Mini Book Review - My Phony Valentine

My Phony Valentine

By Courtney Walsh

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 5/5

No spice (just a couple kissing scenes but not much detail)

This was the perfect little pick me up to get me out of my reading slump, it was so cute and cheesy as expected, but I loved it! I literally laughed and high pitch squealed at parts. I loved how Poppy and Dallas's relationship evolved over their month together, and loved the support and welcoming she got from the hockey wives when she first met them! Highly recommend if you're looking for a cutesy sports romance. 🤍🤍

2024/2/28 Edited to

... Read moreOkay, let's talk about 'My Phony Valentine' by Courtney Walsh, because seriously, this book was an absolute delight and exactly what I needed! If you've been wondering, 'is My Phony Valentine spicy?' or what its 'spice level' is, I can confirm: it's a wonderfully clean romance. While there are a couple of sweet kissing scenes, it definitely keeps things mild, making it perfect for readers who prefer their love stories without explicit details. It’s all about the heartwarming connection and emotional buildup, which I personally adore. What really pulls you into this story is the fantastic blend of popular tropes. Right off the bat, you're hit with a charming 'Hockey Romance' and an intriguing 'Fake Dating' premise. Our main character, Poppy, finds herself in a situation where she needs to pretend to be with Dallas, a hockey player, and the sparks that fly (or rather, the hilarious awkwardness that ensues) are just brilliant. The whole dynamic is set against a cozy 'Small Town' backdrop, which adds so much to the atmosphere. You really get a sense of community, especially with the 'hockey wives' who welcome Poppy into their circle, creating a supportive and fun environment that makes you wish you were part of it too! The journey of Poppy and Dallas is truly what made me fall in love with this book. Watching their relationship evolve from a fake arrangement into something genuine was incredibly satisfying. Courtney Walsh does a fantastic job of building their connection through witty banter, shared moments, and a gradual understanding of each other. I literally found myself laughing out loud at their antics and even doing some high-pitched squealing (the good kind!) at the cute, cheesy moments that just hit right. It’s the kind of book that makes you feel warm and fuzzy inside. For anyone looking for a 'reading slump pick-me-up,' this is it! It’s light, engaging, and pure joy from start to finish. If you're a fan of 'courtney walsh books' in general, you'll find her signature heartwarming style shines through here. The 5-star rating truly reflects how much I enjoyed it – it’s a perfect escape. If you appreciate a good 'My Phony Valentine' book that's packed with charm, heartfelt moments, and zero spice, then grab this one. You won't regret diving into this adorable, feel-good 'sports romance' that leaves you smiling long after you've turned the last page.

Related posts

The image displays the front cover of the psychological thriller novel "Behind Closed Doors" by B.A. Paris, featuring the title in red and a dark keyhole design. Overlay text indicates "BOOK REVIEW" and a "10/10" rating.
Book Review✨🖤 Psychological Thriller
Book Review 🪻🌾✨ Book name: Behind Closed Doors Author: B.A Paris Genre: Psychological Thriller My rating: honestly.. 10/10, I’m hoping to find this thrill in another book. My review: I had no idea going into this book exactly what I was getting into. The words and details used made me picture
RM

RM

631 likes

🎀10 romance books with Jesus 🎀
#nospicebooks #romancebooks #booktok #closeddoorromance #christianbooks
lilysreadingcorner1

lilysreadingcorner1

523 likes

The image displays the book cover for "The Power of the Pussy" by Kara King, featuring a black cat silhouette. Overlaid text indicates a review, stating "I Finally Read It" and "Here's My Review," along with the Lemon8 handle.
This image presents a book review for "The Power of the Pussy," highlighting its benefits for women with low self-esteem and confidence. It includes a rating of 8.5/10 and testimonials, along with the book's ISBN.
The image shows an open book with text, overlaid with instructions to get a paper copy online or an Ebook off Amazon Kindle. A sticky note encourages followers for more reviews, recipes, life hacks, and DIY ideas.
MY BOOK REVIEW ON THE POWER OF THE 🐈‍⬛
I saw this book all over this app & decided to give it a read! This is my review & rating #books #BookReview #booksoflemon8 #bookshelf #reading #readingrecommendations #thoughts
ImTheLoveWitch777

