loves these! 💞 I also SWEAR on telescopic 🥹🫰 #mascaras #lash princess mascara #Lemon8Diary #
kellers_lovesLLJW🥹🫰

kellers_lovesLLJW🥹🫰

134 likes

A flat lay of various makeup products, including palettes, mascaras, primers, and powders, arranged on a white surface. The text 'Rating Makeup Products' is overlaid.
Two makeup powders are shown next to a decorative lamp. One is a black square compact, described as a highly recommended setting powder. The other is a black round compact, described as a less favored loose powder.
A red stick blush and a round compact blush are displayed next to a decorative lamp. The stick blush is praised for easy application and blending, while the compact blush is used to enhance cream blush.
Rating makeup products💄💅
My favorites and some of my least faves that I have tried this year 10/10 recommend :) #makeup #ratingbeautyproducts #ratingproducts #beauty #beautyproducts #makeupproducts #beautyfinds #makeuproutine #makeup2023 #makeuprecommendations
Alayna💓

Alayna💓

174 likes

A person with braided hair makes a puckered face, looking sideways. Text overlays indicate the post is about favorite mascaras, rated best to worst, focusing on a specific mascara line.
A black mascara tube with pink decorative elements and text indicating it's for curl and volume. An overlay describes it as a 'holy grail' that makes lashes look full.
A black mascara tube with mint green decorative elements and text indicating it's for a false lash effect. An overlay states it gives length but not much volume.
My Favorite mascaras rated best to worst
I LOVEEEEE the essence lash princess mascaras but I do want some other recommendations! Leave your fav mascara in the comments🩷 #essence lash princess mascara @essence makeup #favoritethings
Layyy.🫶🏾

Layyy.🫶🏾

11 likes

See more