Rating Prom Dresses I Tried (but didn’t choose)

4/13 Edited to

... Read moreChoosing the perfect prom dress can be both exciting and overwhelming. From my experience trying on several dresses, I found that the right fit and comfort matter just as much as style and appearance. For example, one dress scored a solid 9/10 and I almost chose it, but it wasn’t quite the perfect match because of the sizing and some subtle design details. Another dress rated low—3/10—because it was too big, uncomfortable, and left glitter everywhere, which was a hassle to manage. I also discovered that strapless dresses, although beautiful, were not my favorite due to comfort concerns. Some dresses felt stiff and restrictive even if they looked good, which is something to consider if you plan to dance the night away. My final choice was a 10/10 in fit and style, making me feel confident and pretty. When shopping for prom dresses, it’s helpful to try on multiple styles and pay attention to the fabric, support, and how it makes you feel overall. Don’t settle just because a dress looks amazing on the rack—comfort and how well it fits your body shape are key. Remember to take notes on what you love and dislike about each dress, just like I did, to help make your decision easier. Also, consider practical factors like the dress length, whether it has a train (which might be inconvenient), and if it suits the theme or vibe you want for your prom. Overall, sharing these honest dress ratings helped me avoid buyer’s remorse and feel excited about my final choice. Hopefully, by sharing my experience, you’ll feel more confident and informed in finding the prom dress that makes you shine!

30 comments

Nana5415's images
Nana5415

You chose the most beautiful dress of all. Plus it stands out. Every other girl at prom will have one similar to the first ones. Yours say look at ME‼️‼️‼️

WhereMyTakisAT🥀's images
WhereMyTakisAT🥀

The last one looks so good on you🙏

See more comments

Related posts

Rating Prom Dresses I tried on and why I didn’t ge
I loved the dress I ended up getting 😌 #fyp #promfashion #promdressstyle #promfit #Lemon8Diary @Lemon8 US
Isabella DesRoc

Isabella DesRoc

284 likes

Rating wedding dresses I tried on but didn’t get
Some wedding dresses I tried on while dress shopping in honor of my first anniversary. Dress reveal at end!!! #weddingdress #weddingdressshopping #isaidyestothedress
Emilee

Emilee

112 likes

Prom dresses I tried on but didn’t get
Can’t wait to show y’all the one I ended up with!! Stay tuned for prom season!! #promfashion #promdressstyle #promfit #promdressideas #promseason
kerrr_freeman

kerrr_freeman

677 likes

RATING WEDDING DRESSES I TRIED BUT DIDN’T GET! ✨
Now that I've FINALLY found my wedding dress, here's some of the others I tried on! The first store was closing so I tried on the last few dresses they had left, but I'm so glad we went because I wouldn't have found my dress if we hadn't! I almost picked the very last dress I tr
Allie!

Allie!

19 likes

A smiling woman models a white wedding dress with a lace bodice and a full tulle skirt, rated 9/10 as 'gorgeous but scratchy'.
A smiling woman models a fitted white lace wedding dress with a V-neck, noting it 'didn't hug me in the right places'.
The back view of a woman in a white lace wedding dress with a deep open back and long train, described as 'the show stopper 7.5/10'.
Rating wedding dresses I tried on but didn’t get
Sorry I can’t show my wedding dress yet but I thought this was a fun trend ! 🥰💍 #weddings #weddingdresses
Dani Paisley

Dani Paisley

10 likes

Prom dresses I tried on but didn’t get
It’s my senior year, I really wanted to go all out this year. The dress on the first picture is the one I got and it was a bit pricey. It was $620 but everywhere I looked, I got disappointed. There was nothing like that dress but I am so grateful to have gotten that dress. #prominspo #prom #
Naomi💕

Naomi💕

200 likes

✨PROM DRESSES✨ I tried on… but didn’t buy
#promdresstryon #prom #drew vintage floral dress
Lilly Woratyla

Lilly Woratyla

50 likes

Rating PROM Dresses I Didn’t Get & Why!
There was way more I tried on that I didn’t show. I’ve never tried on that many dresses 😭 Lmk if you wanna see the dress I ended up getting! #prompictures #dress #windsor #promsesson #Lemon8Diary
emma :)

emma :)

