Review the Superstay Teddy Tint Blush 🥰

Puerto Rico
2025/8/10 Edited to

... Read moreOkay, let's talk about the Maybelline Superstay Teddy Tint! When I first heard about this product, I was immediately intrigued, especially with all the buzz around multi-use tints. My big question, and probably yours too, was: can you really use the Maybelline Superstay Teddy Tint as a blush? I got my hands on the shade Petal Rose #40, and I've put it to the test to give you my honest thoughts. First Impressions & Application: When I squeezed a tiny dot of the Superstay Teddy Tint onto my fingers, I noticed its creamy-gel texture right away. It's not too watery, which I appreciate, but also not thick or sticky. For blush application, I prefer using my fingertips because it allows for a more natural, skin-like finish. I dabbed a small amount onto the apples of my cheeks and gently blended it upwards towards my temples. It blended out surprisingly easily! I was worried it might set too fast, like some tints do, leaving me with patchy spots, but this one gave me enough playtime to get a smooth, diffused look. Petal Rose #40 is this gorgeous soft, rosy pink that instantly brightened my complexion without looking overdone. The "Blush" Test: Pigmentation & Finish: What really impressed me was the buildability. One sheer layer of the Maybelline Superstay Teddy Tint gave me a very natural, 'I just got back from a brisk walk' kind of flush – perfect for an everyday look. If I wanted more intensity, I found I could easily layer a second tiny dot, and it deepened the color beautifully without getting cakey or feeling heavy. The finish is definitely more on the natural, semi-matte side, which I love because it doesn't emphasize texture on my skin. It truly looks like my skin, but better, with a healthy pop of color. The shade Petal Rose #40 is just universally flattering, in my opinion, making it a great choice for anyone looking for a subtle, youthful glow. Longevity & Wear: Now, for the real test: how long does it last as a blush? Maybelline advertises "Superstay," and I'm happy to report that it lives up to its name, even on the cheeks! On a typical workday, I applied it around 7 AM, and by late afternoon, around 4-5 PM, I could still clearly see a lovely wash of color. It faded gracefully, rather than disappearing completely or getting patchy. I didn't experience any transfer or pilling with my foundation underneath, which is a huge plus. This makes it a fantastic option for those long days when you don't want to worry about your blush fading away. Pros & Cons of Using it as a Blush: Pros: Excellent blendability, buildable pigmentation, natural-looking finish, impressive long-wear, and the Petal Rose #40 shade is stunning. It really gives you that fresh, healthy glow. Cons: Because it's a tint, you need to work relatively quickly, especially if you're layering. If your skin is very dry, make sure to prep with a good moisturizer or hydrating primer to ensure seamless application. Tips for Best Results: Start Small: A tiny dot goes a long way. You can always add more! Work in Sections: If you're new to tints, apply to one cheek, blend, then move to the other. Use Fingers or a Damp Sponge: Both methods work wonderfully for a natural, seamless blend. Set Lightly (Optional): If you have oily skin or want extra longevity, a very light dusting of translucent powder over top can help, but it's often not necessary. Final Thoughts: So, can you use the Maybelline Superstay Teddy Tint as a blush? Absolutely, yes! In my experience, the Superstay Teddy Tint, particularly in Petal Rose #40, performs beautifully as a liquid blush. It's a fantastic, long-lasting option that delivers a natural, radiant flush. If you're on the hunt for an affordable, high-performing tint that pulls double duty for lips and cheeks, give this one a try. You might just find your new favorite!

Related posts

✨ Blush + Lip Tint for $5? Obsessed.
These e.l.f. Sheer For It Blush Tints are multipurpose magic. I purchased Left on Red, Pink Positive, and Plums Up, all blend like a dream and give that soft, sheer flush I love 💓 The Stain & Tint Brush made application so easy, I already want the rest of the shades. Would you wear these o
Alexandra M Rojas

