Open relationship gone wrong 💔

So my boyfriend and I) agreed to try an open relationship while I study abroad in the US. The rules were super clear: no emotional stuff, protection always, and we tell each other within 48 hours.

A few months in, I hooked up with someone once. No feelings, just physical, followed all the rules. I even told him the very next day.

Instead of talking it through, he blew up on me. He called me cheap, easy, and said I was basically a sl*t for doing it. Then he admitted he never thought I’d actually go through with it — that it was just a “test of loyalty.” Now he’s broken up with me and telling all our mutual friends I cheated.

I feel so betrayed because I followed the exact agreement we made together. Am I really the bad guy here, or was he playing me the whole time?

#AskLemon8 #LetsChat #RelationshipDrama

2025/10/8 Edited to

... Read moreIt's been a tough period processing what happened. When we decided on an open relationship, I genuinely believed we were on the same page. We talked about it for weeks before I left to study abroad in the US. We laid out all the rules, clear as day: no emotional attachment, always use protection, and always communicate within 48 hours. I thought we had excellent communication. I thought we had *trust*. But looking back now, I realize there's a huge difference between agreeing on rules and truly understanding each other's emotional boundaries and unspoken expectations. The core issue wasn't just him blowing up; it was the revelation that he never truly trusted me. He created a 'test' without my knowledge, which is the ultimate betrayal of trust in any relationship, let alone an open one. How can you build a secure attachment when one person is secretly hoping the other fails? This kind of covert testing poisons the very foundation of couple open communication trust. For anyone considering an open relationship, especially long-distance or during a significant life change like studying abroad, please learn from my mistake. Communication needs to go deeper than just a list of dos and don'ts. You need to constantly check in on each other's feelings, anxieties, and evolving comfort levels. What feels okay on paper might hit differently in practice. We didn't do enough of that. We set the rules and assumed that was enough. True trust isn't about setting traps; it's about believing in your partner's integrity and their commitment to the agreed-upon terms, even when you're physically apart. It's about being vulnerable enough to admit if you're struggling, rather than letting resentment fester or setting up covert 'loyalty tests.' The moment he admitted it was a test, all the trust I had in him shattered. It felt like he was sleeping on a bed of lies this whole time, just waiting for me to fail. The distance of me studying abroad definitely added another layer of complexity. It's hard enough maintaining an open relationship when you're in the same city, let alone across continents. The lack of physical presence makes it easier for insecurities to creep in and harder to have those crucial, nuanced conversations. A quick text or call can't always convey the emotional depth needed. If you find yourself in a similar situation, remember you are not 'cheap' or 'easy' for adhering to boundaries you both set. You respected the agreement. The failure lies with the partner who couldn't handle the reality of their own agreement or who harbored unspoken expectations. It's incredibly painful, but it's a harsh lesson in understanding that open relationship communication requires constant, honest, and mutual vulnerability, not just adherence to a checklist. And trust? It's earned through transparency, not tested through deceit. I'm now learning to rebuild my own sense of trust, not just in others, but in my own judgment, and to recognize the red flags of manipulative behavior in the future.

237 comments

✨Tia✨'s images
✨Tia✨

He wanted a way out to make you look bad and got exactly what he wanted 😭

See more(10)
Caetlin Halapin's images
Caetlin Halapin

As a monogamous person, NTA. He agreed to it and agreed to the set boundaries. It’s not a loyalty test if he lied about what he was ok with. He thought he’d have a free pass to sleep around without consequences, and that you wouldn’t use yours. He’s just mad that he was wrong.

