Swag II Was Mid & Here’s 3 Reasons Why:

This wasn’t bad but it wasn’t great either.

It’s been a little over a month now, I think it’s an adequate time to provide a fair assessment on both albums (or the first half and the second half of Swag II).

SWAG was so exciting because it was a surprise album with virtually no skips!! It was fun, romantic, and catchy.

⭐️ Bonus points for it also addressing a ton of things that were happening in the press with him/ him and his family that he didn’t formally talk about prior.

HOWEVER, When SWAG II came out, I was still running on the high of SWAG. Granted it fizzled out a bit, but I was thoroughly satisfied and didn’t need anymore from him right now.

SWAG II made me feel TOO full.

〰️〰️〰️〰️〰️

The tunes were the same, the catchiness was similar, and the meaning behind the songs’ messages were already captured perfectly in SWAG… So this fell short in my eyes.

🤷🏾‍♀️ Maybe it would have been better as another album/ EP type of thing sometime further down the line.

🤷🏾‍♀️ Maybe SWAG II would have been better if it had a different vibe - hip hop or something similar to prior albums?

〰️〰️〰️〰️〰️

OVERALL:

SWAG II left too much room for it to be compared to SWAG and I think that’s what its downfall was.

But maybe it was intentional since the two were combined to create SWAG II - which was unique, I haven’t seen that don’t before.

SN: And on my side of socials.. it didn’t have as much buzz/ people sharing the songs as the first SWAG did. So in my eyes, it made me think other ppl felt the same way.

💭 That’s just me though.. Did you prefer SWAG or SWAG II??

#lemon8tainment

#lemon8contest

#AskLemon8

#hottake

#justinbieber

2025/10/16 Edited to

... Read moreI totally agree with the core idea that there wasn't enough time to breathe between SWAG and SWAG II. It felt like we were still soaking in the magic, the unexpected joy, and the depth of the first album when its sequel dropped. For me, that rushed feeling really impacted my initial listen. It’s almost like having two incredibly rich, decadent desserts back-to-back – you appreciate the first one, savoring every bite, but the second one, even if it's equally good on its own, loses some of its specialness because your palate is already satisfied. That 'Not Enough Time to Breathe Between SWAG & SWAG II' point in the OCR really hit home for me. We needed space to digest the first experience before being presented with what felt like more of the same. And speaking of tracks, I found myself skipping more songs on SWAG II, which rarely happened with the original. It wasn't that the songs were inherently *bad*, but they often felt like variations on themes, melodies, or even lyrical structures already perfected in SWAG. When I hear 'SWAG II Had Weaker Tracks,' it deeply resonates because, while there might have been a few standout moments, many of the melodies or lyrical themes just didn't hit with the same fresh impact or emotional weight as their predecessors. It felt less like evolution and more like iteration, which can be a tough sell for a follow-up album. I was yearning for something that pushed boundaries, or at least explored different facets of the artist's sound, rather than staying so comfortably within the established 'SWAG' vibe. The buzz around SWAG II also felt noticeably different. I definitely noticed a lot more discussion around 'SWAG II Got More Mixed Reviews' online, and in my own circles, people weren't talking about it with the same fervent excitement or sharing songs as widely as they did with the first album. It made me wonder if the artist was trying to capitalize on the SWAG hype a bit too quickly, or if the creative well just hadn't refilled enough for a truly distinct and compelling second chapter. Sometimes, an artist needs that time away, that period of new experiences and growth, to bring something truly fresh to the table. The quick turnaround, combined with the similar sound, really amplified the comparisons, and unfortunately, SWAG II often came up short in those head-to-head moments. If I were to give advice to someone listening to both for the first time, I'd strongly suggest giving SWAG its moment to shine, allowing yourself to fully immerse in its unique charm and unexpected brilliance. Then, approach SWAG II with fresh ears, perhaps expecting something slightly different, or at least prepared for a continuation rather than a drastic departure. Maybe it would have landed better as a standalone project released much later, allowing it to carve out its own distinct identity. It speaks volumes about an album's lasting power when the conversation inevitably circles back to its predecessor. Sometimes, even when the tunes are catchy and the messages are heartfelt, the context of the release – the timing, the expectations, the immediate comparison – can make all the difference in how an audience receives it. What do you guys think? Did you manage to find hidden gems in SWAG II that I might have overlooked, or did you also feel that the original SWAG just reigned supreme?

11 comments

🎧Joyarin🎵's images
🎧Joyarin🎵

Totally agree! SWAG set such a high bar, it was hard for SWAG II to not feel like a repeat.

See more(1)
Nita's images
Nita

Yea, but out of all the songs from Swag and Swag ll, All The Way stays on repeat 😅 that song is so good

See more(1)

See more comments