I Heard You Were Looking For Underrated Books...

I heard you were looking for underrated books with yearning. I think I might know one...

The life of Thalia Smith is the epitome of routine. Get up, go to work, check social media. The only thing that keeps her life from becoming mundane is the hour she allows herself to listen to her favorite true crime podcast.

She never expects how much her life would soon change when she attracts the attention of the host and the producer of the show.

"Who are you, new listener...I can't wait to find out."

Tropes:

Stalkers

Obsessed Men

Kn*fe Play

Psychopath

Bloody Love Triangle

Touch Her and D*e

#stalkertrope #darkromance #horrorbooks #horrorrecommendations #authorsoflemon8

Ohio
2025/5/12 Edited to

... Read moreIf you're looking for underrated books that ignite passion and yearning, you’re in for a treat! Many readers often overlook hidden gems that offer profound storytelling and complex characters. In this article, we highlight noteworthy titles that may not have received the mainstream attention they deserve but offer an engaging escape into different worlds. For instance, consider diving into narratives that feature unique tropes, like stalkers and psychological twists, which are prevalent in modern dark romance and thrillers. These themes not only create tension but also deepen the emotional connections between characters. Books that delve into the psyche of psychopaths or present twisted love triangles challenge readers to think critically about relationships and morality. Podcasts, too, have surged in popularity as they bridge the gap between storytelling and real crime intrigue, making them a fantastic companion to your reading list. Exploring the implications of obsession and passion through various media can enrich your understanding and appreciation of these themes. Remember that reading underrated books isn’t just about escaping reality; it’s about discovering voices and stories that resonate on a personal level. So grab your book list, open your mind, and get ready to unravel captivating tales that are waiting to be uncovered!

Related posts

A collection of dark-covered books with red accents, titled "Underrated Spicy Dark Romance Books," displayed on a white textured background with four red chili pepper emojis.
The book cover for "Green Light" by Jescie Hall, highlighting themes like forbidden, step-siblings, bully romance, roommates, enemies to lovers, and revenge/mystery plot.
The book cover for "Chokehold" by Leigh Rivers & Harleigh Beck, featuring themes of M/M, step-brothers, forced proximity, secret identity, masked men, and "touch him and die."
underrated spicy dark romance books
have you read any of these? these dark romances deserve so much more love! if you’re looking for something new, give these a try. definitely check the content warnings before reading these. #lemon8bookchallenge #lemon8bookclub #booktok #darkromance #bookrecommendations
romance books

romance books

3097 likes

A title card featuring the text "UNDERRATED MINDFUCK BOOKS" with emojis, and "Proceed with caution!" above. A book titled "A DAYBOOK of COMFORT and JOY" is on a table with a gold container and a cup.
The book "The Library at Mount Char" by Scott Hawkins is displayed on a desk with a laptop and monitor. Text describes it as "Mind-Bending," "Hilarious," "Thrilling," and "Profound," praising its imaginative and darkly humorous tale.
The book "House of Leaves" by Mark Z. Danielewski is shown on a bed next to a lamp. Text describes it as "Bewildering," "Unnerving," "Unforgettable," and "Haunting," highlighting its exploration of fear and storytelling.
Underrated mindf*ck books
Ever get that itch for a book that'll leave you staring at the ceiling at 3 AM, questioning everything you thought you knew? 🙋‍♀️ I've got a secret stash of mind-bending reads that'll do just that. We're talking stories that twist and turn, leaving you breathless and disoriented i
Meredith Jao

Meredith Jao

4943 likes

A collage of dark romance book covers with the text 'UNDERHYPED DARK ROMANCE BOOKS' in bold, white letters outlined in black. Red chili pepper emojis are at the bottom, suggesting spicy content.
The book cover for 'Taming Seraphine' by Gigi Styx, featuring a gun, roses, a skull, and handcuffs. Arrows point to tropes like age gap, possessive MMC, serial killer x hitman, he saves her, knife to the throat, and touch her and die.
The book cover for 'Black Sheep' by Brynne Weaver and Alexa Harlowe, with neon pink text on a dark, splattered background. Arrows indicate tropes such as professor x student, age gap, revenge plot, serial killer FMC, he falls first, and enemies to lovers.
underrated spicy dark romances you need to read
have you read any of these? these underrated dark romances deserve more love! if you’re looking for something new, give these a try. #lemon8bookchallenge #lemon8bookclub #booktok #darkromance #bookrecommendations
romance books

