The Stars Are Dying... And so was I.

I tried so hard to like this book. I tried the audio book and the physical book, but I just could not do it. I rarely DNF a book. I have probably only given up on a small handful of books, but unfortunately this was one of them.

The goods: the book is gorgeous. Like drop dead gorgeous. And it sounded like such a good premise.

The bads: everything else. The plot was all over the place. The author desperately needed a few more rounds with an editor. At 24 chapters in, I still couldn't tell what the book was supposed to be, and I was fighting to stay interested. The main character was horribly wishy washy to the point that I was sure that if she went through threshing a dragon would scorch her just to stop listening to her indecisiveness (IYKYK).

Honestly, I'm mad that I spent so much time and money trying to make it through this one.

⭐️ Rating: 0.5 / 5

#lemon8bookclub #dnfbook #thestarsaredying #lemon8challenge #bookwormsoflemon8

2025/2/25 Edited to

... Read moreIf you've ever encountered a book that simply didn't meet your expectations, you're not alone. 'The Stars Are Dying' by Chloe C. Penaranda has left many readers feeling disappointed. The book's beautiful cover and intriguing premise drew me in, but the chaotic plot and inconsistent character development ultimately led to a lackluster reading experience. As part of the #dnfbook community, many readers face the dilemma of whether to continue with a book or abandon it altogether. The phrase 'Did Not Finish' (DNF) resonates with countless book lovers who have encountered similar struggles with narratives that just don't click. Factors like abrupt pacing shifts, unclear character motivations, or excessive plot twists can leave readers feeling frustrated and disconnected. This review highlights important points: an engaging story should capture interest and maintain clarity. Beta readers and experienced editors play a crucial role in refining a manuscript before publication. In this case, additional rounds of editing could have strengthened the storytelling and character arcs, leading to a more cohesive reading journey. If you found yourself struggling with 'The Stars Are Dying' or have thoughts on other DNF experiences, consider sharing your journey. Connecting with fellow bibliophiles can lead to recommendations for better reads and discussions on what makes a book truly captivating.

13 comments

ElizabethReads🌻's images
ElizabethReads🌻

Oh man 🫠 this one might just sit on my Bookshelf looking pretty forever.

See more(2)

Related posts

I’m dying it in like a week SOS help🥲🥲🥲
#helpmechoose #Lemon8Diary #HairStyle #helpme #haircut #shareyourthoughts #storytime #Hair #hairstyles #explore
abbygarrr

abbygarrr

1451 likes

The Stars Are Dying
This is a Nytefall series book. The first one. Idk I just went to barnes and noble and it was on one of the tables and I liked the cover. So far it is good. Anyone else? What is your thoughts? #fallisforthereaders #nytefallseries #books #bookaesthetic
they call me Lor

they call me Lor

6 likes

Dying your hair blonde go badly??!
I had dark brown hair and I dyed my hair blonde and ask the lady at sally to help and it completely messed up my hair and did not go the way she told me it would so I asked a friend and she told me she used box dye?!, I went to the store and got some boxes and then it was yellow and orange tones an
Ccwmikii

Ccwmikii

748 likes

a tan is not worth dying for
may is melanoma awareness month, the most aggressive type of skin cancer. About 10% of melanomas found are genetically related (mine), but the rest are from too much UV exposure from the sun or tanning beds. It can unfortunately happen to anyone, which is why it is so important to take care of
molly

molly

2438 likes

A light green Amazon Kindle device rests on a white fabric with red heart patterns. Text overlay reads "MY 5 STAR THRILLER BOOKS" and "SWIPE," indicating a list of recommended books.
Thriller books I rate 5 stars
Book 1: Tell Me What Really Happened by Chelsea Sedoti -> 5 friends go camping and in the middle of the night one goes missing. Book 2: That's Not What Happened by Kody Keplinger -> She saw her best friend die in the school bathroom during a shooting. Everyone thinks she died a cert
Alice

Alice

1256 likes

The Stars Are Dying book review
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Overall, I really enjoyed the story. I liked how the world building unfolded along with the character development. Since our FMC (Astrea) has lost her memories of her life before the past five years we discover a lot along with her. Astrea is overall likable (with some minor annoyances
Julia 📚✍️👩🏻‍🏫

