I Said No, She’s Not My Kid. Am I Wrong?

My fiancé asked me last weekend if I could “just watch” his daughter for the day so he could go hunting with his friends. It’s just his hobby.

I paused. I like his daughter, but watching her isn’t casual. It’s a full day of responsibility, planning meals, keeping her entertained, making sure nothing goes wrong. And honestly? I had already planned my own quiet weekend.

When I said no, his mood flipped fast. He said I wasn’t being supportive and that “this is what families do.” That comment stuck with me.

We’re engaged, yes. But I’m not her parent. And I didn’t agree to be default childcare whenever he wants a day off. The part that hurt most wasn’t the request, it was how my boundary became a character flaw.

Where do you draw the line when it comes to helping… without disappearing yourself? Am I wrong?

#AskLemon8 #letschat #fiance #momsoflemon8 #relationshipadvice

2025/12/12 Edited to

... Read moreNavigating the responsibilities that come with a fiancé's child can be complex, especially when you're not a parent but are expected to step in as one. The request to babysit while your fiancé goes hunting highlights a common scenario where personal plans clash with family expectations. It's important to recognize that babysitting is more than just a favor; it requires energy, attention, and significant planning to ensure the child’s needs are met throughout the day. This responsibility can impact your well-being, especially if you’ve planned for your own downtime or have other commitments. Drawing boundaries is crucial. Saying no when you're unable or unwilling to babysit on short notice is not being unsupportive; rather, it's an expression of self-care. Healthy relationships involve clear communication where both partners respect each other's limits. Discuss with your fiancé how to share childcare responsibilities fairly. Perhaps establish a schedule or explore alternative care options so that your time is valued. It’s also essential that your fiancé understands that while "this is what families do" might reflect a cultural norm, every relationship defines family differently. Mutual respect and understanding help foster a supportive environment where your identity isn’t overshadowed by imposed duties. Maintaining your autonomy ensures that you don't disappear in the relationship dynamic, preserving your sense of self while supporting your blended family. Ultimately, feeling conflicted about these situations is normal, but prioritizing honest dialogue and boundary-setting will strengthen your partnership and personal well-being.

623 comments

jessicasc2490's images
jessicasc2490

if you marry someone with a child you are literally signing on to be a parent. Period. Otherwise move along to someone without children.

See more(47)
Adriana's images
Adriana

Don’t date people with kids if you don’t want to be a parent 🙄

See more(32)

See more comments

Related posts

A hand with pink almond-shaped nails features small, simple hand tattoos including a butterfly on the ring finger and dots with a heart on the middle finger. Rings adorn the fingers, with text overlay 'HAND TATTOOS Simple and cute'.
A hand with black French tip nails displays various small star and dot tattoos scattered across the back of the hand and fingers, creating a delicate pattern.
A hand with light-colored nails showcases two outline butterfly tattoos on the back, surrounded by numerous small star and dot tattoos extending towards the wrist. A pink neon light is in the background.
I want hand tattoos but he said no !
Ugh I really want hand tattoos, something cute small and simple, nothing too much ! But NOOOO my boyfriend told me I’d regret it and I shouldn’t do it due to being in the criminal justice field in college. I mean I don’t blame him…. He’s not wrong. Having hand tattoos can seem very “unprofessiona
Evie Pagan ✨💕

Evie Pagan ✨💕

5468 likes

Unhealthy things I am unlearning as a mom 🌸
Being a good mom is my top priority. 1. Punishing emotions. I will not get my daughter in trouble for yelling at me, crying, or anything else. If you were crying and somebody told you you have no reason to be, or that they’ll give you a reason to cry, how would you feel? Worse? 2. Shaming.
Shay

Shay

3961 likes

Am I wrong for filing anyway?
Two months ago, my husband announced he “wasn’t happy anymore” and wanted a divorce. He already had an apartment picked out. He said he needed “space to find himself.” I was devastated, but I accepted it. Fast forward: last week he loses his job. Suddenly he’s saying we “should work things out”
heyynick

heyynick

2343 likes

Kobe Bryant was not wrong when he said...
Kobe Bryant didn’t become great by accident. He became great because he refused to be average. While others were sleeping— he was working. While others were talking— he was practicing. While others were waiting for motivation— he built discipline. That’s what most people misunderstand. Greatness is
Trending Topic

