What book was overrated for you?

Almost didn’t finish this book…

They both die at the end.

Was it sad? Sure. Did I cry? No. I loved Mateo. I cared for him but I did find myself bored… maybe I’m just someone that needs twists and turns in books. It just wasn’t my type of book tbh..

what’s your overrated book?

#booksummary #lemon8challenge

2024/7/13 Edited to

... Read moreIn recent years, discussions around overrated books have gained momentum, especially on platforms like social media. Many readers have expressed their thoughts on various titles, including popular works like 'They Both Die at the End' by Adam Silvera. While some appreciate the emotional depth and character development, others find the pacing slow and unengaging. The diversity of opinions highlights how subjective literature can be. Exploring what makes a book feel overrated often comes down to personal preferences in writing style, storytelling, and even genre. Some readers thrive on plot twists and energetic pacing, which naturally shapes their response to slower narratives. This raises the question: what criteria do you use to judge a book's worth? Is it based on emotional impact, character investment, or perhaps thematic exploration? It's essential to share these perspectives, as they enrich the reading community and help readers navigate their next choices more effectively. Additionally, consider how community discussions around overrated books can lead to broader conversations about literary trends and reader expectations. Books that achieve commercial success don't always align with critical acclaim, adding another layer to what readers deem overrated. Engage with the hashtags #booksummary and #lemon8challenge, where many readers are already sharing their thoughts on various titles that didn't quite meet their expectations. Let's highlight these conversations and encourage more book lovers to dissect their literary experiences!

11 comments

Related posts

🚀 BEST Book in 2025 to Be Free From Approval
💡 Quick Thoughts The Courage to Be Disliked is a no-nonsense guide to breaking free from approval-seeking. I’ve heard that it was a bestseller in Japan and I never had the chance to read it until today. This book really flips conventional wisdom on happiness and relationships. Definitely a 4.8/5
Noelle

Noelle

364 likes

over hyped book?
let me know in the comments ! i 100% think The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo by Taylor Jenkins is overrated! absolutely no hate to this author this book was just nottt for me. - - - - - - #lemon8bookclub #lemon8review #readersoflemon8 #taylorjenkinsreid #sevenhusbandsofevelynhugo
blimmi 🍂🤎📚

blimmi 🍂🤎📚

569 likes

🍋 Hugely Disappointing & Overrated?
Maybe You Should Talk to Someone by Lori Gottlieb - Was it overrated ? You tell me! Personally, I was rather disappointed and found this memoir/exploration of therapy lacking or sensationalised. I also found the constant referral to 'The Boyfriend' annoying and tiresome to read. How
readbymarc

readbymarc

8 likes

OVERRATED BOOKS??📕🚫
What’s a book that everyone seems to love but you don’t… Well maybe it’s not that you DON’T but it’s more that you think it’s overrated or overhyped📕🚫 #readersoflemon8 #booksoflemon8 #lemon8readingclub #bookclub
Captain Lemon8

Captain Lemon8

206 likes

Underrated and Overrated Places in the US 🇺🇸
I know some people are going to be upset about my opinions on New York but it’s my opinion 🤷🏻‍♀️ Sedona : This is genuinely one of the most beautiful places I’ve been to in my life! I really like the outdoors, but even if you don’t there a bunch of cute shops located right in the center of town
🏖️🪩✈️

🏖️🪩✈️

111 likes

Is R7 overrated?
Would you buy an R7? #bike #motorcycle #viral #fyp #unfiltered
AZRAEL

AZRAEL

6 likes

Is BALI Overrated?
Bali in your 20's ✈️it's like finding your soulmate in a tropical paradise! 🌴❤️ Ubud, specifically, stole my heart with its vibrant art scene, unique restaurants, lush rice fields, and spiritual vibes. It's the perfect place to find yourself, get creative, and connect with like minded w
CamilasCloset

