✨rating viral NYC 🍕
Mama's TOO! Upper West Side $$$ 5/5
You better come hungry because this pizza is incredibly filling and you definitely get your bang for your buck. The thick, square slices are simply divine and there's a range of flavors and toppings whether you love pasta (cacio e pepe) or meat too. There's even a poached pear. If you want something hearty (and square) this is your go-to.
L'Industrie Pizzeria $$$ 5/5
Another OG spot that really is OG. Probably my favorite pizza in all of NYC and that says a lot as a native New Yorker. It' the perfect texture, cheesiness, and consistency and you cannot miss the freshly topped burrata slice. If I had to pick one NYC slice to eat forever - it would be this one.
Adoro Lei $$$ 3/5
This place has gone viral because you can host a party here and make pizzas while you sip on cocktails and listen to a DJ. The pizza candidly is just OK, but I was impressed I was able to make something edible. Not sure if it would be any different if I didn't make it, but it's fine. Works for the party purpose.
Slicehaus Pizzeria $$$ 3.5/5
This newly opened spot come from some of the L'industrie people - so you know it should be good. I was expecting a different take on its viral sibling. It was decent pizza, with good texture, but I think if I had to choose it would be L'industrie all day.
New York City is renowned worldwide for its iconic pizza culture, and the viral rating of spots like Mama’s TOO! Upper West Side highlights why. Mama’s TOO! offers a unique twist with its thick, square slices that deliver a substantial and flavorful meal. Fans rave about the unusual toppings like spicy salami and the standout poached pear, which add an exciting gourmet touch rarely found in typical pizzerias. For those who enjoy trying blends between classic pizza and pasta flavors, Mama’s TOO! brings that fusion to life on their menu. L’Industrie Pizzeria is frequently mentioned by locals as having some of the best slices in NYC, especially celebrated for perfect texture and the indulgent burrata-topped slice. This pizzeria captures the essence of traditional New York-style pizza with a fresh and consistent approach, making it a favorite for both locals and visitors. For a more social vibe, Adoro Lei offers a party atmosphere where guests can actively make their own pizzas while enjoying cocktails and music. Though the pizza quality is modest, this spot shines as an experience rather than a strictly culinary destination, perfect for groups looking to have fun while dining. Slicehaus Pizzeria, an offshoot connected to L’Industrie’s founders, provides a decent alternative with good texture and flavor. While it may not eclipse its viral sibling in popularity or taste, it offers an accessible option for those wanting fresh pizza in a newer setting. These rankings reflect not just the quality of the pizza but also unique dining experiences that NYC offers. If you’re exploring viral NYC pizza, considering texture, toppings, and ambiance will help you choose the perfect spot. Whether you want hearty, thick slices or classic cheesiness, these top-rated pizzerias are excellent picks for a true taste of New York’s pizza scene.