Trending Topic

1961 likes

She said “my turn”… and didn’t miss 😮‍🔥✨
She watched the walk… studied it… then came back like THIS 👏🏽🔥 HalleMoves doesn’t just follow trends… she levels them up 💫 Confidence ✔️ Energy ✔️ Main character ✔️ This one? Yeah… different. #HalleMoves #KidInfluencer #MiniBoss #ConfidenceStartsYoung #DanceReels #ForYou
Halle Moves | Kid Influencer

Halle Moves | Kid Influencer

240 likes

Was I Wrong to Protect My Son’s Info?
My mom asked me to send her a photo of my 15 year old son’s birth certificate so she could open a bank account for him. At first it sounded harmless, like she was just trying to help. But something in my gut felt off. That document has his full legal name, date of birth, and all the details som
imnothere

imnothere

535 likes

A baby's legs and feet are visible on a changing table, partially covered by a light blanket, with sunlight shining on them. The changing table cover features black line drawings of a fox, leaves, and a teepee. Text overlay reads: "My sister says I crossed a boundary by changing my niece's diaper" and "Lemon8 @anastasia.willow7".
Wrong for doing this?
i was babysitting my 1-year-old niece when she pooped, so I changed her diaper. When my sister got back, she looked horrified and said a man shouldn’t change a girl’s diaper — even her husband “only does it in emergencies.” I told her I’m not watching any child if I have to “ask permission” to c
glazii

glazii

1967 likes

Your kid doesn’t need privacy. They need parenting
They call it “gentle parenting” now. But what I see… is moms scared to upset their kids. Afraid to say no. Afraid to check the phone. Afraid to be the bad guy. I check the tablet. I open the apps. I watch the videos. I watch the games. I will check his future phone. I will check the DMs.
brittany

brittany

1705 likes

An overhead view of a cozy living room featuring a white sofa with a sleeping dog, a wooden coffee table with books, and large windows. The text overlay reads: "I feel guilty for wanting her gone..."
Am I wrong for refusing my grandma to live with us
My grandpa passed away recently, and my grandma has been really down. She stayed with my uncle for a while, but a few days ago, she told me and my mom she wanted to come stay with us “for a week or two.” I was actually happy about it since I’ve always been close to her. But the moment she arrive
Elizabeth

Elizabeth

1233 likes

Am I wrong?
Hey! I figured I'd give this a try and ask your opinion. I'm the orange, sister in law black. Last night I made chicken and mac and cheese for dinner. My dad asked me to save his for lunch the next day, 3.5 decent-sized pieces. I said sure and put it away. Sister in law comes home and I
hiyabambi

hiyabambi

5511 likes

There’s something so wrong with me...
I’m jealous of an actual 18 yo and I hate every second of it. She started struggling with a mental disorder when she was 9, but she’s doing better now. She’s got a spot with the kid’s mental health team, adults who actually believe her. But when I was her age, I was drowning. No one in my corner
Millie✨

Millie✨

984 likes

Da kid not Mine (Billie Jean Cover) AI
lito.312

lito.312

0 likes

A birthday party scene with children holding a large yellow snake, an adult animal handler, and colorful 'HAPPY BIRTHDAY' balloons. An overlay reads 'I DIDN'T INVITE MY KID'S BULLY,' reflecting the article's theme of excluding a bully from the celebration.
Her teacher said I was being “inappropriate.”
My daughter’s turning 6, so I planned a surprise party and handed out invites to her whole class except one girl who’s been bullying her all year. She mocks her eyes, her Korean lunches, and even got physical. The teacher tries, but it never stops. I wasn’t risking my kid’s birthday being ruined
Leyna

Leyna

2441 likes

A wooden table displays multiple creme brulee desserts topped with raspberries, slices of chocolate cake, and mugs of coffee. The image includes the overlay text "Why My Kid's Granny Did This???", relating to the article's narrative.
She Pretends My Child Was Not There And Call My EX
Today was supposed to be a normal pick up. I drove to get my son from her place like always. After that, his grandma called my ex and told him I wanted to pick up my kid, and she doesn’t want to. When I arrived, I knocked and waited. No answer. I called. She picked up and said very calmly, “
heyynick

heyynick

23 likes

The image features Denzel Washington in a suit, smiling, with a younger version of himself in an inset. Text states he will turn 72 this year and shares his quote: "MOST PEOPLE IGNORE THIS:".
Denzel Washington is shown in character, sitting with a serious expression, holding a gun. The accompanying text expresses a wish for morality, respect, and intelligence to become trends again.
Denzel Washington, wearing a black jacket and a cross necklace, looks intently at the viewer. The text lists three types of people to never forget: those who helped, abandoned, or put you in hard times.
Denzel Washington was not wrong 😑 when he said this 🗣️💯
FOLLOW&LIKE&4MORE CONTENT🎥 I POST FOR THE COMMENTS🤣💭 #trending #viral #explore
RobTFA