ImTheLoveWitch777

1575 likes

The image introduces a collection of "no spice" book recommendations, featuring a stack of blank books, decorative bookmarks, and a plush bunny, with books visible on a shelf in the background.
This image displays six book covers under the theme "Fake Dating," including titles like "We Are NEVER Getting Together," "My Phony Valentine," and "How He Got The Girl," recommending clean romance novels.
Six book covers are presented under the "Neighbors to Lovers" theme, featuring titles such as "The Neighbor Playbook," "Cream Punishment," and "The Icing on the Cake," suggesting romantic reads.
Read these books if you’re looking for…
#nospicebooks #cleanromancebooks #closeddoorromance #booktok #bookrecs
lilysreadingcorner1

lilysreadingcorner1

248 likes

📍Review - You Deserve This Shit!
❓How do you manage your day-to-day life? 📚 The book serves as a guide for everyone on how to navigate everyday life while staying connected to their of us rave lost touch with-this essential parrod, many ourselves. 📚 Furthermore, the younger generation often struggles to align with their true
Goodthing1

Goodthing1

802 likes

The book cover for J.T. Geissinger's 'Pen Pal,' featuring a tattooed man, with a 5/5 star rating and a chili pepper rating, indicating a dark romance novel.
A minimalist graphic for 'Pen Pal' by J.T. Geissinger, detailing its author, dark romance genre, 320 pages, and starring Aidan & Kayla, with a quote and scattered handwritten letters in the background.
A collage featuring handwritten letters, intertwined hands, a ring, and portraits of a woman (Kayla) and a tattooed man (Aidan), representing characters and themes from 'Pen Pal.'
Pen Pal Book Review!
WOW!!! This book was not what I expected! 🤯🤯🤯 What a twist!!! Absolutely loved it! Read it in a days time! Highly recommend reading it! It’s no where near what you think it will be AT ALL!!!!! 5/5⭐️ #penpal #bookrecommendations #BookReview #goodreads #darkromance
Squarebear

Squarebear

840 likes

Closed-Door Romance Recs!
Some closed door adult romance for the girlies who don’t like “spicy” books 🥰 ✨Books by Sarah Adams ✨The Bodyguard by Katherine Center Tropes: She’s the Bodyguard, Fake Dating ✨My Phony Valentine by Courtney Walsh Tropes: Fake Dating, Hockey Romance ✨My Lucky Charm by Courtney Walsh
Hannah 🧡

Hannah 🧡

253 likes

The image displays the book cover for 'Bad Fat Black Girl' by Sesali Bowen, featuring a dark-skinned hand with red, jeweled nails holding $100 bills and a gold chain. Text overlays read 'Currently Reading' and 'Worth the Hype,' complementing the article's positive review of the non-fiction book.
Bad Fat Black Girl Review
Bad Fat Black Girl is a powerful, unapologetic exploration of identity, self-love, and the complexities of navigating the world as a fat, Black woman. 📖✨ The author dives deep into the challenges of facing societal expectations, while celebrating the strength that comes from embracing one’s body an
Jael Dior🎤💜🪩

Jael Dior🎤💜🪩

397 likes

🤯 BOOK REVIEW
So I had to take a break from my normal book readings lol, and pick me up a good thriller that I really enjoyed… I been eyeing this one all over KU but kept passing it by until today and it did not disappoint.. pretty much wish i read this sooner 🥴… A must read if you like suspense/ psychologica
💕✨TATIANA✨💕

💕✨TATIANA✨💕

153 likes

A hand holds the book 'Moody Bitches' by Julie Holland, featuring its full title and a testimonial from Christiane Northrup, MD. Overlays like 'Thoughts' and 'Current Reads' suggest a book review or reading list on Lemon8.
Honest Book Review: “Moody B!tches” by Julie l
“Moody Bitches: The Truth About the Drugs You’re Taking, the Sleep You’re Missing, the Sex You’re Not Having, and What’s Really Making You Crazy" by Julie Holland is a bold and insightful look at the emotional and mental health of women. Dr. Holland, a psychiatrist, challenges the conventio
Goddess Luxure

