My Ratings vs Goodreads Part 2 🎀

Mississippi
2024/11/23 Edited to

... Read moreWhile the original post dives into the fascinating world of personal book ratings versus the Goodreads average, it got me thinking about the bigger picture: how do platforms like Goodreads and Lemon8 truly stack up for us bookworms? For anyone searching for 'Goodreads vs Lemon8', it's not just about star ratings; it's about the entire reading journey and how we share it. Goodreads has been my reliable companion for years, primarily for tracking my reading progress, setting yearly challenges, and exploring comprehensive reviews. It’s an invaluable tool for seeing how a vast audience generally perceives a book – for example, checking the average rating for popular titles like 'The Seven Year Slip' or 'Firefly Lane' helps me decide if a book is worth diving into. The sheer database of books available on Goodreads is incredibly impressive, and I appreciate being able to connect with friends and see what they're currently reading. However, Lemon8 has brought a completely different and vibrant dimension to my reading life. Where Goodreads often feels like a structured database for books and reviews, Lemon8 is all about aesthetics, visual discovery, and quick, engaging insights. I’ve discovered so many new books just by scrolling through beautifully curated book stack photos or short, punchy reviews that instantly grab my attention. It’s less about crunching numbers and more about sparking joy and inspiration through visual storytelling. For books like 'You, with a View' or even the charming 'Marrying Off Morgan McBride' series, seeing them presented with gorgeous photography and heartfelt captions makes me want to pick them up instantly. I’ve realized that for me, it’s not really a choice between 'Goodreads vs Lemon8'; they actually complement each other wonderfully. I use Goodreads to meticulously log my reads, check out detailed reviews before committing to a new book, and participate in various reading challenges. Then, I switch over to Lemon8 to find visual inspiration, discover trending books through a more casual browse, and share my own aesthetic book content. This often includes reflecting on why my personal rating for a gripping novel like 'The Only One Left' might deviate from the Goodreads average, offering my unique perspective in a visually appealing way. If you're trying to decide which platform is best for your reading habits, consider what you prioritize. Do you love detailed tracking, a vast database, and in-depth reviews? Goodreads is likely your perfect match. Are you drawn to beautiful visuals, quick recommendations, and a more lifestyle-oriented approach to discussing your reads? Lemon8 might just be your new favorite. Many of us use both because they offer such distinct but equally valuable experiences. Lemon8 has truly introduced me to a more creative and community-focused way of documenting my reading journey, perfectly complementing the analytical side I appreciate on Goodreads.

Related posts

A stack of books and decorative pumpkins on a white radiator, with a mirror reflecting a window. The image is overlaid with text: 'RATING Goodreads' Horror RECOMMENDATIONS part 1'.
A hand holds the book 'All's Well' by Mona Awad, featuring a woman on the cover. Text describes the plot: a drama professor with chronic pain and mysterious benefactors.
A hand holds 'Our Wives Under the Sea' by Julia Armfield, showing ocean waves. Text describes the sapphic literary fiction about a married couple and a deep sea dive.
my ranking of Goodreads’ horror recommendations
Here is my very official unofficial ranking of Goodreads' "best of" horror recommendations. We all know Goodreads measures books according to an imperfect science but I was pleasantly surprised by their offerings this year, though I do think there needs to be more diversity in their lis
bookrvws

bookrvws

118 likes

An aesthetic image featuring a stack of books, a white pumpkin, and a mirror, with the overlay text "RATING Goodreads Horror RECOMMENDATIONS part 2" and a skeleton figure, introducing a book review series.
A hand holds the book "The Only Good Indians" by Stephen Graham Jones, featuring antlers on the cover. The text describes it as a story about Native men haunted by violating customs, ranked #4.
A hand holds the book "Vampires of El Norte" by Isabel Cañas, showing a woman and lightning on the cover. Text describes it as romance/historical fiction about Nena saving her ranch in 1840s Mexico, ranked #3.
goodreads horror ranking pt 2
Here is the much anticipated part 2 to my goodreads horror rankings! I was so pleasantly surprised to see my top ranking even among their recommendations since it is quite a long book. Let me know what you think of these ratings! I'm sure there are plenty of books of their list I would have lov
bookrvws

bookrvws

30 likes

My Ratings vs Goodreads 📖✨
I was pretty close to Goodreads with these 😅 What did you think of these books?? #booktok #bookstagram #bookrecs #bookrecommendations #goodreads
Hannah