See more(2)

See more comments

Related posts

The image shows two hands with fingers intertwined, one hand wearing rings, against a dark tiled background. Overlay text reads "Tips to maintain healthy relationship."
A couple stands in front of a mirror, seen from behind, with a staircase on the left. Overlay text says "Be No.1 supporter" and advises providing positive energy and support.
A person is seated in a car at night, looking out the window at blurred city lights. Overlay text reads "INVEST TIME & EFFORT" and suggests making time for meaningful activities together.
Tips to maintain a healthy relationship
For your beautiful relationship ✨ https://jiffcy.go.link/jpE3m Building a strong, lasting relationship, takes care, patience, and intention. Here are some core tips to keep your connection thriving: ✨ be each other’s number one supporter: celebrate your partner’s goal, achievements, and dreams
Isabella

Isabella

5717 likes

The image displays the title '7 Psychological Ways to Improve your Relationship' in white text with sparkling accents, set against a dimly lit restaurant interior with a table, glasses, and a menu.
The image features the heading 'Actively Look For The Best in Them' and a description about negativity bias, overlaid on a cozy dinner setting with candles, food, and drinks on a table.
The image shows the heading 'N.I.C.E Time' and text explaining the benefits of 'new, interesting, challenging, and exciting' date nights, set against the shadows of two people on a paved surface.
How to Heal a Relationship Gone Sour 💔❤️‍🩹
🤩ACTIVELY LOOK FOR THE BEST IN THEM: Try to seek out solutions, not problems. Humans have a natural negativity bias and it seems when our relationships are going smoothly, we overemphasise the smaller issues. ⛳️NICE TIME: Have date nights that are "new, interesting, challenging, and exciti
irianna

irianna

1829 likes

A woman with long brown hair smiles in a car, with a hand gently touching her head. Overlay text reads "non-sexual FORMS OF INTIMACY". The Lemon8 logo and username are at the bottom left.
A woman lies with her eyes closed, head resting on another person, in sunlight. A black text box lists non-sexual intimacy examples like "long hugs" and "listening". "SWIPE" is visible.
Two women in a kitchen playfully interact with whipped cream and a cake. A black text box lists non-sexual intimacy examples such as "cooking together" and "traveling together".
non-sexual intimacy in ANY relationship 🫶
intimacy is a word we generally associate with romantic relationships … but all it really means is to be deeply or particularly close to another person 💛 there are ways you can be intimate with someone else that stretch across ✨every✨ single type of relationship loving isn’t limited to lovers
carley ◡̈

carley ◡̈

31.8K likes

red flags in a relationship ❌
No relationship is perfect, but it's important to take note of red flags. If your partner is showinf many of these behaviors or patterns, it's crucial to have open and honest communication with them to address these issues. If the issues persist, you may need to reconsider staying in the re
Cleo Natalie

Cleo Natalie

888 likes

Relationship non-negotiables
Boundaries are a form of self-love. 💕 My 3 non-negotiables remind me to stay true to myself, even in love. What are yours? #KnowYourWorth #loveandconnection #relationshiptoself #relationshipadvice #Lemon8Diary
JustQueenDee

JustQueenDee

1402 likes

Why your first healthy relationship is the hardest
I never experienced this before, and I honestly thought I was the problem in my current relationship because I couldn’t reciprocate everything back. My partner did not rush me, and let me take things at my own pace. This is when I realized there’s more to a relationship than distrust, and not ever
Ariana

Ariana

2838 likes

Payback gone wrong 😂
#funny #Couple #couplecomedy #relationship
Lemon8er

Lemon8er

1120 likes

RELATIONSHIP TRAUMA TRUTHS
Hi 👋🏽 my name is Erriona and I’ve suffered a lot of relationship trauma in my life I’m only 18 and I’ve given up on love….. it’s hurts so bad still and I’m still traumatized but I’ve been on my healing journey for 9 months now and I wanna know your thought on this topic or if anything I said you co
lovelyMoo🦋🐮

lovelyMoo🦋🐮

1802 likes

A dark image featuring a bouquet of deep red roses and small white flowers, wrapped in black paper. Overlay text reads "Non-Negotiatiables For a healthy relationship" and "lemon8 @odeevibez" at the bottom.
A pink background with the title "Communication is Key" in blue and white. Black text below emphasizes open, honest communication, respectful understanding of perspectives, and learning to communicate better.
A pink background with the title "Have Goals" in blue and white. Black text below discusses the importance of both independent and shared goals, ensuring future aspirations align for a healthy relationship.
For a healthy relationship - non negotiables
Wooo this year has been so eye opening for me for love. But really? So has my early 20s. Blessed to all my experiences, observations, research & more that has guided me into understanding the importance of a healthy, solid, relationship. 🥹❤️❤️❤️❤️ #lemon8diarychallenge #relationshipadvice #
odeevibez