romance books

10.4K likes

A hand holds a smartphone displaying 'BEST TOOLS & APPS THAT SAVED MY SEMESTER' over a productivity app interface. The image includes the Lemon8 logo and username.
Screenshots of the xTiles app show a weekly planner and an academic semester schedule. Text describes xTiles as a desktop and app for organization with free templates and personalization, a Notion alternative.
Screenshots of the Gradescope website show its interface for delivering and grading assessments, including homework and code. Text describes Gradescope as a tool for automatic grading and instant feedback across various subjects.
Underrated apps and softwares for students 💻📚✏️✨
Hello again thriving scholars! Last night we reviewed the foundation and basis of what is needed to ensure you become the ultimate 'academic weapon' - in other words, becoming the top and best student/best version of ourselves starting this upcoming semester. From note taking to study me
Denisse 🧸💗🩰✨

Denisse 🧸💗🩰✨

3959 likes

A title card for a list of '50 Darkest and Spiciest Books,' with the bold text overlayed on open book pages featuring various excerpts.
A collage of book covers including 'God of Malice' by Rina Kent, 'The Ritual' by Shantel Tessier, 'Her Soul to Take' by Harley Laroux, 'Hooked' by Emily McIntire, and 'Forged in Blood' by Sadie Kincaid.
A collage of book covers including 'Sinners Anonymous' by Somme Sketcher, 'The Predator' by Runy, 'The Never King' by Nikki St. Crowe, 'Lights Out' by Navessa Allen, and 'Brutal Obsession' by S. Massery.
50 darkest and spiciest books
comment down below ur darkest and spiciest book recommendations, I recently started listening to the audiobook of lights out lol #lemon8bookchallenge #lemon8bookclub #spiciestbooks #lemon8challenge #bookwormsoflemon8
Readers.archive

Readers.archive

1392 likes

Underrated Horror Books by Black Authors
see the rest of the books mentioned in my latest Shorts video because videos longer than 1min won't upload here 🙃 . . . #blackhorror #horrorbooks #sinners #gothichorror #blackbooksbyblackauthors
ireadblackbooks

ireadblackbooks

2442 likes

A hand holds a drink over a background of autumn leaves. Text reads "BOOKS THEY DON'T WANT YOU TO READ" with emojis of a dizzy face, stacked books, and a no entry sign, indicating controversial or forbidden literature.
The book cover for "Nineteen Eighty-Four" by George Orwell is displayed on a white textured background, surrounded by descriptive words like "Terrifying," "Prophetic," and "Bleak," with a summary box below.
The book cover for "The Satanic Verses" by Salman Rushdie is shown on a white textured background, accompanied by words such as "Daring," "Dreamlike," and "Controversial," with a summary box beneath.
Books they don’t want you to read
Ever heard of "banned books"? They're the ones that sparked outrage, controversy, and even fear. Some were considered too dangerous, too radical, or too revealing. But here's the thing... they're also often the most thought-provoking, eye-opening, and downright fascinating reads
Meredith Jao

Meredith Jao

2925 likes

books that’ll have you in SHOCK😨
All of these books had me shook while reading them! if it’s not because of a plot twist it was because of the detail or setting in the story. 10/10 would recommend each of these to anyone looking for a good, shocking book! #bookwormsoflemon8 #lemon8bookclub #lemon8challenge #readersoflem
bri ⸆⸉

bri ⸆⸉

950 likes

A hand holds a book in front of a bookshelf, with the text overlay "ACTUALLY UNDERRATED STALKER ROMANCE BOOKS" highlighting the theme of the post. The book's spine is visible, but the cover is not clearly shown.
A hand holds the book "Heart So Hollow" by Emily Nealis, featuring a dark cover with floral and insect motifs, against a backdrop of other books on a shelf.
A hand holds the book "Mind to Bend: Stolen Obsessions Book One" by Aurelia Knight, displaying a dark cover with feathers and rope designs, in front of a bookshelf.
Underrated Stalker Romance Books
I see this caption often, but it’s usually very popular books. Forewarning: I get BORED of books and DNF them quite often. So if I’m saying it is a great stalker romance, expect there to be a thrilling plot and intense scenes, not slow and tedious with a ton of angst. Not my style. But if yo
KittyKingAuthor

