Would you be happy with a handmade gift?

My husband and I spent this weekend with our couple friends and I was telling them how excited I was about the gifts I made. Then the comment came about how diy gifts are cheap because I’m not actually spending money on the gifts. I was definitely shocked by this, especially since she knows I’m a big crafty person. I’ve been thinking about it all day, I can understand that some people the price tag or the brand name is the most important part of a gift, but I don’t think like that. Now I’m worried that my family members are going to have the same thoughts when they open what I made.

Please let me know what your thoughts are, not only have I made gifts but I’ve also bought handmade items from others to gift because I feel like it’s more special when made by someone’s hands! Am I the only one who thinks this way?

#crochetcommunity #crochetproject #crafts @Lemon8 US #DIY #lemon8challenge

2025/12/17 Edited to

... Read moreHandmade gifts often spark a variety of reactions, especially when people emphasize price and brand names as measures of value. However, gifts crafted by hand, such as crocheted scarves, purses, star pillows, Christmas ornaments, and customized keychain wristlets, embody a depth of thought and personal investment that store-bought gifts rarely match. Making handmade gifts like those mentioned brings a sense of connection between giver and receiver, as each stitch or crafted detail represents time, effort, and love. While some may view DIY gifts as "cheap" because they don’t come with a big price tag, this overlooks an essential quality—the uniqueness and authenticity of something made by someone’s hands. Handmade gifts speak to creativity, patience, and the desire to provide something one-of-a-kind and meaningful. In holiday gifting or any special occasion, such presents often become cherished keepsakes with sentimental value that can last a lifetime. Unlike mass-produced items, handmade gifts tell a story and often remind recipients of the giver’s personality and skills. Moreover, handmade gifts can be sustainable and environmentally friendly compared to items produced in factories and packaged in excessive plastics. Choosing or making handcrafted items supports artisans and encourages a culture of appreciating craftsmanship over commercialism. So, when faced with criticism that DIY gifts are "cheap," it’s worth reflecting on what truly matters in gift-giving: the emotional significance, the thought behind the present, and the joy of sharing something personal. Handmade gifts are not just about cost; they celebrate individuality and create intimate connections between loved ones, making them very special indeed.

60 comments

dulcetcrochet's images
dulcetcrochet

I love handmade gifts!! 💕 So much time and care! Unfortunately, there are people who don’t appreciate them 😔 I guess we have to decide whether they would enjoy handmade gifts or not

See more(3)
Mars 🍂🦉's images
Mars 🍂🦉

First of all- not everyone can afford buying gifts- secondly- handmade gifts are the most thoughtful- with how much time and care is put into it? honestly the best way to go

See more(2)

See more comments

Related posts

Would you be okay with a handmade holiday gift?
#moneyhabits #lemon8challenge #lemon8christmas #lemon8contest #lemon8challenge Crocheting holiday gifts helps me avoid the financial pressure that comes with peak shopping season. Instead of buying multiple expensive gifts at once, I plan ahead and make items slowly over time. I can sprea
crochetbyautumn

crochetbyautumn

102 likes

Handmade lop ear bunny bean bag plush 🐰
So soft and squishy, you’ll never want to put it down! Perfect gift for all bunny lovers 🎀 Adults need plushies too ~ Who could resist this little cutie? #handmadeplush #handmadebunny #lopearbunny #beanbagbunny #plushie #plushies #bunnyplush #rabbitplush #cutetoys #kawaiiplush
holly

holly

48 likes

If love was a Gift 🎁❤️!!!
💌 Valentine’s Gift Ideas Made With Love Because the best gifts aren’t the most expensive… they’re the most thoughtful 💗 Here are my favorite ideas, in order 👇 1️⃣ A rose bouquet with a tiny surprise inside 🌹 Flowers, but make it personal. Adding a cute figure or note turns it into a forever
itsamy

itsamy

306 likes

A Handmade Gift Just for You~
No pottery skills required… just good vibes and maybe a little messiness! 😉 #PotteryDate #DIYWithLove #HandmadeMemories #CeramicArt #CoupleGoals
Tutu

Tutu

1915 likes

handmade gift ideas for your lover ✨💕💌
Cute handmade gift ideas!! (for lover) follow for more! 💕 #giftideasforyourbf #DIY #gift #giftsforhim #giftsforbf
Andrea Enriquez 🎀 ✨️