Julia 📚✍️👩🏻‍🏫

1 like

Dying hair ginger in 30 Seconds!
We are clearly not professionals but it turned out cute! #gingerblackgirl #dyinghairathome #fallhaircolor #bleachingnaturalhair #blackgirldyedhair Additional Tips: ✨we used a temporary dye but I would look into a permanent one bc obviously it lasts longer (we used adore
sydney🌞

sydney🌞

178 likes

A Kobo e-reader displays a pronunciation guide for character names from 'The Stars Are Dying,' including Astraea, Nyte, and Hektor. A sticky note reads 'BOOK REVIEW,' and a sticker says '(Finally finished).' The screen also shows the book title and page number.
Book Review: The Stars are Dying 🛑SPOILERS🛑
🛑SPOILERS BELOW🛑 💵 Price: $9.99 e-book/Hardback $23+ (depending on where you buy from) Genre: Fantasy Fiction/Romantic Fantasy Pages: 423-500 ⭐️Overall rating: 9.5/10 Took me a while to finish this one with mom life and work happening. But I'm overall thoroughly impressed by the b
toria

toria

4 likes

A hand holds the black and gold cover of 'The Stars Are Dying' by Chloe C. Penaranda, featuring a winged dagger design. The cover has ornate silver and gold accents.
The Stars Are Dying
Just got this beautiful book the other day! Absolutely stunning! I can’t wait to read it 🤗📚❤️ #booksoflemon8 #booktok #books #booklover #readersoflemon8
Shmittenz

Shmittenz

27 likes

It was everywhere all at once and very confusing!
⭐️Overall rating: 5/10 My Current Read 📖 Name of the Book: the stars are dying 📄 Plot: vague and all over the place 📖 Genre: fantasy ^^^^^^^^^^^SOME SPOILERS!!!!^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ ^^^^^^^^^^^SOME SPOILERS!!!!^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ ^^^^^^^^^^^SOME SPOILERS!!!!^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ ^^^^^^^^^
Kiri2118!

Kiri2118!

6 likes

Dying Light Physics Are Broken 🤣
#gamermom #dyinglight #gamingphysics #disabledgamer #gamerforlife🎮
XTRMHarleyAndTheBeast

XTRMHarleyAndTheBeast

0 likes

I’ve been dying to read this!!
As a first born daughter…we go thru a lot and experience the most because we operate in responsibilities we most didn’t ask for..and it affects us greatly!! This book I feel will answer a lot of the questions I have about life and how I can improve and be a better woman going forward. Has any
Elease Sanders

Elease Sanders

1631 likes

The Stars are Dying from Bookishbox
#specialeditionbooks #booksubscriptionbox #bookreccomendation
Death.by.tbr

Death.by.tbr

12 likes

A white table with a book titled "Pachinko" by Min Jin Lee, a pastry, and a glass of water. Red text overlay reads "THIS BOOK WAS WRITTEN BY A DYING MAN (and you should really read it)".
A hand holds the book "When Breath Becomes Air" by Paul Kalanithi. Overlaid text describes it as "Thought-provoking," "Inspiring," "Heartbreaking," and "Life-affirming," urging readers to give it a read.
A close-up of the book "When Breath Becomes Air" on a textured surface. Overlaid text highlights its "Raw & Honest" nature, describing it as heartbreaking yet beautiful, wise, and a reminder to cherish life.
This book was written by a dying man
Recently, I finished a book that shook me to my core. It was written by someone facing their own mortality, and their words carried a weight that's hard to describe. It made me confront my own fears and priorities in a way I hadn't before. There were moments of intense sadness, reading a
Meredith Jao

Meredith Jao

2876 likes

The Idol Who Hung the Stars
Description: The entire world loved Cheon-sa. That was the problem. No one noticed she was slowly dying behind her perfect smile-until rookie idol Taeyang looked at her and saw a person instead of a star.
Yena 🦊🖤

Yena 🦊🖤

7 likes

the Stars Are Dying stars✨️🤍🖤
My current read, anyone else read this series? did it disappoint? I will update after finishing the series. #shadowdaddy #thestarsaredying #Nyte #Astraea
Abbahhh

Abbahhh

4 likes

Box dying hair since I was 10 years old
#hair #hairstyles
Annie 💕

Annie 💕

1129 likes

The Stars Are Dying 🌟📖😍
it took a minute to get into it but once I did, I really enjoyed it! #booktok #bookstagram #bookrecs #bookrecommendations #romantasy
Hannah

Hannah

9 likes

Been dying for that mcobeauty blush and it was finally on sale 🥹.
Obsessed w everythinggg @target @MCoBeauty @cocokind picked the song in honor of Hillary duff coming outta retirement lmaoo🤣 #targethaul #shoppinghauls #makeup #targetfinds #skincare
lifewithjanessaa

lifewithjanessaa

187 likes

The “Dying” Party That Keeps Winning
MAGA keeps preaching the fall of Democrats—but election after election, blue keeps breaking through red strongholds. Facts don’t lie. The people are speaking. Politics | Democracy | Election Trends Stay informed. Stand for truth, not propaganda. Follow @freedomandjusticeallianc for real updat
Freedom and Justice Alliance

