What do you look for in mascara?

WOW! Check out those lashes!!

Seriously, no words needed—it speaks for itself, right?!

What do you go for in a mascara? Length, volume, or both?

2024/8/23 Edited to

... Read moreOkay, let's be real, finding the perfect mascara can feel like a lifelong quest, right? I've been there! Staring at shelves, wondering which one will give me those 'wow' lashes without clumping or flaking. After years of trial and error (and some serious lash disasters!), I've finally figured out a few things that truly help in narrowing down the options and choosing the mascara that’s just right for *you*. First things first, understanding the different types is key. Are you dreaming of longer lashes that almost touch your brows, or are you craving more voluminous, thicker-looking fringe? Most mascaras fall into a few main categories, each designed to achieve a specific look. Volumizing Mascaras: These are my go-to when I want a dramatic, full lash line. They often have thicker formulas and denser brushes to coat each lash, making them appear plumper and more substantial. If your natural lashes are fine or sparse, a good volumizing mascara can work wonders! Lengthening Mascaras: If you feel your lashes are short, look for formulas that contain fibers or polymers that literally extend the tips of your lashes. The wands are usually slimmer, designed to comb through and stretch each lash upwards. I love pairing a lengthening mascara with a curler for an extra lift! Curling Mascaras: For those of us whose lashes are naturally straight, a curling mascara can be a game-changer. These formulas have a bit more grip and often come with a curved brush that helps to lift and set the curl. I always use my lash curler first, then apply a curling mascara to lock it in. Waterproof Mascaras: Essential for humid days, tear-jerkers, or a day at the beach! While they offer incredible staying power, I tend to use them sparingly because they can be a bit trickier to remove and might dry out lashes if used daily. Always use a gentle, oil-based remover for these! Beyond just the type, the wand and formula play a huge role in the final look. This is where I really started to understand how to choose mascara effectively. The Wand Matters: Have you ever noticed how different mascara brushes look? There's a reason! A fat, bristly brush is usually for volume, while a skinny, plastic, spiky wand is often for definition and length. If you want longer and more voluminous lashes, sometimes a tapered or hourglass-shaped brush can give you the best of both worlds, reaching every lash. I've found that experimenting with different wands, even from the same brand, can totally change the effect. Formula Consistency: Some formulas are drier, which is great for building layers without clumping. Others are wetter, which can be fantastic for a smooth, even coat but might need more drying time. If you're someone who experiences smudging, a 'tubing' mascara might be your perfect mascara solution – these wrap around each lash like tiny tubes and slide off with warm water, no raccoon eyes! What to Avoid: My biggest mascara pet peeves are clumping and flaking. To avoid this, always check the expiration date (yes, mascara expires, usually after 3-6 months!) and pump the wand as little as possible to prevent air from drying out the formula. If it starts to smell or get dry, it’s time to toss it. Also, avoid applying too many coats if the formula isn't designed for layering; sometimes less is more for a clean, defined look. Speaking of application, I’ve picked up a few tricks over the years. To get truly stunning, more voluminous lashes, I like to wiggle the wand right at the base of my lashes and then pull through to the tips. For extra length, I focus on brushing upwards and outwards, especially on the outer corners. And always, always let the first coat dry a little before applying the second to prevent clumping. It makes a huge difference! Ultimately, finding your perfect mascara is a personal journey, but by understanding your lash needs, exploring different types, and paying attention to the wand and formula, you'll be well on your way to achieving those enviable lashes. What a difference mascara can make, right? Happy lashing!

Related posts

Maybelline Firework Mascara Review 💖
GUYSSS!! I’ve found a new mascara I am obsessed with!! I have used this mascara everyday since I first tried it!! I’ve gotten so many compliments after using this mascaras. It seriously is a blend of the features you hope for in a mascara, but all in one! Have you tried this mascara yet? Wha
Mia DeLuca

Mia DeLuca

3205 likes

A store aisle displays various mascara products on shelves, with overlay text indicating a review of favorite mascaras and a star emoji.
A hand holds a pink packaged mascara, rated 8/10. The description notes that three coats are needed for great lashes.
A hand holds a purple packaged mascara, rated 7/10. The reviewer suggests it for casual outings.
Mascara Rating and Why? 👀
I love makeup and that’s why I created this page. I wanted to give you guys my favorite mascaras right now and why I love them. I have tried a lot of different mascaras and I know what I look for in my mascara. Let me know if you have tried these mascaras and is my rating fair? #letschat
Ty 😍✨✌🏽