Alexandra M Rojas

1799 likes

A retail shelf display showcasing multiple units of a new liquid blush tint product in various color packaging. The product is described as a buildable stain for lips and cheeks.
A hand holds a pink-packaged liquid blush tint. A vibrant red swatch is shown, alongside three diverse models demonstrating the sheer red tint on their cheeks and lips.
A hand holds an orange-packaged liquid blush tint. A bright orange swatch is shown, alongside three diverse models demonstrating the sheer orange tint on their cheeks and lips.
✨E.L.F’s $5 Blush Tint Drop 💗
New ELF Sheer For It Blush Tints just dropped and they’re only $5 💗 They’re buildable, easy to blend, and work on both cheeks and lips……so good for summer! I found mine at Target, but Ulta has them too (ELF’s site is sold out right now). I picked up Cherry Coke and can’t wait to share how
6xmoee

6xmoee

1177 likes

Three elf blush tint products in pink packaging are displayed, labeled 'SHEER FOR IT BLUSH TINT' and 'BUILDABLE STAIN FOR LIPS + CHEEKS'. A pink flower clip is nearby. The image is titled 'new elf blush tint swatches'.
new elf blush tint swatches🌸
#blushtint #newmakeup #blushes #newmakeupfinds #drugstoremakeupfavorites
bailey🧸

bailey🧸

1324 likes

Dollar Tree Makup Find & Review
Ioni Cheek & Lip Tint. Dollar Tree has really stepped their game up. #dollartreefinds #dollartreemakeup #dollartreemusthaves #makeupreview #tinasrecovery
Tinassee

Tinassee

44.7K likes

ELF SHEER FOR IT BLUSH TINT REVIEW ❤️
The e.l.f. Sheer For It Blush Tint is one of those products that makes sense when you want something quick, easy, and low maintenance. The formula is lightweight and blends out effortlessly, giving a soft wash of color that looks really natural on both the cheeks and lips. I used the shade Maple La
Bianca Alexis

Bianca Alexis

32 likes

A woman with glowing skin lies down, with text overlaying 'MY FAV SAIE PRODUCTS FOR SUMMER SKIN' and small icons of beauty products.
A flat lay displays various Saie Beauty products, including a slip tint, blush, bronzer, and a lip product, with the text 'THE LINEUP'.
A woman applies 'Saie slip tint concealer' under her eye with an applicator, showcasing the product in use.
BEST SAIE BEAUTY PRODUCTS 🎀 REVIEW✨
Saie Beauty has some amazing products! One of their bestsellers is the Glowy Super Gel. It gives you a natural, dewy glow and it's perfect for everyday wear. Another great product is their Slip Tint, which is a lightweight tinted moisturizer that evens out your skin tone. And if you're look
destiny luna 🌟

destiny luna 🌟

1471 likes

Blush Addition on Buy or Bye!
🌟I am a HUGE blush girl. It’s somthing that to me makes or breaks how my face looks when I have makeup on. Sometimes even when I try to have a no makeup day I usually end up just putting some blush on and feel fine. It is also hard for me to find the right blush because my skin is super sensitive t
Gabby

Gabby

875 likes

maybelline superstay teddy lip tints review 🧸🩷🍇
maybelline superstay teddy lip tints are that girl!!! I 100% love how easy these are to apply and the shades are stunning 💕 I have shades petal core & wild at heart and they are both my go to lippies when I need to head out the door have you tried these? #beautyreview #lemon8challen
Sammie

Sammie

146 likes

Maybelline Teddy Tint Swatches 🧸
#GiftedByMaybelline Swatching 10 shades from the new Maybelline Superstay Teddy Tint line in order from top to bottom! The Shade Order: 1️⃣ Wild At Heart 2️⃣ Skinny Dip 3️⃣ Soft Era 4️⃣ Kneehigh 5️⃣ Coffee Date 6️⃣ Faux Freckle 7️⃣ Cool Grunge 8️⃣ Ribbon Tied 9️⃣ Endgame 🔟 Velvet Ch
Alexandra M Rojas

