The Mayor of Maxwell Street

Ummmm I need to speak to Avery Cunningham because what was this ending?? Historical fiction is one of my top 5 genres so I was looking forward to finally reading this. I really was enjoying the story and was hoping for a happy ending for Nelly until that epilogue because it’s still unclear what happened exactly. 3.5/5 stars.

#books #blackauthors #readingjournal #historicalfiction

2024/12/13 Edited to

... Read moreFinishing a book and being left with more questions than answers can be such a wild ride, right? My recent experience with 'The Mayor of Maxwell Street' by Avery Cunningham definitely proved that! While I loved immersing myself in the historical setting and getting to know Nelly, that ending just… well, it stumped me. It got me thinking a lot about why authors choose ambiguous endings and how we, as readers, process them. Sometimes, a vague ending can spark incredible discussions, making you ponder the characters' fates long after you've turned the last page. It challenges you to consider different possibilities, almost like you're part of the storytelling process yourself. But then there are times it just feels incomplete, leaving you craving a bit more closure. It's a fine line to walk! For those of us who adore historical fiction, whether it's sweeping sagas or intimate character studies, an unexpected twist can be both exhilarating and frustrating. If you're someone who, like me, appreciates a story that makes you think, even if it leaves you pondering, you might actually enjoy books with a good, debatable ending! If you're constantly on the hunt for your next historical fiction gem, especially after finishing a captivating read like 'The Mayor of Maxwell Street,' or if you're like many searching for compelling stories akin to what 'the gilded blade' might offer, there are so many incredible books out there to explore. I find that seeking out historical fiction by Black authors often brings a fresh perspective and delves into rich, often overlooked, periods and experiences. Titles that come to mind for their intricate plots and strong characters might include 'The Vanishing Half' by Brit Bennett (though more contemporary, it touches on historical themes of identity) or 'Homegoing' by Yaa Gyasi, which is a powerful multi-generational historical saga. These books, much like 'The Mayor of Maxwell Street,' offer deep dives into historical narratives with complex emotional landscapes and often, surprising turns. And speaking of books, isn't it amazing how much a cover can influence you? I remember picking up 'The Mayor of Maxwell Street' partly because that cover, with the woman in a vibrant red headwrap and pearls, set against what looks like a cozy, blurred living room background, just drew me in. It promised a certain kind of historical narrative, full of character and perhaps a touch of mystery. A good cover can be the first hook, but the story inside is what truly matters. Always remember to check reviews and summaries too, especially when you're delving into a new sub-genre or author! To make the most of your reading journey, I highly recommend keeping a reading journal, as I do. It’s perfect for jotting down your thoughts on endings – whether they're satisfying or baffling – and for tracking authors and genres you love. It helps you articulate why a book resonated with you, or why it didn't, and guides your future reading choices. For anyone who found themselves captivated by the historical setting and strong female characters in 'The Mayor of Maxwell Street,' or is curious about similar immersive reads, diving into other historical fiction by diverse voices is a fantastic next step. You might discover your next five-star read, or at least one that sparks a lively debate about its conclusion!

11 comments

Related posts

If you read this.. read that
So if you read/ are reading The Secret Life of Maggie Grey I recommend the Hoodwinked series! It came out way before and is by the same author (different pen name) and it gives the same energy except it’s not based on a school but families and how they are connected by magic and other nonsense! It
Kaylee D

Kaylee D

582 likes

A bookstore interior with shelves and tables displaying books. Overlay text reads 'The book series I just finished,' indicating a review of a book series.
Book covers for 'CAPONE' and 'CAPPADONNA' series by JAHQUEL J. are displayed over a bookstore background. Overlay text reads 'The Delgato Brothers!!!' with fire emojis.
Book covers for the 'CAPRI in a perfect world' series by JAHQUEL J. are displayed over a bookstore background. Overlay text reads 'Baby doll Capri Delgato' with fire emojis.
The Delgato Siblings 🔥💗
I.. absolutely.. loved.. this.. series!! It had everything I want in book! If you’re into urban romance that follows a group of siblings/friends.. this is for you! There is a lot of 🔫ing, and drama but a whole lotta love ☺️ ⭐️ Rating: 5/5 #blackgirlsreadbooks #blackgirlsread📚 #delgat
Kaylee D