Ty 😍✨✌🏽

1004 likes

A flat lay shows three mascara tubes and a black eyelash curler on a white surface. The text indicates a mascara tutorial for long lashes and a 3-step routine.
A black eyelash curler is centered on a white surface. The text identifies it as an eyelash curler, described as effective for curling lashes.
A rose gold mascara tube is shown on a white surface. The text identifies it as a mascara for adding volume and making lashes look fuller.
Mascara Recommendations✨
These are some of my must have products for making my lashes look longer and more full!🫶🏼 I tend to alternate between the L’Oréal lash paradise mascara and the Ilia limitless mascara for adding volume, but I always use the telescopic for separating my lashes at the end since the wand is very precis
Melanie

Melanie

3338 likes

A person with reddish-brown hair and closed eyes, surrounded by several tubes of a lash product. Text overlay asks if it's a 'Must Have for STRAIGHT LASHES?'. A tube and wand of the product are shown at the bottom right.
A person's face showing a comparison of natural lashes on the left eye and enhanced lashes on the right eye, achieved with only mascara and no lash curler.
A close-up of a person's face, looking upwards, highlighting the enhanced length of the lashes on the right eye after applying mascara.
Straight lashes struggles? Try this mascara!
Meet your new lash bestie! 💫 The Essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara isn’t just mascara— it’s a curling wand for straight lashes, giving you that dreamy, lifted look without the hassle. 🪄✨ One swipe, and you’re royalty! 👑💖 #shareyourthoughts #mascarareview #makeuptips
Catty Rivera 🫧🎐🌸

Catty Rivera 🫧🎐🌸

1448 likes

HOW TO: MASCARA
hai girlies i had to stop wearing lashes for a min because they would get too annoying or itchy so, im gonna show yall what products i use for my lash growth and just to get the lash effect you need ;) - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - You will need - Hair Growth
⃟

695 likes

A woman with long, wavy hair and prominent eyelashes looks at the camera from inside a car. Text overlay suggests achieving similar eyelash results.
i LOVE this mascara!!
This is what I always do… ✨First, curl your eyelashes ✨Then, put on your mascara and let it dry ✨Then, curl them again!! #mascara #eyelashes #makeup #lemon8challenge #lashes #Lemon8 #currentlywearing #beautyfinds #makeuptips #makeupideas
Zoe

Zoe

286 likes

A pink textured background with white text that reads "Why I will NEVER use another mascara," featuring two 'X' symbols.
A close-up view of a hazel eye with natural eyelashes, looking upwards, with the word "Before" at the top.
A close-up view of a hazel eye with mascara applied to the eyelashes, looking upwards, with the text "After 1 coat!" at the top.
Why I will NEVER use another mascara
I LOVE this mascara! I have tried my fair share of mascaras and this one is by far my favorite. I use the L’Oréal Paris Makeup Voluminous Original Mascara in the shade Deep Burgundy. I have hazel eyes so the burgundy helps bring out the green! In one coat I get such a lift and the color is subtle b
Tia_425

Tia_425

2243 likes

What mascara do you guys want me to try?
#fyp #mascara #lashes #eyelashes #mascarareview
Nic@Night

Nic@Night

50 likes

Buy or Bye : Mascara Edition
Here’s my buy or bye on mascaras!! Can’t recommend the ilia and elf mascaras enough! Whats your fav mascara? #byeorbuy #lemon8challenge #beautyfinds #beautyreview #makeuprecommendations #lemon8beautycrew #lemon8beautycoupon #Lemon8Box
dani :)

dani :)

188 likes

A new mascara product in its packaging, featuring a model's eye with enhanced lashes, is displayed on a surface with other blurred makeup items. Text on the image indicates it's a 'Top 5 Mascara' and highlights its 'very black' shade, suggesting volume and lift.
✨ New Mascara Alert + My Top 5 ✨
I just tried this new mascara and the volume immediately caught my attention 😍 My lashes look fuller, darker, and lifted without feeling heavy or clumpy. It builds really nicely and gives that bold lash look I love right away. Since lashes are kind of my thing, here are the top 5 mascaras that a
Tiana 🇵🇷

Tiana 🇵🇷

36 likes

How to apply mascara
What’s your favorite mascara??? #mascaratutorial #easymakeuplook #simplemakeuptutorial #simplemakeuplook #mascara
Biiutiful

Biiutiful

68 likes

5 Mascara Tips + Recs for Voluminous Lashes
Want your lashes to look fuller, longer, and fabulous all day long? Here are 5 must-know tips to take your mascara game to the next level! 1. Start with a lash primer Lash primers help separate and prep your lashes for mascara, allowing it to cling better and stay put all day. Plus, th
anika🍒

anika🍒

64 likes

Colorful Mascara Hack with this hack
OMG SCREAMING, I can’t believe I didn’t think of this earlier I mean i can go CRAZYYYY CRAZYYYY with a look #pink #pinkaesthetic #mascara #makeup #makeuphacks
Ynaleone