Andrea Enriquez 🎀 ✨️

169 likes

DIY gift ideas 🧸✨🌷
#DIY #GiftIdeas #pinterest #craftideas #Lemon8Diary some DIY gift ideas for anyone in your life 🥰 i love personal and handmade gifts so here is more inspiration! 🌷comment any you make i would love to hear how they turn out :)
xoxo

xoxo

422 likes

Gift 7 of handmade gifts is a custom journal!
Gift 7 of handmade gifts is a custom journal. You can draw whatever you think the person receiving it would like! And to add a special something, write a affirmation on each page! #dollartree #handmadegifts #homemade #GiftIdeas #gifts
rescueromance

rescueromance

86 likes

Have you ever handmade a gift you wanted to keep?!
I love making handmade crochet gifts for people during Christmas time, but I always find myself so sad once I give it away. Especially after I’ve spent sooo much time on a project, such as this gorgeous plaid blanket, I’m always a little sad to say goodbye 🧶🎁 Don’t get me wrong, I love gettin
micah neeld

micah neeld

11 likes

Handmade Bath Salt Set - Relaxing Spa Gift - Laven
Turn your bath into a calming self-care ritual 🤍 This handmade bath salt set is crafted with care using soothing ingredients and delicate floral blends. Each scent is designed to help you relax, unwind, and enjoy a peaceful moment just for yourself. ✨ Includes: • Lavender Relax - ca
sowilogifts.store

sowilogifts.store

1 like

10 Unique DIY gift ideas you can make yourself🪡 ✨🎨
There’s nothing I love more than giving a handmade gift… it always feels extra special! 🎁 With the holidays coming up, I’ve been loving all the creative DIY gift ideas and I wanted to share a few of my own! These are all DIY projects I’ve made over the past year that would make perfect gifts fo
Lauren Lieser

Lauren Lieser

717 likes

Handmade baby gift- DIY fabric name banner🪡
Made the sweetest little fabric name banner using the leftover scraps from a baby quilt🤎 It’s a super beginner-friendly sewing project and a cute way to use leftover fabric instead of tossing it! Supplies I used: • fabric scraps (front + back) • batting • pinking shears • ribbon • water-sol
Lauren Lieser

Lauren Lieser

228 likes

HANDMADE VALENTINES GIFT INSPIRATION 💖
These are some of my favorite gifts I’ve made previously! I found these inspo photos on Pinterest! I’d love to share with you lovelies! These are all pretty simple and so fun to make 🥹🫶🏼 ❤️💐❤️💐❤️💐❤️💐❤️💐❤️💐❤️💐❤️💐❤️ * Credits to all the owners 🥰🫶🏼 #valentinesdayfinds #giftsforhim #valen
🦇Ari🦇

🦇Ari🦇

99 likes

The Cutest Handmade Gift 🎀
Make this forever bouquet with me! ✨ Perfect for your bestie. #diygift #crochet #cute
BloomCraft Studio

BloomCraft Studio

2 likes

Crochet Gift Ideas That Are ACTUALLY Worth Making
If you’re anything like me, you’ve already started mentally assigning crochet projects to everyone you know. Because nothing says “I love you” like accidentally spending 12 hours making a scarf you *swore* would only take two. 😂 All of the ideas have been put into a Pinterest board I made with t
Dani

Dani

913 likes

Handmade Crochet Plush Dolls | Cute Gift Idea
These adorable handmade crochet dolls are the sweetest companions! Soft, fluffy, and full of love—perfect for gifting or decorating your space. Each one is carefully crafted with cozy yarn and tiny details. Ready to bring a smile to your day! 💛 #HandmadeCrochet #CrochetDoll #PlushToy #
Anna❤

Anna❤

10 likes

Handmade gifts for your boyfriend
#giftideasforyourbf #giftsforbf #gifts for him
K❤️YLA06

K❤️YLA06

3070 likes

Handmade Crochet Baby Rattle with Wooden Ring
Handmade Crochet Baby Rattle with Wooden Ring ❤️ This handmade crochet baby rattle makes a thoughtful and charming gift for welcoming a new baby. Designed with a soft, neutral look, it’s perfect for modern nurseries and baby showers. ✨ Product details: • Handmade crochet animal rattle •
emilybox.store

emilybox.store

2 likes

Easy handmade holiday gift idea!
With a slice of wood and just a few paint colors, create a thoughtful handmade gift for a friend or family member. 💜🎄✨ #holidaycrafts #handmadeholidays #handmadegiftsthischristmas #christmascrafts #holidaydiy
Ami ☕️ | ✨Artist✨

