What I took to Plato’s Closet VS what I got!!

2024/9/16 Edited to

... Read moreAfter my last visit to Plato's Closet, where I parted with 33 items for $88, I often get asked: 'Is it really worth it?' My experience, like many, was a mix of 'yay, cash!' and 'hmm, that's it?' So, let's dive deeper into how selling at Plato's Closet actually works, and some tips I've picked up along the way. First off, many wonder, 'how does Plato's Closet work?' It's pretty straightforward. You bring in your gently used, current-style clothing, accessories, and shoes. They have buyers who go through your items, usually while you wait. They're looking for specific brands, conditions, and styles that are popular right now. They then make you an offer on the spot for the items they want. You can accept or decline. Simple, right? But the devil is in the details of what they actually accept. A common question I see is, 'does Plato's Closet take H&M?' or 'does Plato's Closet take Forever 21?' Based on my most recent haul, where items like my blue top and that red garment with the H&M tag were considered, the answer is generally yes, they do take popular fast-fashion brands! However, it's not a guarantee. The key is condition and style. They want items that are clean, free of stains or tears, and still trendy. If your H&M sweater looks brand new and is a current style, it has a much better chance. They also look for specific items like purses and accessories, so don't just bring clothes! Even those sparkly rose gold sandals might find a new home if they're in great shape. Now, onto the burning question: 'can you negotiate with Plato's Closet?' In my experience, and from what I've gathered from other sellers, negotiation isn't really an option. Their pricing system is pretty set. They have a 'plato's closet price chart' internally, or at least a standard way they 'how does Plato's Closet price clothes' based on brand, condition, and demand. They offer you a percentage of their anticipated resale price. It can feel low sometimes, especially when you think about what you paid for the item initially. This is where managing expectations comes in. You're selling to a business that needs to make a profit. To make the most out of your selling trip, here are some 'plato's closet selling tips' I always follow: Clean & Pristine: Wash and fold your clothes nicely. Items should be free of odors, stains, and pet hair. Presentation matters! Current & Trendy: They're looking for styles that are in demand right now, usually within the last 18 months. Check for Damage: Before you go, thoroughly inspect each item for rips, tears, missing buttons, or broken zippers. They won't take damaged goods. Variety Helps: Don't just bring one type of item. Mix it up with different brands, sizes, and categories (tops, bottoms, dresses, shoes, accessories). Manage Expectations: Remember, it's not about getting back what you paid. It's about decluttering and getting a little cash for items you no longer wear. Ultimately, 'is selling to Plato's Closet worth it?' For me, it generally is for decluttering and getting a little extra cash, even if it feels like '33 items for only $88 dollars is highway robbery' sometimes. It's a quick way to offload clothes you don't wear, especially if you're not interested in the effort of selling online. Just go in with realistic expectations!

30 comments

Ur mom's images
Ur mom

I suggest trying to sell in mecari!

Taylor.t.o.t 🦖's images
Taylor.t.o.t 🦖

I used to bring my stuff there but I do not anymore. 1. I feel like it depends on who is working and what they deem cute, bc even tho it goes through the machine, I have taken the same load multiple times and they will pick new things each time. 2. They give you $1.50 for a shirt they’re going to sell for $10-$12.

See more(1)

See more comments

Related posts

A clear plastic shopping bag, likely from Plato's Closet, filled with various items, including some pink clothing. The image has a text overlay that reads "Plato's Closet Haul".
A bright pink hoodie with the "GAP" logo embroidered on the front. The hoodie is laid flat on a striped rug.
Two small crossbody bags are displayed on a striped rug. One bag is black with a silver chain, and the other has a snakeskin pattern with a gold chain.
I spent less than $100 at Plato’s Closet…
By far one of my best Plato’s Closet hauls 🤍 I spent under $100 for everything! Here are the details👇 ✨ Gap hoodie – $8 ✨ Zadig & Voltaire crossbody – $20 ✨ Dyfne sports bra – $8 ✨ Hello Kitty Loungefly – $12 ✨ Pink Palm Puff hoodie – $12 Follow along if you love affordable, realisti
Jade

Jade

1174 likes

What I got at Plato’s Closet
Keep reading for prices! This Urban Outfitters dress is my favorite thing I’ve thrifted! It’s backless and perfect for warm autumn days out ✨ This piece was $14 even with the original tags! Normally $89, this was about 85% off! Everybody needs a fall flannel and this is the perfect one for
Elise