Ynaleone

103 likes

You’re Probably Applying Your Mascara Wrong
I’m not even going to lie, I was blessed with somewhat decent eyelashes. However over the years with age, I have noticed a difference in the thickness, length, and texture of the hairs. With these application tricks, I have noticeably longer lashes that last almost all day! My top fave affordab
Jayme

Jayme

3617 likes

No mascara makeup
This is my go to glowy base makeup routine. If youd like a breakdown of the products, let me know 🫶🏼 also what do you think of no mascara makeup looks?? I’m kind of obsessed… #lemon8partner #glowymakeup #glowymakeuplook #glowymakeuproutine #quickneasymakeup
Katelynn 💗

Katelynn 💗

126 likes

Maybelline Mascara 🩷
This is the new stocking stuffer!! This is the Maybelline Firework Mascara and it truly does it all! If you prefer a natural look or a volume look, you can get both with this mascara depending on how many layers you use! It’s so affordable and totally worth it! I put this exact mascara in my bio!
Mia DeLuca

Mia DeLuca

1254 likes

A smiling woman with long dark hair showcases a natural makeup look, featuring glossy lips and a radiant complexion, with text overlay "no mascara + foundation makeup" and Lemon8 branding.
Four panels illustrate makeup steps: spot concealing, contouring with cream bronzer on cheeks, applying cream bronzer for nose contour, and applying cream blush, all by a woman with dark hair.
Four panels show makeup blending and finishing steps: blending cream blush, blending nose contour, setting makeup with translucent powder, and applying lip tint, performed by a woman.
no mascara + foundation makeup look 🌸
Embrace the natural glow with my no-mascara, no-foundation makeup look! 💁‍♀️ The key? Spot concealer magic! Ditch the heavy foundation and opt for your trusty concealer—blend with your fingertips for a seamless finish that effortlessly camouflages imperfections. Why fingers? Because they warm up th
Lindsay Moreno

Lindsay Moreno

37 likes

What’s your favorite mascara?
I love to wear mascara, but i noticed after continuous use my lashes don’t look as healthy as when I don’t wear mascara for a while. What’s your favorite mascara? And what’s the best way to take off mascara? Because I guess it could be my removal process that damages them. I usually buy telescopic
Cece

Cece

515 likes

The “Face Lift” Mascara Hack
My face literally went from 📉 to 📈with one coat! Who needs a brow lift when L'Oréal Extensionist exists? Extensionist? More like an instant wake-up call. Am I crazy or does the left side of my face look 2 inches higher? The asymmetry was actually scary for a second. Don’t sleep on this ma
EffortlesslyChiic

EffortlesslyChiic

27 likes

No Mascara Makeup Look 💄
I decided to try this soft natural makeup and I felt like the vibe called for no mascara. What do you think? Would you have added mascara? #beauty #makeup #Makeuplook #mascara #naturalmakeup
Gabi 🌸

Gabi 🌸

17 likes

A flat lay shows various mascara tubes arranged in a circular pattern on a light blue floral fabric, with the text 'mascara roulette' and a star in the center.
A tube of Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara is displayed on a floral fabric, with text indicating a negative review and a rating of 1/5.
An Elf Lash N Roll Mascara tube is shown on a floral fabric, accompanied by text giving a negative review and a rating of 2/5.
★MASCARA ROULETTE★
mascara roulettteeeee! <3 im rating some of the mascaras i have laying around, in this adorable mascara roulette :) im trying to keep the reviews simple and straight to the point. yes or no and a small explanation to why. im more picky with my mascaras than i am with anything else in my ma
chellene

chellene

400 likes

5 minute no mascara makeup look🌸🥰✨
My 5-minute, no-mascara makeup look ✨ For days when I want to feel put together but still look like myself, this is my go-to. It’s soft, fresh, and effortless — perfect for running errands, coffee dates, filming content or just making yourself feel a little better👏 I focus on glowing skin, ligh
kheadington

kheadington

23 likes

Honest review of Sky High Mascara
💌 Brand: Maybelline 💵 Price:$10 👍Pros : Makes eyelashes have more volume! Purchased from: Walmart ⭐️Overall rating: /10:10 Additional Tips: I honestly like to get a paper towel and get some of the mascara off the brush before applying so it’s not too thick looking on eyelashes! #skyh
Carissa Juhl