RobTFA

1941 likes

She did him WRONG!
#friendzoned #datingadvice101 #romance
lavattsorchids

lavattsorchids

2493 likes

A person in a denim skirt gives a piggyback ride to a child in a blue top, while another child in yellow stands nearby. The image includes the text overlay: 'My husband's bsf is too involved with my kid' and 'Lemon8 @nicolette.revive'.
Am I wrong for kicking her out?
My husband’s childhood best friend used to help a lot with our baby—babysitting, bringing food, even refusing payment. I appreciated it… until I started noticing she was coming over at night when I was on shift. Yesterday, I came home to find my son calling her “mama.” I told her to leave, and s
Leyna

Leyna

503 likes

A desk setup shows a computer monitor displaying work applications, a white keyboard, and a mouse on a dark blue mousepad. Pink text overlaid on the image reads 'I GOT FIRED FOR WORKING TWO JOBS', reflecting the article's theme.
Is it not allowed to have two full-time jobs ?
I was working two full-time jobs to get ahead before my first kid arrives. I was doing fine balancing both and getting my work done. Then Job 2 found out about Job 1 through a former coworker, apparently. They fired me instantly… and the next day, they contacted Job 1. Guess what? Job 1 fired
Clariza

Clariza

970 likes

More please she said!?!?!
A toddler fav in our home (my oldest will snack on them as well) and it’s a great way to sneak in some veggies!! Chicken Broccoli Fritters Lb of ground chicken 1 Egg 1 cup bread crumbs Whatever spices you want to add Bag of broccoli cut into tiny tiny pieces Cheese (eye it some like
Momma K

Momma K

558 likes

Am i wrong?
the thing is, i always thought those types of people (people that have to make everything they do linked to lgbtq in some way) were extremely stupid and annoying, i never said it publicly but it was always in the back of my mind. I know we should not judge people for the way they decide to be ha
Sophia☘️

Sophia☘️

434 likes

A hand holds the "HOPELESS Necromantic" book by Shiloh Briar, featuring a man, a pink-haired woman, and a skeleton on the cover. Text overlay reads: "SHE RAISES HELL. HE RAISES THE DEAD. WHAT COULD POSSIBLY GO WRONG?".
SHE RAISES HELL. HE RAISES THE DEAD. WHAT COULD POSSIBLY GO WRONG?
RELEASING MAY 2026—When new recruit Helspira takes on the doomed mission that no other soldier wants, life—and death—start to get a little complicated. Helspira must play escort to Sikras—a frustratingly handsome necromancer with the power to raise the dead—as he attempts a mission that he’s fai
Jessie 🔪🖤🥀

Jessie 🔪🖤🥀

72 likes

rapper kid ink
rapper kid ink song name put on #fypシ゚viral #song 🎵🎧
shadow 09

shadow 09

0 likes

A view inside a bus with two people seated in the foreground, seen from behind. Overlay text reads: "I am not giving up my bus seat to a pregnant woman," accompanied by a sad face emoji and a broken heart emoji. The Lemon8 logo and username are visible.
She could’ve taken a cab — it’s not my job.
Yesterday, I took the bus downtown after being on my feet all morning. I sat near the front because I was exhausted. A few stops later, a visibly pregnant woman got on, looked around, and came straight to me asking for my seat. I said, “I’m sorry, I’m really tired too. I can’t give it up.” She r
💙Lucyy

💙Lucyy

138 likes

Am I wrong?
So a little back story. I was going on a weekend trip with a friend. But i was currently house sitting my grandparents house. so i went back home to grab a few things before i left for that weekend. when i walked in my step dad just started yelling at me. and i was so confused because i haven’t bee
Haley

Haley

3601 likes

Am I wrong want my kid get into private school?
My husband says it’s unfair to even consider private Christian school for our bio son just because his two older daughters (from previous relationships) likely won’t have the same opportunity. 💔 Here’s the thing: I’m not responsible for funding his other kids' education. We split essentials 50
notyourcarol

notyourcarol

3 likes

A woman with red and black hair, dark eye makeup, and a nose ring wears a black top with gold buttons, exposing her midriff. She has a confident expression. The text 'She Said What She Said!' is overlaid, and a Lemon8 logo is in the corner. The background shows a blurred crowd.
Ava, She Ain’t Wrong Either
About Charlie Kirk, Ava said, “ “If you want people to have kind words when you pass, you should say kind words while you’re alive.” And she’s 100% correct! He didn’t give minorities grace and love when he was alive, he was spewing hate. And for yall garnering sympathy for his wife, she shared his
L a n a i s Li 🧚🏽‍♀️