Alexandra M Rojas

5 likes

A person's face with five blush swatches on the cheek, ranging from plum to red and pink. Text indicates 'Blushes for Neutral Skin Recommendations | Swatches' and the creator's handle.
Three plum-toned blush products are displayed on a textured surface: a liquid tint, a small tube, and a round compact. Text identifies them as Armani, Huda Beauty, and Rare Beauty blushes.
Two red and pink blush products are shown on a textured surface: a rectangular liquid tint and a cylindrical bottle. Text identifies them as Maybelline and Rude Cosmetics blushes.
Blush recommendations for Neutral undertones
Neutral skin girlies.. these blush shades hit just right 💋 I tried a mix of plum, red, and pink blushes to see what flatters best on my neutral undertone. Spoiler: They all make your skin pop in the best way 👏 🍇 Plum Picks: - Rare Beauty Soft Pinch in “Truth” – soft matte & so wearab
nicaabarientos

nicaabarientos

58 likes

The under eye Blush trick ✨
Is it just me or did this hack somehow bring life back to the makeup look? Blush Prodcuts + brightening concealer Armani beauty luminous silk cheek tint Rhode pocket blush Kosas revealer extra bright concealer #lemon8partner #makeuphacks #blushhacks #blushplacement #makeuprec
Hannah Williams 💋🍒

Hannah Williams 💋🍒

42 likes

e.l.f Maple Latte Blush Tint! 🤎🫦✨
It's Back e.l.f Maple Latte Blush Tint!! So affordable! So good! 🤎🫦✨ #elftintedblush #elflipstain #tintedblush #elfcosmetics #blonzer 💌 Brand: elf cosmetics 💵 Price: $6.00!
sophieluv.x0

sophieluv.x0

10 likes

A person demonstrates a transition blush technique, holding a warm-toned stick blush and a bright pink liquid cheek tint. Their cheeks show a blend of these blush shades.
Two blush products, a warm-toned stick blush and a bright pink liquid cheek tint, are displayed on a wooden surface, illustrating a blush combo.
A close-up of a person's face with blush applied, showcasing the blended warm and pink blush shades in natural sunlight.
Transition blush shades
My new favorite blush hack: transition blush Start with a warm tone blush: Toasted teddy Rhode pocket blush Finish with bright pink blush: Armani luminous silk cheek tint shade Bold pink #lemon8partner #transitionblush #blushhacks #blushtechnique #blushcombo
Hannah Williams 💋🍒

Hannah Williams 💋🍒

15 likes

A drawer filled with various makeup items, including compacts and tubes, with a large text overlay 'FAV BLUSH'S under $25'. The items are arranged in a cosmetic organizer.
Two gray stick blushes, one in a red shade and another in a coral shade, identified as lip and cheek cream blushes. The shades are 'flip' and 'quirk'.
A hand holding a red solid blush stick, described as an on-the-glow blush or tinted moisture stick. The product is in the shade 'ruby'.
best blush’s under $25 🎀🤍💋
Milk Lip + Cream Cheek Cream blush: $24 -both of these blushes are phenomenal, the formula is sooo creamy & buildable it’s the perfect ‘clean girl blush’ formula & im too obsessed with the shade ‘Quirk’, gives the most perfect naturally sunkissed color Pixi On-The-Glow blush in shade ‘R
Kayla Loninger

Kayla Loninger

333 likes

A hand with light-colored nails holds a brown blush stick, revealing the dark reddish-brown product. The text 'RHODE BLUSH' is displayed above the item, with decorative sparkles.
Rhode blush in toasted teddy 🧸
I’ve been obsessed with this pocket blush in the shade Toasted Teddy lately. It’s the perfect warm, bronzy rose that gives my skin that natural sun-kissed glow without looking too heavy. The formula blends out so easily with just my fingers, and I love how buildable it is—whether I want something s
Cynthia

Cynthia

21 likes

A flat lay shows five blush products on a gray textured surface, including liquid, stick, and powder blushes. The image is titled 'My top 5 favorite blushes' and features decorative white sunbursts and pink flowers.
A single liquid blush bottle, described as 'soft pinch liquid blush in joy,' is centered on a gray textured background. Text highlights its pigmentation and long-lasting nature.
A pink stick blush, labeled 'cooling water jelly tint blush stain in spritz,' is shown on a gray textured background. The text indicates it's suitable for a sunburnt look and can be used as a lip tint.
Top favorites: Blush edition🩷
My most used blushes in my makeup collection💖 #lemon8partner #beauty #makeup #makeupproducts #blush #blushrecommendation #blushes #makeuptips #makeupcollection #productreview
Melanie