Carissa Juhl

138 likes

A flat lay shows five different mascara tubes on a light-colored, textured surface. The text overlay asks, "WHAT'S YOUR FAVORITE MASCARA?". Visible mascaras include Too Faced Better Than Sex, GrandeDRAMA, Lancôme, Fan Fest, and L'Oréal Telescopic.
WHAT’S YOUR FAVORITE MASCARA?
🖤 What mascara makes your lashes look soooo long? 🖤 Is your mascara smudge proof? 🖤 Do you prefer waterproof mascara? Photo credit🖤: @alli weatherly #mascarareview #mascararecommendations #mascara #mascaratips #waterproofmascara #makeuprecommendations #makeupproducts #let
Lemon8 Beauty

Lemon8 Beauty

880 likes

A person demonstrates how to use brow gel as mascara, holding a lash curler, brow gel, and a spoolie. Inset images show a 'Before' and 'After' comparison of an eye, highlighting the difference in lash appearance.
A person holds an eyelash curler, demonstrating the first step of curling lashes as usual before applying any product.
A person holds a clear brow gel container and a clean spoolie brush, illustrating the second step of the process.
How to Use Brow Gel as Mascara
HOW TO USE BROW GEL AS MASCARA: Do you ever have those days where you want to do your makeup, but you can’t be bothered to apply mascara?! In my opinion, applying mascara can sometimes be my least favorite step due to how time-consuming and how particular I want my lashes to be. BUT, I thi
MADDY MCCLAIN

MADDY MCCLAIN

239 likes

Eyelash/Mascara Routine
One thing I love are my lashes looking like spider legs 😅 Here’s the routine and products I’ve been using lately to get my desired lash look! 1. Covergirl Ultimate Boost Volume Primer 2. L’Oreal Telescopic Carbon Black (not the gold one) 3. L’Oreal Telescopic Extensionist 4. Rimmel London
Cynthia

Cynthia

17 likes

How to Avoid Getting Mascara on Your Eyelids
HOW TO AVOID GETTING MASCARA ON YOUR EYELIDS: I can’t tell you how many times I’ve done my mascara just so it can completely get all over my eyelids and ruin my eyeshadow look that I just did. One too many! I’ve been searching ways to avoid this, tools, techniques for mascara application,
MADDY MCCLAIN

MADDY MCCLAIN

72 likes

No mascara makeup look!
Wearing no mascara makes your makeup look softer and a little more fresh in my opinion! Plus not having to remove mascara at night is a win in my book haha. Do you prefer mascara or no mascara? The products – BASE Versed skintint in 4W Tower28 concealer in IE Maybelline powder in fair light
stephanie tran

stephanie tran

30 likes

A close-up of a person's eyes, one with natural lashes and the other with extended, volumized lashes after applying a lash product. A black tube with a teal-handled wand is shown, along with text indicating a lash product.
A smiling woman with long, defined eyelashes, showcasing the effect of a lash product. She has green glitter nail polish and decorative lines around her face.
A black tube of a lash extending product with silver lettering, displayed next to its teal-handled wand with a black brush, on a plain background.
ELF MASCARA ✨
I have been asked quite a bite recently what mascara I use and you guys… it’s @elfcosmetics and it’s like $7???! By far my favorite mascara 💗 Don’t mind the fact that I look cross eyed 😂 #elf mascara #elf #mascara #makeup #baileypeterson
bailey peterson ✨

bailey peterson ✨

45 likes

A person's face with text overlay indicating four tips for achieving long, beautiful lashes, highlighted with sparkling graphics.
A list of four mascara application tips for best results, including wiggling the wand, layering, not pumping, and using the tip for definition.
A black mascara tube with green accents, accompanied by text describing its volumizing and lengthening benefits for sculpted lashes.
4 mascara tips + must-have products
Let’s dive into tips and my top mascaras of the season🥰 Mascara tips for best results: • Wiggle and lift: Start at the base of your lashes, wiggle the wand, and lift up to the tips to get full volume and length. • Layer up: Apply multiple coats to add volume without waiti
anika🍒

anika🍒

49 likes

A hand holds an orange mascara package, with "COLLEGE GIRL BEAUTY FAVES" text. Two other mascara packages, green and purple, are visible in a store aisle, surrounded by stars and hearts.
A hand holds an orange mascara package in a store aisle. Overlay text rates the product highly and mentions its availability at a retail store for under ten dollars.
A hand holds a green mascara package in a store aisle. Overlay text describes the product as making lashes look long and available at a retail store for under ten dollars.
Best Mascara for College☺️✨
Sooo, I almost always get asked on what mascara i use and why it lasts so long. This is the best mascara i have ever used. It's been my go to so far my entire college experience. I also like looking for products that last the whole day (meaning i can cry and it wont run LOL) idk how but this d
Alexia ❄️🎀✨⭐️🧸💗

Alexia ❄️🎀✨⭐️🧸💗

24 likes

See more