Freedom and Justice Alliance

0 likes

The image displays the title "TIPS TO MAXIMIZE YOUR PHONE BATTERY" in red text over a blurred white background. Below the title, a white battery icon shows 5% charge, with a lightning bolt and charger icon, indicating a critically low battery.
This image, titled "USE AIRPLANE MODE," provides instructions on how to use airplane mode to quickly charge a phone when the battery is critically low. It explains that airplane mode reduces power consumption by turning off Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, and cellular signals.
Titled "LOW BATTERY MODE," this image explains how to activate and benefit from low battery mode. It notes that the device suggests turning it on at 20% battery and details how it saves power by reducing background activity, extending battery life.
‼️What do you do when your phone is dying⁉️
🚨 Woke up LATE & Phone’s NOT Charged?! 🚨 Here’s How I Survived 💪📱 Ever had one of those mornings? You wake up, realize you’re already late, and then… BAM! Your phone didn’t charge all night. Now you’re rushing to get ready, but you know you’ll need every bit of battery you can squeeze out. N
🌸Gen✨𖥔 ′ ⩇⩇:⩇⩇ ⋆☾⋆⁺₊ ✧

🌸Gen✨𖥔 ′ ⩇⩇:⩇⩇ ⋆☾⋆⁺₊ ✧

1701 likes

places i’m dying to visit: pnw edition
This is my current travel bucket list for the pacific northwest! I hope this gives you guys some ideas and also give me some more recommendations if you have any :) Some things I have already done that were really fun and I would recommend are: -🏄‍♂️Surfing the coast: the breaks on the oregon
Paige Michalski

Paige Michalski

2404 likes

The Stars Are Dying book tour
book 2 tomorrow❤️
MegaUltraLorde96

MegaUltraLorde96

6 likes

A woman at a beauty salon with white dye applied to her eyebrows, asking if others get nervous trying new beauty treatments like brow dyeing or waxing.
A woman's face showing her eyebrows with dye oxidizing, turning from white to a light brown color, indicating the 20-25 minute process is underway.
A woman's face with her eyebrows now a darker brown after dyeing, with text explaining they were previously blonde in spots and needed the darker color.
Do you ever get nervous waxing / dying your brows?
#lemon8contest #AskLemon8 yes I have had my brows waxed before it has just been a while! this time I'll definitely be keeping the plucking up with. but I definitely was a bit nervous dying my brows.. and it was nothing.. just let it turn from white to brown while it oxidized.. they need
ᴛᴇꜱꜱᴀ ᴍᴀʀɪᴇ✨️

ᴛᴇꜱꜱᴀ ᴍᴀʀɪᴇ✨️

7 likes

An overhead view of several people's feet on a ground covered with brown pine needles, with the text 'Dying my hair and these are the inspo' overlaid.
A person with a layered haircut featuring chunky highlights in blonde, red, and dark brown, serving as inspiration for hair color.
A person with dark hair styled with vibrant blue highlights, showcasing an inspiration for blue highlights on brown hair.
Dying my hair and these are the inspo
Hair color inspo #coloredhair #hairinspo #lemon8bookclub
🖤⚢⚞ARI⚟ ⚢🖤

🖤⚢⚞ARI⚟ ⚢🖤

6 likes

Two dark-covered fantasy romance books, 'The Stars Are Dying' and 'When Falls Night The World Will Drown In Starlight' by Chloe C. Peñaranda, are displayed on a white fluffy blanket. The covers feature gold lettering, stars, and character illustrations.
The Stars Are Dying x Chloe C. Peñaranda ✨
Isn’t she gorgeous? A villain gets the girl, star crossed romantasy 🖤 #fyp #booktok #fantasy #romantasyrecs #bookish
bookish.lei

bookish.lei

6 likes

Falling was not part of the plan... nor was dying
Listen, I didn't think I'd miss that jump, NOR would I die either. #vtuber #vtubers #vtubermodel #horizonzerodawn
Sammichplays

Sammichplays

1 like

I Thought I Was Dying but I Was Just DETOXING
Last night, I tried putting castor oil in my belly button (because TikTok said so, duh). I felt totally fine before bed… but then I woke up feeling like I got hit by a truck. Nausea, body aches, chills, and the worst stomach cramps ever. At first, I thought I was sick. But then I realized—this w
Abby

