Elysia vs Kay Ali

When I tell you, both of these smell the same! I hate that I paid $138 for my Kay Ali Yum Pistachio Gelato after I got my Elysia Pista Sundae which was 24.99.

Even with dry down, it still smells the same to me.💌 Brand:Kay

💵 Price:138.00 3.4 oz

💌 Brand:Elysia

💵 Price:24.99

you can get the Elysia brand on JomaShop.com

#kayali #perfume #perfumelayering #perfumedupe #elysia

2025/8/26 Edited to

... Read moreOkay, so you've heard the buzz, right? The Kayali Yum Pistachio Gelato is absolutely divine – that creamy, sweet, addictive pistachio scent has everyone hooked. But let's be real, the price tag can be a bit of a dream-crusher for many of us. For a 3.4 oz bottle, dropping $138 is a significant investment for a perfume. That's exactly why I went on a mission to find a worthy alternative, and oh my goodness, did I hit the jackpot with Elysia Pista Sundae! When I first smelled the Elysia Pista Sundae, priced at an astonishing $24.99, I honestly couldn't believe my nose. It’s almost uncanny how similar it is to Kayali's cult favorite. Both fragrances open with that delightful burst of sweet pistachio, but it's not just a fleeting resemblance that disappears in minutes. Even as they dry down, the cozy, warm, and inviting gourmand notes linger beautifully on the skin, making you smell absolutely edible and comforting. For me, the Elysia doesn't just mimic the initial top notes; it captures the essence of the Kayali throughout its wear, from the first spray to the soft, lingering base. I've worn both on different days and received compliments, and unless you're a super-sniffer with a highly trained nose, it's incredibly hard to tell them apart. And for a fraction of the cost – we're talking about saving over $100 here – it's an absolute no-brainer for anyone who loves that pistachio dream without the hefty price tag. It truly feels like a luxury scent experience without the luxury cost. Now, beyond just the Elysia Pista Sundae, my journey into pistachio scents didn't stop there. Thanks to my obsession with finding affordable alternatives to high-end fragrances, I've also stumbled upon other fantastic options that deserve a shout-out. For instance, have you seen the Fine'ry. Pistachio Please? This one is another gem you might spot if you're exploring the pistachio fragrance world. While it might have its own unique twist, perhaps leaning a little more into a nutty or creamy vanilla accord, it definitely plays in the same delicious sandbox as the Kayali and Elysia. It’s often more readily available in mainstream stores, making it another accessible option for those wanting to dip their toes into the pistachio trend without breaking the bank. Each of these offers a slightly different nuance, but they all share that irresistible creamy, nutty, and sweet signature that we're all craving from a good pistachio scent. Finding dupes isn't just about saving money; it's about making luxury more accessible and discovering amazing scents you might otherwise miss. It empowers us to enjoy our favorite fragrance profiles without feeling guilty about the expense. My advice for anyone looking for their next signature scent, especially in the gourmand family, is to always do your research, read reviews like this, and don't be afraid to try out more affordable brands. Often, these brands put immense effort into crafting high-quality, long-lasting fragrances that can stand toe-to-toe with their pricier counterparts. You might just find your new holy grail, a hidden gem that delivers all the joy without the financial sting. The Elysia Pista Sundae truly blew me away with its similarity to Kayali Yum Pistachio Gelato, and it's proof that sometimes, the best things (and scents) don't have to come with the biggest price tag. Give it a try, you might just fall in love and save a pretty penny!

13 comments

TheScentAlchemist🌹🍓🧁🍒🍰🍭's images
TheScentAlchemist🌹🍓🧁🍒🍰🍭

How long does Elysia last? I’ve been eyeing all of their scents inspired by Kayali!

See more(2)

Related posts

Two red perfume bottles are shown: Kay Ali Eden Juicy Apple 01 and Elysia Apple Rouge. They are placed side-by-side on a gray fabric surface.
Kay Ali vs Elysia
Kay Ali Apple Eden $100 Elysia, eden rouge, $24.99 To me, they both smell the same until you get to the dry down. The Elysia It’s more intense. #kay ali #kayalifragrance #dupesfordays #jomashop #jomashopsale
Eulisha A

Eulisha A

31 likes

A hand holds two bottles with pink liquid. The larger bottle has a gold cap and is labeled 'ELY SIA LYCHEE FIZZ'. The smaller bottle has a clear faceted cap and is labeled 'KAY ALI EDEN SPARKLING LYCHEE | 39'. The background is blurred.
Kay Ali vs Elysia
Kay Ali Eden sparkling Lychee 💵 Price:100 for1.7 oz Elysia Lychee Fizz💵 Price:24.99 #kayali perfume #kayali #dupesfordays #elysia
Eulisha A

Eulisha A

19 likes

Two shimmery purple perfume bottles are displayed on a dark background. The left bottle is labeled ELYSIA Vanilla Sugar with a gold cap, and the right bottle is labeled KAY ALI Vanilla Candy Rock Sugar | 42 with a clear faceted cap, comparing the two fragrances.
KAY Ali versus ELYSIA
💌 Brand: KAY ALI💵 Price: $138 💌 Brand:ELYSIA💵 Price: $25 at Joma shop I had already bought ELYSIA and my husband bought KAY ALI for me too for my birthday, he was made after I made him smell both of them, he told he could’ve saved some money and I said Nanana boo you have to get me the real st
Eulisha A

