I have roughly 200 pages left, and I put it back on the shelf…
I found myself having to physically force myself to pick this up and read it. I stopped caring about what was going to happen next, and how things would unfold. I got through Fourth Wing so fast in comparison.
And don’t get me wrong, I had HIGH hopes for this book, especially as a follow up to Fourth Wing.
Unfortunately, you can only stick with the “Enemies to Lovers” trope for the same couple for so long before things start to get weird!
Let me know your thoughts below - a strong argument could persuade me to pick it back up again!
... Read moreIt's totally valid to DNF a book, especially when a particular trope just isn't working for you anymore! I completely get what you mean about the 'enemies to lovers' dynamic. It's a foundational fantasy romance trope, especially popular in books featuring strong leads and high stakes, often with awesome elements like dragons and fire creating epic backdrops. But, as you pointed out, when that push-and-pull extends too much within the same couple across multiple books, it can definitely start to feel less organic and more like manufactured drama, making it hard to stay invested.
Beyond that central romantic dynamic, Iron Flame (and by extension, *Fourth Wing*) is absolutely packed with classic fantasy tropes that readers either adore or find themselves getting a bit tired of. For instance, the 'academy setting' is huge – a common and beloved way to introduce new characters, develop skills, and build a world from the ground up. Think about the intense, often brutal, training at Basgiath War College, the challenging trials, and the fierce rivalries that shape the cadets. This trope often naturally leads to powerful 'found family' dynamics, where disparate individuals, often outsiders, form unbreakable bonds through shared hardships and mutual support, which is definitely a major highlight for many fans of the series.
Then there's the compelling 'chosen one' or 'special destiny' trope. Without giving too much away, Violet certainly finds herself at the center of some pretty epic prophecies, ancient secrets, and world-altering revelations. This can be incredibly exciting, making the protagonist's journey feel profoundly important and giving the narrative immense stakes. However, some readers might prefer a hero who achieves greatness through sheer grit, strategy, and hard work rather than what can sometimes feel like a predetermined fate or convenient plot armor.
Another big one is the 'secret powers' or 'hidden abilities' trope. Our main characters frequently discover latent talents or unexpected strengths that prove crucial to overcoming seemingly insurmountable odds. This can be incredibly gratifying to read, offering moments of triumph and empowerment, but it also carries the risk of feeling like a convenient deus ex machina if not handled carefully and integrated seamlessly into the world-building.
And let's not forget the 'mentor figure' trope, often represented by tough-love instructors, wise elders, or even enigmatic allies guiding the younger generation. These characters can provide much-needed wisdom, emotional support, and crucial plot insights, but their roles can also sometimes feel a bit predictable. The overarching political intrigue, the looming war, and the rebellion narrative also play a significant role, adding layers of 'us vs. them' conflict that extend far beyond just the romantic tension, often involving 'ancient evils' and 'world on the brink' scenarios.
Ultimately, Iron Flame leverages many popular fantasy tropes that have captivated readers for generations. Whether these tropes hit or miss often depends on personal preference, the reader's familiarity with the genre, and how fresh and compelling the author makes them feel in their execution. While the 'enemies to lovers' might have lost its magic for you, perhaps the strong 'found family' bonds, the thrilling 'academy' challenges, or the epic dragons and fire battles could still offer something compelling if you ever decide to pick it up again? It's always fascinating to discuss how different tropes land with different readers and what makes them truly shine or fall flat!
It’s boooooorrrrrrriiiiimnnnnnnggggg. Mine collecting dust. I wanna slap a publisher in the face. This shizz shoulda been fanfic on a watt pad site. No disrespect to RY toast but honey is dry
See more comments