odeevibez

1608 likes

A couple dances in a field at dusk, with text overlay "Things I've Learned During My First Serious Relationship [ as someone with anxious attachment ]". The image has a decorative border and the Lemon8 logo with username @kelsavl.
A light brown background with a dark brown cloud shape at the top, featuring the title "Number One: You can be together and still be individuals" and bullet points about maintaining individuality in a relationship. The Lemon8 logo and username @kelsavl are at the bottom.
A light brown background with a dark brown cloud shape at the top, featuring the title "Number Two: It is more than okay to take things slow" and bullet points about consent, emotional connection, and setting boundaries. The Lemon8 logo and username @kelsavl are at the bottom.
Things I Learned in My First Serious Relationship
If you don’t have much experience in serious relationships, then this is for you! This is what I’ve learned during my first healthy, serious relationship💗 #relationship #relationshipadvice #love #relationshiptips #relationshipgoals #relationshipgrowth #advice
𝒦𝑒𝓁𝓈𝑒𝓎 𝒥𝒶𝓎

𝒦𝑒𝓁𝓈𝑒𝓎 𝒥𝒶𝓎

1532 likes

Two people's hands gently hold small pink and yellow flowers, symbolizing connection. Overlay text reads "The rule of 5 IN A RELATIONSHIP" with an arrow pointing to the flowers, suggesting the core elements of a healthy relationship.
The image features the title "1. Honesty" in blue. Below, white text boxes explain that honesty in relationships is about authenticity and transparency, distinguishing it from brutal honesty which is fear-based and accusatory.
The image displays the title "2. Trust" in blue. White text boxes detail how to build trust, emphasizing reliability, respecting boundaries, and open communication, and not blaming a current partner for past trust issues.
The rule of 5 in a relationship ❤️✨
Healthy relationships involve honesty, trust, respect and open communication between partners and they take effort and compromise from both people. There is no imbalance of power. Partners respect each other’s independence, can make their own decisions without fear of retribution or retaliation, an
Allison 🎀

Allison 🎀

222 likes

My next relationship…
My therapist told me to write down what I look for in my next relationship… here’s what I wrote ❤️‍🩹 - Security - Validation - Attention - Effort What will you look for your in your next relationship? #lemon8diarychallenge #relationshippoetry #writinggoals #summerbod #re
Taylor Vee 🦋 | Lifestyle

Taylor Vee 🦋 | Lifestyle

1559 likes

toxic traits in a relationship (DON’T DO THESE!)
Some big relationship DON’TS include: don’t speak badly of your partner ~ instead work through conflict directly with your partner don’t lie ~ including white lies, which can be extremely toxic to your relationship don’t withhold information ~ be open and honest with your partner don’t d
Cleo Natalie

Cleo Natalie

333 likes

A person is resting on a gray couch under a blanket, with a fireplace mantel in the background. Overlay text asks, 'How do you define healthy relationship? Is our relationship healthy?' accompanied by a red heart icon and Lemon8 branding.
How do you define healthy relationship?
Hey guys, I've been thinking about this a lot lately. For me, a healthy relationship means open communication, respect for each other's boundaries, and feeling supported through ups and downs. But sometimes I wonder, are we really ticking all these boxes? How do you guys measure a healthy r
Anj