Goddess Luxure

2432 likes

Self-discipline book review
I recently bought this book off Amazon for roughly $15 and it quickly became an amazing investment. I am a nutrition coach and I work with a lot of clients who struggle with self discipline, which is why they look into hiring a coach to help them with the transition into eating healthier. I am
Taylor Trace

Taylor Trace

2537 likes

The front cover of Ali Hazelwood's book "BRIDE," featuring a woman and a wolf, with text "my thoughts on this new BookTok fave!" and "Bride Review." It highlights the Barnes & Noble exclusive edition.
The back cover of Ali Hazelwood's "BRIDE," displaying a plot summary about a vampyre bride and werewolf alpha, along with review quotes and a four-and-a-half-star rating. An arrow points to the summary text.
An open copy of the book "BRIDE" held by a hand with star tattoos and a green ring. A red overlay features the quote: "Maybe you're not meant for me the way I'm meant for you, but I'm going to choose you anyway, over and over and over again."
🧛🏻‍♀️BRIDE REVIEW🐺
This book has taken the bookish world by STORM! ✨It’s a vampire/werewolf love story, and it DELIVERS! ✨I am an Ali Hazelwood stan, and I can confidently say that this is her best book. ✨If there is one thing about an Ali Hazelwood book you’ve got to know is that: 1. The FMC will be absolu
mikalasreads

mikalasreads

188 likes

Book Review
🩷 BEST SERIES 🩷 FEBRUARY READS 🩷 when i say i DEVOURED this series, i ate. it. up. i’ve read it twice! individually and overall, this series gets a 5/5⭐️ #booktok #bookwormsoflemon8 #spicybookrecs #seriesreview
Ashley Summers

Ashley Summers

928 likes

The book cover for Maya Angelou's 'The Heart of a Woman' features a woman's silhouette and red-orange flowers on a dark background, resting on a white fluffy surface. A quote from Kirkus Reviews is visible.
Book Review
This book is absolutely amazing. Maya Angelou’s early life was truly one worth writing about. She eloquently writes of the duality of women and the lives our grandmothers were forced to live. Having a child at 17, receiving the assistance of her mother and shortly after taking full custody. May
Marlesia

Marlesia

496 likes

A stack of romance novels by authors like Lucy Score and Elsie Silver, with arrows pointing to corresponding tropes such as 'small town romance,' 'enemies to lovers,' 'hockey romance,' and 'marriage of convenience.' Nail polish bottles and a floral painting are also visible.
Book review 🌸
#booksummary #lemon8challenge Twisted hate is one of my number ones but lmk if there is a book u want a review on and I will see if I have it
Ameliamarieisme

Ameliamarieisme

3225 likes

The book cover of 'Creepy Crayon!' shows a scared rabbit character, Jasper, holding a purple crayon that appears to be drawing on paper. The title is in large purple letters, and the authors' names, Aaron Reynolds and Peter Brown, are visible.
An open book displays the title page of 'Creepy Crayon!' with the title in dripping purple letters. The authors' names, Aaron Reynolds and Peter Brown, are also visible, along with publisher information.
An open book shows two pages. The left page depicts Jasper Rabbit looking at a purple crayon on the ground. The right page shows a hand holding the purple crayon, which has a smiling face.
📚✨ Creepy Crayon! Review – A Cute & Spooky….
📚✨ Creepy Crayon! Review – A Cute & Spooky Adventure 🌟💜 Have you ever read a book that’s both cute and a little spooky? Well, Creepy Crayon! by Aaron Reynolds and Peter Brown is exactly that! 🎃🖍️ This adorable yet eerie story follows Jasper Rabbit 🐰, who discovers a crayon that seems too
Gypsy Thyme