CamilasCloset

2593 likes

Which Anime Listed Is The Most Overrated?
All these shows are great but there’s one obvious outlier here. But what do you guys think? #Anime #animerecommendations #jujutsukaisen #AnimeLover #memes
t_porter59

t_porter59

11 likes

Lemon8Is overrated
I’m pretty good at trend forecasting with apps. I don’t see this app being a real thing. It’s created by the tiktok brand, i felt they only designed as a backup for tiktok but it’s not doing what it’s suppose to. #lemon8challenge #influencerlifestyle #ootd #trends #viral
Xoxo

Xoxo

433 likes

Is Disney overrated? Let’s talk 👀
I want to hear your honest opinions in the comments 🤓✨ #disneyworld #disneytravelagent #disneytips #disneyworldplanning #disneyplanner
Bethany • Travel Planner ✨

Bethany • Travel Planner ✨

15 likes

Loyalty Is Overrated
#jamesharden #cavs #nba #trending #fyp
RunningThroughReality

RunningThroughReality

4 likes

The image displays the book cover for 'Every Voice AIN'T FROM God' by Tanisha Stewart, featuring a woman's face partially covered by red, dripping paint-like elements. Overlaid text reads 'Currently Reading' and 'Worth the Hype', with the Lemon8 logo and username '@heirbabyj' also visible.
Books: because reality is overrated.
Book Review Book name: Every Voice Aint From God Author: Tanisha Stewart Genre: Black & African American Christian Fiction, Black & African American Women Fiction, Suspense Thriller My rating: 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟 My review: Tanisha has done an exceptional job with this Christian Based Thriller. At
Ja’Han

Ja’Han

149 likes

BOOKTOK MADE ME READ IT!
Overrated books on my shelf! These are a few of my opinions on books I think are NOT worth the hype. I’ll post my top recs next!! What books do you think are over rated?🤐 #Lemon8Diary #shareyourthoughts #embracevulnerability #booklemon8 #goodreads #dnf #overrated #books #
Katie Kelly

Katie Kelly

16 likes

⚠️ Motivation is overrated, Do you agree?
I think motivation is overrated. Here's the truth no one wants to hear: You won't always feel like doing the thing that matters. Not every morning feels inspiring. Not every goal feels exciting. But discipline? That's what shows up when motivation doesn't. That's
Better Life Routine

Better Life Routine

20 likes

✨🛑 perfect is overrated, authentic is powerful 💯✨
You are not a drop in the ocean; you are the entire ocean in a drop. Stop shrinking yourself to fit into a narrative that doesn't serve you.🫶🏼 #embracewisdom #motivational
Sierra nicci

Sierra nicci

6 likes

A hand holds three Ariana Grande body mists: Cloud, Sweet Like Candy, and Moonlight, with text questioning if they are "OVERRATED?" and asking the viewer to "Hear me out" regarding Ariana Grande fragrances.
Three Ariana Grande body mists (Cloud, Sweet Like Candy, Moonlight) are shown with text stating they "smell just OK" and are "extremely overhyped," aligning with the article's review.
A bottle of Ariana Grande's Sweet Like Candy perfume is displayed with its box, accompanied by text expressing disappointment that it didn't smell like candy or last long, as mentioned in the article.
Overrated Fragrances: Part 1
Ariana Grande Perfumes & Body Mists – Honest Review I’ve tried several scents from the Ariana Grande fragrance line, and to be completely honest—they’re very overrated and underwhelming. A lot of them are marketed as sweet, dreamy gourmand scents with notes like vanilla, marshmallow, or cand
HeyItsAshleyK1

HeyItsAshleyK1

51 likes

Is Culver’s Overrated??
What Do Yall Think?? #culvers #burgers #fastfoodreview #fastfoodorder #foodreview
Jas & Kam Food Reviews

Jas & Kam Food Reviews

718 likes

Overrated VS. Underrated U.S. States 🇺🇸
@Lemon8 Travel launched the #states I’ve been to #lemon8challenge today so obviously I had to jump in - go to their page to check out how to participate! For this challenge, I added my own little twist to the map. I included the states I’ve traveled to and the states I’ve driven through
Eliza Jade 🌎

