Rating Prom Dresses I Tried (but didn’t choose)

4/13 Edited to

... Read moreChoosing the perfect prom dress can be both exciting and overwhelming. From my experience trying on several dresses, I found that the right fit and comfort matter just as much as style and appearance. For example, one dress scored a solid 9/10 and I almost chose it, but it wasn’t quite the perfect match because of the sizing and some subtle design details. Another dress rated low—3/10—because it was too big, uncomfortable, and left glitter everywhere, which was a hassle to manage. I also discovered that strapless dresses, although beautiful, were not my favorite due to comfort concerns. Some dresses felt stiff and restrictive even if they looked good, which is something to consider if you plan to dance the night away. My final choice was a 10/10 in fit and style, making me feel confident and pretty. When shopping for prom dresses, it’s helpful to try on multiple styles and pay attention to the fabric, support, and how it makes you feel overall. Don’t settle just because a dress looks amazing on the rack—comfort and how well it fits your body shape are key. Remember to take notes on what you love and dislike about each dress, just like I did, to help make your decision easier. Also, consider practical factors like the dress length, whether it has a train (which might be inconvenient), and if it suits the theme or vibe you want for your prom. Overall, sharing these honest dress ratings helped me avoid buyer’s remorse and feel excited about my final choice. Hopefully, by sharing my experience, you’ll feel more confident and informed in finding the prom dress that makes you shine!

4 comments

Nana5415's images
Nana5415

You chose the most beautiful dress of all. Plus it stands out. Every other girl at prom will have one similar to the first ones. Yours say look at ME‼️‼️‼️

AmyMcNog's images
AmyMcNog

That’s beautiful!! So feminine and summery! 🥰

See more comments

Related posts

Rating Prom Dresses I tried on and why I didn’t ge
I loved the dress I ended up getting 😌 #fyp #promfashion #promdressstyle #promfit #Lemon8Diary @Lemon8 US
Isabella DesRoc

Isabella DesRoc

282 likes

Prom dresses I tried on but didn’t get
Can’t wait to show y’all the one I ended up with!! Stay tuned for prom season!! #promfashion #promdressstyle #promfit #promdressideas #promseason
kerrr_freeman

kerrr_freeman

673 likes

Rating wedding dresses I tried on but didn’t get
Some wedding dresses I tried on while dress shopping in honor of my first anniversary. Dress reveal at end!!! #weddingdress #weddingdressshopping #isaidyestothedress
Emilee

Emilee

112 likes

A smiling woman models a white wedding dress with a lace bodice and a full tulle skirt, rated 9/10 as 'gorgeous but scratchy'.
A smiling woman models a fitted white lace wedding dress with a V-neck, noting it 'didn't hug me in the right places'.
The back view of a woman in a white lace wedding dress with a deep open back and long train, described as 'the show stopper 7.5/10'.
Rating wedding dresses I tried on but didn’t get
Sorry I can’t show my wedding dress yet but I thought this was a fun trend ! 🥰💍 #weddings #weddingdresses
Dani Paisley

Dani Paisley

10 likes

RATING WEDDING DRESSES I TRIED BUT DIDN’T GET! ✨
Now that I've FINALLY found my wedding dress, here's some of the others I tried on! The first store was closing so I tried on the last few dresses they had left, but I'm so glad we went because I wouldn't have found my dress if we hadn't! I almost picked the very last dress I tr
Allie!

Allie!

19 likes

✨PROM DRESSES✨ I tried on… but didn’t buy
#promdresstryon #prom #drew vintage floral dress
Lilly Woratyla

Lilly Woratyla

24 likes

Prom dresses i tried on but didn’t get 🌻✨🤍🫶🏼
Rylee🌻🫶🏻🤍

Rylee🌻🫶🏻🤍

0 likes

Prom dresses I tried on but didn’t get
It’s my senior year, I really wanted to go all out this year. The dress on the first picture is the one I got and it was a bit pricey. It was $620 but everywhere I looked, I got disappointed. There was nothing like that dress but I am so grateful to have gotten that dress. #prominspo #prom #
Naomi💕

Naomi💕

200 likes

rating prom dresses i tried on my senior year💃
dress reveal at the end>>> #prom dress #promrecap #promdressideas #promgirl Missouri
Emalee Elyse💐

Emalee Elyse💐

487 likes

PROM DRESSES 🎀✨
Which style is your favorite? #prominspo #dresstoimpress #glam #promfashion #dressup👗 ✨
Addi Jane

Addi Jane

149 likes

Prom dresses I tried on but didn’t get
All the dresses I tired on were from Windsor and Macy’s! I will reveal the prom dress I got after prom! #promdress #promdresses #summerbod #tryonreview #tryonhaul
Riley

Riley

66 likes

Rating PROM Dresses I Didn’t Get & Why!
There was way more I tried on that I didn’t show. I’ve never tried on that many dresses 😭 Lmk if you wanna see the dress I ended up getting! #prompictures #dress #windsor #promsesson #Lemon8Diary
emma :)

emma :)