Eulisha A

66 likes

jk
elysia

elysia

1 like

Two perfume bottles are displayed on a white surface. One is smaller, pink and purple, with a faceted cap. The other is larger, with an orange to purple gradient, and a floral-shaped cap.
KAY ALI FLEUR MAJESTY & ELY SIA ELEGANCE 🫶
#kayali #elysia #perfume #Fragrance #fyp
Olga25

Olga25

30 likes

bride elysia 🫶
I keep forgetting about this app 💔 I need to cosplay bride ellie again 🙏 #elysia #honkaiimpact3rd #elysiacosplay #cosplay #hi3rd
Karma

Karma

2 likes

A collection of five Elysia perfume bottles is displayed. Scents include Apple Rouge, Elegance, and Vanilla. The bottles feature golden caps, some with floral designs, and vary in liquid color from red to light pink. The word 'ELYSIA' is prominently displayed at the top.
🔥Elysia🔥 Kayali dupes 🥰 love them ALL🥰🥰🥰
#elysia #perfume✨ #jesusisking #vanillaperfume #perfume tiktok
🩷 Ajalicia's Sweets 🩷

🩷 Ajalicia's Sweets 🩷

25 likes

ooo kkkkayyy
elysia

elysia

0 likes

Elysia 💕
Hihi, first time using this app 😽 #elysia #cosplay #videogame #honkalimpact3rd #hi3
YonXaer♧

YonXaer♧

17 likes

elysia

elysia

0 likes

Trader Joe's must have
#trader joes #musthaves #traderjoesgroceryhaul #traderjoes #Lemon8Diary
elysiadesire

elysiadesire

451 likes

elysia

elysia

2 likes

elysia

elysia

0 likes

elysia

elysia

0 likes

Elysia — Where Romance Meets Confidence ✨
A gown made to turn heads. ✨ Elysia blends ethereal lace and flowing tulle with a daring leg-slit design — a perfect balance of grace and confidence. Every step reveals a hint of allure, making this gown unforgettable from every angle. 💍 Would you dare to show a little leg on your wedding day?
CalistaCouture

CalistaCouture

35 likes

elysia

elysia

0 likes

😝
elysia

elysia

1 like

truly the most magical experience. would do the pain over and over again for my beautiful babies❤️
elysia

elysia

0 likes

cheeto girl😂
elysia

elysia

22 likes

shake shake shake
elysia

elysia

0 likes

Day 3 of 75 Medium ✨
Day 3 y’all, I’m trying to get better at making healthy meals and the stuff bell peppers were so good, also these workouts be killing me but I know they are going to have me snatched by the end of it lol. #75mediumjourney #fypシ
Elysia Gomez

Elysia Gomez

2 likes

Day 10 of 75 medium ✨
It was such a good day every time i go to the gym in the morning I feel so motivated for the rest of the day lol 💪🏽🤍 #75daysstrong #75days #Lemon8
Elysia Gomez

Elysia Gomez

6 likes

ELYSIA COLLECTION 🫶
#fragranceworld #elysia #perfumes #perfume #fy
Olga25

Olga25

17 likes

A hand holds three perfume bottles: Khair Confection, Elysia Vanilla Sugar, and Yara Candy, against a background of string lights and heart bokeh.
A Khair Confection perfume bottle with an orange-brown and blue gradient, gold cap. Text lists notes like pear, vanilla, marshmallow, and main accords including sweet, vanilla, and woody.
An Elysia Vanilla Sugar perfume bottle, pink with a floral cap. Text details notes such as vanilla orchid, jasmine, tonka bean, and main accords like sweet, amber, and vanilla.
Which DNA you like?
Khair Confection Elysia Vanilla Sugar Yara Candy They all give OG vibes however and this is my strong however bcuz I did smell Kayali Vanilla Candy Rock Sugar and I must say that ELYSIA smells exactly the same #Lemon8 #candyscent #fragranceoftheday
Sweet Tee Scents

Sweet Tee Scents

12 likes

😂😂😂😂
elysia

elysia

9 likes

that i don’t have
elysia

elysia

0 likes

Day 7 of 75 Medium
Finished a full week of hitting my goals, can’t wait to do more 💪🏽😊 #75daysstrong #fypシ
Elysia Gomez

Elysia Gomez

1 like

:)
elysia

elysia

0 likes

that’s meeee
elysia

elysia

0 likes

cherry blossom 🌸
elysia

elysia

0 likes

Day 8 of 75 Medium ✨
Went to the gym early in the morning, I had an amazing day today, it was super productive with cleaning my apartment and ending it with reading my book and doing my bible study 🤍 #75daysstrong #75days
Elysia Gomez

Elysia Gomez

2 likes

elysia

elysia

0 likes

Day 1 of 75 Medium ✨
First day of starting the 75 challenge and excited to achieve my goals and work hard 🤍💪🏽 #75medium #firstday
Elysia Gomez

Elysia Gomez

3 likes

elysia

elysia

1 like

Day 9 of 75 Medium
This day wasn’t really all that eventful lol but almost at double digits of this challenge 😂🤍 #75mediumjourney
Elysia Gomez

Elysia Gomez

14 likes

ughhhh i’m fighting so hard to not go backkkk
elysia

elysia

2 likes

Day 5 & 6 of 75 Medium
lol i’m slacking with the taking pictures but y’all this week I will get better but still pushing myself to do all my goals and so proud I’m going to be a full week soon 💪🏽🤍 #75mediumjourney #75days #fyplemon8
Elysia Gomez

Elysia Gomez

0 likes

See more