Melanie

167 likes

Fenty Beauty Blush Review 🍒
#FENTY BEAUTY #fentybeauty #blushreviews #cherryblush #blush
Alex

Alex

257 likes

Blush Placement Trick for a Lifted Face & Smooth Under-Eye 💕
How to achieve the perfect smooth under eye while keeping glowy summer skin ✨ lifted, bright, and seamless without making the rest of your makeup look matte 💕 The secret is focusing the powder only where you need it and using blush strategically to create lift and warmth before you even reach fo
jenny

jenny

531 likes

Elf Blush / Lip Tint💄
I Found This And Fell In Love. It’s Super Pigmented And Stays On All Day Without Even Using Setting Spray & I Feel Like The Best Part Is It’s Only $8 !!! Such A Steal #beautyholygrails #lemon8challenge #elf✨ #elfbeauty #blush
𝓐𝓵𝓮𝓮𝓼𝓱𝓪

𝓐𝓵𝓮𝓮𝓼𝓱𝓪

9 likes

A woman with long brown hair wears a natural-looking blush. An inset image shows a pink stick blush product. Overlay text describes it as an underrated blush for summer.
A three-panel image shows a woman applying a pink stick blush to her cheek, demonstrating the application process. Overlay text identifies it as a jelly tint in the shade 'chill'.
A close-up image shows a swatch of a reddish-pink, glossy product on skin. Overlay text describes its jelly-like consistency, beautiful blending, and cooling sensation.
Summer blush obsession🩷
If you haven’t tried the Milk Makeup Jelly Tint yet, this is your sign! 🧊 The cooling sensation is honestly so refreshing for these warm days, and the color "Chill" gives the perfect natural flush. So gorgeous and perfect for summer! #summermakeup #verifiedonlemon8 #lemon8partner #h
amandasanz

amandasanz

4 likes

A flat lay shows a compact blush stick, a lip tint tube, and a lip liner pencil on a light surface, with text overlaying the image.
Multiple views of a cream blush stick in a compact case are shown, including the closed case, its bottom label, and the open case revealing the brown-toned blush product.
A dark brown lip tint tube is displayed, with one view showing the closed tube and another showing the applicator tip with the glossy, dark brown product.
The Ultimate Fall Lip + Blush Combo 💄💋
I’ve been loving warm browns + rich burgundy tones lately for my makeup! It’s so flattering and so on season. 🤎 Blush: Rhode Pocket Blush in Toasted Teddy (the prettiest warm brown flush) 🍷 Lips: Makeup Forever Lip Liner in Free Burgundy topped with Rhode Peptide Lip Tint in Espresso (the dream
jenny

jenny

66 likes

A makeup stick and its packaging are displayed on a white surface. The packaging shows a color swatch, and the stick reveals a dark reddish-brown makeup product.
A makeup stick with its cap removed, revealing a dark reddish-brown product, is shown next to its cap on a white surface. The color is described as bronze terracotta.
A swatch of a reddish-brown makeup product is applied to a person's forearm, demonstrating its color.
rhode blush in toasted teddy 🧸
as fall is approaching I am in the mood for some warm terracotta blushes and rhode toasted teddy looked perfect 😍 I absolutely love the rhode blushes. they are super creamy and blend able. 🧸 toasted teddy - bronze terracotta. perfect for fall makeup and everyday makeup. #lemon8partner #b
Nitza ♡

Nitza ♡

239 likes

SHEGLAM Jelly-Licious Hydrating Lip & Blush Tint-C
#lemon8bookclub #sheglam #lipgloss #beautyfinds
Janaa🦋

Janaa🦋

390 likes

honest makeup review: blush edition 🎀
blush has to be one of my FAVORITE steps in my makeup routine~ i guess you could call me a blush connoisseur lol 🙂‍↕️ a good blush means everything to me, so here are my honest reviews of ever liquid blush in my makeup collection! honest liquid blush reviews: 🎀 rare beauty soft pinch liquid blu
momo  ᡣ𐭩 •。ꪆৎ ˚⋅

momo ᡣ𐭩 •。ꪆৎ ˚⋅

128 likes

Day 1: Saie Blush and Highlight review
blush: 8/10💗 love the pigmentation Highlight: 7/10 it could definitely be a bit more glowy #lemon8partner #makeup #makeupreview #saiebeauty #saieblush
Kailee Castillo

