Overhyped Romance Books

These are some of the most overhyped romance books (in my opinion) that I’ve read recently and the reasons why.

📘Brutal Prince: For enemies to lovers, this gave absolutely nothing. I tend to like Sophie Lark’s writing, but this one was so boring to read and lacked any sort of excitement for me.

📘Dance of Thieves: I really tried to like this because I’m a fan of romance/fantasy, but the characters were so one-dimensional to me and it was very predictable.

📘Spanish Love Deception: I really tried to enjoy this book, but it just got so cheesy after a while that I almost DNFed it.

📘Love Hypothesis: I absolutely love Ali Hazelwood, but this book isn’t one of my favorites of hers. I can’t stand the miscommunication trope and it just lacked the spark that a lot of her other books have.

📘Twisted Love: This is my least favorite Ana Huang book (close to Twisted Hate). Out of all the couples, I just really found nothing interesting within these two. I do enjoy the series though, overall.

@Lemon8 BookClub

#lemon8bookclub #lemon8bookclubchallenge #letschat #romancebooks #books #booktok

2024/6/6 Edited to

... Read moreIn the world of romance literature, certain titles often gain immense popularity, making them highly anticipated reads among avid fans. However, not every hyped book meets expectations. For instance, 'Brutal Prince' by Sophie Lark presents itself as an enemies-to-lovers tale but falls short in excitement and character depth, leaving readers craving more engagement. Similarly, 'Dance of Thieves' struggles with one-dimensional characters that dilute its romantic fantasy essence, while 'Spanish Love Deception' veers into cheesiness, risking reader commitment. Ali Hazelwood's 'Love Hypothesis' showcases her talent yet disappoints with overused tropes like miscommunication, failing to deliver the usual spark. Lastly, in 'Twisted Love', a popular series by Ana Huang, the chemistry between characters feels lacking compared to previous installments, raising questions about character development. For those navigating through sensationalized book recommendations, critical perspectives provide a refreshing and honest approach to identifying what truly resonates in romance novels. Readers are encouraged to delve deeper into discussions around narrative elements, character arcs, and thematic execution when selecting their next book to ensure that their reading journeys are both enjoyable and fulfilling.

13 comments

Mariana • sahm's images
Mariana • sahm

I agree with Twisted love. It started out pretty good and then as it went on it started to feel a little predictable. So much was going on at once… idk. It felt weird the last half. Also, the mmc didn’t have to hate literally everything😭

See more(1)
kiana's images
kiana

the only one i enjoyed from these was spanish love deception. it was corny but it fit for me and was like a cute lil lifetime movie 😭😂 the twisted series is a miss for me entirely… i do not get the appeal

Related posts

Cowboy Romance Books you've been sleeping on
#romancebookrecommendations #romancebooks #romancebookrecs #romancereader #lemon8bookclub
Lacy Chantell

Lacy Chantell

1440 likes

A person is shown reading a book in bed, with the title "SPICY BOOKS AND THE SPICY CHAPTERS 2" and chili pepper emojis, indicating a list of spicy book chapters.
This image displays book covers from the 'From Blood and Ash Series' by Jennifer L. Armentrout, including 'From Blood and Ash', 'Kingdom of Flesh and Fire', 'The Crown of Gilded Bones', and 'The War of Two Queens', with specific 'spicy' chapter numbers listed below each.
This image features book covers from 'The Empyrean Series' by Rebecca Yarros, including 'Fourth Wing', 'Iron Flame', and 'Onyx Storm', with specific 'spicy' chapter numbers listed below each.
😉Spicy chapters in popular romance books
Spicy chapters only. You've been warned🔥 These scenes rewired my brain. 👀Check the triggers before you dive in! Did I miss your fave? Drop it below ⬇️ #lemonschallenge #lemon8bookclub #spicychapters #spicyrecommendations #romancebooks
ClaraReadsRomance

ClaraReadsRomance

1361 likes

An overhead shot of several hockey romance book covers, including 'Collide' and 'Icebreaker', with chili pepper emojis and a candle. The text overlay reads 'SPICIEST HOCKEY ROMANCE BOOKS PART 2', indicating a list of spicy hockey romance recommendations.
The book cover for 'Collide' by Bal Khabra, featuring two college students. Keywords around it describe the plot: college, reverse grumpy x sunshine, hockey captain x psych student, he falls first, found family, and research partners.
The book cover for 'Him' by Sarina Bowen and Elle Kennedy, showing the back of a male figure with a hockey stick. Surrounding text highlights themes like roommates, forced proximity, gay for you, bi-awakening, second chance, and childhood friends to lovers.
spiciest hockey romance books
what’s the best spicy hockey romance you’ve read so far? part two of the spiciest hockey romances you need to read! if you loved the first set, you’ll love these even more! here are more spicy hockey romances to add to your tbr. make sure you check out part one if you haven’t already! #lemon
romance books

romance books

1373 likes

Dark Romance Series books
Whats up awesome readers! Do you love reading dark romance just as much as I do? If the answer is yes, then I have a whole list of dark romances. These are dark romance series meaning theirs multiple books that all connect, but they can be read as a standalone if needed. Have fun! Be aware of any
Books by Ann✨