L a n a i s Li 🧚🏽‍♀️

29 likes

She said her order was wrong… watch what happens 😂
#fyp #food #funny #pizza #foodie Lugos NY Pizza
Lugo's New York Pizza

Lugo's New York Pizza

1875 likes

Rating Things My Niece Has Said
#youngest child #niecelove #toddlermom #quote I know everyone says this but she is the funniest kid I’ve ever met😂 Let me know if you want more in the comments because there is so many more quotes! ⬇️⬇️⬇️
dani<3

dani<3

339 likes

A close-up of a hand wearing a sparkling diamond engagement ring with a halo setting, against a blurred background of trees and sky. Text overlay reads: "He proposed with his ex's RING." The Lemon8 logo and username @aubreyjorge are also visible.
Am I wrong for wanting my own ring??
So here’s the deal. My boyfriend proposed during a trip and I said yes. But the ring? It was actually meant for his ex. I knew about it early in our relationship he tried to sell it, I even helped. But since resale value was low, he kept it. Now I can’t stop thinking about it. He once planned th
Aubrey

Aubrey

406 likes

Michael Jackson was not wrong when he said....
Michael Jackson wasn’t just a superstar — he was a symbol of perfection, pain, and unmatched dedication. From a very young age, he wasn’t living a normal childhood. While others played… he performed. While others rested… he practiced. He gave the world magic — but behind the scenes, he carried pres
Trending Topic

Trending Topic

1564 likes

Strict roommates or am I in the wrong?
for starters, i’m all for accountability, just not the blame game. these messages seem like pent up frustration that is being taken out on me all at once. this conversation started at 7:30am! i moved into this place last august and things were great until roommates number 1 started ignoring me out
bianca

bianca

1602 likes

A silhouette of a person sits on a swing, facing a vibrant sunset over water. An empty swing hangs beside them. The scene is bathed in warm orange and yellow light, conveying a sense of contemplation or solitude. A Lemon8 watermark is visible.
Am I the only one who thinks parents should never tell their kid
So basically whatever I’m sad or would do stuff my mom said something like oh it’s not about your feelings and you should stop having these feelings, but she never actually listens to you when I have to say something every time I’m actually tried to talk. She’s always like oh it’s not a bunch of fe
Love

Love

0 likes

Am I wrong?
AITA FOR NOT BABYSITTING MY SISTERS KID #aita #storytime #makeupstorytime
SelfCare Sister

SelfCare Sister

319 likes

Your slow-to-warm kid is not broken 🌱
She’s so shy.” I heard that about my kid at every birthday party, every playdate, every new class, and I could see her shrink a little every time someone said it. But here’s what I wish I had known sooner: slow to warm up is a temperament type, not a personality flaw. It’s been studied fo
Mom Wife Teacher Life

Mom Wife Teacher Life

15 likes

A cozy indoor scene shows a person relaxing on a dark sofa, with a round wooden coffee table in the foreground holding lit candles and books. In the background, a kitchen with dark cabinets is visible. Overlay text reads: "My dad's new wife called herself my kid's second mom."
I Stoped her because She’s Not…🤌
I told my dad’s new wife to stop calling herself my kid’s “second mom,” and now the whole family is acting like I caused a scene. I don’t hate her, she’s nice enough, but she’s been in our lives for five minutes. She didn’t carry my child, she didn’t raise them, she’s not co-parenting anything.
carsick

carsick

29 likes

Am I wrong for choosing my bf over my family?
Me and my bf have been together for almost three years and by the time we’re both 18 it’ll be about 3 and half to 4 years and I know I’m young, but I’ve had experiences with guys, I’ve only had two bf’s but I’ve also been through other stuff that I won’t talk about here and out of all of them (besi
Lovelygummy

Lovelygummy

4 likes

She Said What She Said...
Fellas, Don't Be Afraid To Date a Successful Woman. There's nothing wrong with approaching a woman with a Master's degree, PhD, or a career as a doctor, lawyer, CEO, nurse practitioner, or business owner. A strong, educated, hardworking woman isn't your competition, she can be
Crawford Dupree M.