Kailee Castillo

157 likes

A dark, slightly blurred image of a drugstore makeup aisle, featuring shelves stocked with various beauty products. The title "Reviews: Viral Drugstore Makeup" is prominently displayed over the image.
Five yellow tubes of NYX Professional Makeup Blur Screen Primer SPF30 are displayed. Overlays indicate two stars, pros like skin protection and oil control, and cons such as eye irritation for sensitive skin.
Several tubes of Maybelline Fit Me Concealer in different shades are shown on a store display. Overlays highlight four stars, pros like lightweight and natural finish, and cons including not full coverage and creasing.
Review: viral drugstore makeup 🥰💋
1. NYX MAKEUP BLUR SCREEN PRIMER ⭐️⭐️ Pros: protects your skin, blurs pores, and controls oil Cons: irritates my eyes, not good for sensitive skin 2. MAYBELLINE FIT ME CONCEALER ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Pros: very neutral finish, feels lightweight, good for everyday use Cons: not full coverage, creases u
Nikki

Nikki

80 likes

Two boxed liquid blush tints are shown. The pink/purple boxes indicate they are buildable stains for lips and cheeks, with volume details. An overlay identifies them as lip and cheek tints.
New Elf Blush Lip + Cheek Tint 👄💖
New elf liquid blush 😍😍😍 picked up my favorite shades; left on red & plums up ❤️ Now yall know i’m not the biggest fan of a liquid blush 😬 but if applied correctly, which is *quickly* if you’re using it as a blush - it will all work out 😍 nonetheless i love a liquid blush that can be
Aracely 🌸

Aracely 🌸

124 likes

e.l.f. Sheer For It Blush Tint🍒
Multi-Use, Long-Lasting Lip & Cheek Makeup, Creates A Natural Flush Finish, Vegan & Cruelty-Free, Pink Positive Link: https://amzn.to/4ePw9Wr #amazonbeautyfinds #elf putty blush #elf liquid putty
M A I💗👩🏽‍🦱

M A I💗👩🏽‍🦱

0 likes

ColourPop Cosmetics Liquid Blush Review
ColourPop’s liquid blushes are literally AMAZING, they’re perfect for “no makeup” makeup looks and full glams. I personally loved “Wildest Dreams” 🩷 which is your favorite? Let me know 🥰 #color pop blush #blushcolors #blush colors #blushblackgirls #COLOURPOP #makeupreview #makeupswa
Ms. Imani E.

Ms. Imani E.

134 likes

Low Contrast Makeup: Nude Pink Blush & Lips 🌸
Low contrast makeup with nude pink tones ✨ soft, blended, and effortlessly put together 💄 This is my go-to when I want everything to look cohesive and natural without anything standing out too harshly. It’s all about keeping tones similar so the whole look feels smooth and diffused. For cheek
jenny

jenny

30 likes

A collection of five different liquid blush products in various shades, displayed on a reflective surface. Text overlay indicates a selection of favorite liquid blushes.
Three liquid blush products in shades of berry, mauve, and dusty rose, with text indicating the colors. They are displayed on a reflective surface.
A close-up of a liquid blush applicator with product on it, held above an open container, with two other liquid blush containers in the background.
Liquid Blush Recommendations 🐰🎀💌
Products: 1. E.L.F. Camo Liquid Blush ∘ $7 ∘ these are probably my favorites because of the pigmentation and affordability! blends out super well and love the shade ranges they have some great dupes! shades: ☼ Berry Well ☼ Suave Mauve ☼ Dusty Rosé 2. Benefit Playtint Lip and Cheek Sta
Nat🎀

Nat🎀

129 likes

BLOOMEFFECTS Blush Review
Over a year ago, #Allure sent me this #BLOOMEFFECTS Tulip Tint Lip & Cheek Balm in shade Crispa Coral, and I am just now getting around to trying it. 👀🫣😵‍💫😬🤦🏼‍♀️ I received 13ml (0.4 oz) of this liquid #blush which retails for $20.30. (That's $50.75 an ounce! 👀🤯😵‍💫) I didn't reali
GitanaLaBella