Books by Ann✨

276 likes

Romance Edition 🥰
Overhyped, Underhyped , Appropriately hyped romance books ! #bookrecommendations #romanceandfictionbooks #books #booktok
riahreads

riahreads

104 likes

Sports Romance books
I love reading sports romance books just as much as any other books. Here’s a list of sports romance books that I’ve read or are currently in my TBR. Let me know what you think of these books or if you have any suggestions. Happy reading.📖 #Lemon8Diary #Lemon8 #book #booksoflemon8 #books
Books by Ann✨

Books by Ann✨

453 likes

Dark Romance books
What’s up readers! I’m back with more book recommendations but with dark romance. Keep in mind some of these books have serious trigger warnings ❗️so please review and be mindful before reading these books. Let me know what you think of these or comment more dark romance books. Happy reading.📖
Books by Ann✨

Books by Ann✨

745 likes

Under Over and Appropriately Hyped Books
Sorry not sorry. #overhypedbooks #booktok #bookrecs
Jaimee 🧚‍♂️ 🐉 🩵

Jaimee 🧚‍♂️ 🐉 🩵

1589 likes

Young Adult ROMANCE BOOKS
“Closed-Door Romance Novels include most of the action happening behind a closed door. There may be an intimate scene or two, but it will be minimal.” Books summaries below ❤️⬇️ BETTER THAN THE MOVIES: In this rom-com about rom-coms, a hopeless romantic teen attempts to secure a happily-ever-
Lauren 📕

Lauren 📕

697 likes

The image displays open books with the text overlay '25 SPICY ROMANCE BOOKS TO ADD TO YOUR TBR LIST'. A 'lemons @readers.archive' watermark is at the bottom.
Four book covers are shown: 'King of Wrath' by Ana Huang, 'For The Fans' by Nyla K., 'Haunting Adeline' by H.D. Carlton, and 'Brutal Prince' by Sophie Lark, against a background of open books.
Four book covers are displayed: 'God of Malice' by Rina Kent, 'The Ritual' by Shantel Tessier, 'Hooked' by Emily McIntire, and 'Praise' by Sara Cate, on a background of open books.
25 spicy romance books to add to your tbr list
here’s my monthly post unfortunately I was running out of time today so I had to do 25 instead of 50 #lemon8bookchallenge #lemon8bookclub #lemon8bookworm #book #booktok #bookaesthetic #booksoflemon8 #bookrecommendations #bookrecs #bookboyfriend
Readers.archive

Readers.archive

1302 likes

The cover of the book 'Lights Out' by Navessa Allen, featuring a blue skull with an X and a heart in its eye sockets against a black floral background. Text on the cover reads 'NEW YORK TIMES BESTSELLER' and 'THE COUPLE WHO SLAYS TOGETHER, STAYS TOGETHER'. A 5/5 rating is handwritten on the image.
Lights Out: Navessa Allen
I hesitated on reading this book, I won’t even lie. I seen it all over TikTok… all over instagram… even on Lemon8. I figured it was probably going to be overhyped or just not worth reading. Man, was I wrong 😮‍💨🤌🏻 This book is HILARIOUS. I loved every aspect of it. I guess I’m officially in m
Mama_Reads22

Mama_Reads22

1391 likes

ROMANCE BOOKS
spice free!!🌸 #books #romancebooks #youngadult
🍵🩰

🍵🩰

701 likes

Overhyped, under hyped, and appropriately hyped romance books! Just my opinion!!! #booktok #romancebooks #romancebooktok #overhypedbooks #underhypedbooks
Brianna | BookTok

Brianna | BookTok

7 likes

my FAVORITE romance books!
if someone asks me for romance book recommendations i’ll ALWAYS recommend these! ✨ Offside by Avery Keenan (18+) ✨ The Deal by Elle Kennedy (18+) ✨ Throttled by Lauren Asher (18+) ✨ Love, Theoretically by Ali Hazelwood (18+) ✨ Better Than the Movies by Lynn Painter (YA) ✨ Icebreaker by Hann
Chloe Palmieri