Kaylee D

54 likes

Number generator book challenge day 3
I completed the challenge today. My goal was 2 hours and I got just there. I read rock bottom girl by my favorite author Lucy score. I started this book a few months ago but needed to return it to the library so now I’m finally finishing it. I am loving the book so far. I continued listening to ugl
Diana Espinoza

Diana Espinoza

2 likes

A bookstore shelf filled with various books, featuring a large overlay text that reads "Summer Reads." Many book titles are visible, suggesting a summer reading list.
A person holds the book "SWIPED" by L. M. Chilton, featuring a colorful abstract face on the cover. Other books like "THE GUNCLE ABROAD" are visible on the floor.
A person holds the book "THE GUEST" by Emma Cline, which has a bright green cover with a blue hand illustration. The person wears denim shorts and sandals.
Summer TBR
This summer’s TBR stack is like really pretty. ☀️📚 #summertbr #summerreads #summerbookreads #summerbookhaul #summerreadinglist #summerbooks
Brooke Sager

Brooke Sager

11 likes

✨7 Books✨
Here are 7 more books I have received from The #bookofthemonth club❤️🥰 I absolutely love this subscription service and receiving new books to help grow my personal library #books 🫶🏼 #lemon8bookclub #Butleronbooks #bookwormsoflemon8
Butleronbooks📚

Butleronbooks📚

3 likes

An image showing three book covers from the Drew Collins series: "The Secret World of Maggie Grey," "The First Family," and "When a Wolf Loves the Moon." The text overlay reads "If you read these.." and "SWIPE." The books are displayed in a bookstore setting.
If you read these..
“The Mortal Affairs” by Granger is out now!!! If you have read the first 3 books in the Drew Collins University series definitely read book 4! It follows along with what is happening in the first books but Maggie and the girls aren’t in it! It’s a parallel and actually really cool because you get m
Kaylee D

Kaylee D

240 likes

A bookstore interior with shelves and display tables filled with books. Pink overlay text reads "What I'm currently reading," highlighting various book titles like "BLACK CAKE" and "Nine Perfect Strangers."
Current read
I’ve been in the #jahquelj universe pretty much all year so far! I usually just read one book at a time but she always leaves on a cliffhanger so trying to savor #quasim as long as possible. It’s so good and definitely more in my feels with him & Blair’s story #currentlyreading #blac
Kaylee D

Kaylee D

13 likes

A bookstore interior with shelves of books, featuring pink overlay text that reads 'Cozy Book series for Fall' and a white 'SWIPE' arrow, introducing a book recommendation.
Cozy book series for Fall
My favorite series for Fall! (even though summer doesn’t end until the 22nd 😆) Follows a family of witches looking for love! They each find their person but in mysterious ways. It’s such a cozy read! Like light a fall themed candle and drink green tea type of vibes ☺️ let me know if you’ve read
Kaylee D

Kaylee D

19 likes

have you read anything on my tbr list?
Wide genre range on my current physical TBR list! Have you read anything? Let me know in the comments🥰 I think I’m most excited to read “Everyone in my Family has Killed Someone,” “Interesting Facts About Space,” & “Gone Girl.” Which should I read first? #lemon8bookclub #booksoflemo
anniemurphy

anniemurphy

39 likes

Chitown Stand Up! Street Food Vibes!
Food Review Jims Original Maxwell Street Polish Food Recs in Chicago 🍽✈️ 📍Location: 1250 S Union Ave, Chicago, IL 60607 Context & thoughts: One of the best street food spots in the city that’s highly underrated. Skip the menu Go ask for a deep fried polish with everything (gri
My Life Be Like