Anj

25 likes

A couple, with the woman kissing the man's cheek, smiling outdoors. Overlay text reads "20 HEALTHY RELATIONSHIP HABITS TO INCREASE HAPPINESS & TRUST," introducing an article about relationship advice.
A bulleted list on a light pink background detailing 20 relationship habits, including "Never go to bed angry" and "Date nights weekly," providing practical tips for a healthy relationship.
A couple smiling, with the man holding the woman, on a path with an archway. Text describes how the author and her boyfriend developed habits over four years to build a stable, communicative, and trusting relationship.
20 important relationship habits for happiness 💓💌
Over the last four years of our relationship, my boyfriend and I have developed quite a few habits that continue to keep our relationship and each other happy! Relationships take WORK, so developing healthy routines is incredibly important. Cultivating positive habits has allowed us to create more
Sarah Jolie 🌸

Sarah Jolie 🌸

167 likes

A pile of US dollar bills, including five and twenty-dollar denominations, is displayed on a light surface. Overlayed text reads "My Bf wants us on the same phone plan," with a Lemon8 logo and username in the bottom left corner.
Am I wrong for protecting myself financially here?
My bf asked me to join his phone plan so he could save money, but I’m hesitant. I already pay our mortgage and utilities, plus help with car repairs and other expenses. I’ve tried to have open talks about finances before, but he refuses to share his income, debts, or expenses. I’m worried that i
Gorgaz

Gorgaz

940 likes

A chocolate cake with raspberries, a vase of flowers, and a lit candle on a table, with text overlaying "RELATIONSHIP NONNEGOTIABLES NEVER SETTLE & SET THAT BAR HIGH."
A white background displays a bulleted list titled "MY NONNEGOTIABLES," outlining 17 essential qualities and expectations for a relationship, including communication and emotional intelligence.
A couple smiles outdoors against a green landscape, accompanying text titled "LEARNING HOW TO SET THE BAR HIGH," explaining the author's journey to defining relationship non-negotiables.
❤️‍🔥my relationship MUST-HAVES❤️‍🔥
Having the experience of dating my boyfriend has seriously raised the bar for me so much. It’s made me realize how many things are nonnegotiables for me in a relationship. Healing my anxious attachment has also shed a lot of light on what I consider to be reasonable expectations. So I wanted to sha
Sarah Jolie 🌸

Sarah Jolie 🌸

626 likes

A screenshot of a text message from a boyfriend discussing overcoming relationship challenges together, emphasizing mutual support and not ending things over fixable problems. The text is overlaid with 'How my boyfriend and I communicate'.
A screenshot of a text message from a boyfriend stating they will work on issues together, acknowledging personal work needed, and reiterating 'us against the problem, not us against each other'.
A screenshot of a text message from a boyfriend expressing that everyday with his partner reinforces his desire to marry them, highlighting deep affection.
Accountability in A Relationship
My boyfriend has taught me so much about how to actively communicate in an argument w/o shutting down. Although I still do it sometimes it’s a work in progress. He always reassures me and tells me it’s us against the problem not me n him against eachother. Growing up my feelings were always mis
Aamarii🦂♏️

Aamarii🦂♏️

2329 likes

A person takes a mirror selfie, with the text overlay "3 things that will RUIN YOUR RELATIONSHIP (Often overlooked)" in red and white font, introducing the article's topic.
A coffee table features a white floral arrangement, decorative pumpkins, and a book. The text overlay reads: "Not being on the same team Operating as individuals instead of a unit."
Curved shelves display various neutral-toned decorative objects. The text overlay states: "Poor communication Not expressing needs and feelings or understanding your partner."
This will ruin your relationship 🙅🏽‍♀️
There are three key things that are often overlooked that ruin relationships. Relationships take work and it’s important to be intentional every single day to be successful. ✨ not being on the same team: you have to know that you both have each other’s best interest at heart. You both have the s
Chandler

Chandler

917 likes

A close-up of two hands, one larger and one smaller, holding each other against a blurred evening landscape with city lights. The text 'I begged for an open relationship' is overlaid in yellow, along with 'Lemon8 @jadenpark508'.
I begged for an open relationship...
I (22F) was the one who asked for an open relationship. My boyfriend (25M) and I had been together for a while, and I guess I just got... bored? There was nothing wrong with him, I just wanted more excitement. He agreed (surprisingly chill), but said very clearly that if he caught feelings for some
jadenpark508

jadenpark508

556 likes

✨🥰6 Phrases That’ll Strengthen Your Relationship💗✨
✨ The way we communicate can either build a bridge, or a wall. These small, intentional phrases hold so much power in a relationship. They say: 1️⃣ I care. 2️⃣ You’re safe here. 3️⃣ I’m not perfect, but I’m committed to growing with you. 📝 When you say things like: 🔸 “What do you need fr
Margarita