40 likes

Prom dresses I tried on but didn’t get
All the dresses I tired on were from Windsor and Macy’s! I will reveal the prom dress I got after prom! #promdress #promdresses #summerbod #tryonreview #tryonhaul
Riley

Riley

68 likes

A smiling young woman holds a pink 'I said yes to the dress' sign in front of a wooden wall with a 'Birdie Bridal Stockyards' neon sign. Text overlay indicates she is rating wedding dresses she tried on but didn't choose as a 2025 bride.
A young woman takes a mirror selfie wearing a strapless, full-skirted wedding dress with intricate beading. The dress is described as heavy, with details loved but feeling like something was missing.
A close-up mirror selfie shows the bodice of a strapless, beaded wedding dress on a young woman. The dress is rated 8/10, described as gorgeous, highlighting the intricate pearl-like details.
rating wedding dresses i tried onbut didn’t get
🛍️: Birdie Bridal Stockyards #2025bride #wedding #weddingdress #weddingplanning
sierra florez

sierra florez

2 likes

Rating prom dresses i tried on
#beautyfinds #promdress
ashlynwhalen

ashlynwhalen

3 likes

A tabby cat sits on a black bucket next to a white house siding. Text overlay reads "Rating prom dresses I tried on!!" with a Lemon8 watermark.
A person models a dark blue strapless prom dress with a high slit, standing on a black platform. Text overlay rates it 8-10, stating it was loved for its pretty neckline.
A person models a shimmering bronze-gold prom dress with cutouts and a deep V-neck. Text overlay rates it 10/10, noting it was a second choice but the color washed them out.
prom dresses I tried but didn’t get!
Let me know if you wanna see the one I got! First two are at Black Tie White Satin, the next 3 are from dillards, last one is from a local quince shop #promfashion #promdressshopping #promdress #Lemon8Diary #prom
Trin :)

Trin :)

4 likes

Prom dresses I tried on but didn’t get😱
#promfashion #promfit #promdress #promdresses #promdressideas
Mattia Nelson

Mattia Nelson

23 likes

A person tries on a light pink prom dress with a beaded bodice and thin straps, noting the beading but disliking the shape and lack of a slit.
A person tries on a light purple halter-neck prom dress with ruched detailing and a high slit, finding it too big despite liking the shape and slit.
A person tries on a vibrant hot pink prom dress with a v-neckline and a high slit, noting it was too tight on the stomach and legs.
prom dresses i tried on and didn’t get!
All of these dresses are STILL AVAILABLE at THE PAISLEY BRIDE working there gives me more opportunity to try the dresses on before others love my boss 🫶🏻
andi miller

andi miller

560 likes

A young woman takes a mirror selfie in a bathroom, wearing a grey sweatshirt. The image has a text overlay "PROM DRESSES I TRIED ON, BUT DIDN'T GET (And why)" and a pink "swipe" arrow pointing right on the sink.
A young woman, with her face blurred, models a light blue strapless prom dress with a sparkly bodice and a flowing tulle skirt in a dressing room. The caption states the top felt too heavy for a strapless design.
A young woman, with her face blurred, sits in a dressing room wearing a light blue strapless prom dress adorned with flower appliqués. The caption mentions loving the color and appliqués, but disliking the cut.
Prom dresses I tried on, but didn’t get (and why)
#promfashion #promdressstyle #promdress #promdressideas #promfit
Jordan💫

Jordan💫

12 likes

Ranking Wedding Dresses
This was such a fun & comfortable experience!! Wait til you guys see what I did choose🫣 #2026bride #weddingdress #brideera #bridetobe J. Jones Evening Wear
jordyn woods

jordyn woods

4 likes

rating prom dresses i tried on my senior year💃
dress reveal at the end>>> #prom dress #promrecap #promdressideas #promgirl Missouri
Emalee Elyse💐

Emalee Elyse💐

488 likes

Prom Dresses I Tried On But Didn’t End Up Getting
I’m in love with the dress that I got😍😍 -I’ll share some prom pictures in may🫶 #prom #prominspo #prom2025 #promdress #promfashion
Bella Norris