Gypsy Thyme

716 likes

A collage featuring four hockey romance book covers: 'Romancing the Grump', 'Just Don't Fall', 'My Phony Valentine', and 'Betrothal or Breakaway'. It also shows stacks of books and a person reading, highlighting summer hockey romance reads.
The book 'Romancing the Grump' by Jenny Proctor is displayed on a brown surface, featuring a bearded man in a hockey jersey on the cover. Two pinecones are placed next to the book.
A hand with light blue nail polish holds the book 'Just Don't Fall' by Emma St. Clair, featuring abstract figures and autumn leaves on the cover, against a light brown couch background.
Hockey Romance Reads For Summer 🫶
These four books made me FEEL. The sizzle. The love. The humor. If you jump on the hockey romance bandwagon, I cannot more highly recommend that you read these! #hockeyromancebooks #hockey romance #sports romance #summer romance #hockeyromancebook #lemon8bookclub #lemon8boo
Kimmie ᨒ↟

Kimmie ᨒ↟

18 likes

A hand holds the front cover of the book "Tender Beasts" by Liselle Sambury, a YA thriller. The cover features two figures with a torn-paper effect, set against a dark green textured background. The image includes a "BOOK REVIEW" overlay.
Tender Beast Book Review 🐻🐾
Book Review : ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5 Stars Meet the mysterious Behre family, where secrets and tragedy seem to follow them around. Sunny who definitely lives up to her name is determined to “Take Care of Dom” and prove his innocence when he’s accused of murder. The author definitely keeps you guessing until
rickeashonte

rickeashonte

155 likes

A book titled "Love & Other Words" by Christina Lauren rests on green grass with small white and pink flowers. The image is titled "BOOK RECS BASED ON TROPES/THEMES" and lists various romance tropes.
A collage of 12 book covers under the heading "HOCKEY ROMANCE." Titles include "Shutout," "Unsteady," "Canadian Boyfriend," "Icebreaker," "Mile High," "Cross Checked Hearts," "Collide," "Breakaway," "The Mistake," "The Graham Effect," "Consider Me," and "Sweet Collide."
A collage of 12 book covers under the heading "CLEAN/YOUNG ADULT." Titles include "Better Than The Movies," "The Cheat Sheet," "Famous for a Living," "Love & Gelato," "The Summer I Turned Pretty," "The Do-Over," "The Upside of Falling," "The Off-Limits Rule," "My Phony Valentine," "Picking Daisies on Sundays," "To All The Boys I've Loved Before," and "The Bodyguard."
book recs based on trope
save for future reads!! here are some recs based on my fav tropes/themes! let me know if there’s any other tropes you’d want recommendations for, for a future post! what’s your fav trope??? #romancebookrecommendations #bookrecommendations #BookReview #booktropes #readersoflemo
mads

mads

1224 likes

Book Review | My New Favorite Thriller🎀
❗️ NO SPOILERS❗️This is book is now on the list of thrillers that I’m OBSESSED with!! I can’t even express how good this book was!❤️ (jk i actually can LOL) Book name: They’re Watching You Author: Chelsea Ichaso Genre: Fiction, Thriller, Suspense, Romance, YA, Mystery, Dark Academia My rating
Bri Bri🎀

Bri Bri🎀

481 likes

Book Review: Not Since You
Rating: 4.5/5⭐️ Title: Not Since You Author: Dulcie Dameron Review: This was such a delightful read!! This was my very first Christian Contemporary Romance & I absolutely adored it!! The faith aspect was so refreshing to have in a romance! The mystery in this was intriguing bu
Caitri Riding

Caitri Riding

177 likes

Black Girl Read: Book Review📚
Babe!! This was one of the BEST books I have read recently! I loved it. This book is about four sisters and how they differ but have more things in common than they realize. Black girl read FOR SURE! Plus a black author. Chefs kiss💋🤌🏽 #blackgirlbookreview #blackgirlsreadbooks #blackgirlsread
Mariah Kristine