Hannah

58 likes

A book titled 'Practice Makes Perfect' by Sarah Adams is displayed on a floral patterned sheet. Overlays read 'The book I'm currently reading' and '+ my GoodReads status updates'. A 'Swipe' arrow is at the bottom right.
A GoodReads status update shows the user is on page 59 of 335 of 'Practice Makes Perfect' by Sarah Adams, with 17% progress and the comment 'Annie is so relatable omg'.
A GoodReads status update shows the user is on page 106 of 335 of 'Practice Makes Perfect' by Sarah Adams, with 31% progress and the comment 'just kiss already fr'.
My GoodReads status update 🫶🏼
This book is so cute! If you can’t find my account then drop your user and i’ll find you! #books 🫶🏼 #goodreads #reading📖 #foryoupage
Kenzie|📚🎀

Kenzie|📚🎀

15 likes

My rating vs Goodreads 📖✨💕
#goodreads #BookTok #bookish #fyp #bookstagram #bookworm #bookrecs
Hannah

Hannah

11 likes

A Kindle e-reader with a clear case displays 'THIS IS MY Emotional Support KINDLE' with butterfly and floral designs. The text 'Goodreads 2024' is overlaid on the screen, which rests on a pink and white striped blanket.
A collage of romance novel covers, including 'The Fine Print,' 'Terms and Conditions,' 'Final Offer' by Lauren Asher, 'My Dark Romeo,' 'My Dark Desire,' 'King of Wrath,' and 'It's a Date (Again).' The image is labeled 'Romance.'
A collage of mystery/thriller novel covers, including 'Ask for Andrea,' 'Hidden Pictures,' 'One by One,' 'Home Is Where The Bodies Are,' 'Ward D,' 'The Teacher,' 'The Housemaid,' and 'The Housemaid's Secret.' The image is labeled 'Mystery/Thriller.'
Goodreads 2024
Current Reads for 2024, I love to flip flop from spicy romance and thrillers 🤭 #lemon8diarychallenge #2024books #2024reads #goodreads #booktok #spicyromance #thrillerbooks
Mia Mewborn

Mia Mewborn

31 likes

A collage of open books forms the background for the title "BOOKS I READ THIS MONTH february 2024," with decorative hearts saying "XOXO" and "CUTIE PIE."
The book cover for "Crying in H Mart" by Michelle Zauner, featuring a red background with white text and an illustration of noodles forming an 'H'.
The book cover for "What Moves the Dead" by T. Kingfisher, depicting a dark, eerie scene with a rabbit-like creature covered in mushrooms.
MY FEBRUARY 2024 READS (&their ratings)
These are the books I read this month (February 2024). My goal for this year is to read 24 books, so far I have read seven books out of my 24 book goal:) 🍜Crying in H Mart 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟/5 🍄What Moves the Dead 🌟🌟🌟🌟/5 ☠️We Have Always Lived in the Castle 🌟🌟🌟.5/5 #lemon8bookclub #2024readinggoals
kaytlin!

kaytlin!

12 likes

A smiling woman wearing glasses holds a copy of 'Wuthering Heights' by Emily Brontë. Text overlay invites viewers to connect on Goodreads, with the user's Lemon8 handle @helloimamanduhh.
A screenshot of Amanda Player's Goodreads profile, showing her profile picture, 297 books read, 55 friends, and a TikTok link. It also lists genres, reading challenges, and a total of 301 books.
A continuation of Amanda Player's Goodreads profile, displaying her TikTok link, genres (fantasy, fiction), 2025 reading challenge progress (97 books), and a total of 301 books. It also shows 'Currently Reading' and 'Want to Read' sections with book covers.
✨Goodreads✨
Let’s be friends on Goodreads! I always love to see what’s everyone is reading ❤️🎧📚 #reading📖 #books 📚 #goodreads #booktok #lemon8bookclub
Amanduhhh

Amanduhhh

5 likes

MY GOODREADS
let’s be GOODREADS friends so I can like all your updates & see what you’re reading 📖 Check out my profile on Goodreads! https://www.goodreads.com/user/show/126073519 #goodreads #friends #books #booktok #bookrecommendations
tanner nicole

tanner nicole

12 likes

A flat lay of numerous books scattered on a surface, featuring titles like "A Court of Wings and Ruin" and "Every Summer After." A torn paper in the center reads, "Let's be friends on Goodreads! <3" inviting connections over reading.
Let’s be friends on Goodreads! <3
Finally out of my book slump 🥳 Ready to dive back in & begin my Goodreads 2024 reading challenge! Looking for book friends to get book recs from & maybe share some book inspo with 🥰 I especially love romance (smut & vanilla) and fantasy. Some of my favorite reads thus far include Ar
Lea