Abby

34 likes

Dying over these in store finds!!!!👀🤭✨
Found these in store and predicting they will sell out!!🚨‼️ https://liketk.it/68mbH
Jenna Wood

Jenna Wood

19 likes

Tattoo Inspo ✍🏼 | Pieces I’m dying to get!!
The perfectionist and graphic designer side of me keeps waiting for the right time to get a tat but the cowboy boots are calling my name omg 🤠 which tats are your fave??? #hellolemon8 #lemon8creator #tattoo #tattooideas #pinterestgirlaesthetic #pinterestgirl #pinterestaesthetic #my
Miryam Bevelle

Miryam Bevelle

2875 likes

Two hands hold Victoria's Secret shopping bags in a mall, with the store in the background. Overlay text asks 'IS THIS APPITE DEAD!???' addressing the Lemon8 app's vitality, suggesting a discussion about the app's activity.
“Lemon8 Is DYING”
I’ve seen multiple posts about how this app is dead. It truly isn’t! I use this app daily, sometimes looking for inspiration, sometimes looking for notes to help with class, and other times i’m looking for things that can improve my life! Skincare SELLS! Think about things in your life that you can
кαуℓα <3

кαуℓα <3

571 likes

A dark room with a television displaying 'The Purge' movie, a bowl of popcorn, and a blanket, suggesting a cozy movie-watching setup. The text overlay reads 'The best horror movies on Hulu'.
A collage of six horror movie posters: Bone Tomahawk, Mandy, Watcher, The Autopsy of Jane Doe, Bad Hair, and The Boogeyman.
A collage of six horror movie posters: Alien, Prey, Clock, Good Boy, Infinity Pool, and Monsters.
The best horror movies on Hulu 🎥
– Bone Tomahawk (2015) Genre: Western, Horror, Drama Stars: Kurt Russell, Patrick Wilson, Richard Jenkins Directed by S. Craig Zahler Kurt Russell stars in S. Craig Zahler’s Western horror film Bone Tomahawk, opposite an ensemble that also includes Patrick Wilson and Oscar-nominee Richard Jen
Rachelle Smith

Rachelle Smith

202 likes

Favorite Hair Care Products After Dying My Hair
I’m so excited to share my favorite hair care products that have made a huge difference in my hair health and appearance! 💇‍♀️✨ Here are my top picks: ~One of my absolute favorite hair care products is Mielle Rosemary Mint Hair Growth Oil. It has worked wonders for my hair, making it feel strong
BriannaGarfield

BriannaGarfield

164 likes

The Stars Are Dying - Chloe C Peñaranda
I really wanted to love this one but I struggled with the writing. I feel like I was confused mostly. I’d have to read some parts multiple times. But the story itself is actually pretty good. And i still found myself interested in where the story was going. I’m going to continue this series for su
Liss.readsbooks📚🐉

Liss.readsbooks📚🐉

3 likes

A collage of four images showing individuals with different colored locs, including blonde, orange, and dark shades. The central text overlay reads "DOS & DONTS OF DYING LOCS," indicating a guide for coloring locs.
A collage of four images featuring people with various colored locs. A large "DO" is overlaid, followed by a list of three tips for dyeing locs: use gentle dye, section neatly, and moisturize before and after.
A collage of four images displaying individuals with different colored locs. A prominent "DON'T" is overlaid, accompanied by a list of three warnings: avoid harsh chemicals, don't dye too frequently, and refrain from excessive heat styling.
Dying Locs 101 🌱
I don’t know about y’all, but I dyed my hair for the first time when I had my locs and it taught me so much so it was only right that I put y’all on! 💕🌱 #locjourney #dyedlocs #locs #menwithlocs #womenwithlocs
Jayla 🤎

Jayla 🤎

572 likes

A flat lay showing a book, a rosary, and a lit candle, with a pink overlay text that reads 'Spicy books I'm Dying to read' and a red chili emoji.
The book cover for 'Ambition' by K.V. Rose, with a text overlay 'Predicting: 5/5⭐️' and a caption explaining the user's interest in the dark romance novella.
The book cover for 'Stolen Heir' by Sophie Lark, with a text overlay 'Predicting: 4/5⭐️' and a caption explaining the user's enjoyment of the series' first book.
Spicy books I’m Dying to read🌶️✨
I absolutely love reading dark romance and I’ve been dying to read more lately. I’ve been reading a lot of romantasy but the type of spice and tropes are completely different so I miss it. These are just a couple of books I’m dying to read. Ambition by K.V. Rose Predicting: 5/5⭐️ I saw one of
Spookyrevioos