Elise

39 likes

A hand holds a brown corduroy mini-skirt, revealing the inner waistband with "BURBERRY" text. Overlays read "Burberry Mini-Skirt" and "From Plato's Closet," with shocked emojis.
A brown corduroy tiered ruffle mini-skirt is displayed on a mannequin or rack, paired with a white top, in a store setting.
A hand holds a brown corduroy mini-skirt, showcasing the inner waistband with the "BURBERRY" brand name visible.
I found a BURBERRY SKIRT in PLATOS CLOSET😱😱😱
Guys this is a steal of a lifetime🥹🥹 This skirt was $14😱 So believe me when i tell you i was the happiest person to have found this steal! Everyone knows burberry is a high end clothing brand, very cutesy, very demureeee so this was just a blessinggg🥹🥹. ⭐️Overall rating: /5: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
ms.rackssss_

ms.rackssss_

2746 likes

Plato’s Closet Finds!
I highly recommend going to Plato’s closet (it’s a trendy goodwill!!) but you just have to look for your style because they have so much variety!
🎀🍪Brookie🍪🎀

🎀🍪Brookie🍪🎀

442 likes

A black and white image featuring a cracked stone sculpture of a face, with the quote "LOVE IS A SERIOUS MENTAL DISEASE." -PLATO- overlaid. The Lemon8 logo and username @darknightbeacon are visible at the bottom left.
Plato
#DarkNightBeacon #beaconofthedarknight #shininghopethroughtheshadows #plato
Ðαʀƙ

Ðαʀƙ

159 likes

A white Plato's Closet shopping bag with the store's logo and slogan, featuring text overlays that read "PLATO'S CLOSET HAUL" and "SWIPE," indicating a recent thrift store purchase.
A flat lay of accessories from a Plato's Closet haul, including a gold Tory Burch Bracelet, a clear and black NWT VS Bag, and a black Lululemon Keychain.
A green Free People Movement Dress with a small zipper detail, laid flat on a white surface, showcasing a recent Plato's Closet find.
Plato’s Closet Haul
Check out my AMAZING finds today! I’m an avid Plato’s Closet shopper, so if you are wanting to see more like & follow along! #shopping #haul #clothinghaul #clothes #shop #thrift #thrifting
Jade

Jade

947 likes

Plato’s closet haul
Total of it all coming down to $187 to $130 :) #platosclosethaul #ShoppingHaul #shoppingfinds
Andrea 🎀

Andrea 🎀

965 likes

The exterior of a Plato's Closet store with its prominent red and white sign. Overlaid text reads "MY FiRST TiME SELLING TO," indicating a first-time experience selling items at this location.
plato’s closet first timer! 🧦💰🛍️
i’ve always heard things about plato’s closet and the services that they provide, but i’ve never lived anywhere near one to experience it myself. then i realized that one opened literally down the road from me a few months ago! i couldn’t wait to go and see how lucrative this could be for me, since
ayersellie

ayersellie

475 likes

A cardboard box filled with various clothes, including a cow print top, a red floral dress, and patterned shoes, labeled 'what i took to Platos Closet'.
A cardboard box containing fewer items, including patterned shoes, a black puffer jacket, a black t-shirt, and a red floral dress, labeled 'vs what i Got Back'.
A Platos Closet receipt showing 14 out of 26 items were bought for $41, with reasons for acceptance and rejection, and text overlays listing items taken and not taken.
Platos Closet
#platoscloset #shopping
CHLOE

CHLOE

150 likes

Plato’s closet finds!!✨
Ed Hardy strapless dress 💵 Price: $11.00 Fashion Nova Blouse 💵 Price:$7.00 Ugg slippers 💵 Price: $20.00 #platos closet #platoscloset #fashionfinds #fashionnova #girlfashion
Mary Vincent

Mary Vincent

128 likes

A person's hand with rings and French manicured nails holds a patterned handbag with a gold chain strap, representing a thrifting haul from Plato's Closet and Goodwill.
A teal crewneck sweatshirt with the phrase "SOME PERSONAL SPACE?" printed on the front, laid flat on a light-colored surface.
A blue quarter-snap collared sweatshirt with ribbed cuffs and hem, laid flat on a light-colored surface.
PLATO’S CLOSET & GOODWILL THRIFT HAUL
Had a thrifting adventure and here are some of my clothing finds from Plato’s Closet and Goodwill!! For the discontinued items, I used similar products from the brand website’s to gauge the prices as they are no longer listed, so take that with a grain of salt. I am so excited to incorporate som
lexi schmeltz ✨