My Life Be Like

3 likes

A person holds the book "The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue" by V.E. Schwab, resting on their lap in what appears to be a vehicle.
The cover of the novel "Long After We Are Gone" by Terah Shelton Harris, featuring an illustration of a house surrounded by trees.
A person with dark skin and a red sweater holds an open book, showing pages with text.
Girls Who Love To Read
Where are the girls that love to read?? I love meeting new people and talking about books. I would love to find people who love reading and talking about books as well📚🤍 #girlswholovebooks #girlsthatread #books are life🤍 #books are life🤍 #blackgirlcreator
TytasiaKiara

TytasiaKiara

4 likes

My childhood favorite
Blueberries for Sal started it all! #booktok #favoritebooks #childhoodbook #bookworm
bookworminmaine

bookworminmaine

0 likes

Historical Fiction Book Recs By Black Authors
Celebrating Black History Month with a dive into powerful historical fiction written by Black authors. These stories offer rich perspectives, untold narratives, and unforgettable characters that bring history to life in the most profound ways. Let's honor the past, celebrate the present, an
Ariella Eden

Ariella Eden

17 likes

Foogiano back in jail? What happened to foogiano? Is foogiano the next Pooh shiesty? #foogiano #poohshiesty
Mr.448😮‍💨🍃

Mr.448😮‍💨🍃

0 likes

BOOKS I READ IN JUNE ANDJULY
Forgot to make a post for my June reads so decided to combine both! I was so hooked on Love Island that honestly I wasn’t reading books 🤣 I was so invested but I brought it back around come July 😄 I will say the common denominator with the books I’ve read lately is that there is always some mess
Kaylee D

Kaylee D

52 likes

My Weekend Read
I have a slow weekend coming up, so why not pull out a new book! My Current Read 📖 Name of the Book: The Mayor of Maxwell Street 📄 Plot: Black Chicago in the 1920’s 📖 Genre: Black Noire #reading 📖 #lemon8bookclub #bookofthemonth #booktok #Lemon8Diary #lemon8creator #
Dr. Ari Elyce

Dr. Ari Elyce

5 likes

A book spread with the title 'books to help you celebrate Black History Month (all year long)' in white text, featuring 'Black History Month' in a decorative script font.
Six book covers recommended for 'lovers', including 'Take a Hint, Dani Brown', 'Honey & Spice', 'Seven Days in June', 'The Wedding Date', 'Before I Let Go', and 'This Could Be Us'.
Six book covers continuing the 'lovers' theme, featuring 'The Partner Plot', 'Whenever You're Ready', 'Outdrawn', 'Curvy Girl Summer', 'Pardon My Frenchie', and 'On Rotation'.
Book Recs for BHM (and Beyond)
Here are my recommendations to help get you started. Which was your favorite? 💛 #bhm #blackbooks #blackbookrecommendations
E.M. Wilson 📚

E.M. Wilson 📚

2 likes

90 street to 116 street FDR & Surrounding history🌸
90 street to 116 street FDR and Surrounding history: 🎬 The Vibe: What You See Today This 26-block stretch is a tale of two neighborhoods shifting seamlessly into one another. 116th to 96th Street (East Harlem / El Barrio): This section is vibrant, culturally rich, and highly active. You'll s
Mujahid Bakht

Mujahid Bakht

2 likes

If you read this.. read these
Married to a Brownsville Bully 📚 #bookreccomendation #blackgirlsread📚 #blackgirlsreadtoo #jahquelj
Kaylee D

Kaylee D

342 likes

A bookstore interior with bookshelves and tables displaying books. Pink text overlay reads 'Books I read in September SWIPE' with a white arrow, indicating a reading wrap-up.
A bookstore interior featuring four book covers from the 'Owensen Witches' series by Dreia Wells: 'Chosen,' 'Temptation,' 'Destiny,' and 'Salvation.' Pink text describes them as paranormal romance reads for fall.
A bookstore interior with the book cover 'Tell Me I'm Not Dreaming' by Monique Fisher prominently displayed. Pink text describes it as a cute read about four friends finding love after a tarot card reading.
Books I read inSeptember
Have you read any of these?? My busy season starts at work this month working long hours so going my reading less for the rest of the year! I’ll def be reading more short novellas #readingwrapup #septemberreads #blackgirllemon8 #blackgirlsreadtoo #blackgirlsread📚
Kaylee D