Crawford Dupree M.

19 likes

I mean he’s not wrong!
#nokings #protest #donaldtrump #reminder
90s Kid

90s Kid

58 likes

She said she enjoyed it!
Favorreviews

Favorreviews

0 likes

Got accused for something I never did - AMA!
I used to work for an enrichment company where we’d go from school to school providing a thirty hour program. Really, it was meant for daycares. Our program started from age 2-VPK. I did the theater side but we also had a soccer program. It was the week before Thanksgiving back in 2022. I go to
✨ Karem ✨

✨ Karem ✨

3 likes

She changed, but I’m still not ready
Me and my sister have been no contact for years. She reached out recently saying she’s grown and wants to reconnect. I told her I’m happy she’s working on herself—but that doesn’t mean I’m ready to bring her back into my life. I told her part of real growth is accepting that not everyone will fo
Aubrey

Aubrey

17 likes

Didn’t bring kid home
For my daughter’s 10th birthday, we went to NYC—something we’ve done for years. She brought three friends, including a new girl, “Leah.” Beforehand I explained the rules: expect lots of walking, bring a bag, stick together, and no cabs unless necessary. The whole trip Leah complained first about
Isabella

Isabella

357 likes

A young child makes a funny face with text overlay "Kids Shows My Toddler Isn't Allowed To Watch" and "The REAL list..." against a blue sky, serving as the article's title image.
A streaming service screenshot shows Blippi in an orange outfit in a colorful bounce house, with the title "Blippi's Ultimate Bounce House Challenges" and episode details.
A streaming service screenshot displays Peppa Pig characters, with the show title "Peppa Pig" and episode information, reflecting the article's discussion of the show.
Kid shows I don’t allow my toddler to watch
These are some shows I don’t let my toddler watch. This is the REAL list not a joke like last time. Some of y’all got HEATED at my last post of this😂 The last post I posted the issues the shows had for kids and why it could be bad for them. Now if your child is well behaved and the show coul
Saige | Toddler mom✨🪴❤️

Saige | Toddler mom✨🪴❤️

139 likes

Things my mom Has said to me
She is usually 90% of the time sending me sentences that are spelt wrong or make no sense, but sometimes she is a little funny! #dearmom #lemon8contest #lovelettertomom
Harlye

Harlye

2099 likes

Husband said I “owe him” dinner since I don’t work
My husband came home yesterday, saw I hadn’t started dinner yet, and immediately snapped, “What have you even been doing all day?” All day? Let’s see: keeping a toddler alive, folding laundry, cleaning the bathroom, organizing toys, planning meals, and wiping up the same spill three times becaus
Natrol

Natrol

502 likes

A person and a child, both with emojis covering their faces, wear party hats (red and blue) while sitting together. The image features the text overlay: "Told my parents I won't babysit for free anymore," against a green background, illustrating the article's theme of refusing free babysitting.
Am I wrong for putting my foot down?
I used to be an only child, but once my parents started having more kids, everything changed. I got the smallest room, no more friends over, and eventually I was “volunteered” to babysit so they could have date nights. It started as once in a while… then became every week, hours at a time. They’
Luna🌛

Luna🌛

28 likes

Save this if your Kid's Lunchbox keeps coming home full 📌
What i was doing wrong: 🚫 packing what i thought she should eat 🚫 copying lunches i saw online 🚫 sneaking in "one new thing" every day that would end up not being touched what actually worked ✅ let her help plan her lunch the night before ✅ she picks from real kid frien
Candice I Lunchbox Hero App

Candice I Lunchbox Hero App

7 likes

Am I wrong for filing anyway?
Two months ago, my husband announced he “wasn’t happy anymore”, and wanted a divorce. He already had an apartment picked out. He said he needed “space to find himself”. I was devastated, but I accepted it. Fast forward: Last week he loses his job. Suddenly he’s saying “we should work things out
Loren

Loren

143 likes

A group of young people sit on a grassy lawn, one playing a guitar, with UCLA banners in the background. An exploding head emoji covers the guitarist's face. Overlay text reads: 'My best friend told her boyfriend my secret,' reflecting the article's theme of betrayed trust.
am i wrong for cutting her off?
My best friend of 7 years told her boyfriend a private secret I’d shared with her because she “wanted a second opinion.” I only found out when he made comments that made it clear he knew. When I confronted her, she brushed it off and said it wasn’t her fault. She still wanted to hang out when sh
Gazelle

Gazelle

27 likes

See more