KittyKingAuthor

809 likes

Underrated Books (imo)
I loved all of these so much. The plot, the story, the execution, the detail, the twists and turns and everything in between made these books 5 star reads for me! If you’ve read any of them, what were your thoughts? #books #reading #bookrecommendations #explore #lemon8bookclub
K Reads📚

K Reads📚

242 likes

A hand with pink nail polish holds a yellow book titled "EITHER / OR" by Elif Batuman. The image has an overlay text "UNDERRATED MINDF#CK BOOKS" and a Lemon8 watermark.
A book cover for "I'm Thinking of Ending Things" by Iain Reid is displayed, with text describing it as psychological chaos and slow-burn horror. It has a "MINDFUCK RATING: 4.5/5" and mentions a Netflix film.
The book cover for "The Last House on Needless Street" by Catriona Ward is shown, with text calling it a mind game and a masterpiece of deception. It features a "MINDFUCK RATING: 5/5" and a Stephen King quote.
Underrated mindf*ck books
Ever read a book with a twist ending that ripped the proverbial rug out from under you? If so, congratulations! You’ve found a mindf*ck book. A true mindfuck isn’t just about one shocking plot twist. It’s the kind of story that makes you question everything—the characters, the plot, even your ow
Meredith Jao

Meredith Jao

677 likes

Underrated series pt.4 <3
This is SUCH a good college sports romance series!! This is a semi-popular series on booktok/bookstagram, but it deserves so much more attention and love in my opinion. It’s kinda like the Off Campus series but football! Kandi Steiner is another author that writes really great, spicy, and swoon w
AnxiousGirlBookClub

AnxiousGirlBookClub

221 likes

Underrated books📚
#booktok #bookrecommendations #lemon8bookclub #fyp #underratedbooks
AnxiousGirlBookClub

AnxiousGirlBookClub

593 likes

Underrated books📚 pt.2
#fyp #lemon8bookclub #bookrecommendations #booktok #bookwormsoflemon8
AnxiousGirlBookClub

AnxiousGirlBookClub

318 likes

A fantasy castle built into cliffs with lush greenery, featuring the title '5 Underrated Fantasy Books' in green script. The Lemon8 logo and user handle are at the bottom.
The cover for 'The Queendom of Shadows & Steel' by R.Skye, showing a sword with fire and flowers, is presented alongside tropes like forbidden love, slow burn, and elven realm, against a backdrop of ancient ruins.
The cover for 'Of Kingdoms and Curses' by Amy Woodruff, featuring a purple amulet and crystals, is displayed with tropes including forgotten memories, contemporary setting, and star-crossed lovers, over ancient ruins.
✨5 Underrated Fantasy Books✨
I feel like we all have been recycled the same 5 fantasy book series SO here is 5 that I believe are criminally underrated. The Queendom of Shadows and Steel: She died once. Now she’s back, with forbidden magic and vengeance. Step into a world of elven courts, deadly betrayal, and slow-burn rom
Sage|INHC

Sage|INHC

313 likes

An image titled 'THRILLERS I want to read this fall' featuring a stack of three books: 'The Wife Upstairs', 'Please Tell Me', and 'The Silent Patient'. Autumn leaves and pumpkins decorate the scene, set against a blurred bookshelf background.
The book 'The Wife Upstairs' by Freida McFadden, with its cover showing a silhouette in a broken window. A synopsis of the thriller novel is displayed alongside the book on a textured rug.
The book 'Please Tell Me' by Mike Omer, featuring a blue dollhouse and a key on its cover. A detailed synopsis of the mystery novel is presented next to the book on a textured surface.
Mystery/Thriller Books I’m looking forward to 😱
I’ve heard good things about The Wife Upstairs and aThe Silent Patient was so popular last year. I can’t wait to read these! 🍁🎃🍂 #thrillerbooks #mysterybooks #fallbooks #bookrecommendations #bookwormsoflemon8
🌛𝔰𝔞𝔪🌜

