It was ok for me

⭐️Overall rating: 3/5:⭐️⭐️⭐️

It has been twenty-five years since Caroline Winterfield disappeared into the woods. Her three best friends have decided to come together to celebrate Caroline and to see one another again. Each has grown into fantastic women.

Talia, a mother, Midge the town cop, and Kelly has been divorced twice and has bought Haven Cliff. The mansion that Caroline's Great-Great-Grandfather built. That is surrounded by curses and sat empty for years. Kelly has restored it to its former glory, all for Caroline. On the day of the anniversary, a man is discovered dead. He has links to the girls, specifically to Caroline. Was it an accident or is there more to his fall?

This was a good book but it just dragged along for me. I almost dnf but I know a lot of people liked this book so maybe it will be for you but this book did not hold my attention and took forever for me to get through.

#bookreccomendation #lemon8bookchallange #lemon8bookworm #bookreview

2025/4/12 Edited to

... Read moreIn 'The Fourth Girl' by Wendy Corsi Staub, the story unfolds twenty-five years after Caroline Winterfield's mysterious disappearance, bringing her friends together to honor her legacy. Talia, Midge, and Kelly have evolved into remarkable women; their reunion at Haven Cliff, restored by Kelly, reignites buried memories. As they reminisce, a shocking discovery complicates their gathering—a man's body, linked to Caroline, is found. This twist raises questions: Did the fall occur by accident, or is there a darker truth? Readers have mixed feelings about the pacing of the narrative. While some find depth in the character development and the exploration of friendship's impact over time, others may agree that the plot unfolds slowly, affecting engagement. The themes of memory, loss, and the weight of secrets resonate throughout, capturing the essence of how the past continues to influence their lives. For those intrigued by character-driven mysteries, this book can offer a profound experience, despite its pacing. As you dive deeper into the storyline, consider how past relationships shape our present selves and what puzzles remain unresolved when friendships are tested by time.

Related posts

Thankfully, the drivers was OK
Joe E Corrado

Joe E Corrado

1538 likes

Beyonce Ok Girl
The #queen did it again ! #cowboycarter was amazing! FOMO got the best of me on this one I was gonna skip this tour but I’m so glad I didn t ! #beyonce giiirrrrlll 3hours non stop! Show me another one that can do it ! Now let me get these boots off #cowboycarter #cowboy #cowboycar
Becky!💋

Becky!💋

360 likes

Clearview OK est. 1903 AbeLincoln Trading Post
From a trading post to a fellowship bar and now abandoned with hopes of a revival, this building was truly a testament of its heyday. #oklahoma #blackoklahoma #blackhistoryeveryday #blacktown #historicalblacktown #blackhistoricaltowns #oklahomablacktowns
Capricorn Black ♑️

Capricorn Black ♑️

293 likes

Two square bottles of hair and body mist, one labeled 'Vanilla Caramel Sugar' and the other 'Pistachio Delight', both with gourmand notes, part of a Marshall's haul.
A hand holding a bottle of 'Almond Vanilla All Over Body Oil' by Botanical Relaxation, infused with almond and rosehip oil, for softening and moisturizing.
A clear glass perfume bottle with a decorative cap, labeled 'Eau de Parfum Praline & Pistachio', resting on white tissue paper.
Ok marshall’s… i see you 👀
Why yall ain’t tell me Marshall’s was the spot for DUPES and DEALS!? 😵‍💫 but it’s ok I went snooping lol I was actually on a prowl for the Miimiic Perfumes and oils in which I found but only ended up with one which was the SDJ 62 Dupe which is number 32 $7.99 for the first two sprays Van
TayBae💜

TayBae💜

348 likes

i’m a homebody…and that’s ok
for so long i tried to convince myself i was a party girl at heart, but i’ve finally accepted that i’m NOT. i love to be social and go out sometimes, but i need AT least 1 night on the weekend to just relax and do what i like to do. if you told me 3 years ago that two of my favorite things would be
Caroline

