Car insurance recommendations?

Hi all - coming up on a renewal for my boyfriend's car insurance and Geico is quoting us a 50% increase in my 6-month premium with no changes to our driving record (23, no tickets/accidents). I read through the thread from a month or so ago and lots of folks talked about switching between Geico and Progressive when whoever you currently have came up with one of these crazy increases. I did this successfully last year but now they are both quoting the same ~50% increase. I also checked State Farm, Allstate and Amica and all of these were worse. I don't want to decrease my level of coverage. Any recommendations of local companies or other alternatives that might do better? Thanks!

Edit: Just want to add a list of the companies that I now know for sure are the same or more than Geico/Progressive, based on current pricing.

#car

#lemon8car

#caressentials

#caraccessories

#AskLemon8

2024/2/29 Edited to

... Read moreAs auto insurance premiums continue to rise across various providers, many drivers are searching for alternatives that offer competitive rates without reducing coverage. The recent surge in costs from companies like Geico and Progressive, with reported increases around 50%, can be particularly frustrating for young drivers with clean records. In navigating this challenging landscape, consider exploring options beyond the well-known giants. Local insurance companies often provide tailored services and competitive rates that could better suit your needs. It's also essential to stay informed about the insurance landscape in your area. Recent data shows varying premium rates across Canadian cities, highlighting the disparities that can exist within local markets. For instance, the median rates in cities like Calgary and Edmonton range around $3,182 and $3,150 respectively, indicating that regional factors significantly affect insurance pricing. Investigating these nuances can lead to potentially lower rates based on your city. Additionally, ensure that you leverage comparison tools that allow you to view quotes from multiple insurers side-by-side. By maintaining comprehensive coverage options while actively seeking competitive pricing, you stand a better chance of securing a favorable premium. Remember to review discounts that you might qualify for—many insurance providers offer incentives for bundled policies or safe driving records, which can further decrease your costs without compromising your coverage level. In summary, an informed approach to switching insurances and a willingness to explore lesser-known local providers can yield the best outcomes in this time of rising premiums.

21 comments

Teresa Salinas's images
Teresa Salinas

State Farm is a fraud refusing to pay a claim considered totaled since may 2025 asking for absurd proof from 2017

Alex's images
Alex

Geico

See more comments

Related posts

A black car is parked outdoors with text overlaid asking "I need help Finding Cheap Car Insurance???. A pink air freshener hangs from the rearview mirror inside the car.
Cheap Car Insurance???
Idk Besties… paying nearly $300 for car insurance is kinda crazy… where can i find something cheaper? Ive tried progressive, Geico, and national general and they all are over budget. Any recommendations?
Raven McNeal

Raven McNeal

633 likes

This is a breakdown of Cash Value Life Insurance 💸
Here’s the truth about how cash value life insurance REALLY works (and what they don’t want you to know) Full Breakdown👆💡 #cashvaluelifeinsurance #wealth #financialfreedom #finance #infinitebanking
FullSendFinance

FullSendFinance

35 likes

A white Toyota Corolla sedan is parked in front of a bright yellow building. The car has a California license plate "8CVD008". Overlaid text asks, "How to reduce insurance cost?". This image illustrates a discussion about car insurance.
How can I lowered my monthly car insurance?
I just bought a Corolla SE today and I was quoted $530/month from Geico for full coverage in NYC. I have 2 speeding tickets on my record but still I feel like that is ridiculously high? From reading online on some forums it seems like most people are paying $100-$200 for the same car. They told
Kaia

Kaia

102 likes

the right health insurance for college students
Each student's situation is unique. Take the time to explore options and find the plan that aligns with your specific needs. 🌟 If you'd like more examples or additional information, feel free to ask! #Lemon8 #lemon8partner #personalfinance #financebabeash #finance #insurance
Financebabe

Financebabe

757 likes

How to get Cheaper Car Insurance!😉💰
#car #insurance #save #savemoney #budget
Frugal Buddy