Eliza Jade 🌎

39 likes

High Ground Is Overrated… Watch This 💀
They really thought high ground was an auto win 😭💀 Zero Build hits different when it’s just aim, movement, and outplays. No builds. No excuses. Just straight pressure 😤 Watch how this turns into a clutch… 🔥 Like if high ground is overrated 🔥 Comment what you would’ve done 🔥 Subscribe for
MstrComms

MstrComms

0 likes

Overrated foods
#food #foodreview #foodoflemon8 #restaurant #foodie
Ann_K

Ann_K

3 likes

Reality is overrated, 
I choose books.📖🖤
Reality is overrated, I choose books.📖🖤 #fyp #trending #booktok #bookish #bookaesthetic
𝐑𝐄𝐈𝐆𝐍📕🖤

𝐑𝐄𝐈𝐆𝐍📕🖤

8 likes

A stack of books, a coffee cup, and white decorative pieces on a wooden table. The top book has an overlay stating 'Overrated books that lost me' with emojis, serving as the article's title image.
The cover of James Joyce's 'Ulysses' with text overlays describing it as 'a headache in book form' and feeling 'more like homework than reading,' reflecting an unpopular opinion.
The cover of Elizabeth Gilbert's 'Eat Pray Love' with text overlays stating it felt like 'a very long Instagram caption' instead of profound self-discovery, indicating it was 'not for me.'
Overrated books people pretend to love but lost me
Overrated books that lost me 😬 Here’s my hot take: some books are only “beloved” because people feel guilty admitting they didn’t like them. But reading isn’t homework. Not every book is going to land for every reader. And that’s okay. I’ve definitely had moments where I close a book and thin
Meredith Jao

Meredith Jao

12 likes

Do you think your 20s were overrated?
I don’t look back on my 20s with nostalgia. I look back with exhaustion. It’s wild how many of us were praised for being “strong” when we were really just struggling in silence. No one told us that constant hustle wasn’t a personality trait. No one told us that being broken and pretty wasn’t
brittany

brittany

385 likes

Overrated Books 📚
Comment yours below! 👇🏼 #booktok #overratedbooks #tiktokbooks #booksoflemon8 #readersoflemon8
Lyssa the Bookworm ✨📚

Lyssa the Bookworm ✨📚

2 likes

A display of folded t-shirts on wooden shelves, featuring various graphic designs including 'GOLF', 'I CHROMATOPIA' with a mask, and 'AMERICA IS D POISON!' in different colors.
A person wearing blue jeans holds a yellow shopping bag with the black 'GOLF' logo on their lap, seen from a top-down perspective.
Several jackets in various colors and patterns, including pink, orange, and cream, hang on a clothing rack with 'GOLF' branded hangers and tags.
Overrated & Overpriced?
Just came back from the Tyler, the Creator’s store in SoHo NYC. Absolutely LOVED the vibes. But tbh everything in the store was so expensive. I bought a tote bag for $35. Well, YOLO😀 #lemon8diarychallenge #fyp #sohonyc #tylerthecreator #fashion
.

.

129 likes

Perfume because plain air is overrated.😸
Wheww this combo was so unique. Out here smelling like a toasted rice crispy with spiked smoked peaches mixed together.🤯 , that’s the best way I can describe this combo lol. Sand + Fog has released a few new parfum oils and I was blessed to snag 2 for my husband and I. I got him midnight blue and
B.Chantal

B.Chantal

33 likes

Hype Check? Worth it or Overrated? 🤔🤯
The Silent Patient is insanely good. I couldn’t stop reading until I hit the last page! I’m a sucker for psychological stuff, and this book nails it with all the trauma and therapy vibes. What blew my mind was how everything connects in the end. I had a hunch about the plot twist halfway through
Karen Aldrigui