Spookyrevioos

2657 likes

Why Your Potted Plants Are Dying
Are you having issues being able to grow potted plants? The problem maybe Root Rot. Root Rot occurs in the soil when the water is sitting in the pot too long around the root of the plant causing it to rot. It’s caused by overwatering or must times poor drainage. The solution is to either buy
AmandasCozyCasa

AmandasCozyCasa

34 likes

A pink princess philodendron plant in a green pot on a wooden surface, showing signs of distress with two large, discolored, orange-pink leaves drooping towards the front.
A pink princess philodendron plant removed from its pot, with its roots and soil exposed, resting on a white and green floral patterned mat, with text overlay 'Start by removing the plant from pot'.
Two large, discolored, orange-pink leaves from a pink princess philodendron plant lying on a white and green floral patterned mat with loose soil, with text overlay 'Remove all of the dead leaves'.
Saving a dying plant (root rot)
Guys!!! my pink princess philodendron started dying on me during spring time, which is weird because she was thriving during winter, which usually is when plants struggle the most. I knew that I have to do something about it quick before it started to drop more leaves and my first thought it wa
Yesenia

Yesenia

45 likes

A stack of five cozy mystery books with fall themes, topped by a white mug featuring the 'Luke's Stars Hollow Coffee Shop' logo, suggesting books for Gilmore Girls fans.
The book cover for 'The Pumpkin Spice Cafe' by Laurie Gilmore, depicting a charming cafe, accompanied by a plot summary about a fresh start in a small town.
The book cover for 'Pumpkin Spice & Everything Nice' by Katie Cicatelli-Kuc, showing a couple on a bench amidst autumn leaves, with a plot summary about a New England village coffee shop.
GILMORE GIRL FANS: These books are for you! 🫶🍁📚☕️
I am an ADVIDE Gilmore girls fan. I have watched since I was in middle school. An OG fan when it wasn’t on Netflix (I don’t even think Netflix was a thing?!) but the show came out with NEW episodes weekly in the WB. Yeah.. those were the days. Nowadays I of course own all the DVDs lol but I wil
Ashlie

Ashlie

872 likes

The stars are Dying
Book one of A Nytefall Novel My Current Read 📖 Name of the Book: The Stars Are Dying 📄 Plot:Astraca is a prisoner of her own mind and must escape the man holding her. A quest that leads her to the Libertem trials where she must win in order for her to be safe from harm by vampires. But even winn
Jodi N

Jodi N

5 likes

I'm speechless 😶.. ¹by¹ our childhood memories are dying more&more
#disneychannel #robertcarradine #lizziemcguire #rip #sosad
ᎷᎧᏒᏰᎥᎴ ᎷᏬᏕᏖᏗᏒᎴ™️

ᎷᎧᏒᏰᎥᎴ ᎷᏬᏕᏖᏗᏒᎴ™️

35 likes

LAST, CURRENT, AND NEXT READS
Last: Bride by Ali Hazelwood Goodreads rating: 4.1/5 ⭐️ My rating: 3.5/5 ⭐️ This was my first book by Ali Hazelwood and I was SO excited for it!! I’m convinced if I had sat down and read this in one go, I would have given it a higher rating, but I just didn’t have the time for that. I didn’t fi
Allie!

Allie!

31 likes

Dying My Hair
I've been dying my hair at home for over a year now with this exact dye & I am obsessedddd. The brand is Daeng Gi Meo Ri and I use the black dye. It's a beautiful, natural black and is free of a lot of harmful ingredients. The box comes with everything you need to dye your hair
Alyssa

Alyssa

26 likes

i’m not afraid of dying…
this is your sign to do everything you would ever want to do while you can !! more information on the locations below ⬇️⬇️ 📍 Location 1: Angels Landing 🗺️ Description: 5.4 mile trail | permit required | in Zion National Park 💸 Price Range: $6 for permit ⭐️ Rating: 10/10 AMAZING HIKE
kalinawolf

kalinawolf

2089 likes

Peace Lily Isn’t Dying (It’s Dramatic)
I propagated the pups from my Peace Lily and a few leaves started turning yellow. Before you panic this is normal. After dividing or repotting, peace lilies often drop older leaves while they focus on root growth. It’s called transplant shock, and it doesn’t mean your plant is dying. The key:
AddictPlantMami

AddictPlantMami

27 likes

I’ve been dying to read this!!
My next read. I've heard good things about it so i'm excited #currentread📚 #books #lemon8bookclub #Lemon8Diary #bookrecommendations
Kennie🖤

Kennie🖤

434 likes

See more