lexi schmeltz ✨

55 likes

A hand holds a fan of US dollar bills, including $100, $50, and $20 denominations, over a car steering wheel. The image features the title "TIPS FOR SELLING AT PLATO'S CLOSET," suggesting advice for earning money.
Two light blue plastic bins are filled with neatly folded clothing items, including jeans, shorts, and a black hat. An overlay text reads, "clean, folded, in nice bins!", emphasizing the importance of presentation for selling clothes.
Various clothing items, including leggings, jeans, shorts, and a striped shirt, are displayed on a tiled floor. Text advises to "Stick to mall brands" and notes that "most plato's have their own social medias! they will post what they need!".
TIPS TO MAKE THE MOST MONEY AT PLATO’S CLOSET
Plato’s Closet is a consignment style store that gives you cash for your gently used clothing!!! Over the years, I have learned quite a few tips to make the most money when selling to them! 1) Make sure everything is clean and nicely folded. I recommend nice bins over trash bags. It just look
savingswithsav

savingswithsav

1509 likes

Platos Closet Fall Haul 🍂🍁
Found the cutest fall clothes this past weekend at Plato’s! #downtowngirl #fallthrift #platoscloset #thrifting #Hauls
Ash Ishikawa

Ash Ishikawa

128 likes

Plato's Closet Haul !!
Plus a little heart pin I got too! first post on this app ! I will try to post more if I can 🤭 #platosclosethaul #Lemon8Diary #fashionfinds #closetoyou
☆Lily☆

☆Lily☆

7 likes

Plato’s closet partnership!! 🤭✨
With spring break just around the corner, you know I had to stop by my favorite shopping place 🤭 I always find the best statement pieces here ✨ Don’t skip your local Plato’s Closet….you never know what gems you might find 🤍 . . . #fashion #Haul #shopping #fashionfinds #Lemon8
Caytlyn | Beauty | Lifestyle

Caytlyn | Beauty | Lifestyle

32 likes

Come shopping at Plato's with me! 🥰🛍️✨
Scored some amazing finds at Plato's Closet today! Who knew style could be this affordable? 👗✨ What is your favorite place to shop?⬇️⬇️⬇️ #letschat #platosclosethaul #lemon8challenge #fallcollection #BackToSchool #ShoppingHaul #shopping #summerdiary #lemon8contest #fash
Tara🌸

Tara🌸

31 likes

What I got at the Plato’s Closet Athletic Event 💪🏽🏋️‍♀️
Soooo many gym shark items, ahhhh! #platoscloset #platosclosethaul #thriftfinds #thrifting #shoppinghaul
Mikaela

Mikaela

93 likes

Plato’s Closet🌼🌼
Spring is here🌷🌷 what better way to collect some change and spring clean? This is your sign to take your clothes to Plato’s Closet! This task took only a hour and I was able to make over $100✨ #closetdeclutter #unfiltered #embracevulnerability #Lemon8Diary #shareyourthoughts
Jala Bryanna🤎

Jala Bryanna🤎

11 likes

HAS ANYONE ELSE PLATOS DONE THIS
my local platos used to have an option to shop some of their stuff online and now its gone? has anyone else’s done this? #lemon8challenge #lemon8diary #lemon8summer #lemon8contest #platoscloset #letschat #diarychallenge
Kylee Keener

Kylee Keener

299 likes

My Plato favorito ❤️
Barbie❤️

Barbie❤️

70 likes

Plato’s closet, Overland Park, KS
this trip only set me back $59. i absolutely loved what this location had to offer!! #platoscloset #thriftfinds #Haul #clothing
brooke

brooke

67 likes

My issue with Plato’s Closet
Back in 2021, I got these super cute shoes and at the time they were about $100 or so. Unfortunately they didn’t fit me well, so I thought I’d take them to my local Plato’s closet and get them sold. When I got there, they said the highest they would give me $27 for the shoes. The shoes were brand n
ella 🪼

ella 🪼

87 likes

Second Hand Shopping 🛍️ at Plato’s Closet in Naples Florida
#secondhand #vibtagestyle #WhereToShop #shoppinginspo #platos closet
Shay