Karen Aldrigui

18 likes

✨☁️ Ariana Grande’s CLOUD | IS IT OVERRATED?? 💦✨
✨ Cloud is sweet, airy, cozy, and honestly one of the best celebrity perfumes out there. BUT… this Cloud set from Ulta? Yeah… it’s giving “pretty but not worth the price tag.” 😭 😡 Here’s my issue: ~ The scent is gorgeous but fades FAST ~ The mist is cute for layering but not long-lasting ~ An
Margarita

Margarita

21 likes

The book 'Outliers: The Story of Success' by Malcolm Gladwell is displayed open on a surface covered with pages from other books, with a white overlay featuring the title and author.
A digital interface presents four reading style options: 'Heart' for author-style narration, 'Flash' for key ideas in cards, 'Deep' for conversational narration, and 'Build' to create a custom style.
A digital interface titled 'Your Knowledge Agent' shows options for reading content in 'Storytelling,' '5min,' or 'Cards' formats, with book covers like 'Elon Musk' and 'The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck' visible.
🎙 Outliers—The Book That Exposes the Success Myth
🎧 Featured on Top Shelf Summaries This week’s podcast episode breaks down Outliers—the book that proves success isn’t just about talent but hidden advantages, timing, and insane practice hours. If you’ve ever wondered why some people seem destined to win, this book will change how you see success
ShelfbyAriel

ShelfbyAriel

5 likes

What’s An OVERRATED SONG Right Now?
Nate

Nate

37 likes

benson boone is overrated!
I am just joking. Benson boone is my husband. Some people dont like him!!!! Whats your opinion abt him? If you like him, whats your favorite song? ngl i love GHOST TOWN. Ughhhb or work of arrrrrrrt. Ughhhhh all of them!
Emma Cole

Emma Cole

38 likes

BEST Book & App in 2025 for Modern Wisdom
📚 Intro (Rating: 8.5/10) The Truth About Everything by Brianna Wiest dives into self-awareness, decision-making, and the uncomfortable clarity of honest living. ✨ Key Takeaways 1️⃣ Truth Hurts (But Heals): Facing reality—no matter how brutal—builds strength and frees you from self-deception. P
Aria Collins

Aria Collins

38 likes

Teslas are INCREDIBLY overrated.
Actually, as an owner of a Model 3, I can safely say, it is biggest disappointment I have ever owned, vehicle wise. While I will credit Tesla with pushing the electric car forward, the actual car is garbage. The battery gets less than 50% of what they say. They refuse to integrate car play or
Brook Makenzie🫶

Brook Makenzie🫶

129 likes

A woman in a blue bikini stands under a waterfall surrounded by dense green foliage. The image asks, "Bali Overrated? Underrated? Great?"
A person in a flowing yellow dress enjoys a Bali swing ride high above lush green rice terraces and palm trees. The text highlights Bali swings as "Perfect."
A woman stands beside a large elephant in a shallow pool, surrounded by tropical plants. The image labels Mason Elephant "Sanctuary" as "Overrated" due to harmful practices.
Bali: Overrated? Underrated? Great?
Bali Bali is an incredible destination located in Indonesia🇮🇩 Let’s explore what’s worth it, overrated, or great for your itinerary! Bali Swing/Activities similar: Great✨ I loved the Bali swing- it was beautiful and the rice terrace are gorgeous to look at. Definitely add this to your list
Jadethetraveler

Jadethetraveler

33 likes

A cozy reading scene with a stack of books, an open book, a bowl of snacks, a glass of water, and a lit candle by a window. The image features text overlay: 'MY Underrated Perfectly rated Overrated Books!'
A book titled 'What I Should've Said' by Max Monroe, featuring pink sunglasses on its cover, standing upright on a light-colored surface. Another pair of pink sunglasses is in the foreground.
A book titled 'Better Than The Movies' by Lynn Painter, with a bright yellow cover depicting cartoon figures, resting on a white textured surface, likely a bedsheet.
My underrated,perfectly rated,and overrated books!
And in that order!! I feel like everyone should have what I should’ve said as a must read! It is well-written and had me curled up and crying by the end. It had a good plot and was an absolutely amazing book in my opinion! Honestly I could make a whole post about What I should’ve said and why
Bookish.Karsyn