🌛𝔰𝔞𝔪🌜

20 likes

ROMANCE BOOKS that you’ve probably never heard of
Now I don’t want to discredit the authors, but here are some books that I had never heard of. Which is cool, because it gives me the option of exploring new genres of writing through different authors. Comment below some of the books from this list that you have read, or want to read. #bookwormsof
Nehemiah

Nehemiah

194 likes

60 BOOKS YOU PROBABLY HAVEN’T HEARD OF
these are a bunch of the books that i am planning to read this year and some that i have already read! i love sorting my TBR by seasons, that way i can really be in the mindset of the book when i read it! it makes cozy autumn reads that much more atmospheric, and summer reads that much more fun
kendall 🪩

kendall 🪩

19 likes

Underrated series pt.5 :)
I love this series!! Hockey romance are one of my favorite type of books to read (there’s just something about hockey romance you know what I mean lol). If you loved the Off Campus Series, or the Playing for Keeps series, this is another series for you!! Kandi Steiner has become one of my favor
AnxiousGirlBookClub

AnxiousGirlBookClub

29 likes

Spilling Book Tea 🫖 - Underrated Edition
📚Calling all my dark academia lovers!!! If you want a gloomy, misty, tale that give you the best fall vibes... "One Dark Window" by Rachel Gillig is for you!  📚If you enjoy a good enemies to lovers trope... this is for you! 📚If you wish to be immersed into a mystical land with the fai
Dani

Dani

106 likes

A white textured paper overlay with the text "BOOKS THAT CAUGHT MY EYE @ B&N" and a butterfly graphic, set against a blurred background of bookshelves in a Barnes & Noble store. A "SWIPE" arrow points right.
A book titled "The Adventures of Amina Al-Sirafi" by Shannon Chakraborty, featuring a ship battling a kraken. A pink sticky note reads "SILLY PIRATE ADVENTURE?? SIGN ME UP!!" A "Buy 1, Get 1 50% Off" sticker is visible.
A book titled "The Book That Wouldn't Burn" by Mark Lawrence, with an intricate cover depicting a city of buildings. A note states, "the cover and description caught my eye...but the first chapter didn't hook me enough." A "Buy 1, Get 1 50% Off" sticker is present.
BOOKS THAT CAUGHT MY EYE @ B&N
I did a cursed thing and walked into a Barnes and noble with no intention to spend money…but I took photos of every book that interested me! Inanna caught my eye the most and I’ve been reading it since😭 underrated!! #lemon8challenge #books #lemon8bookclub #lemon8bookchallenge #booktok
lizz

lizz

952 likes

Romance Books I gave 5 Stars!!📚
I wanted to share my top, all time favorite new adult romance books. I’ve been reading romance books since around 2021 and out of the ones I’ve read so far, these are the ones that I’ve rated 5 stars and think about 24/7. Little warning that I do recommend looking up trigger warnings before readi
brielle🌷🎧📚

brielle🌷🎧📚

409 likes

Underrated Books
Obviously 🤷🏼‍♀️ #marriageofconveniencetrope #friendstolovers #roommatestolovers #secondchanceromance #workplaceromancetrope
Veronica Wynne 💙 Author

Veronica Wynne 💙 Author

157 likes

most UNDERRATED BOOKS on my shelf
I love these so much #booktok #underratedbooks #favoritebooks #romancebooks #booksilove
bookxmommy

bookxmommy

169 likes

An open book on a white bedspread displays an illustration of a man and a woman in a bedroom, with the text "books i will always defend" on the left page.
A hand holds the book "Wildfire" by Hannah Grace, featuring a cabin illustration. Annotations highlight "one night stand," "golden retriever mmc," and "healing," along with a quote from the book.
A hand holds the book "Shutout" by Avery Keelan, depicting a couple kissing. Annotations indicate "brothers best friend," "soft only for her," and "roommates," accompanied by a quote.
underrated romance books
like/save for later <3 🔥wildfire: everyone says this book is boring compared to icebreaker but i loved it so much, i thought it was such a sweet love story. i loved both the fmc and mmc & side characters. he’s so soft n sweet but has a dirty mouth ugh i love russ sm. idk what it was but
mads