Lea

48 likes

1 ⭐️ GoodReads reviews that give me life
What other books should I do? #read📚 #goodreads #reading📖 #bookrecommendations #BookReviews #foryoupage
Kenzie|📚🎀

Kenzie|📚🎀

50 likes

How to log into Goodreads
#goodreads #kindle #kindle paperwhite #kindletutorial
chrissypenrod13

chrissypenrod13

43 likes

A person in a blue dress takes a mirror selfie, with text overlay 'BOOKS I WANT TO READ IN 2024' and book, heart, and rainbow emojis. The bottom left corner shows 'Lemon8 @ohshannonkay'.
A screenshot displays five book covers from the 'A Court of Thorns and Roses' series by Sarah J. Maas, including 'A Court of Silver Flames' and 'A Court of Thorns and Roses'. Below are Goodreads ratings and a 'Want to Read' button.
A screenshot shows the book cover for 'Regretting You' by Colleen Hoover, featuring torn paper text on a red background. Below are Goodreads ratings, reviews, and a checked 'Want to Read' button.
GOODREADS INSPO✨📚
goodreads is my ALL time favorite app for bookmarking your favorite reads + ratings✨🩵 CURRENT READ: ↓ ↓ ↓ The Seven Husbands of Evenlyn Hugo✨ AITHOR: Taylor Jenkins Reid ─── ⋆⋅☆⋅⋆ ─── there are tons of great options and TONS of 5 star books waiting for you to read!
SHANNON

SHANNON

16 likes

Rebecca Yarros Goodreads Ratings
I have had the pleasure of bringing to you some gems amount the sea of reviews for Rebecca’s books. While most of us agree that they’re good books. I wanted to share these purely for entertainment purposes. They had me cackling 😂 True Goodreads Ratings: ⭐️ FOURTH WING 🩷 4.5 stars ⭐️
Ashlie

Ashlie

10 likes

Stalk my Goodreads, Send recs 🫶🏼
#goodreads #bookrecs #darkromancebooks #booktok #favoriteread
jay

jay

14 likes

lets be friends on goodreads!!
yall i love connecting through different apps and my love for reading and just growing more and more and would love to connect and see what others are reading as well!! link is also on my profile!! @ zyannimacdougall!! #lookingforbookfriends #reading📖 #readingfriends #reading📚 #bookishgir
zmac🍒🖤🐅

zmac🍒🖤🐅

23 likes

LETS BE FRIENDS ON GOODREADS
all my goodread friends, unite!! #lemon8diarychallenge #goodreads #books #lemon8bookclub #Lemon8Diary #booktok #healthylifestyle2024 #embracevulnerability #letsread #needbookfriends
tanner nicole

tanner nicole

9 likes

A pink overlay with the text "BOOKS I READ THIS MONTH January 2024" covers a photo of a room with stacks of books on a white table, flowers by a window, and a poster on the wall.
The book cover for "Nineteen Claws and a Black Bird" by Agustina Bazterrica features a pink bird and a hand with black fingernails on a black background.
The book cover for "Maid" by Stephanie Land shows yellow rubber gloves and a New York Times Book Review seal, with text about hard work and a mother's will to survive.
BOOKS I READ in JANUARY (with my ratings)
🐦‍⬛Nineteen Claws and A Black Bird (⭐️/) 🧽Maid (⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/) 📚Class (⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/) 🔍The Haunting of Hill House (⭐️⭐️⭐️/) #januaryreads #2024reads #goodreads #book
kaytlin!

kaytlin!

20 likes

A bookshelf filled with books, featuring a white tote bag with the text 'gorgeous gorgeous girls love BOOKS'. Overlaid text reads 'New Year New Goodreads Goal' and 'swipe!'.
A Goodreads screen showing a reading goal of '0 of 50 books read' with '364 days left'. It notes '0 of 15 achievements collected' and states 'last year i only read 34 books, this year im shooting for 50!'.
A screen displaying 'Challenge Details' with six bookmark-shaped icons for 'January Reader', 'February Reader', 'March Reader', 'April Reader', 'May Reader', and 'June Reader' challenges, labeled 'FUN CHALLENGES!'.
2025 Goodreads Challenges
What are your reading goals this year? #yearlyreadinggoals #lemon8bookclub #goodreads #readingchallenge #shareyourthoughts
el <3

el <3

3 likes

My goodreads says I’m reading 21 books
#currentlyreading #goodreads #bookish #lemon8bookclub #books
Jamie Bolton