Bookish.Karsyn

11 likes

Overrated activities in New York 🌆
Overrated activities in New York & what to do instead 🌆 📍Overrated: SUMMIT One Vanderbilt 📍Do instead: Top of The Rock or Edge SUMMIT One Vanderbilt is cool BUT so busy! In my opinion, the view is also not quite as good as the one from Top of the Rock. I’d recommend you choose
Iisa Hero

Iisa Hero

36 likes

Trimming Is Overrated?🤔
✨ Trimming Is Overrated? Let’s Discuss! ✨ Today’s topic: “Trimming Is Overrated” – Is frequent trimming really necessary for everyone? 🤔 As a handmade hair care formulator and nutritionist, I’ve found that retaining length can often be more about protective styling and less manipulation. ⭐️He
KinkeyNaturalley-AfroHair Care

KinkeyNaturalley-AfroHair Care

26 likes

Overrated
Idk how I let TikTok hype me up about this perfume 😒… uk how you it is when everybody hopping on the bandwagon. Well that was def me with this purchase… it’s a musk which I have plenty on those in my collection but this here is giving mother board vibes at Jesus will do it missionary Baptist church
Shavon

Shavon

26 likes

Motivation is overrated…
This is what the accountability club is for 🫶🏼✨ I’ve created the making a mindset accountability club to create a community of growth, support, and a place you can go to reach out for ideas, check in on your goals, and lean on others so you don’t have to do this alone. 🫂 Follow along if you’r
Haley Gilmore

Haley Gilmore

5 likes

A top-down view of two pieces of avocado toast on a light plate. The dark bread is topped with a white spread and sliced avocado, seasoned with black pepper. White text asks, "What food do you find to be overrated?" Lemon8 branding is visible.
OVERRATED FOOD? 🧐
What food do you find overrated? 🍣 Is there a food you want to try but just can’t get into? 🫣Is there a food/drink item or restaurant you find too trendy? #overrated #lemon8food #food #foodie #letschat
Lemon8 Food

Lemon8 Food

421 likes

Four EOS Shea Better Cashmere Body Washes are lined up, featuring vanilla cashmere, coconut waters, fresh & cozy, and pink champagne scents. The image includes 'EOS BODYWASHES' text, decorative bubbles, and a heart graphic.
ARE EOS BODY WASHES OVERRATED?!!
So.. I was able to finally find the Vanilla Cashmere body wash. I must say, it smells exactly the lotion! I tried the other scents, and they smell nice too. The body wash is very moisturizing and leaves my skin very soft. The scent lasts on my skin for some time. Overall, I don't think EOS
MyBeautyByDeja

MyBeautyByDeja

60 likes

Trying The Most OVERRATED Donuts In Our State?
What Do Yall Think? #donuts #foodies #foodreview #unfiltered
Jas & Kam Food Reviews

Jas & Kam Food Reviews

224 likes

A dark purple book titled 'Gothikana' by RuNyx, featuring a floral and skull design, rests on a black patterned blanket. A clear bookmark with pressed purple and pink flowers and a tassel is beside it. The book cover includes a quote: 'POETIC, EERIE, AND BEAUTIFUL'.
What’s an overrated book? 🤍
#gothikana #runyx #darkromance #booktok #booksoflemon8
Em🦇

Em🦇

3 likes

What music artist do you feel is overrated?
lol i know this is gonna make a lot of people mad but i really feel like glorilla is don’t get me wrong i like some of her songs because they are catchy and that’s what it’s about but chile me seeing her as a actual musician/ artist no. #letschat #lemon8contest
Lyrique Lee

Lyrique Lee

24 likes

See more