Kaylee D

13 likes

A bookstore interior with tables of books. Pink text overlays read "Books I read In May" and "Swipe" with an arrow, indicating a book review post.
A bookstore scene featuring the book "Children of Blood and Bone" by Tomi Adeyemi. Text indicates the reader took a break from usual reads for world-building.
A bookstore setting with three covers from the "Married to a Brownsville Bully" series by Jahquel J. Text recommends the series, stating it was preferred over "Staten Island Love Letter."
Books I read in May!
Dabbled in a few different genres in May! Fantasy YA , Urban, Contemporary Romance, Mafia 😄 Have you read any of these?! #booksireadinmay #blackgirlsread📚 #blackgirlslemon8 #blackgirlsreadtoo
Kaylee D

Kaylee D

28 likes

Away from my usual thrillers! 📖 ✨
I love getting my monthly boxes from Aardvark Book Club and Book of the Month! Here are my two picks! Are either of these on your TBR? #lemon8bookclub #lemon8bookchallenge #tbr #botm #aardvarkbookclub
Madi📖💭✨

Madi📖💭✨

19 likes

A hand holds a package of Maxwell Street Station Famous Smoked Fresh Polish Sausage, showing the net weight of 53.33 oz (3.33 lbs). Other packages of the same sausage are visible on a shelf in the background, along with Kiolbassa Beef Hickory Smoked Sausage and a price tag of $14.79.
Maxwell Smoked polish..do you think they taste the same
#costcofinds #costco #lemon8food
Quita

Quita

9 likes

March book wrap up
I am running through #jahquelj books like lara Croft 🤣🤣 I am enjoying her books very much! I’ll be reading Staten Island love story next! What are some book your read in March? Quasim I and II Staten Island Love Letter by Jahquel J #blackgirlsread📚 #blackgirllemon8 #indieauthor #b
Kaylee D

Kaylee D

17 likes

Here is an amazing piece of Midwest history!
In 1856, 42-year-old John L. Thorne stepped off a steamboat onto First Street in Hastings, Minnesota Territory. Already successful as a dry goods merchant in New York, Thorne quickly became one of the most influential men in early Hastings. Within just a few years he was elected mayor, built a beau
Sully

Sully

7 likes

A man with a beard and sunglasses, wearing a blue patterned suit jacket with white stripes and an Adidas logo, smiling and holding up two fingers. He has a patterned headband.
A man with an afro, beard, and glasses, wearing a white striped shirt, black vest, and black tie, with his arms crossed. He has a bee-shaped brooch on his vest.
A man with braided hair, sunglasses, and a beard, wearing a red blazer over a white t-shirt and multiple gold chain necklaces, smiling.
HAPPY 53rd BIRTHDAY MAXWELL! 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Mizzotta

Mizzotta

243 likes

Happy 24th Birthday Bria M.Davenport - Juneteenth Federal Junebug
"Dear Diary... Today is the happiest day of my life to date! Today we celebrate the birth of my very first child, Georgia Southern University Alumni and US Army soldier Bria M. Davenport. #ItsHardBeingADavenport , but at least it's fair."-MAYOR, ASCAP(PNC) 2006-2026. 💌 Brand: Cutwater
MAYOR

MAYOR

2 likes

Book Haul!
Went to the @bookwarehouseoutlet for their March sale as a late birthday present to myself! I had a blast as always & even picked up a couple of books that aren’t in the normal genres I normally read! Can’t wait to go back! 😁 There’s a 3 day sale happening April 24-26! #bookwormsoflemo
thelifeofk

thelifeofk

7 likes

Portillo’s: Chicago Street Food at Its Finest 🌭✨
#ThingsToDo #lemon8challenge Dive into Chicago’s classic comfort food at Portillo’s: the legendary Chicago-style hot dog, topped with mustard, relish, onions, tomato, pickle spear, sport peppers & celery salt—served in a steamed poppy-seed bun, dragging your dog through the garden 🌭🌿 .
Dear Cravings