Jamie Bolton

7 likes

An image titled 'the BOOKISH ALGORITHM PERSONALITY PICKS...' asks 'Did Goodreads get your personality reads right??' and features the Goodreads logo, books, and a tote bag.
An image titled 'Reader Type: Just the Classics Please' displays book covers including 'One Hundred Years of Solitude', 'Invisible Man', 'Song of Solomon', 'To the Lighthouse', 'To Have and Have Not', and 'Wuthering Heights'.
An image titled 'Reader Type: Book-to-Screen' displays book covers including 'Project Hail Mary', 'People We Meet on Vacation', 'Postmortem', 'The Love Hypothesis', 'Bridgerton', and 'Reminders of Him'.
Goodreads Picked Books Based on Personality 👀
Apparently Goodreads thinks it knows reading personalities?? Based on different reader personality types, Goodreads suggested books that supposedly match each one. So naturally… I had to look through the recommendations and see if they actually fit. Some of them feel spot on, and others have
TheBookishAlgorithm

TheBookishAlgorithm

12 likes

A person wearing cherry-patterned socks holds two romance books, 'You, Again' and 'Happy Place,' while three other books are stacked on their lap. The image is titled 'My Goodreads Romance TBR'.
A book cover for 'Out on a Limb' by Hannah Bonam-Young, featuring a couple on a beach, with keywords like 'Accidental pregnancy,' 'One night stand,' 'Slow burn,' 'Forced proximity,' and 'Disability Rep.'
A book cover for 'Beach Read' by Emily Henry, showing two people on beach towels, with keywords like 'Small town romance,' 'Forced proximity,' and 'Rivals to lovers.'
Goodreads Romance TBR!🫶
Here are some romance books I have on my Goodreads TBR! And a little bit of information about them. Let me know in the comments if you have read any of them and what you thought about it!!✨⬇️⬇️⬇️ If you wanna see what i thought about them follow me on Goodreads! @olivia withers #lemon8bookcl
Olivia Withers

Olivia Withers

43 likes

Books on my TBR List On GoodReads!📚✨🤩
Good Reads is one of my favorite apps at the moment! Here are some books that are at the top of my TBR list right now!😋🩷 🌼Mad Honey By Jodi Picoult & Jennifer Finney Boylan 🌼IceBreaker By Hannah Grace 🌼A Flicker In The Dark By Stacy Willingham 🌼Funny Story By Emily Henry 🌼Things We Nev
Lexie🍀

Lexie🍀

13 likes

Design with T🪄 | Goodreads App Redesign!
𝘿𝙚𝙨𝙞𝙜𝙣 𝙬𝙞𝙩𝙝 𝙏🪄 | Check out my insta @tothetcreations for more! goodreads has been one of my top favorite apps lately because i’m a #bookgworl 📚 and after talking with some friends & other users of this app I saw a few ways to make it even more user friendly! This is just 1 of many scre
Tylar Cimone

Tylar Cimone

9 likes

An open book displays the title "1 star GoodReads reviews that give me life (pt 2!)" on a cherry-patterned sheet. A smartphone playing music and black headphones rest on the book, indicating a reading and listening activity.
A GoodReads 1-star review for 'Powerless' by Lauren Roberts, where luqman states, 'i've read fanfictions written by 12 year olds on wattpad with better plot than this.'
A GoodReads 1-star review for 'The Hunger Games' by Suzanne Collins, where katie expresses a desire to burn the book and criticizes the characters as 'flatter than paper.'
1 star GoodReads reviews that give me life
PART 2 😝 These are so funny 😭😭 #reading📖 #BookReview #1starreviews #goodreads #goodreadsreview #booktok #books #bookishaesthetic #fypシ #reading📚
Kenzie|📚🎀

Kenzie|📚🎀

112 likes

GOODREADS HOLIDAY BOOK LIST
Goodreads has a brand new list of holiday themed books! Have you read any of these?? #bookrecommendation #christmas #lemon8bookclub #goodreads #romancebooks
amanda ✨ 📖 🐭 💅🏼

amanda ✨ 📖 🐭 💅🏼

22 likes

Add me on Goodreads!
Let’s be friends! I’m trying to use the app more to log my reading and keep track of how much I read! Check out my profile on Goodreads! https://www.goodreads.com/user/show/147254324 #lookingforbookfriends #readingasthetic #goodreads #readersoflemon8 #readingaesthetic
🫧sandra🫧

🫧sandra🫧

24 likes

A smartphone displays the Goodreads app icon with a long-press menu open, showing options like 'Update Progress' and 'Scan Books.' The image is titled 'Goodreads Hack.'
A smartphone screen shows the Goodreads page for 'Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix,' displaying current and other editions. Text explains how to set the edition you're currently reading.
A smartphone displays the Goodreads app on the profile page for 'Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix,' with instructions to go to the book's page after setting it to 'currently reading.'
goodreads hack you might not know! 📖
This is going to sound SO Virgo of me to say, but one of my biggest pet peeves with Goodreads was setting a book as "currently reading" and the cover image not matching the actual book I have (lol)! Not only that, but often times the page number would also be inaccurate and when updating th
LIV CHARETTE