Ami ☕️ | ✨Artist✨

6 likes

Handmade gift
Handmade gift #dagger #handmade #gift #giftideas #collection
The shadow’s edge

The shadow’s edge

37 likes

Handmade gift
Handmade gift #dagger #handmade #gift #giftideas #collection
The shadow’s edge

The shadow’s edge

41 likes

Handmade Gifts for your Boyfriend! pt. 3
I’m back with even more “actually good” gifts for your boyfriend or significant other! These gifts, while small and handmade, are sure to bring a smile to your partners face! idea one: a collage of important mementos collecting, collaging, and framing important moments in your relationship can
Avery

Avery

2294 likes

Clever Handmade Cat Pouch for Everyday Carry
If you love small accessories that are both cute and actually useful, this handmade cat pouch is the kind of piece that instantly stands out. It is designed in a soft pink cat shape with a gentle, minimal face, a front butterfly pocket, and a wrap-style strap detail that makes the whole pouch feel
FolkMake

FolkMake

9 likes

🦖 Handmade Dino Tote with Statement Bow (Yes, It H
Okay but how cute is this one?! 😍🦕 This handmade tote features: • Fun dinosaur adventure print • Oversized matching bow 🎀 • Fully lined interior • Large inside pocket • Soft neutral gray lining for durability It’s playful but still practical — perfect for: ✔️ Busy mamas ✔️ Teachers ✔️
BigZlittleu Creations

BigZlittleu Creations

2 likes

Mother’s Day handmade gift
#mothersday #diyflower #flowergift #handmadeflower #giftideas #giftforsister #diyflowers #diyinspiration #diy
URUniqueNo.1

URUniqueNo.1

97 likes

🌟 Title: Handmade Crochet Lovey Dolls – One-of-a-K
🌟 Title: Handmade Crochet Lovey Dolls – One-of-a-Kind Plush Companions ✨ 🧶 Product Description: These adorable hand-crocheted lovey dolls are the perfect blend of charm and craftsmanship! Each one is lovingly stitched with soft, fluffy yellow yarn, featuring a sweet pink face, rosy cheeks, and
Anna❤

Anna❤

5 likes

🎄 Last-Minute Crochet Christmas GiftsHandmade
Last-minute crochet Christmas ideas you can still make today 🎄✨ Mini mushroom 🍄, Christmas gnome 🎅, and mini tree plushies 🌲 Perfect for gifts, craft fairs, or cozy holiday decor 🧶💝 ✨ FREE pattern available (see pinned post) Handmade with love 🤍 👇 Which one would you gift? #crochet #
My Crochet Stitches

My Crochet Stitches

11 likes

Handmade gift
Handmade gift #dagger #handmade #gift #giftideas #collection
The shadow’s edge

The shadow’s edge

10 likes

Handmade Crochet Character Plushies
✨ Handmade crochet plushies! Soft, unique, and crafted with love. Ready to ship! Perfect gifts. 💖 🔖 Hashtags #HandmadeCrochet #Amigurumi #CrochetPlush #HandmadeGift
Anna❤

Anna❤

7 likes

The perfect handmade gift is finally here! 🎁
With guaranteed Christmas delivery, this Handmade Crocheted Oversized Hoodie comes beautifully packaged and personalized with up to 3 colors and 3 length options. Wrap yourself in the ultimate blend of comfort and style with this oversized, chunky crochet hoodie—a wearable hug designed for those
Stitches By Franci 🧶

Stitches By Franci 🧶

55 likes

Would you like a handmade gift like this?
I didn’t buy a gift. I made one. ✨ A tiny world in a lamp. Would you like a handmade gift like this? #crochet #handmade #fyp #lamp #birthday
K&E'scrochetlife

K&E'scrochetlife

2 likes

Lucky Chinese New Year Phone Case 🧧✨ Handmade
Lucky vibes only 🧧✨ Chinese New Year phone case Red for luck. Gold for prosperity. ✨ This handmade Chinese New Year phone case is inspired by traditional lucky symbols—red pouches and Chinese knots—made to welcome good fortune, happiness, and fresh starts. Perfect for Lunar New Year outfits, d
CreamyCases