Dear Cravings

8 likes

History of the Uptown FDR Drive & Cinematic.🌸🍋🌸🍋🌸🍋
🏙️ The Uptown FDR Drive: A Visual Summary FDR Drive, Uptown Manhattan, NYC Driving, New York City POV, FDR East River Drive, @TheBakht, Manhattan Skyline, Driving in NYC, Upper East Side, Roosevelt Island views, NYC Landmarks, NYC Highway, 4K Drive NYC, Queensboro Bridge, RFK Bridge, Carl Schurz P
Mujahid Bakht

Mujahid Bakht

1 like

Maxwell ‘Fistful Of Tears’ was begging for sax
Maxwell ‘Fistful Of Tears’ was begging for sax #maxwell #fistfuloftears #sax #music
ChrisMitchellJazz

ChrisMitchellJazz

130 likes

NYC mayor Zohran Mamdani at the Queens Pride Parade.
Pro-Palestine, anti-genocide LGBTQ+ New Yorkers and allies participated in the Queens Pride Parade in Jackson Heights, Queens; Lenapehoking (New York City) on Sunday, June 7, 2026. They said, "Free, free Palestine," "No Pride in genocide," "Viva, viva Palestina," "Pro
Javier Soriano

Javier Soriano

0 likes

Plaza Mayor: Madrid’s Iconic Square ✨
📍 Plaza Mayor From royal ceremonies to everyday tapas, Plaza Mayor is the beating heart of Madrid. ✨ Wander through the square, grab a seat at one of the outdoor cafés, and don’t forget your photo at Calle de los Cuchilleros, the charming street right off the plaza. 👉 Travel tip: Arrive ear
yuriabroad

yuriabroad

21 likes

📖
Currently reading 📖 #currentread📚 #booksoflemon8 #bookrecommendations #bookaesthetic
Fitnessrissy

Fitnessrissy

0 likes

NYC mayor Zohran Mamdani at the Queens Pride Parade.
Pro-Palestine, anti-genocide LGBTQ+ New Yorkers and allies participated in the Queens Pride Parade in Jackson Heights, Queens; Lenapehoking (New York City) on Sunday, June 7, 2026. They said, "Free, free Palestine," "No Pride in genocide," "Viva, viva Palestina," "Pro
Javier Soriano

Javier Soriano

0 likes

Pro-Palestine New Yorkers at the Queens Pride Parade.
Pro-Palestine, anti-genocide LGBTQ+ New Yorkers and allies participated in the Queens Pride Parade in Jackson Heights, Queens; Lenapehoking (New York City) on Sunday, June 7, 2026. They said, "Free, free Palestine," "No Pride in genocide," "Viva, viva Palestina," "Pro
Javier Soriano

Javier Soriano

0 likes

Little video showcasing my art at @mainnmaxwell that I brought restock to this week! ✨ This shop is located right on Main Street in downtown Greenwood, SC and has a large variety of talented local artists work in here! 🧚🏼🪄🦄 #art #artist #artistsofinstagram #noai #localart
Aquabun

Aquabun

3 likes

When ICE Seized the Mayor, His City Showed Up
"Almost a Gestapo nation": When ICE seized the mayor, his city showed up By Bob Hennelly, May 13, 2025, from Salon.com Last Friday, federal immigration police seized Ras Baraka, the mayor of this city, off a public street outside Delaney Hall, a controversial private prison operated b
Fight Oligarchy

Fight Oligarchy

15 likes

A person's arm with a "MAYOR" tattoo holds another's socked foot, while other feet in socks are visible. Blue underwear and a Nautica tag are also present, suggesting a relaxed indoor setting.
A chat interface labeled "Lobby (55)" displays user comments, including personal remarks and financial claims, alongside user profiles and timestamps, indicating an active online discussion.
A continuation of the chat interface shows more user comments discussing financial claims related to shoes and personal relationships, with mentions of "Myspace nicholaskhobb" and various user profiles.
Lobbying MAYOR Carolyn Tunnell Court TV Fact Sheet
"MocoSpace, Myspace, wherever... In any space there's an opportunity to be discovered, taken, chanced. Nothing beats being alive like staying alive."-MARIONSTANLEY, ASCAP(NYPDnews/PhillyPolice/PauldingSheriff) '06-CURRENT. RED HAT RED JACKET PRODUCTIONZ. #CourtTV #FactSheet #Lo
THASALESMAN