mads

1292 likes

A person browsing books in a bookstore, with text overlay promoting "Underrated NON-FICTION that's stranger than most fiction." The image sets the scene for a discussion about captivating non-fiction reads.
The book "Being Mortal" by Atul Gawande, highlighted with themes like medical philosophy, aging gracefully, mortality meditations, and life's priorities, described as a tough but important read on end-of-life care.
The book "The Psychopath Test" by Jon Ronson, presented with keywords such as psychological thriller, moral ambiguity, diagnostic dilemmas, and dark fascination, exploring human nature and mental illness.
Underrated non-fiction stranger than fiction
Guys, I'm a total sucker for a good story, and these non-fiction books have absolutely blown me away. Seriously, they're stranger than anything I could dream up. We're talking serial killers lurking at world fairs, the secret lives of cadavers, and the mind-boggling world of neurologica
Meredith Jao

Meredith Jao

257 likes

Underrated books I can’t stop thinking about
All of these are 5 stars and not talked about enough. #books #bookwormsoflemon8
Ashley Kordas - Phillips

Ashley Kordas - Phillips

88 likes

✨Hyping Underrated Books Part 5✨
Quicksilver by Callie Hart Amazing book, amazing characters, and amazing plot. What else could there be? Patiently waiting for book two.00 #calliehart #quicksilver #bookrecs #BookTok #fantasybook
lexi_reads_00

lexi_reads_00

1061 likes

A white tote bag with blue handles and a fruit pattern, filled with several books, is displayed on a textured surface. Red text overlays read "UNDERRATED BOOKS I THINK DESERVE MORE ATTENTION Pt.3."
The book cover for "The Two of Us" by Taylor Torres, featuring purple hummingbirds and floral designs, is shown on a textured background. Text highlights themes like "Small town" and "Childhood lovers," along with a plot summary.
The book cover for "Camera Shy" by Kay Cove, with a dark background and pink roses, is displayed. Text highlights themes such as "Swoon worthy MMC," "Forced Proximity," and "Learning Body positivity," accompanied by a plot summary.
Underrated books Pt.3
#fyp #book #lemon8bookclub #underratedbooks #bookwormsoflemon8
AnxiousGirlBookClub

AnxiousGirlBookClub

30 likes

Underrated Gothic novels I never see online
Fellow bookworms, gather 'round the virtual campfire! 🔥 I'm about to spill the tea on some seriously underrated gothic novels that deserve WAY more love 🖤 You know how it is, you scroll through #BookTok and it's the same five books over and over again... (Don't even get me starte
Meredith Jao

Meredith Jao

3566 likes

Underrated Romance series pt.2🤎
I read the Sugar Lake series 2 years ago. And it’s a romance series that is definitely underrated!! I think now that Bloom Books is publishing it and giving it new covers it will probably start to hopefully gain more popularity :)) I haven’t read much of Emily Mcintire’s books. She’s the author
AnxiousGirlBookClub

AnxiousGirlBookClub

27 likes

Kindle Unlimited books that were worth it
Here are some Kindle Unlimited reads that have stuck with me. Save this for later and tell me what I should read next. 🩵☺️ #kindleunlimited #bookrecommendations #darkreads #psychologicalfiction #readinglist
Moonstruck Pages

Moonstruck Pages

194 likes

A smiling woman with curly hair sits on stairs, promoting books you've never heard of. Text reads: 'books you've never heard of that you need to read now!!' with an open book and candy icons.
A hand holds the book 'CANDELARIA A NOVEL' by Melissa Lozada-Oliva, rated five stars. Text describes it as 'unhinged' and 'a story of love that eats us alive,' with an unpredictable plot.
A hand holds the book 'Is Mother Dead A NOVEL' by Vigdis Hjorth, rated five stars. Described as a 'norwegian domestic thriller' and 'longlisted for international booker prize 2023,' with the quote 'to mother is to murder, or close enough.'
books you’ve never heard of🤭
I pride myself on giving a spotlight to GREAT books that just do not get the love and appreciation they deserve via social media. These were two books I finished recently that I think the literary fiction & unhinged women readers would absolutely eat up. Both were five star reads for me
aubrei

aubrei

55 likes

A hand holds three books, with text overlayed that reads 'UNDERRATED BOOKS I NEVER SEE ONLINE' and emojis. The image introduces a list of underrated books.
The book cover for 'Dopamine Nation' by Anna Lembke, MD, is displayed. Text describes it as a book about addiction, dopamine cravings, and breaking free from toxic habits.
The book cover for 'The Seeker of Nothing: A Fable on Owning Your Life' by Kabir Munjal is shown. Text describes it as a journey about finding fulfillment beyond material success.
Books that are criminally underrated
I'm actually shocked that no one talks about these books. Like, why is this not on every “must-read” list? These stories & ideas blew my mind, changed my perspective, and left me OBSESSED. But for some reason?? They don’t get nearly the hype they deserve. So here I am, doing the work and pu
Meredith Jao