Frugal Buddy

14 likes

Can life insurance help build wealth? 🏦
💡 Why do the wealthy use life insurance in their portfolio to grow wealth? Here’s your answer in under 60 seconds! 🏦 #wealth #financialfreedom #bank #hack #insurance
FullSendFinance

FullSendFinance

21 likes

Commercial Cleaning Insurance
#insured #cleaningmotivation #cleaningbusinessstartup # #cleaningbusinessowner #cleaning
Ultimate Cleaning Biz Academy

Ultimate Cleaning Biz Academy

8 likes

Tips Before You Take Your Insurance Exam
3 essentials I feel you should think about before you sit for ANY license exam. I have 3 of them and I did this for all 3 insurance exams #insurance #exams #insuranceagent
versatilechi

versatilechi

62 likes

3 benefits to cash value life insurance 📝
Looking for a financial safety net that grows with you? 🌱💸 Cash value life insurance offers: • Guaranteed Growth 📈: Your policy builds cash over time, giving you access to funds. 💰 • Tax Advantages 💵: Withdraw cash value tax-deferred, keeping more money in your pocket. 🎉 •
FullSendFinance

FullSendFinance

15 likes

Insurance companies during the LA fires 🥲🔥
#comedy #meme #memes #insurance #fire
Kyle Sorensen

Kyle Sorensen

617 likes

This image explains why people get life insurance, listing reasons like replacing income, paying debts, protecting children's future, covering final expenses, and leaving a legacy, then questions what happens to the money after death.
This image details what happens when someone passes away, including family grieving, immediate bills, frozen assets, and court involvement if no legal plan exists, emphasizing the complications that arise.
This image describes the consequences of not having a will or trust, such as probate court, lengthy and costly processes, court-decided distribution, and potential unchosen guardians for minor children.
How to protect your life insurance proceeds!
Life insurance isn’t enough if you have minor kids… Did you know that if your beneficiary is under 18, the life insurance company won’t pay them directly? Instead, the money could get tied up in court, and a judge, not you, decides who manages it. 👶🏽💸 That’s why having a will or trust is jus
Tasha S.

Tasha S.

12 likes

Auto insurance 101
Protect your assets by getting good coverage #car #dealership #negotiation #pegjoseph
PEG JOSEPH

PEG JOSEPH

11 likes

A baby in a monster-patterned onesie with medical tubes, highlighting the #1 tip for baby health insurance. The text overlay reads: "#1 TIP: HEALTH iNSURANCE FOR BABY."
A baby in a patterned onesie, with text advising to look into a separate plan for baby, suggesting CHIP. A search bar graphic shows "CHIP [STATE NAME]."
A baby in a brown onesie, with text describing CHIP benefits: medical, dental, vision, monthly fees based on income, and often cheaper than family plans.
Need Baby Health Insurance? Read This First! ⬇️
When I found out I was having twins, one of the first things I thought about was health insurance. Heath insurance for TWO babies seemed like it was going to be expensive! My health insurance bill would double to $600/mo to get the family plan on my jobs health insurance! Wow! So I researched
Modern Mom | Shannon

Modern Mom | Shannon

280 likes

How to prepare for your Insurance Exam!!
Nobody told me what the life insurance exam was REALLY like—so I’m telling you. If you want to pass on the first try, save this. #LifeInsuranceExam #InsuranceLicense #StudyTips #PassTheTest #LifeInsurance101 #BlackWomenInFinance #TikTokTeacher
USMBroker

USMBroker

30 likes

I love being a licensed insurance agent 🤍✨
✨ Work From Home Life ✨ Sharing a peek into my daily routine as a part-time insurance professional + full-time mama ❤️ A lot of you ask about my job — my company isn’t hiring right now (my position is internal only), but if you’re interested in the insurance industry, the best first step is gett
Mama Lisa 🦋

Mama Lisa 🦋

233 likes

How to get the BEST Life Insurance Premiums 🔐
Life insurance is the EASIEST and BEST way to ensure your family's financial success even after you're gone. It allows you to leave behind a legacy for your family TAX-FREE 🍵💜 Unfortunately, the older you get the more expensive life insurance becomes especially if you develop health issu
adviceforwomen

adviceforwomen

83 likes

How To Get Paid Thru The Insurance Companies
#charlestonwhite #hiphopnews #comedy
URBCLIPZ

