Stories of dolphin abduction and underwater civilizations capture our imagination largely because dolphins are indeed known for their intelligence and complex social interactions. Real science confirms that dolphins have sophisticated communication skills, can recognize themselves in mirrors, and cooperate effectively in groups. These traits fuel the plausibility of such legends, making them popular topics online. However, while dolphins demonstrate impressive problem-solving abilities and social cooperation, there is no verified evidence supporting claims of humans being kidnapped by dolphins or underwater cities built under their command. These stories typically spread through exaggerated videos and repeated online posts, often blurring the lines between fact and fiction. Personally, the fascination with dolphin intelligence has led me to read numerous scientific studies highlighting their behaviors in the wild. For example, researchers have documented how dolphins use signature whistles to identify themselves, showing a level of individuality and communication complexity comparable to primates. This undoubtedly elevates their mystique. Despite the absence of proof of such abduction incidents, reflecting on these stories encourages us to appreciate the natural marvels of dolphin communities and to remain curious—but critical—about sensational claims. Engaging with credible research helps strike a balance between wonder and skepticism, enriching our understanding of the animal world without falling for viral myths.