Chloe Palmieri

877 likes

A stack of books on a wooden surface with the pink and blue text overlay "ROMANCE BOOKS I WON'T STOP RECOMMENDING." Decorative stars and hearts are around the text, with the Lemon8 logo and username @mikalasreads at the bottom.
A hand holds the book "The Sun Is Also a Star" by Nicola Yoon. The cover features colorful abstract lines. Text overlays include "CREAT YA LOVE STORY" and "HE FALLS FIRST," highlighting its young adult romance theme.
A hand holds the book "Twisted Games" by Ana Huang. The white and gold cover shows the title and a crown. Text overlays read "PRINCESS/BODYGUARD LOVE STORY" and "CREAT SPICE!!!," indicating a spicy romance.
💗romance books I won't stop recommending💗
These are four romance books I will always be screaming from the rooftops for people to read! I have read so many books, and these love stories I cannot get out of my mind. The Sun is Also a Star: This is a young adult romance that has had my heart since the day I read it over a year ago! The tw
mikalasreads

mikalasreads

619 likes

romance books for the girlies✨️💅🏼
Some of my favorite swoon worthy romances! #readersoflemon8 #lemon8bookclub #lemon8bookchallenge #bookgirly #romancebooks #readingrecommendations #bookaesthetic #bookwormsoflemon8
leeah

leeah

260 likes

3 overhyped books, 3 underhyped books, 3 appropriately hyped books. And I’m always right. #bookrecs #underhypedbooks #booktokrecs #romantasy #popularbooks
Jaimee 🧚‍♂️ 🐉 🩵

Jaimee 🧚‍♂️ 🐉 🩵

181 likes

Books I regret purchasing🙂‍↕️
The first two were overhyped and just bad but I had no motivation what’s so ever after buying the last 4 books due to the horrible reviews.😅 #books 🫶🏼 #readingaesthetic #reader #book #booktok
Kyla 🫧

Kyla 🫧

776 likes

An open book with pages showing text, overlaid with 'spicy dark romance books' in bold white letters with a black outline. A Lemon8 watermark is in the bottom left corner.
The cover of 'DOES IT HURT?' by H.D. Carlton, featuring a lighthouse and a woman's silhouette. Text overlays mention 'enemies to lovers,' 'dark romance,' 'tattooed,' and 'morally grey mmc,' highlighting themes.
The cover of 'HAUNTING ADELINE' by H.D. Carlton, displaying a skull and dark, gothic imagery. Overlaid text indicates themes like 'enemies to lovers,' 'stalking,' 'insta love/lust,' and 'dark themes'.
spicy dark romance books
I absolutely can’t get over these books and the spicy scenes in them 😭😭 #lemon8bookchallenge #lemon8bookclub #lemon8bookworm #book #booktok #bookaesthetic #booksoflemon8 #bookrecommendations #bookrecs #bookboyfriend
Readers.archive

Readers.archive

468 likes

A collage of dark romance book covers, including 'Promises and Pomegranates,' '365 Days,' 'Claiming You,' 'Kelli Maine Taken,' 'Comfort Food,' 'The Paper Swan,' 'Prisoner,' and 'Hostage,' with the title '9 DARK ROMANCE BOOKS *HE KIDNAPS HER EDITION*'.
The book cover for 'REDRABBIT' by Devyn Rivers, featuring red and black abstract art, with text stating 'she's taken by the enemy and held in a warren'.
The book cover for 'THE PAPER Swan' by Leylah Attar, showing a person partially submerged in water, with text 'the boy she once knew is out for revenge..the girl he once knew doesn't know why..'.
9 dark romance books *he kidnaps her edition*
For the book besties who love a good kidnapping story. 😉 #darkromance #darkromancebooks #lemon8bookclub #readersoflemon8 #bookstagram #booktok #spicyromance #bookrecommendations
ᥲrιᥱ❦

ᥲrιᥱ❦

378 likes

Dark Mafia Romance Books
⚠️Trigger Warning⚠️ Hi readers. Do you love reading mafia books, I know I do! Here’s some book recommendations. My favorite is the Sinners Anonymous series and the perfectly imperfect series, I absolutely love those series. What’s your favorite dark mafia romance book? Enjoy! Happy reading.📖
Books by Ann✨