URBCLIPZ

7 likes

Life insurance is the most side hustle join us.
It never be late to change your life #insurance #insuranceprotection #financialfreedom connect with us to day.
Therese Mukantu

Therese Mukantu

6 likes

I hope they have good insurance!
Stolen catalytic converters on a Toyota tundra #exhaustsystem #trucks
Krisbuchowicz

Krisbuchowicz

9 likes

Life insurance is the worlds safest industry 🚨🚨🚨
This is why the right kind of life insurance isn’t advertised. 💼 This is why life insurance is a guarantee for you and your family. 👨‍👩‍👧‍👦 This is why you should have it. ✅ #wealth #financialfreedom #bank #insurance #taxfree
FullSendFinance

FullSendFinance

5 likes

🦋5 Steps To Become A Life Insurance Agent
Becoming a life insurance agent/financial specialist changed my life as a young mom. The flexibility, the purpose, the income, and the chance to help families every day. I love helping other people get started the right way. I know how overwhelming it can feel when you don’t know where to start
Isabel

Isabel

16 likes

Work from home Life Insurance Agent
Perks of being a work from home life insurance agent is being able to work on the go! #lifeinsurance #lifeinsuranceagent #insuranceagent #insurance #workfromhome
lifeinsurancemarv

lifeinsurancemarv

25 likes

The best places to get life insurance 🫶✨
When you hear the term life insurance, you probably don’t think about something that you currently have. A lot of times you think of life insurance is only for the elderly, but really everyone should have life insurance. Life insurance protects the closest people around you financially if something
Kylie 💸🫶🏻

Kylie 💸🫶🏻

24 likes

A car interior shows ten-dollar bills fanned out on the dashboard, with an infotainment screen displaying music. Overlay text reads 'Car Insurance Payment' with a calendar highlighting the 6th day, suggesting a payment date. A decorative keychain hangs from the rearview mirror.
Car Insurance Payment
#carinsurance #paymentplans #hondaccord #bodytransformation #lemon8challenge
Kiera Currie

Kiera Currie

87 likes

The image features a stack of US dollar bills tied with a black ribbon, with the text "MONEY HOW TO USE LIFE INSURANCE WHILE YOU'RE ALIVE." It promotes financial education and life insurance tips.
This image defines "LIVING BENEFITS IN LIFE INSURANCE" as features allowing access to part of a death benefit while alive, providing financial help for serious illnesses or emergencies.
The image explains how living benefits work, detailing that they are part of certain life insurance policies, triggered by conditions like terminal, critical, or chronic illness, allowing early payout.
How to use Life Insurance while you’re Alive
#lifeinsurance #lifeinsurancetips #livingbenefits #financialeducation #financialtips
Davina Nicole

Davina Nicole

18 likes

How to become a REMOTE INSURANCE AGENT
I've been working from home for 2 years and thought I'd she the process of how I got my job! I was scrolling on Indeed one day and saw a company offering PAID training for their insurance license, so I applied. I thought it was a scam at first, but it turned out to be real! What you wan
Ziewitnotea☕️

Ziewitnotea☕️

37 likes

Life & Health Insurance Exam
Here goes study week!!! My exam date is April 2nd! Anyone else about to take their L&H exam? #insuranceexam #stateboardexam
Hollie 🐝📚

Hollie 🐝📚

25 likes

Indexed universal Life insurance is the recommend.
Subscribe to my YouTube channel for the full video.
LIFEINSURANCEHQ

LIFEINSURANCEHQ

4 likes

Let’s Talk About That Car Insurance Bill
Let’s be real — car insurance feels like a scam sometimes. But there are legit reasons it’s higher than you want… and most people don’t even realize they can negotiate or switch. According to Investopedia, factors like age, location, credit score, and even how much you drive can all push your r
Mari 🦋