LIV CHARETTE

74 likes

My November TBR & their Goodreads rating ⭐️
Qotd: are there any of these I MUST read asap? I just finished The Keeper of Magical Things and liked it! Cute, cozy & magical ✨ 4.25⭐️ #books #tbr #reader #canva #goodreads
Jules ✿

Jules ✿

37 likes

A smiling woman with long brown hair looks at the camera. An overlay reads "Add me on Goodreads!" with an arrow, and "Lemon8 @jennaydovay" is at the bottom, inviting users to connect on the platform.
Add me on Goodreads!
Link in bio 🤍 Let me know and I’ll add you back! #goodreads #readersoflemon8 #bookwormsoflemon8
Jenny 📚

Jenny 📚

3 likes

A person stands in a parking lot at night, smiling, with the text overlay "My 2025 Goodreads wrap" and emojis of books and pink hearts.
A light background displays text stating that in 2025, 70 books were read, totaling 21,463 pages and 36,487 minutes.
A light background displays a list of top reading genres for 2025, including Romance, African American, Urban, Contemporary, Fantasy, and Thriller, with corresponding book counts.
My 2025 Goodreads wrap📚💕
Another year another wrap up! My reading goal was 60 and I hit 70! Yay! Let me know if y’all want a full list of all the books I read! Here’s to 2026 #2025reading #2025wrapped #blackgirlsreadtoo #goodreads
Kaylee D

Kaylee D

17 likes

📖 is this app better than Goodreads?
i've been on the app for about a week or so & i absolutely love it! everyone is so welcoming & friendly! & the customization for your profile is chefs kiss! highly recommend if you'd like to chit chat about books, laugh at bookish memes, or just post about your book review
ciara janaé ꨄ︎

ciara janaé ꨄ︎

26 likes

Goodreads Bookmail📚
Have you ever gotten bookmail from a Goodreads giveaway? I rarely see many people post about getting bookmail this way, so I figured it was impossible, but this is the second time I've received bookmail from it! Not gonna lie, I had no idea what this book was..I just loved the cover. But it
Mel

Mel

20 likes

A stack of glittery, shimmering books in gold, pink, and blue. Overlay text reads "Add Me On GoodReads" with a pink heart emoji. The Lemon8 logo and username are in the bottom left corner.
Add Me On GoodReads
📚 Looking for more friends on GoodReads! I am open to reading any books but I do prefer romance novels. And I don’t mind spice 🔥🔥🔥 🩵 I like to buy books but I also love to visit the library and check out books. Being at the library is so peaceful for me. I also love to collect bookmarks
Ash V

Ash V

57 likes

A Goodreads 2025 Reading Challenge pop-up shows "Congrats! You've reached your goal." It indicates 25 of 20 books read, 177 days left, and 125% completion, with confetti falling. The background is blurred, showing similar challenge information.
Goodreads: Reading Challenge 🎊
I can’t believe it’s half of the year and I already finished my reading goals for this year! 🥳 How many books do you guys have left to read? #goodreads #readingaesthetic #readingrecommendations #readingwrapup #lemon8bookclub
Jenn☀️

Jenn☀️

4 likes

Goodreads Romantasy- put a finger down!
#putafingerdown #romantasy #goodreads #booktok
✨ Anna ✨

✨ Anna ✨

6 likes

A person stands in an archway made of books, with text overlay announcing a Goodreads 2024 Wrap Up. A small sign indicates 'NOTEBOOKS STATIONERY PENS'.
A collage of ten book covers is displayed, including 'Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone' and 'God of Fury'. Below, statistics show '107 Books Read' and '42,867 Pages Read'.
A collage of ten book covers, including 'The Ballad of Never After' and 'Just for the Summer'. Text states, '5-star reviews all around, and these are just a few of the books I loved this year.'
Goodreads 2024 Wrap Up 📖
It was a great reading year! I’ll have to share my five star reads with you guys soon 🤭 #booktok #bookish #goodreads #booksoflemon8 #bookrecs
Aura 🩵✨

Aura 🩵✨

22 likes

books i’ve read and their ratings 📚
these are some of the 45 books i read last year and what I rated them on goodreads! Check out my profile on Goodreads! https://www.goodreads.com/user/show/159173771 have you read any of these books? 🌸 #books #reading #booktok #readingrecommendation #favoriteread
Krista

Krista

3 likes

See more