THASALESMAN

0 likes

Book Ideas 💡 🍋
Check out some of these books and let me know what you think! 🤔 #book #books #booktok #booksoflemon8 #bookaesthetic #Lemon8Diary #whatsinmybag #embracevulnerability #storytime #helpmechoose
Desiree

Desiree

67 likes

Maxwell ‘This Woman’s Work’ was begging for sax
Maxwell ‘This Woman’s Work’ was begging for sax #maxwell #thiswomanswork #sax #music
ChrisMitchellJazz

ChrisMitchellJazz

327 likes

Two book covers by A.E. Valdez, 'Snow King Catches His Snowflake' and 'Winter's Eve Then, Now, & Always,' both from the Three Kings series, are displayed in a bookstore with the text 'If you read these..'.
The book cover for 'North King's Unexpected Inevitability' by A.E. Valdez, part of the Three Kings Series, is featured in a bookstore with the text 'Read this!' and 'Book 3 is now out!!'.
Four book covers by A.E. Valdez, including 'All I've Wanted All I've Needed,' 'Colliding with Fire,' 'The Beginning of Forever,' and 'A Worthy Love,' are shown with the text 'Other books in the same universe'.
North’s book is out
A.E Valdez released the 3rd book in the Three Kings series!! Currently reading and loving it so far! It you read her other books you’ll like this series too #aevaldez #blackgirlsread📚 #blackgirlsreadtoo
Kaylee D

Kaylee D

14 likes

Day #2 of pride month Harvey Milk
Harvey Bernard Milk (May 22, 1930 – November 27, 1978) was an American politician and the first openly gay man to be elected to public office in California, as a member of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors. Milk was born and raised in New York. He acknowledged his homosexuality in adolescen
Angel Vazquez

Angel Vazquez

0 likes

Maxwell ‘This Woman’s Work’ was begging for sax
Maxwell ‘This Woman’s Work’ was begging for sax #maxwell #thiswomanswork #sax #music
ChrisMitchellJazz

ChrisMitchellJazz

247 likes

Wi Maxwell get to walk?
#trump #maga #Republican #democrat #elonmusk
The Handsome Liberal

The Handsome Liberal

171 likes

Book friends wanted 🖤
#gettoknowme
Katie

Katie

2 likes

Maxwell Winslow the House of secrets
Very good movie I think the kids will get a good one out of this. It’s a good movie for family night.
Angelus- the movie man

Angelus- the movie man

2 likes

Janet Jackson and Maxwell together in London
#trending #relatable #explore #celebrity #fyp
The Real Yvette Rants

The Real Yvette Rants

498 likes

@Christopher Street and I sat down with @Congressman Maxwell Frost to discuss the Trans Bill of Rights! Thank you Congressman Frost for standing with the trans community! 🏳️‍⚧️ #TransBillOfRights #TransRightsAreHumanRights #ProtectTransYouth #LGBTQAdvocacy #ChristopherStreetProject
Rose Montoya

Rose Montoya

5 likes

Memorable Moments of Maxwell The Cat
#cat #catsoftiktok #cats #catlover #lovecat
Fuzzy Chaos

Fuzzy Chaos

44 likes

Mississippi Book Festival Shenanigans!
Have you ever attended the Mississippi Book festival? If not add it to your bucket list! This one was another year in the books. Check out all the authors I met and let me know who you would have been excited to see! #weekendvibes😘 #blackbooktok #wellreadblackgirl #fyp #bookrecomme
Melanatedreader

Melanatedreader

7 likes

Maxwell ‘Bad Habits’ was begging for sax #maxwell
Maxwell ‘Bad Habits’ was begging for sax #maxwell #badhabits #sax #music
ChrisMitchellJazz

ChrisMitchellJazz

243 likes

See more