Bella Norris

8 likes

A woman models a strapless red prom dress with a ruffled, layered skirt and a high slit, standing outdoors. The image has text overlay "PROM DRESSES I'd wear if I were not 31 years old" and "lemon8 @loverofgingerale."
A woman poses in a rust-colored strapless prom dress featuring a corset-style bodice and a dramatic high-low ruffled tulle skirt. She wears silver embellished heels in a plain studio setting.
A smiling woman wears an off-the-shoulder light blue prom dress with a floral print and ruffled tiers, standing outdoors next to a vintage light blue van.
Prom dresses I’d wear (if I weren’t 31 years old)😂
Yes I know I’m 31 and yes I still look at prom dress trends 😂 they are just so beautiful and I felt so beautiful at my prom but now I see such beautiful dresses that I can’t help but think what ones I’d wear if I were in high school now! So here they are! Which ones your favorite? Or do these all s
Kirsten

Kirsten

198 likes

prom dresses i didn’t get and why
#lemon8bookclub #prom2024
jxlianna.1

jxlianna.1

63 likes

rating all my old hs dance dresses!!
#promdresstryon #homecoming #homecomingdressideas #dresses #fashion
KAYLA🤎🧸✨🐆

KAYLA🤎🧸✨🐆

729 likes

A model in a white, ornate wedding dress with a high slit, standing in a luxurious setting. Overlaid text reads "Dresses I tried on, but didn't pick SWIPE," indicating a series of dresses that were not chosen.
A person from behind wears a white, off-the-shoulder, lace mermaid wedding dress with a long train in a bridal shop. Overlaid text indicates the back was "not low enough," there was "too much lace," and the dress "felt stiff."
A person wears a white A-line wedding dress with a lace bodice and spaghetti straps in a bridal shop. Overlaid text states they were "looking for more form fitting" and "loved the top, not the bottom" of the dress.
Dresses I tried but didn't say 'yes' to...
I'm a procrastinator, so I waited 4 months out to go dress shopping. I went to a sample store because I knew I needed to walk out with the dress, I had no time to order and do alterations. I had a great time trying on beautiful, discounted samples. I tried on 6 dresses total, and I found my dre
MP

MP

11 likes

prom dresses i didn’t get! (and why)
dress reveal APRIL 5th!!! store: TERRY COSTA in dallas! #prom #terrycosta #promdress #promseason
madi 💋

madi 💋

199 likes

Prom dresses I tried on but didnt get and why
I'm a sophomore going to prom for my second time (boyfriend is older) and I didn't hardly try on dresses in the color I originally wanted but I absolutely love my dress. It also doesn't really go with the theme but that's ok!
Rileigh Justice

Rileigh Justice

3 likes

Wedding dresses I tried on but didn't get
#fOrevawithBart #2024bride #weddingdresses #weddingjourney #wedding
O&B

O&B

1 like

A woman from behind, wearing a light pink ball gown with a ruffled skirt and lace bodice, in a bridal shop. Text overlay: 'Wedding Dresses I tried on vs..'
A woman in a champagne-colored tiered ball gown, holding a phone, looking into a mirror in a bridal shop. Text overlay: 'Prom Dress Vibes Pretty Champagne Color Loved the skirt 5/10 Made me look short :/'
A woman in an ivory ball gown with a ruffled skirt and embellished bodice, posing in a bridal shop. Text overlay: 'Loved the Bodice Style Pretty Ivory Color LOOOVE the skirt!! 9/10'
Rating Wedding Dresses I Tried on Vs… 💍
These photos recently came up on my snap memories from when I was wedding dress shoppping in 2018! (Hello 2016 makeup and eyebrow blindness 🫣) Fiancé era was so fun and such a magical time 💍❤️ Going in, I knew I wanted a ball gown type dress. I wanted to feel like a princess 💕✨ Poofy skirt wa
Lili 🌸