GitanaLaBella

2 likes

Patrick ta blush review!
These are my all time favorite blushes! I decided to get two of the newest shades. This is my review of the shades “she’s the moment” & “not too much”: Both of these colors are perfect for these coming seasons. -She’s the moment has a very vibrant bouncy vibe, it makes you look flushed and i
Salomé Alvarado

Salomé Alvarado

481 likes

A flat lay of various blush products including liquid, stick, and compact forms from different brands, displayed on a light fabric. Text overlays read 'Honest Rating' and 'Blush REVIEW', indicating a product comparison.
Blush Review
My honest blush reviews! @Lemon8 US @Lemon8 Beauty Saie Dew Blush     •    Pros: Super popular, creamy, easy to blend, very natural/dewy finish, high pigment but buildable.     •    Cons: Can be too dewy for oily skin types, and takes a little learning curve. Tower 28 BeachPlease Blush
Grace Newell

Grace Newell

65 likes

NEW superdewy SPF30 skin tint
In-depth reviews always over here on this page!! I love putting new products to the ultimate test and this one exceeded my expectations. Especially for being a skin tint the fact that it held up over 10 hours is actually impressive. Would you try this? Let me know down below. #makeuprevolut
LALALUVBEAUTY

LALALUVBEAUTY

42 likes

i can finally use my spring blush 🌸✨
i’m so happy it’s spring because this means all the lighter, baby pink makeup shades are ready to be used. i tried this makeup look using some pink rhode products and also tried a shimmery eye with brown mascara instead of black. the new rhode drop is in it’s way to me also, so i’ll review those sh
Rita Rogers

Rita Rogers

130 likes

Date cake blush & pbj lip tint 🍇✨🍰
#rhodeskin #makeup #liptint #blush #lemon8beauty
Briana Molina

Briana Molina

148 likes

A hand holds the Juvia's Place liquid blush packaging, which is pink with an illustration. Text overlays indicate a review of the liquid blush.
A hand holds an open Juvia's Place liquid blush bottle and its large doe foot applicator. Text notes the product size and applicator type.
A person applies the lightweight, multi-use liquid blush directly to their cheek using the doe foot applicator, showing the product in use.
Juvia’s Place Blush Review!✨💖
@Lemon8 Beauty #Lemon8Box #beauty #beautyfinds #blush #review #makeup #juviasplace #beautyproducts #beautyreview #makeupproducts
Juliet C.

Juliet C.

23 likes

Sheer for it blush tint
💌 Brand: @elfcosmetics 💵 Price:$5 ⭐️Overall rating: 8/10
Bishuwish

Bishuwish

34 likes

An overhead flat lay displays various Rhode beauty products, including multiple lip tints, a phone case, a pocket blush, a milky toner, and a branded pouch, all arranged on a light-colored textured surface for a product review.
Six Rhode peptide lip tint and treatment tubes in different shades are shown with individual ratings and a description of their light wash of color, non-sticky feel, and preference for scented versions over unscented.
A single Rhode pocket blush in 'freckle' shade is displayed with an 8.5/10 rating. The accompanying text describes it as a dewy cream formula that provides a natural flush and is buildable.
Rhode Beauty Review 🫐
#rhode #rhodepeptidelipshape #rhodepeptideliptreatment #rhodebeauty #makeup
t ʕ ´•̥̥̥ ᴥ•̥̥̥`ʔ

t ʕ ´•̥̥̥ ᴥ•̥̥̥`ʔ

79 likes

Milk Jelly Tint in PHreeze
Ok cousins, I think I just found that girl of jelly blushes the Milk Makeup Cooling Water Jelly Tint in "pHreeze" is giving skin loving glow, juicy hydration, AND color that actually lasts. 👏🏽✨ This bouncy, buildable jelly texture glides on like a dream and dries down into the prettiest
Vasharee | Beauty For The Busy

Vasharee | Beauty For The Busy

11 likes

Anastasia Beverly Hills skin tint review part 2
What do yall think? #makeup #beauty #anastasiabeverlyhills #lemon8beauty #skintint
Zee

Zee

694 likes

See more