Margarita

281 likes

Jewelery Robbery Gone Wrong #onearmedrobber #gamer
Jewelery Robbery Gone Wrong #onearmedrobber #gamer #game #fps
EndureCzar

EndureCzar

0 likes

How to keep your relationship from getting boring?
1. Explore New Hobbies Together: Discover shared interests and engage in activities that both of you enjoy. 2. Regular Date Nights: Schedule regular date nights to keep the romance alive and create special moments. 3. Surprise Each Other: Plan unexpected surprises or spontaneous activities to add
Megan Snyder

Megan Snyder

3588 likes

RELATIONSHIP ADVICE NO ONE WILL TELL YOU... 🤫❤️‍🔥
Hey besties! 💖 Let’s get real for a sec—there’s a LOT of relationship advice out there, but sometimes it feels like everyone is just repeating the same stuff. 🙄 So, I’m here to spill the underrated, no-BS truths that people aren’t talking about when it comes to love and relationships. Ready for som
Lushie Club 💖

Lushie Club 💖

4301 likes

5 Relationship Tips for Lasting Love 💕
We all crave deep connections, but real relationships take work! Here are my 5 tips for nurturing love and staying close, even when life gets busy. ✨ 1️⃣ Prioritize Communication 🗣️ Open, honest communication is the backbone of any strong relationship. Make time to share your feelings and liste
Caroline 🫶🏼

Caroline 🫶🏼

68 likes

Sneak attack gone wrong😭
I am kinda…😭😂 #helldivers2 #hd2 #funny #enjoy #thanks
TOXIC_FADEAWAY

TOXIC_FADEAWAY

1 like

Acknowledging Your Godly Relationship🤎
Key aspects of a godly relationship:🗝️🤎 • Unconditional love: Reflecting God's love, which is not based on conditions or performance. • Forgiveness: Willingness to forgive each other as God forgives us • Communication: Open and honest communication, seeking to understand each other's
TheNajaSimone

TheNajaSimone

1604 likes

Asking him to take off my clothes, GONE WRONG🫣
What did you think would happen? #watchtilltheend #coupleshumor😂😂 #funnyvideo #relationship #couples
A&J

A&J

832 likes

Would you be in an open relationship?
I’m curious what’s YOUR view on this! I’m very monogamous in relationships but I feel like I’ve been hearing more people be in an open relationship and I’m curious why that’s the case?? I would struggle with trust after being cheated on in every relationship I’ve had … I know it’s different bec
rachel

rachel

17 likes

🫧💐spring clean YOUR RELATIONSHIP 🌸🍋
SPRING CLEANING SZN is among us friends!! In the spirit of decluttering our physical spaces, it's also a perfect time to declutter our emotional selves! I absolutely LOVE spring bc it brings such good energy for ~rebirth~ and ~renewal~. With that being said, here's how you can SPRING CLEAN
Sarah Jolie 🌸

Sarah Jolie 🌸

37 likes

A flat lay shows a tablet displaying a study guide, a physical Bible, pens, a lit candle, and a cup of tea, with the overlay text "How to Develop an Intimate Relationship with God."
A pink-toned graphic lists six steps for developing an intimate relationship with God: Read your Bible daily, Seek His heart, Confess your sins, Be open and honest, Submit to Him, and Learn to forgive others.
A smartphone displays a blog post titled "How to Develop an Intimate Relationship with God," showing a person reading a Bible and text about daily Bible reading, with an arrow pointing to it and the text "Check out blog LINK IN BIO."
Develop an Intimate Relationship with God 💗
Developing an intimate relationship with God requires daily dedication and intentional actions. In my blog, I list six steps on how to invite God's presence into your life, aligning your heart with His. www.higherinhim.com
Dateria