CreamyCases

1 like

The handmade jerryfish for you as a gift 🥰🥰
#hellolemon8 #handmade #woodworking #mechanical #craft #relax #toys #DIY #woodentoys #cute
lemon6

lemon6

1 like

DragonBall inspired gift box 🐉
I actually crafted this for a friend/coworker due to showing him a fallout one I made my fiance. He really loved Dragon Ball and I figured a little "thinking of you" or "thank you" gift would be great to gift him for all he does. And so I made this! Everything was pretty much ha
Starwatcher

Starwatcher

66 likes

Handmade gift
Handmade gift #dagger #handmade #gift #giftideas #collection
The shadow’s edge

The shadow’s edge

222 likes

I was given a handmade gift at a convention!
Anime convention story time!! 🌼 A couple years back, I cosplayed Shinobu from Demon Slayer: Kimetsu no Yaiba at an anime convention and I was handed this handmade wood painting by the artist herself! Apparently she had made quite a few paintings of her favorite KNY characters and was handing th
SpicyLatté

SpicyLatté

24 likes

ideas for handmade gifts and promise ring
#ValentinesDay #valentine #girftideas #gift ideas #giftideasgf #giftideasforher #darryring #promisering #girlssupportgirls #girlfriend #boyfriend #pandora #jewelry #gold
Vale38

Vale38

106 likes

Handmade gift>
Bible bags made with love!💗 #handmadegifts #HANDMADE #sewing #DIY #foryoupage
The Powell Twins

The Powell Twins

2 likes

💚Handmade > Store Bought‼️ 🎁
Let’s make this holiday feel a little more personal. More heart. More homemade. More of that slow, cozy joy we all crave this time of year. These are the kinds of gifts people remember because they feel like love. Not rushed. Not last minute. Just simple and thoughtful. As you look throu
Cam✨

Cam✨

901 likes

Handmade Gift I Made For My Friend - Crochet
Handmade gifts are always the best !! It shows just how much you care for them and it gives you a moment to make something w. your desired craft !! ✨💖 This was a baby blanket I made for a friend using my own pattern, w. a few personal modifications special for my friend’s child. If you’re wanting
micah neeld

micah neeld

112 likes

Handmade Thank You Cards
One of these is included in every order with a personalized, handwritten note on the back to go with the order!☺️ feel free to DM me for orders or place one on my website if you see something on my page that you enjoy, or one that would make a perfect gift for somebody you know! Any comments
Naomi's Knickknacks

Naomi's Knickknacks

1 like

Handmade Valentine’s gift , brooch ❤️
#handmadebrooch #valentinesgiftidea #valentinesjewelry #valentines2026 #giftideaforher
MagicHands Studео

MagicHands Studео

0 likes

easy DIY handmade gift idea for mom!🐚🌾
the easiest diy handmade gift and so cute for outside home decor! #mothersdaygift #mom #diy #handmadegifts #homemade
Ash Edwards

Ash Edwards

87 likes

Handmade Christmas Grape Soap🎄🍇🧼🫧🛁✨
#handmadechristmas #christmasgiftideas #soap #soapmaking #fyp
Rosalycandle

Rosalycandle

17 likes

Handmade gift
Handmade gift #dagger #handmade #gift #giftideas #collection
The shadow’s edge

The shadow’s edge

27 likes

handmade anniversary gift 💝
If your love language is handmade gifts, you need to make a scrapbook album for your next anniversary! I wrote him a letter every month to document our love story — and then put each note together with some of my favorite pictures to make a cute album! Here are some page inspo ideas for you
kaylen faye

kaylen faye

230 likes

HANDMADE GIFTS for xmas/holidays🎄
I always love making gifts for my friends and family around the holidays!! Here are a few gifts (some of which I've done myself): 1. diy pebble tic tac toe board & bag - easy to paint and customize to your giftee! 2. homemade vanilla extract - gets better over time and you can make it in
Hannah

Hannah

493 likes

Handmade Gift Ideas For Him
Kiss Card 💋 💰Price: $0 (If have all supplies) If you don’t own the supplies 💰Price: $10 or less Jar 🫙 💰Price: $0 (If you have all supplies) If you don’t own supplies 💰Price: $15 or less Matching Bracelets 👚 💰Price: $0 (If you have all supplies) If you don’t own supplies 💰P
Cheyanne

Cheyanne

623 likes

See more