Lili 🌸

37 likes

A young woman with a ponytail smiles outdoors, with text overlay "PROM DRESSES I DIDN'T GET AND WHY Swipe." She is wearing a cow print top and dark pants, standing in front of trees and bushes.
A young woman tries on a dark green V-neck prom dress in a mirror, with a friend beside her. Text notes the color was loved but the plain middle needed more, rating it 7/10.
The back of a dark green prom dress with a criss-cross lace-up design is shown in a mirror, with text "Loved the back."
Prom Dresses I Didn’t Get and Why
These are just a few that I tried on and a few reasons I didn’t pick them! #prom
Summerb

Summerb

3 likes

prom dresses I didn’t choose and why!
#prom #promdressstyle #promdressinspo #dress #promfit
Sanya 🤨

Sanya 🤨

4 likes

prom dresses
last year was my senior prom!! i went prom dress shopping in tennessee. there were so many amazing dress options. all of the dresses were beautiful but not for me. i fell in love with the dress i chose. i went last minute shopping so basically all the dresses were on sale. #promseason #pro
Madi Graci🪩

Madi Graci🪩

1043 likes

Rating my dresses 👗 🍋🌸🫶✨
Dresses- BRANDS 🛍 Slide 1- Lulus Slide 2- Etsy Slide 3- In White Slide 4- Shein Slide 5- Express Slide 6- Amazon Slide 7- Banana Republic Slide 8- Etsy Slide 9- H&M
Evelina🦢

Evelina🦢

6 likes

Prom dresses I tried on
Gracie

Gracie

199 likes

rating prom/hoco dresses!
guess which ones i got! i got 2 prom dresses, and one hoco dress. #promfashion #promseason #promdressideas #promfit #hocodresses
ave🪩🎀🤍👙

ave🪩🎀🤍👙

357 likes

Prom dresses I almost got, and why I didn’t 😉
You should see the scratches and rashes i have from trying on all those different dresses. battle scars! we went to dillards in jacksonville and one place in jesup🎀💞
Luvwisteria

Luvwisteria

11 likes

A white background with scattered pink outline flower drawings, featuring a central pink rectangle with the text "Prom dresses i tried but didn't buy and why" in dark pink.
A person with reddish hair takes a mirror selfie in a dressing room, wearing a light purple, strapless, sparkly prom dress. The caption states, "The color was too light for me."
A person with reddish hair takes a mirror selfie in a dressing room, wearing a dark blue prom dress with a sheer, structured bodice and a patterned skirt. The caption reads, "Looked good but wasn't a fan of the designs on the dress."
Prom dresses i tried but didn’t buy
🫶🫶🫶 #prom #dressshopping
LillyG

LillyG

17 likes

A young woman models a white and blue floral pattern prom dress with a high slit, holding a white flower bouquet outdoors. The dress features a corset-style bodice and thin straps.
A person wears a long, form-fitting orange sequined prom dress with a sweetheart neckline, reflected in a mirror. The dress has intricate patterns and a mermaid-style silhouette.
A person tries on a long, gold and silver sequined prom dress with a deep V-neck and high slit, taking a mirror selfie in a dress shop. Other dresses are visible in the background.
Prom Dresses I Tried on!
All the prom dresses I tried on and the ones i ended up buying!! #dressrecommendation #fashion #fashionfinds #fashionstyle #Lemon8Diary #beautyfinds #clothes #style #shoppinghaul #shopping
Ella :)

Ella :)

17 likes

Prom dresses I didn’t get and why!
✨Outfit Details: All of these dresses were from Dillards! Every dress expect what I got was under $200! #promfashion #promfit #dresses
✨ kj sumrall ✨

✨ kj sumrall ✨

14 likes

RATING HIGH SCHOOL DANCE DRESSES I WORE
out of all of these i think senior hoco is my favorite cause i had the best time at that dance in that dress #highschooldance #hoco #dress #helpmechoose #ratings
grace raymond

grace raymond

1029 likes

Prom dresses and where🥰
Dress 1) either from JCPenny’s or Kohl’s (I think) Dress 2) Dillards Dress 3) Dillards Dress 4) Dillards Dress 5) Windsor Dress 6) Macy’s Dress 7) Macy’s Store Haul TryOn #Shopping🛍️
Danica Eyestone

Danica Eyestone

141 likes

See more