Caroline

898 likes

The vibe was ok, but not what I was expecting 🤔
Let me know your thoughts 💭 #houseofflameandshadow #sarahjmaas #books #fantasybooks #bookworm
Breetwo3

Breetwo3

7 likes

A woman with long dark hair and a black cap, with text overlay "HERBS FOR BEAUTY Hair, Skin & Nails & tips" and the Lemon8 handle @k_janeee__.
A close-up of dried herbs with a blue text box detailing the benefits of Moringa, highlighting its rich content of antioxidants, vitamins, iron, amino acids, and other minerals.
A close-up of dried herbs with a blue text box describing Jamaican Sarsaparilla & Burdock Root, noting their richness in minerals, antioxidants, and their use for skin issues and toxin removal.
Ok sis, let’s get into it! 🌿💄
💄Yeah external products like face serums and hair oils can help with hair and skin, but SIS, that real glow up comes from the inside out! That inner healing! ✨ •✨Imagine if you utilized and focused on inner and outer beauty. Now that’s ultimate health and vitality! One that last LONG TERM! •
K_janee_

K_janee_

177 likes

A young woman with curly brown hair and blue eyes makes a puckered face in a car. Text overlays ask, "Ok girls... What did you get your boyfriend for Christmas??" with Christmas tree emojis.
Ok girls… what did you get him for Christmas???
Let me know in the comments what your budget was and what you did with it!!! I want to hear all the ideas 🎄 #christmas #christmasgiftideas #christmaswishlist #giftsforhim
Alaina Dines

Alaina Dines

16 likes

it’s ok to be bigger than your partner🫶🏼
When Brent and I first started dating, I struggled sooooo much with the fact I was bigger than him. In my head I believed no one like him could possibly be attracted to me. But you know what? He is. And he has continuously shown me that. He treats me better than I could ask for tbh. He’s shown me t
ashley

ashley

445 likes

It’s ok to be Young and Modest 💞
04/02 was my first birthday dressing modestly — and let me tell you, modesty isn’t just about rules or restrictions. It’s not just about what you wear, but why you wear it. God led me to this shift, and it’s been beautiful. My body is a temple, and now I dress like I truly believe that. It’s abou
DiamondRae

DiamondRae

45 likes

Looooook! 👀
Fun fact: my favorite Jordan is the Jordan 1… I like lows and mids. It’s my go to shoe! If you see me in some Jordan’s, they will definitely be 1’s! I stumbled across this painting at Burlingtons. I wish I would have got it. When I went back a guy already snatched it up. I was too late! #j
Eboni 🧚🏾‍♂️

Eboni 🧚🏾‍♂️

15 likes

A person with facial piercings, tattoos, and a black cap with a beer and taco emoji, wears a denim jacket and pink earphones. They are taking a selfie in a colorful room with small red, blue, and yellow chairs, and a striped carpet, possibly a waiting area.
ITS OK TO ADMIT TOU NEED HELP! LOVE YOURSELF DUMmi
#lemon8diarychallenge i’ve always said no matter what that it’s OK to admit that somebody or even yourself needs help. There’s no weakness in that whatsoever learning to love yourself respect others respect yourself and to also make new meaningful friendships with other people instead of staying
JoCIE poo

JoCIE poo

5 likes

It's ok to take your own path in life🫶
Do you sometimes feel like your path in life is a little different than others? Or feel pressured by society? Pressure to go to college. Pressure to graduate, work and reach a certain level financially. Then get married. Then have kids. But make sure you travel while you're young. But also save
sarah

sarah

3 likes

It's ok to be a beginner ❤️
🔹The first time you tried to ride your bike? You couldn’t do it. 🔸The first time you attempted to tie your shoes? You couldn’t do it. 🔹The first time you picked up your pencil to write your name? You couldn’t do it. 🔸The first time you looked at a multiplication problem? You couldn’t do
Melissa Heffron

