crumbl vs. subway: oreo cookies 🖤🥛

Okay, so you've seen the hype, right? The Subway Footlong Oreo cookie has been everywhere, and as a huge cookie fan, I just had to try it and see how it stacks up against my beloved Crumbl Oreo. This wasn't just a quick bite; I did a full-on side-by-side comparison to give you the real tea on both of these sweet treats! First up, let's talk about the Subway Footlong Oreo Cookie. When I first saw this long, rectangular cookie, I was intrigued. It's truly a sight to behold! Visually, it lives up to its name – it's definitely a foot long, making it perfect for sharing (or not, no judgment here!). The cookie itself is a soft-baked chocolate cookie, loaded with classic Oreo cookie crumbles, and generously filled with that signature white cream filling. My experience was that it was incredibly soft and chewy, almost like a brownie-cookie hybrid. The cream filling was sweet and abundant, though sometimes it felt a little too much for me, overwhelming the cookie flavor slightly. It's a fun, novelty dessert, and definitely hits the spot if you're craving something substantial and super sweet after your sandwich. It's a bold move for Subway to step into the dedicated dessert game with such a viral item, and it certainly got people talking, including me! If you're looking for a massive, shareable, and intensely sweet Oreo experience, this one's a contender. Now, let's turn our attention to the Crumbl Oreo Cookie. Crumbl is known for its rotating menu and massive, thick cookies, and their versions of Oreo cookies, like the Cookies & Cream or Oreo Birthday Cake, are always a hit. The one I compared was their classic Cookies & Cream, which is a round cookie with a beautiful swirled frosting on top, generously adorned with more crushed Oreo cookie crumbles. From the first bite, you get that distinct Crumbl soft, almost cakey texture. The frosting is usually a cream cheese or vanilla buttercream, perfectly sweetened and balanced with the chocolate cookie base. What I appreciate about Crumbl's take is the balance; the cookie flavor, the creaminess of the frosting, and the crunch from the cookie crumbles all work together harmoniously. It feels more refined, like a gourmet cookie experience. While it's not a 'footlong,' one Crumbl cookie is substantial enough to be a whole dessert on its own, and easily shareable for two. So, for the ultimate side-by-side comparison: If you're into novelty, sheer size, and a super soft, almost fudgy texture with a very prominent sweet cream filling, the Subway Footlong Oreo is your pick. It's a fun, indulgent treat that's great for an exciting sweet craving. However, if you prefer a more traditional, perfectly baked large cookie with a balanced flavor profile, a delicious frosting, and a slightly firmer yet still soft texture, then Crumbl's Oreo cookie variations are likely to win your heart. Crumbl often has different Oreo-themed cookies on their weekly menu, so there's always something new to try. Beyond just these two Oreo giants, it's worth noting that both places offer other dessert options, though their focuses differ. Subway primarily offers various cookies, usually in smaller sizes, and occasionally other baked goods, but they generally don't carry items like ice cream. Crumbl, on the other hand, is a dessert destination, exclusively focusing on their amazing gourmet cookies, with a new lineup every week. While I didn't find a Crumbl cookie in the Philippines to compare directly, their global popularity speaks volumes about their quality and variety. In conclusion, both cookies offer a fantastic Oreo experience, but they cater to slightly different cravings. For a fun, over-the-top, shareable chocolate-and-cream extravaganza, grab the Subway Footlong Oreo. For a consistently excellent, satisfyingly gourmet, and beautifully crafted cookie, Crumbl is the way to go. Which one will you choose for your next dessert fix?