Mariah Kristine

93 likes

A stack of white-spined books with a pink overlay text that reads "Romance Books to read on Valentine's Day with none of the spice." A brown plush bunny is visible on the right, and other books are in the background.
An e-reader displays "My Fake(ish) Valentine" by Raney Ark, surrounded by physical books on shelves. Text labels point to themes like "Valentine's Day," "Fake Dating," "Gamer MCs," "No Spice," and "Millionaires."
An e-reader displays "My Phony Valentine" by Courtney Walsh, surrounded by physical books on shelves. Text labels point to themes like "Hockey Romance," "Fake Dating," "Meddling Grandma," "Romcom," and "Small Town."
No spice romance books for Valentine’s Day
#booktok #nospicebooks #valentinesdaybooks #romancebooks #bookstagram
lilysreadingcorner1

lilysreadingcorner1

72 likes

No spice, just butterflies🧸
#nospicebooks #closeddoorromance #bookrecs #cleanbooks #booktok
lilysreadingcorner1

lilysreadingcorner1

118 likes

pretty in 🌸💖 pink 💖🌸: book covers edition
Happy Valentine’s Day! In case you don’t want something romantic… I got you! 😉 I love romance (so no shade here) but sometimes ya gotta switch it up, so here’s some very cute pink covers to stay on theme of the holiday… but different genres! [BOOKS PICTURED] 🎀 “Beautiful Bodies” by Kimberly
hannah 📖

hannah 📖

61 likes

BOOK REVIEW: THE CARTEL 1-3
RATING: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5 Yall said ima be in the ride for my life with this book…. WHEEWWWWWW BABYYYYY I DID NOT KNOW WHAT I WAS GETTING MYSELF INTOOO OKAYY!!!!! The cartel 1-3 was AMAZING!!!!! Like PAGE AFTER PAGE AFTER PAGE 🔥🔥🔥 I couldn’t put it down I swear I couldn’t I stayed up all night yester
˚ ꕥ Catera ꕥ˚

˚ ꕥ Catera ꕥ˚

150 likes

A hand holds the white cover book "A Love Letter to Whiskey" by Kandi Steiner, featuring gold script. Overlays read "My Honest BOOK REVIEW" and "Rating: 5/5", with small heart emojis. The book is a 5th Anniversary Edition, with a quote from Penelope Ward.
My Honest Book Review 📖🥹🫶🏻
Book name: A Love Letter To Whiskey 🥃 Author: Kandi Steiner Genre: Romance Good Reads Rating ⭐️: 4.36 My rating⭐️: 5 My review: Where should I even begin???? The main character B? Oh I hated her .. every chapter the hate grew bigger .. and JUST WHEN I THOUGHT I LIKED HER ! Boom .. she di
Martha

Martha

264 likes

Book review coming soon!
Just picked this up at Barnes and Noble yesterday. Anyone read it yet?!?! Opinions?!? I will be updating yall when I finish! #booktok #BookReview #books #christianbooks #chrisitiangirl #jesusgirl #christianbooks #christianblogger #jesuslemon8 #jesuslovesyou
Beth

Beth

724 likes

A woman holds L.J. Shen's "Damaged Goods" (All Saints #4) and a stack including "Pretty Reckless" and "Broken Knight" from the All Saints series. She is in front of bookshelves, illustrating the book review of the series praised for its complex characters and emotional depth.
book review 💜
LJ Shen did what only LJ Shen could do, she broke our hearts made us fall in love with beautifully complex characters. This series was truly a journey and seeing Lev and Bailey’s relationship grow through complete darkness was brilliant. Bailey’s addiction is a major topic in the book, it’s not
Liz ✨🌼🎀

Liz ✨🌼🎀

43 likes

The book cover for 'Percy Jackson and the Olympians: The Sea of Monsters' by Rick Riordan, featuring a cyclops and a ship, is displayed on a white surface. Overlaid text indicates a 10/10 rating, 279 pages, and reviewer reactions to plot points like Grover, Clarisse, Polyphemus, and Luke, noting it was read in one sitting.
PJO Book review pt. 2!!
I finished PJO Sea of Monsters recently so I wanted to do a review! Overall rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 10/10 Review: Grover gets kidnapped and pretends to be a female cyclops so he doesn’t get eaten. The barrier on Camp Half-Blood got poisoned by an unknown person. Supposedly where Grover is being h
Aisling 🤍

