My Boyfriend and I tried Crave Cookies…
A Crave just opened down the street from us and we were excited to try the cookies and compare them to Crumbl!
I honestly liked them better than Crumbl 👀 I feel like Crumbl’s cookies have a specific taste in their batter that I don’t particularly love whereas Crave definitely taste more homemade and less assembly-line-y!
Have you tried Crave before? What did you think of their cookies vs. Crumbl?
Okay, so after my initial taste test with my boyfriend, I've had more time to reflect on the Crave Cookies experience, especially when thinking about how it stacks up against Crumbl. While my first impression was a strong win for Crave, let's dive a bit deeper into what makes these cookies stand out and why you absolutely need to try them – especially if you're a Crumbl fan looking for something new. First, let's talk about the cookies themselves. The original article mentioned how Crave tastes more homemade, and I truly stand by that. Crumbl often has a distinct base flavor that can sometimes overpower the specific cookie flavor, almost like a signature "Crumbl taste." With Crave, each cookie feels like it could have come straight from a talented home baker's kitchen. The textures are just spot on – think soft, chewy, and perfectly baked. From what I’ve seen on their menu boards, they offer a good mix of classics and unique rotating flavors. For instance, my boyfriend and I were thrilled to try what tasted like a Girl Scouts' Samoa-inspired cookie. The coconut, caramel, and chocolate were just heavenly! And their twist on a classic Chocolate Chip but with a Caramel spin was a delightful surprise. But the real showstopper for me was their Snickerdoodle with cookie butter – pure indulgence and perfectly spiced. It's those little details that really make a difference. Beyond the cookies, Crave also has an incredible loaded soda menu. This was a huge novelty for us! You know how sometimes you just want something a little extra with your sweet treat? Crave totally nails it. Their menu, which I peeped on a digital screen in the store, boasts creative concoctions like the "FULL BLITZ," "CRANBERRY CRUSH," and the intriguing "COKE-O-LADA." It's not just a soda with a splash of syrup; these are thoughtfully crafted drinks designed to complement your cookie experience. It’s like a mini dessert and drink combo all in one. We had so much fun choosing our drinks, and it definitely enhanced the whole "date night" vibe. Walking into a Crave Cookies store is also a pleasant experience. The one we visited had a really clean, modern aesthetic with a sleek black and white counter and clear menu boards. It felt welcoming and efficient, not like a rushed factory line. Even while waiting for our order, which we did on a light-colored floor, the atmosphere was relaxed. It's clear they put thought into the customer journey, from the moment you step inside to the moment you walk out with your crave-worthy box of cookies. Now, if you're still on the fence about whether to try Crave over Crumbl, I'd say give Crave a shot if you appreciate a more "homemade" and less uniform cookie experience. Their unique flavor combinations, especially for their rotating selection, are worth exploring. And honestly, don't skip the loaded sodas – they're a game-changer! I’ve noticed that while Crumbl often has a larger fan base, the "crave vs crumbl reddit" discussions often highlight that Crave offers a different kind of quality, focusing on that fresh-baked, lovingly made feel. For me, the decision is pretty clear: Crave has won a special place in my heart (and my stomach!).