Meredith Jao

75 likes

Underrated Fantasy Books
🐲I tried to pick an assortment of books that I haven’t seen much or if any content about since it seems like most fantasy recs consist of either fourth wing or ACOTAR🐲 #fantasybookrecommendation #fantasyrecommendations #books #booktok #reading #fantasybooks #fantasy #lemon8bookcl
JustaBookBaddie

JustaBookBaddie

87 likes

Underrated fantasy books
Incredible Fantasy Romance books that are incredible series! Truly criminally underrated! A soul to keep-(almost completed series) @OpalReyneAuthor Bound to the shadow Prince- @Ruby Dixon A Symphony of Sava
Mimisays411

Mimisays411

24 likes

A person holds a stack of five light-colored books, with text overlayed that reads 'my top 5 standalone novels of 2024'. The person is wearing patterned socks and light green pants, with a Lemon8 logo and username in the corner.
The book 'I Who Have Never Known Men' by Jacqueline Harpman is displayed on a textured gray surface. Text highlights it as #5, 164 pages, dystopian, literary fiction, and thought-provoking, with four red stars indicating its rating.
The book 'Young Mungo' by Douglas Stuart is shown on a gray textured background. It's labeled #4, 416 pages, heartbreaking, literary fiction, and LGBTQ+, with four and a half orange stars for its rating.
my absolute favorite A++ top 5 books of 2024
Since 2024 is coming to a close, i thought I’d share my top 5 standalone reads of the year! I read multiple series this year, but i didn’t think it would be fair to include books within a series in my top five. If that were the case there’d be several books two or three included (or eight…looki
molly

molly

454 likes

Books you didn’t know were on Kindle Unlimited ✨
#kindlebooks #kindleunlimited #kindlerecommendations
Life with Raye 🩵

Life with Raye 🩵

16 likes

Books I wanna read in 2026!
Books that I heard are really good, I love a series so I’m definitely going to read these in 2026. ~Flawless ~Heartless ~Powerless ~Reckless ~Hopeless Elsie Silver ~God of wrath ~God of malice ~God of run ~God of fury ~God of pain ~God of war Rina Kent ~Wild love ~Wild eye
The Hidden plot

The Hidden plot

451 likes

Apple Books Are Underrated 🥺📚🤦🏾‍♀️
Heyyyy! Now, I know people love KU and all but personally, I really like to use Apple Books (yes, I know they’re completely different apps). I have browsed on KU so I definitely understand why people prefer it. However, AB is criminally underrated. I will say that you could get books cheaper elsewh
Ajah Mykala

Ajah Mykala

114 likes

An underrated book series you should read
I read a lot of obscure books, but I always want people to know about them 😭🫶🏾 Go to tiktok to see the full video! #blackgirlswhoread #mmromance #romancebooks #bookrecommendations
desireealicea

desireealicea

264 likes

A hand holds a stack of short books on a colorful crocheted blanket. The image has text overlays that read "short books" and "for short attention spans," along with the user's handle and Lemon8 logo.
The book "I Who Have Never Known Men" by Jacqueline Harpman is displayed on a crocheted blanket. Overlays indicate it's 164 pages, literary fiction, dystopian, and translated from French, with a Goodreads summary.
The book "Heatwave" by Victor Jestin is shown on a crocheted blanket. Overlays highlight it's 112 pages, coming of age, literary fiction, and translated from French, accompanied by a Goodreads summary.
books 200 pages or less 🤓
Who doesn’t love a book you can read in one sitting or at least over 24 hours?? Most of these books are literary fiction (i say most, i mean all but one) so you won’t see many fantasy or sci-fi elements here. But that doesn’t make them less good! I finally found my flavor of book once i started
molly

molly

467 likes

See more