40 likes

A smiling woman wears a light blue tiered ruffled prom dress with a corset-style bodice and a high slit, standing by a lake with trees in the background.
A light yellow satin halter-neck gown with a front cutout detail is displayed on a mannequin against a plain background.
A woman smiles wearing a royal blue tiered ruffled prom dress with a corset-style bodice and a high slit, standing outdoors with greenery.
prom dresses inspo🧚‍♀️
2026 prom dress inspo #dresses #prominspo #promdress #birthday dress
ohmollydress

ohmollydress

190 likes

Prom dresses I tried on but didn’t get😱
#promfashion #promfit #promdress #promdresses #promdressideas
Mattia Nelson

Mattia Nelson

23 likes

A person takes a mirror selfie in a fitting room, wearing a long, dark red textured prom dress with spaghetti straps. The image introduces a series of prom dresses tried on but not purchased.
A person models a light pink prom dress featuring a tiered, ruffled skirt and a corset-style bodice with spaghetti straps. The accompanying text notes the color was too light, no pockets, and the slit was too high.
A person poses in a shimmering light blue prom dress with a full skirt and a cowl neck, showcasing the pockets. The text indicates it was a close runner-up, but the skirt wasn't considered big enough.
Prom dresses I tried but didn’t buy part 1
Part 2 and a full tour of the last one soon! And the one I got! #promfashion #promdress #promdresses #promdressideas #promfit
🥀𝔐𝔬𝔯𝔞𝔫𝔞🥀

🥀𝔐𝔬𝔯𝔞𝔫𝔞🥀

1 like

A tabby cat sits on a black bucket next to a white house siding. Text overlay reads "Rating prom dresses I tried on!!" with a Lemon8 watermark.
A person models a dark blue strapless prom dress with a high slit, standing on a black platform. Text overlay rates it 8-10, stating it was loved for its pretty neckline.
A person models a shimmering bronze-gold prom dress with cutouts and a deep V-neck. Text overlay rates it 10/10, noting it was a second choice but the color washed them out.
prom dresses I tried but didn’t get!
Let me know if you wanna see the one I got! First two are at Black Tie White Satin, the next 3 are from dillards, last one is from a local quince shop #promfashion #promdressshopping #promdress #Lemon8Diary #prom
Trin :)

Trin :)

4 likes

cute prom dresses i would wear
#prom #dresses #cute #gorgeous #beautiful
Abby Oneill

Abby Oneill

111 likes

A person tries on a light pink prom dress with a beaded bodice and thin straps, noting the beading but disliking the shape and lack of a slit.
A person tries on a light purple halter-neck prom dress with ruched detailing and a high slit, finding it too big despite liking the shape and slit.
A person tries on a vibrant hot pink prom dress with a v-neckline and a high slit, noting it was too tight on the stomach and legs.
prom dresses i tried on and didn’t get!
All of these dresses are STILL AVAILABLE at THE PAISLEY BRIDE working there gives me more opportunity to try the dresses on before others love my boss 🫶🏻
andi miller

andi miller

558 likes

Prom dresses I tried, but didn’t buy
All dresses are from Windsor <3 💵 Price: 150-250
🥀𝔐𝔬𝔯𝔞𝔫𝔞🥀

🥀𝔐𝔬𝔯𝔞𝔫𝔞🥀

6 likes

Prom Dresses I Tried On But Didn’t End Up Getting
I’m in love with the dress that I got😍😍 -I’ll share some prom pictures in may🫶 #prom #prominspo #prom2025 #promdress #promfashion
Bella Norris

Bella Norris

8 likes

Prom dresses I tried on, but didn’t get (and why)
#promfashion #promdressstyle #promdress #promdressideas #promfit
Jordan💫

Jordan💫

12 likes

Prom Dresses I tried on but didn’t buy!! 🪩💐💖
#prom #promdress #shopping
claire :)

claire :)

6 likes

🌟 Prom dresses 🌟
#princess aesthetic #princess style #princess vibes @Forthegirls
Forthegirls

Forthegirls

238 likes

Rating all kbeauty products what I tried in 2023✨
#kbeauty #kbeautyskincare #kbeautyproducts #beautyfinds #healthylifestyle2024 #unaesthetic #skincaretips #skincareroutine #skinproducts #kbeautyfinds
Yasuan Vega

Yasuan Vega

599 likes

Prom dresses I’d wear (if I weren’t 31 years old)😂
Yes I know I’m 31 and yes I still look at prom dress trends 😂 they are just so beautiful and I felt so beautiful at my prom but now I see such beautiful dresses that I can’t help but think what ones I’d wear if I were in high school now! So here they are! Which ones your favorite? Or do these all s
Kirsten