Aisling 🤍

192 likes

A hand with iridescent nail polish holds the book 'Hurricane Summer' by Asha Ashanti Bromfield. The cover features a woman with a flower in her hair under a rainy sky, with the tagline 'Sometimes the storm is inside of you.' A 'BOOKLIST (starred review)' quote is also visible.
Book Review 5 ✨
5 ⭐️s! I did not want to put this book down! This book deals with classism, colorism, father-daughter dynamics, finding yourself & learning the power of distruction & finding your own voice! While the Island of Jamaica is preparing for what seems to be its worst hurricane yet, Tilla is simu
Lia Lockhart

Lia Lockhart

63 likes

A person holds a coffee cup next to a laptop and saucer on a wooden table, with text overlay 'the sh*t they never taught you *an honest book review'.
The book 'the sh*t they never taught you' by Adam Jones & Adam Ashton is displayed on a yellow background, with a 4/5 star rating and a review comment.
An open book and cup are on a bed next to a lamp, illustrating 'Key takeaway #1: Mindset Matters' from the book.
The sh*t they never taught you (book review)
Okay, raise your hand if you ever felt like school totally ripped you off. 🙋‍♀️ Like, we learned about photosynthesis but not how to handle a breakup or file taxes. 🤦‍♀️ Adulting is HARD, and it feels like no one gave us the playbook. This book is not all-time cheat code imma be honest, though I
Meredith Jao

Meredith Jao

949 likes

The book cover for "Men We Reaped: A Memoir" by Jesmyn Ward, featuring an old photograph of two young Black children, rests on a white fluffy surface. The cover includes a quote from The New York Times Book Review and the author's name. A Lemon8 watermark is visible at the bottom left.
Book Review 📚
If you are easily triggered, this may not be a book you would want to read. In order to go out into society and experience others without judgement, we have to know where they came from. The author perfectly illustrates the lives of four young, Black men who died very young. Their tragic deaths sho
Marlesia

Marlesia

262 likes

A hand with a pink ombre nail holds the book 'A Worthy Love' by A.E. Valdez, featuring a woman with curly hair on the cover. Text overlays include 'Vegas SECRET,' 'Love Heals,' 'Close Proximity,' 'Fuckenemies,' and 'He falls first.' The background shows bookshelves, and the bottom has 'BOOK REVIEW' with Lemon8 branding.
Book Review ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
A.E. VALDEZ HAS DONE IT AGAIN OMG! This book was amazing (the entire series is 5 stars) but this book in general was amazingly written. This book had me on a 🎢 (because of Reese goofy ASS) 1 minute I was laughing, crying and throwing the book across the room(because of REESE 😂). #unfiltere
Katie May

Katie May

267 likes

Sunny Disposition Book Review
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️5/5 STARS!! I absolutely loved this book. Not only am I a sucker for a good hockey romance, but forced proximity is also one of my favorite tropes. Some other amazing tropes within this book that I love are Grumpy x Sunshine, hates everyone(ish) but you, and hidden identity. This bo
LKBooks

LKBooks

2086 likes

A flat lay shows blank-spined books, bookmarks, and a plush toy, with text overlay "romance books I'll always recommend" and "lemon8 @lilysreadingcorner1".
A grid displays 23 "no spice" romance book covers, including titles like "But He's My Grumpy Neighbor," "The Valentine's Bet," and "Cursed by Love," with "@lilysreadingcorner1" at the bottom.
A grid displays 21 "no spice" romance book covers, featuring titles such as "Stick to Me," "Fake Dating the Girl Next Door," and "The Politics of Love," with "@lilysreadingcorner1" at the bottom.
Romance books I’ll always recommend🎀
All are no spice books💖 #bookrecs #booktok #bookstagram #nospicebooks #bookrecommendations
lilysreadingcorner1

lilysreadingcorner1

42 likes

Book Review: Now With You
Rating: 4/5⭐️ Title: Now With You Author: Dulcie Dameron Review: I truly enjoy the characters in this inter connected series a lot. This was just a short little novella, but I thought there was some really sweet tender stuff in it none the less. This was my first time with an age gap
Caitri Riding

Caitri Riding

80 likes

See more