Books by Ann✨

483 likes

An open book on a white bedspread displays an illustration of a man and a woman in a bedroom, with the text "books i will always defend" on the left page.
A hand holds the book "Wildfire" by Hannah Grace, featuring a cabin illustration. Annotations highlight "one night stand," "golden retriever mmc," and "healing," along with a quote from the book.
A hand holds the book "Shutout" by Avery Keelan, depicting a couple kissing. Annotations indicate "brothers best friend," "soft only for her," and "roommates," accompanied by a quote.
underrated romance books
like/save for later <3 🔥wildfire: everyone says this book is boring compared to icebreaker but i loved it so much, i thought it was such a sweet love story. i loved both the fmc and mmc & side characters. he’s so soft n sweet but has a dirty mouth ugh i love russ sm. idk what it was but
mads

mads

1286 likes

A collection of romance novels, including 'Punishment,' 'Wild Love,' 'Credence,' and 'Highest Bidder,' are displayed on a white textured surface. The image features a text overlay that reads 'spicy age gap romance books,' highlighting the genre of the featured literature.
The book 'Highest Bidder' by Sara Cate is shown, featuring the Eiffel Tower on its cover. Text indicates a 35-year age gap, a rich male lead, and an accidental pregnancy trope, with themes of dark romance.
The book 'The Doctor' by Nikki Sloane is displayed, with a stethoscope on its cover. Text highlights a 22-year age gap, a doctor male lead, and a friends-with-benefits to lovers trope involving an ex-boyfriend's dad.
spicy age gap romance books
rich fictional men>>>real men #lemon8bookchallenge #lemon8bookclub #lemon8bookworm #book #booktok #bookaesthetic #booksoflemon8 #bookrecommendations #bookrecs
Readers.archive

Readers.archive

894 likes

💐My 10/10 romance books as a reader 💐
#reading #romancebooks
🎀𝒦𝒶𝓉𝓎🎀

🎀𝒦𝒶𝓉𝓎🎀

464 likes

The image features a stack of books with the overlay text "BookTok books I don't like." It includes decorative book and sparkle icons, along with a Lemon8 watermark.
The book cover for "The Silent Patient" by Alex Michaelides is displayed on a pink fuzzy blanket. The image includes a 2/5 star rating and comments "SLOW" and "PREDICTABLE."
The book cover for "We Were Liars" by E. Lockhart is shown on a pink fuzzy blanket. The image includes a 1/5 star rating and comments "boring" and "main girl is so annoying."
popular books I don’t like 🤷🏻‍♀️
Here are three popular books I just didn’t care for. Most of them were okay just way too overhyped which led to me being dissappinted. 😕 Let me know your opinions on these books, and also any other popular books you don’t like. ❓❔ #lemon8bookclub #lemon8bookchallenge #bookrecommendations
elyssa🎀📚

elyssa🎀📚

706 likes

The image displays the book cover for 'Icebreaker' by Hannah Grace, featuring a female figure in a purple dress and a male figure in a hockey jersey. Text overlay states 'romance books written by lgbtq+ authors', alongside a glass of green drink and sticky notes.
The book cover for 'Boyfriend Material' by Alexis Hall is shown, featuring two male characters and London landmarks. Text overlays describe it as 'book 1 out of 2', 'fake dating', 'bad boy x good boy', and 'opposites attract'.
The book cover for 'They Both Die at the End' by Adam Silvera is displayed, showing two silhouetted male figures. Text overlays include 'science fiction world', 'BROKE MY HEART', 'instant love/ connect', and 'young adult'.
romance books written by lgbtq+ authors
for anyone looking for spicy lgbtq+ books I highly suggest anything written by Katee Roberts #lemon8bookchallenge #lemon8bookclub #lemon8bookworm #book #booktok #bookaesthetic #booksoflemon8 #bookrecommendations #bookrecs
Readers.archive

Readers.archive

542 likes

Popular booktok books 📚
“under hyped-appropriately hyped-over hyped” edition ✨ #tiktokbooks #popularbookrecs #bookgirl #lemon8books
Dani 🧚🏼‍♀️

Dani 🧚🏼‍♀️

9 likes

🫧Is EOS overhyped?🫧
I finally got my hands on all 4 body washes!! Do you think this brand is overhyped? Which scent is your favorite from this brand? #letschat #eos
🐆PrettyRe🐆