Mari 🦋

21 likes

How to Become a Life Insurance Agent
I never imagined myself working in financial services, let alone life insurance. But becoming a mom changed my life. I wanted to break cycles within my family. And secure my daughter’s future. Building up a fully protected financial house for us all. I wanted to make an impact and show other fa
Isabel

Isabel

13 likes

Life insurance with a savings account attached ‼️
Bet you didn’t know: There’s a hidden savings account inside cash value life insurance! 💰💡
FullSendFinance

FullSendFinance

9 likes

Car insurance for full coverage is a SCAM 😭
I cannot believe this! I got into a car accident, I have a $1k deductible and they are telling me my cars worth $2k 😭 I bought it LESS than a year ago for $10k CASH!! And dealerships are selling my exact car with higher mileage for $11k… but Kelly blue book estimated $2k (which is what AAA is going
LifeW/Ana

LifeW/Ana

216 likes

Insurance Agent (PROS)
Are you considering getting your insurance license? Here is a few pros #insurance #insuranceagent #pros …
versatilechi

versatilechi

37 likes

Remote job verifying insurance!
#remotejobs #wfhjobs #jobs #work
Jobswithporsche

Jobswithporsche

23 likes

LIFE INSURANCE 101: Living Benefits
Most people think life insurance only matters when you’re gone. But what if it could protect you while you’re still living? With living benefits, you can access your policy during critical moments like a heart attack, cancer diagnosis, or stroke. It’s not just about leaving a legacy—it’s about
Ari

Ari

9 likes

Life Insurance at work, only covers you On The Job
DanTheFinanceMan

DanTheFinanceMan

11 likes

A person's hand holds a Pearson VUE exam result document from the Florida Department of Financial Services. The document shows a 'PASS' for the FLA Health Agent exam with a score of 75 (passing score 70) on 09/14/2024, along with a section analysis.
I PASSED my insurance exam on the 5TH try!
Lord knows that it has been a journey but all that hard work did pay off although this is my fifth time taking this two hour test it was very much worth it because now I have been available to many opportunities. I’m currently enrolled with an insurance company and am active in training at the mome
jaekira

jaekira

177 likes

💜 More Than Insurance… It’s Love in Action!
A few soft reminders about who I am and what I do 💜✨ I believe protection is more than paperwork… it’s love, preparation, peace of mind, and making sure the people we love are cared for. Whether I’m sharing coffee posts ☕, encouragement 🌊, educational chapters 📖, or little moments of humor 😂
Pull Up Agent LLC

Pull Up Agent LLC

7 likes

Choose The Right Insurance Policy
@Welcome Baddies When it comes to selecting the right insurance policies, it's essential to consider your specific needs and risks across health, life, auto, and home insurance. Factors like your age, health status, financial situation, and whether you have dependents all play a crucial rol
Welcome Baddies

Welcome Baddies

38 likes

ADULT LIFE : HEALTH INSURANCE BASICA
I got a new jobs and had to pick out a new insurance plan and it felt overwhelming so I had to do some research because these things aren’t taught in high school .. some basics #adultlife#stable #healthinsurance #lemon 8
Esmee

Esmee

1049 likes

A24 and an insurance adjuster
The car is unbelievable #a24 #deathofaunicorn #newmovies2024 #insurance
Autumn Ivy

Autumn Ivy

26 likes

Study with me for the life insurance exam!
Wish me luck!! If you have any tips pls let me know as well! #insurance #lifeinsurance #studywithme
Madison

Madison

15 likes

✨Insurance Girlie🤍
#wfh #sahmlife #momsoflemon8 #wfhm #fyp
Vanessa

Vanessa

186 likes

Licensed Insurance Agent (Health/Life)
#insurance #BOSS #business
DigitalMarketingWithKay💰💵💻

DigitalMarketingWithKay💰💵💻

11 likes

Answering Insurance Questions With One Word
#insuranceagent #carinsurance #homeinsurance #reddit
🌟Cara🌟

🌟Cara🌟

0 likes

See more