Shay

4 likes

THRIFTING AT PLATOS CLOSET
honestly plato’s closet is letting me down with their prices lately but these were my finds of the week! #platos closet #TryOn #closetshopping #fashionfinds #falloutfitideas #fallwardrobe #thriftfinds #thrifting
mimi🫶🏼

mimi🫶🏼

37 likes

A white plastic bag filled with thrifted items sits next to a blue Hoka shoe box on a black and white striped rug, showcasing a Plato's Closet haul.
A pair of white Hoka running shoes with black soles are displayed inside their open box on a black and white striped rug, priced at $30.
Two Free People leather bags, one black and one brown with a red scarf, are laid out on a black and white striped rug, priced at $12 and $10 respectively.
Insane Plato’s Closet Haul 👀
Found some really good pieces today… which one would you take home? 🛍️✨ 💌 Hokas — $30 💌 Brown Free People leather bag — $10 💌 Black Free People leather bag — $12 💌 Frankie’s Bikinis dress — $12 💌 Skims x Nike wrap top — $20 💌 Skims x Nike leggings — $18 💌 Alo shorts — $20 Follow along i
Jade

Jade

24 likes

Spring thrift finds at Plato’s Closet 🛍️
Thrift Finds at Plato’s Closet #thriftfinds #thriftingfinds #thriftshopping #thrifthaul
Dominica Amauri

Dominica Amauri

22 likes

Plato’s Closet #lemon8thrifthaul
I had the best time here and I actually went twice in 24 hours. This was the one in Atlanta GA and my first time at Plato’s closet. I will definitely be back! #thrifting #lemon8thrifthaul #blackcontentcreator #blackgirlcreator #blacklemon8creator #blackgirllifestyle #thrifthaul #
Leah Chenaè

Leah Chenaè

66 likes

A pair of green and yellow striped pants with a security tag hangs on a hanger against a black background. The image includes text indicating a "BUY or PASS" decision.
A person models striped pants in a fitting room, wearing a white crop top and white sneakers. Text overlay indicates a "PASS" decision for the pants, noting they are "Baggy in front".
A person models grey sweatpants with a white drawstring in a fitting room, wearing a white crop top and white sneakers. Text overlay indicates a "BUY" decision for the pants.
Plato’s haul
So sad about those first pants #platoscloset #platos closet #thriftfinds #thriftwithlemon8 #thrifthaul #Haul
Danielle

Danielle

234 likes

Took clothes to Plato’s….
#lemon8diarychallenge Realistically, I thought I was going to make $15 to $20 Soooo I’ll take the $27 I always have high hopes when I go because the first time I ever went to Plato’s I brought a ton of stuff and made $300🤯 #platoscloset #thrifting #trending #viral #clothingupcycl
Rayray

Rayray

2310 likes

Plato’s Closet
#storytime #lemon8contest
⭐️Sigma Lover⭐️

⭐️Sigma Lover⭐️

3 likes

A white Plato's Closet shopping bag and a teddy bear on a black chair, with text overlays indicating a 'Mini Shopping haul' from 'Plato's Closet'.
Folded thrifted clothes, including light-wash jeans and pink shorts, next to a teddy bear on a black chair.
A pair of light pink Under Armour shorts with orange trim, displayed with a price tag indicating size small and a price of $12.00.
Plato’s closet haul 🪩🍒
Thrifted Brand New Jeans from Pacsun Under Armor shorts size small 💵 Price: 12.00 Nike shorts size small 💵 Price: 12.00 Packs on Jeans size 28 BRAND NEW 💵 Price: 15.00 #thriftfinds #platoscloset
Chrissie

Chrissie

91 likes

A pair of black "No Boundaries" jeans hangs on a clear hanger, displaying two price tags. One yellow Walmart clearance tag shows $4.00, while a white Plato's Closet tag prices the same jeans at $10.00.
I found this at my local Plato’s closet.
I see this stuff at other stores also. They get clothes or decorations and with a clear as day previous price tag. But Plato’s closet never takes them off, on this picture above you can see the pants has a tag saying it’s from Walmart and it was on sale for $4.00s , but underneath Plato’s closet pu
Skyla

Skyla

64 likes

I <3 Plato’s Closet
This store and uptown cheapskate I loveee. I always find something!
<3

<3

43 likes

Plato's Part 1
✨️ Thrift store find! Come with me to checkout @platosclosethumble. This stkre is located at: 9747 Farm to Market 1960 Bypass Rd W, Humble, TX 77338. - #thriftfinds #platoscloset #thriftstore #thrifting #thriftstorefinds
Jennie_J

Jennie_J

63 likes

Plato’s Closet Is So Underrated ❤️❤️❤️
Look at the cute pieces that I found for CHEAP!! •Pretty Little Thing •H&M •Express #fyp #cutefinds #tiktok #platos closet #foryou
TatianaJ