🐆PrettyRe🐆

1808 likes

Are the G8X M cars overhyped ??
I’m just curious as to what certain people say, I personally love the G82 M4 but would still take an F82 M4 almost anyday. #carsoflemon8 #bmw #g82 #m3 #g80 Atlanta
imjustbuba

imjustbuba

145 likes

An illustration of a couple embracing, with the woman taking a selfie. Text overlay reads 'Romance Books with Hispanic/LatinX MCs'. The image also includes 'Lemons @marnays07' and 'alexdrawl' signatures.
Four book covers by author Elena Armas are displayed: 'The Spanish Love Deception', 'The American Roommate Experiment', 'The Long Game', and 'The Fiance Dilemma'. Pink heart icons are at the top.
Four book covers by author Elizabeth Acevedo are shown: 'The Poet X', 'Clap When You Land', 'With the Fire on High', and 'Family Lore'. Pink heart icons and 'not really romance' text are at the top.
Romance Books With LatinX MCs 📚
In honor of Hispanic Heritage Month, I wanted to share with you guys a list of books with Hispanic and Latinx representation!!! Here's a list of mostly romance books that I've read or plan to read with Hispanic and Latinx MCs! I hope you enjoy them!!! Feel free to drop some more recom
Marnaysha 🇭🇹♡

Marnaysha 🇭🇹♡

973 likes

My Favorite Romance Books For Teens (no sex)
To all the boys I’ve loved before 💌: Lara Jean keeps her love letters in a hatbox her mother gave her. They aren’t love letters that anyone else wrote for her, those are the ones she’s written. One for every boy she’s ever loved – five and all. When she writes, she can pour out her heart and sou
Maggie

Maggie

329 likes

New absolutely NOT overhyped book alert. We who will ☠️ by Stacia Stark is ELITE romantasy. #staciastark #romantasybooks #booktokrecs #bookreview #fantasybooktok
Jaimee 🧚‍♂️ 🐉 🩵

Jaimee 🧚‍♂️ 🐉 🩵

34 likes

clean romance books to read next
these books got me back into reading…i love love love sarah adams #books #romance #sarahadams
maddy 🩷

maddy 🩷

141 likes

book opinionz 👀
I’ve seen this trend on tiktok but i wanted to join in too! So here are two books i think are overhyped, two books i think are underhyped, and two books i think are hyped up the appropriate amount!! 👀 The Silent Patient and Powerless both reallyyyyy let me down :/ The direction The Silent Pa
molly

molly

789 likes

CURRENTLY READING
📖Currently Reading: Iron Flame by Rebecca Yarros 📍Chapter 42, page 571 ✨ Thoughts So Far: I originally didn’t want to read this series because I thought it was going to be one of those books people overhyped. HOWEVER, I am absolutely loving everything about it. The dialogue is better in Iron Flam
Rachel Torres

Rachel Torres

12 likes

An open book rests on a bed in a sunlit room with plants by the window. Overlay text reads "Book that too overhyped My opinions."
A hand holds the book "Things We Never Got Over" by Lucy Score, featuring a light blue cover with daisies, against a white knit blanket. Overlay text expresses disappointment.
The book "The Unhoneymooners" by Christina Lauren, with a vibrant yellow cover featuring a toucan and tropical foliage. Overlay text describes a lack of chemistry and an unexpected ending.
✨Book that too overhyped✨
#lemon8bookclub #Lemon8Diary #Lemon8 📖: There are people out there who love this book. I have no hate to the author, just my own opinion, but who knows, I might like this book in the future ✨️What book do you think are overhyped?✨️
xoxoli( *・ω・)ノヽ

xoxoli( *・ω・)ノヽ

13 likes

books i want to read
why i’m afraid of them: 1. haunting adeline - is it overhyped? is it too dark? is it cheesy writing? 2. pride and prejudice - as an english major, i don’t love reading classics in my free time 3. throne of glass - im waiting on the graphic audiobook coming out soon! 4. 7 husbands - i want
emalee

emalee

78 likes

A stack of popular romance and fantasy books rests on a wooden nightstand next to a bed. An overlay asks, "LET'S BE REAL What book is overhyped I'll go first," alongside a vase of red flowers and a disco ball.
The book "Icebreaker" by Hannah Grace is displayed on a white textured surface. An overlay states, "#1 honestly I've read wattpads better than this book, the book lost it's plot mid-way through."
The book "Powerless" by Lauren Roberts is shown on a white textured surface. An overlay reads, "2# This one might be more of a hot take, Is this book good? Yes. is it way overhyped still? Yes. Both can be true at the same time."
Be truthful, what books are lowkey overhyped??
Hope this didn’t make any of you guys mad. All these books are good (except icebreaker) but just don’t deserve all the hype they get. #books #BookReview #reading #booktok #read
Fatuma’s 𝔹𝕠𝕠𝕜𝕞𝕒𝕣𝕜

Fatuma’s 𝔹𝕠𝕠𝕜𝕞𝕒𝕣𝕜

69 likes

See more