Melissa Heffron

2 likes

A purple-themed desk setup featuring a monitor displaying an anime character, a white laptop, speakers, and a purple-lit Kiiboom mechanical keyboard. The wall is decorated with hexagonal lights, a digital clock, and anime art, creating a vibrant aesthetic.
A close-up of a Kiiboom Phantom 68 mechanical keyboard with clear, crystal-like keycaps and vibrant purple RGB lighting. The keyboard has a transparent casing, and a small pink figurine is visible nearby on the white desk.
A full view of a purple-themed desk setup featuring a monitor, a white laptop, and a crystal mechanical keyboard with purple lighting. The desk is adorned with speakers and a gaming console, complemented by wall decorations and hexagonal lights.
OK THIS PURPLE KEYBOARD
Ok ok i am loving the purple set ups so far! So another purple keyboard to go with my purple theme is the Kiibomm Phantom 68 oh my gosh it's beautiful. I never had a kiiboom keyboard before and it's such a dream to finally own one. ITS CHEFS KISS * The lighting rbg is shining amazingly thro
lexii 🌸

lexii 🌸

19 likes

Changes are OK!
The day eventually arrived! Officially moving today and starting a new job tomorrow!!! 🫠🫣🥹 For the past week I tried to transition into a healthy and productive routine. The first two days I even woke up early and hit the gym first thing in the morning. By the third day I got my period and terri
September1st

September1st

3 likes

Ok I’m a believer
Saw this on either here or on Insta! And the person was bragging about how amazeballs it was ok so I bit and ordered it to see what the hype was about all Imma say is “Do believe the hype” OMG its one of the best purchases ever when I say it gets all the “Possibles” like my grandma used to say it
Lippiequeen707

Lippiequeen707

79 likes

TWENTY PHO HOUR OKC 🤭
Pho-real, OKC knows how to serve a vibe + flavor! Stopped by @twentyphohour.okc and let me tell you… this was AN UNPHOGETTABLE EXPERIENCE! From the 2D comic-style decor to the wings on the wall (perfect for pics), every corner screamed aesthetic. I ordered: • Thai Tea w/ Lychee Jelly🧋
Champaigne Jackson

Champaigne Jackson

3 likes

Ok I might be a shopaholic 😂
No, but seriously having a sense of style is key and it’s a trait I don’t take for granted. I was taught it’s not what you wear but HOW you wear it 🥰 #shoppinglife✌🏾 #shoppingaddict #shoppingfinds #shoppingislife✌🏼 #shoppingaddiction
Khoki

Khoki

113 likes

‼️🤔Ok Brainiacs; help me solve this Math Problem🤔‼️
‼️💭🤔Ok Brainiacs; help me solve this Math Problem; when I thought I was SMART???🤔💭‼️ #foryou #fyp #MathChallenge #BrainTeaser #SmartButStumped #MathHelp #ProblemSolver #FeelingStuck #MathWoes #BrainiacsUnite #HelpMeSolve #MathConfusion #NeedMathHelp #BrainyButLost #Math
🧞‍♀️ MrsExquisiteDailyInsight

🧞‍♀️ MrsExquisiteDailyInsight

6 likes

OK FIRST POST
I thought this was like twitter but it's attached to tiktok and now i'm confused 🤭 standby while i figure myself out 🕺🏾🕺🏾🕺🏾 but anyways HI GUYS ! say it back🌚
thatssoreygann

thatssoreygann

2 likes

It’s ok to step back
I work at my local animal shelter. This year has been hectic. We just got a new director and we’ve been having a hard time hiring and keeping staff. But since my new boss has started, things have gone down hill quickly. I’ve been harassed by my boss and it’s been piling up on my shoulders for month
Kiri_Simp

Kiri_Simp

3 likes

Broken Bow, OK
The drive was so worth it! 🤍 #brokenbow #brokenbowoklahoma #brokenbowcabin #hochatown
Brianna Mendoza

Brianna Mendoza

7 likes

See more