TatianaJ

6 likes

A person takes a mirror selfie, wearing a black and white plaid fuzzy jacket over a black cutout top and black jeans, holding a black purse. The image has a text overlay that reads "FASHION finds plato's closet edition."
A black long-sleeved lace top with a wide neckline is laid flat on a light-colored surface.
A pair of light blue seamless high-waisted biker shorts with ribbed details on the waistband and sides is displayed, with a price tag showing $4.00.
Plato’s closet fashion finds ✨🌸🤍
plato’s closet haul 🌟🛍️ #Lemon8Diary #fashionfinds #healthylifestyle2024 #shopping #fashion #fashioninspo #haulfinds #lululemon #goingoutoutfit #shopwithme
Em💛

Em💛

20 likes

An exterior view of a Plato's Closet store with a brick facade and light-colored upper section. The store sign is visible, and decorative doodles surround the building. Text overlay reads 'PLATOS CLOSET Finds', indicating a shopping haul.
A pair of dark blue and light blue athletic shoes, identified as On Cloud Monsters, are stacked against a light blue background. The shoes feature a unique sole design. Text indicates a price of $45.99, with decorative flower graphics.
A pair of light grey athletic shorts, identified as Lululemon Hotty Hot shorts, are displayed against a purple background. The shorts have an elastic waistband. Text indicates a price of $15.99, surrounded by colorful flower graphics.
PLATOS CLOSET FINDS
My best pickup from Plato’s!! The shoes were brand new and this store had TONS of lululemon for so cheap! Will be going back! What is your best Plato’s find? #oncloud #lululemon #platoscloset #summerdiary #diarychallenge #lemon8challenge
Olivia Wilson

Olivia Wilson

36 likes

My thrifting hall from Plato’s closet
I recommend going to Plato’s they have good prices and cute clothes n shoes they have more stuff but I like looking at clothes n shoes.
addiii🤍

addiii🤍

9 likes

Part 3 Thrifting Series @ Plato’s!
Kate Spade $35 Nine West $14 Carhartt $15 Empyre $14 Aaliyah Tee $10 IG: prettyrickiashlyn TikTok: rickiashlyn To see the video⬆️ #platoscloset #platosclosethaul #thrift store #thriftwithlemon8 #thriftwithme #blackgirl🍋🎱 #blackinfluencer #blackgirlinfluencer #pintere
i♡ricki

i♡ricki

8 likes

A clear plastic bin filled with various clothes sits on asphalt with yellow lines, next to a person's foot in a boot. The overlay text reads "I HATE SELLING TO PLATOS CLOSET," reflecting the user's frustration with selling clothes.
I hate selling to Platos closet 😭
I came in with good brand-name clothing, no damages, and we're barely used. they looked through it and took 4 items. I got 10 dollars and a tub of new clothes that are in my car 😭 it may just be my store, but good luck!
shellabrão

shellabrão

832 likes

A person holds two reusable bags filled with thrifted items from Plato's Closet, standing on dark pavement with chalk drawings. The bags contain clothing and shoes, reflecting a successful secondhand shopping trip, with text overlay 'Plato's Closet Thrift Finds!'.
Plato’s Closet Thrift Finds
Found So Many Amazing Pieces Like: • FREE PEOPLE • Princesses Polly •Aritzia •Abercrombie & Fitch And so much more! You can find all these pieces over on my instagram 😆 #thriftaddict #thrift haul #thriftit #reseller #reseller #platos closet #secondhand #fashi
Sweetthriftyjay

Sweetthriftyjay

5 likes

We love being a part of your lives! No matter what you need, Plato’s Closet Algonquin has got your back!!!! #platosclosetalgonquin #summercoming #wedding #gym #gentlyused
Platos closet Algonquin

Platos closet Algonquin

15 likes

Plato de la abundancia 🫰🏻🙏🏻 siempre en tu hogar 🏠
#gettoknowme
Itzel 😌

Itzel 😌

217 likes

A meme image featuring three cats photoshopped to resemble owls, sitting on a log. Overlayed text reads 'DOODLE DUMP!! (SPLATOON FANS INTERACT!!)'
A black and white sketch of a character with headphones, a skull emblem on their headwear, and a bandaged arm. Up and down arrows are drawn next to the character.
A blue ink sketch of a female character with large eyes, long hair, a bow on her head, and a dress. The drawing is on white paper.
i lobe splatoob….
#splatoon #splatoon3 #art #doodle #artist
samster 🇰🇭🇱🇦

samster 🇰🇭🇱🇦

57 likes

See more