Kirsten

193 likes

Prom dresses I tried on but didnt get and why
I'm a sophomore going to prom for my second time (boyfriend is older) and I didn't hardly try on dresses in the color I originally wanted but I absolutely love my dress. It also doesn't really go with the theme but that's ok!
Rileigh Justice

Rileigh Justice

3 likes

Ranking Wedding Dresses
This was such a fun & comfortable experience!! Wait til you guys see what I did choose🫣 #2026bride #weddingdress #brideera #bridetobe J. Jones Evening Wear
jordyn woods

jordyn woods

3 likes

Prom Dresses I Can’t Decide On
Little Foody

Little Foody

164 likes

Prom dresses I tried on
#lemon8diarychallenge
Emma

Emma

6 likes

A silver, heavily embellished mermaid prom dress with intricate detailing on the bust and a long, flowing train. The image also features text 'PROM Insporation DRESSES'.
A vibrant red, sequined mermaid prom dress featuring a deep V-neck, strapless design, sheer side panels, and a dramatic train.
A black, heavily beaded mermaid prom dress with a deep V-neck, intricate lace detailing on the bodice, and a long, sparkling train.
PROM DRESSES
Dress inspo for prom!!! #promdressstyle #promdressideas #promfashion #promdress #lemon8beauty
Baddie

Baddie

140 likes

2 SHEIN dresses 1 teacher. 0 patience for deciding
Just a teacher trying to figure out which dress is giving ✨first week energy✨ #sheinteacher #teacheroutfit #teacherfashion 💵 Price: $💌 Brand:SHEIN👍Pros :EVERYTHING 🤔Cons:Can’t bend over in the t shirt dress⭐️Overall rating: 8/10
✨Mrs. Mills/Educator/3rdGrade✨

✨Mrs. Mills/Educator/3rdGrade✨

1 like

A person tries on a black sequined strapless prom dress with a high slit in a store, noting it was too heavy and big despite liking the style.
A person tries on a royal blue corset-style prom dress with a high slit in a fitting room, appreciating the color and corset but finding it too plain.
A person tries on a white iridescent halter-neck prom dress with a high slit in a fitting room, finding it flattering but feeling cheap and itchy.
PROM DRESSES I TRIED ON BUT DIDNT GET
#prom dress #prom2024 #dresses #promshopping #promseason (I got the silver one btw )
caseyp123

caseyp123

161 likes

Two women in long, flowing prom dresses, one yellow and one light blue, dancing outdoors in a grassy area with water and trees in the background. The image has text overlay "PROM DRESSES AND WHERE TO BUY THEM 2024 trendy dresses."
A woman in a white maxi dress with floral patterns and lace details stands on a boardwalk, with a historic building and beach visible in the background. An inset shows the dress on a model.
A smiling woman with blonde hair wears a light blue tiered ruffled maxi dress, posing in front of a white greenhouse with glass panels and potted plants.
links to popular PROM DRESSES 💅
here are some links to the most viral prom dress of 2024!! just in time to purchase before prom szn 🫶 #promdress #promseason #dressinspo #links #lemon8creator #contentcreator
ella 🪩🛼💐

ella 🪩🛼💐

386 likes

2nd Hand Prom Dresses For Sale
All of these prom dresses can be found on Facebook if you search used prom dresses and more are being added daily. They have only been used once. Most are willing to ship, so if you want that special dress but can't afford it, this may be just for you. #promdressshopping #promdressstyle #
Advice to live by

Advice to live by

6 likes

rating prom/hoco dresses!
guess which ones i got! i got 2 prom dresses, and one hoco dress. #promfashion #promseason #promdressideas #promfit #hocodresses
ave🪩🎀🤍👙

ave🪩🎀🤍👙

349 likes

A smiling young woman holds a pink 'I said yes to the dress' sign in front of a wooden wall with a 'Birdie Bridal Stockyards' neon sign. Text overlay indicates she is rating wedding dresses she tried on but didn't choose as a 2025 bride.
A young woman takes a mirror selfie wearing a strapless, full-skirted wedding dress with intricate beading. The dress is described as heavy, with details loved but feeling like something was missing.
A close-up mirror selfie shows the bodice of a strapless, beaded wedding dress on a young woman. The dress is rated 8/10, described as gorgeous, highlighting the intricate pearl-like details.
rating wedding dresses i tried onbut didn’t get
🛍️: Birdie Bridal Stockyards #2025bride #wedding #weddingdress #weddingplanning
sierra moore

sierra moore

2 likes

Rating prom dresses i tried on
#beautyfinds #promdress
ashlynwhalen

ashlynwhalen

3 likes

rating all my old hs dance dresses!!
#promdresstryon #homecoming #homecomingdressideas #dresses #fashion
KAYLA🤎🧸✨🐆

KAYLA🤎🧸✨🐆

259 likes

Prom dresses I tried on
Gracie

Gracie

198 likes

See more