Dateria

721 likes

A couple kisses by a vibrant blue geothermal pool, with text overlay "GOOD SIGNS OF A healthy relationship" and "Swipe!!", indicating a multi-image post about relationship advice.
A smiling couple takes a selfie outdoors on a scenic trail, surrounded by text bubbles listing "clear communication, respect, trust, prioritizing quality time together, and support system."
An embracing couple smiles indoors, with text bubbles highlighting "putting the effort, shared values, plans for the future, maintaining independence, and love and affection" as healthy relationship signs.
WHAT TO LOOK FOR IN A HEALTHY RELATIONSHIP ✨
Here are some good signs of a HEALTHY relationship! Open & honest communication ~ it’s important for both partners to freely express their feelings and thoughts without any judgment Respecting one another ~ being kind and having mutual respect for each other and speaking highly of each ot
Cleo Natalie

Cleo Natalie

42 likes

A couple embraces in a mirror reflection, with the text overlay 'how my boyfriend and i maintain a healthy relationship'. This image serves as the title for an article about relationship maintenance.
A couple takes a mirror selfie, with the word 'communication' overlaid. This image illustrates the importance of communication in a healthy relationship, as discussed in the article.
A couple is seen in a crowded outdoor night setting, with the word 'trust' overlaid. This image highlights the trust aspect of their relationship, as described in the accompanying text.
how to maintain a HEALTHY relationship
communication: communication is the main thing that will keep your relationships afloat. without the constant communication and reassurance between two partners either party can become unsure about their emotions. being open to talking about an issue is very important because it’s both of you again
sash

sash

1506 likes

🏒💔 Horror Movie Love Gone Wrong 💔🏒
🏒 This is literally me thinking I can change him 😭 Like girl… he’s Jason Voorhees, not a “he just needs love” project 💀 The red flags could literally be dripping from the machete and I still could think “but maybe he’s different with me” or that he can change 😭 🏒 But foreal though, horror movie
Margarita

Margarita

23 likes

A couple, a man and a woman, are playfully posing in a golf cart ride labeled 'The Birdie ATX'. The man holds a prop gun, and the woman is at the wheel. The image is titled 'Our Love Story' with a 'SWIPE' indicator.
A screenshot of a direct message conversation from June to August 2017. The messages show an initial flirtation, asking if single, requesting a phone number, and a follow-up message indicating the sender felt ignored.
A selfie of a couple in a car. The woman, wearing a floral bucket hat, sunglasses, and a denim jacket, is in the foreground. The man, also in sunglasses and a denim jacket, is driving in the background.
DM Gone Wrong ?
From the screenshot you can see when he initially messaged me. When we first started talking we were both FRESH out of relationships. I was apprehensive but open. We had this immediate connection like no other person I’ve ever met. It felt like we had grown up together and reconnected lol. We’re bo
JustTina

JustTina

11 likes

A top-down view of two people's legs and feet on a wooden floor, one in black sneakers and the other in orange sneakers. Yellow text reads 'AMA: Open Relationship to Poly', surrounded by stars and sparkles, relating to the article's theme.
👩‍❤️‍💋‍👨Open relationship and poly: AMA👨‍❤️‍💋‍👨
I never thought I would be in a poly let alone posting about how I’m in one on the internet. My boyfriend and I have been in an open relationship for about 2 years now. We never thought we would find someone who would be willing to join our relationship AND be compatible for both of us, but we
⛱️Sandy Seashore⛱️

⛱️Sandy Seashore⛱️

7 likes

ingredients for a happy & long relationship 🫶
Me and my husband have been together for over 14 years. Our relationship isn’t perfect, but I definitely think there are certain things that have helped contribute to our happy and long relationship, which include: maintain open & honest communication keep your relationship “FUN” and cont
Cleo Natalie

Cleo Natalie

10 likes

See more