I Said No, She’s Not My Kid. Am I Wrong?

My fiancé asked me last weekend if I could “just watch” his daughter for the day so he could go hunting with his friends. It’s just his hobby.

I paused. I like his daughter, but watching her isn’t casual. It’s a full day of responsibility, planning meals, keeping her entertained, making sure nothing goes wrong. And honestly? I had already planned my own quiet weekend.

When I said no, his mood flipped fast. He said I wasn’t being supportive and that “this is what families do.” That comment stuck with me.

We’re engaged, yes. But I’m not her parent. And I didn’t agree to be default childcare whenever he wants a day off. The part that hurt most wasn’t the request, it was how my boundary became a character flaw.

Where do you draw the line when it comes to helping… without disappearing yourself? Am I wrong?

#AskLemon8 #letschat #fiance #momsoflemon8 #relationshipadvice

2025/12/12 Edited to

... Read moreNavigating the responsibilities that come with a fiancé's child can be complex, especially when you're not a parent but are expected to step in as one. The request to babysit while your fiancé goes hunting highlights a common scenario where personal plans clash with family expectations. It's important to recognize that babysitting is more than just a favor; it requires energy, attention, and significant planning to ensure the child’s needs are met throughout the day. This responsibility can impact your well-being, especially if you’ve planned for your own downtime or have other commitments. Drawing boundaries is crucial. Saying no when you're unable or unwilling to babysit on short notice is not being unsupportive; rather, it's an expression of self-care. Healthy relationships involve clear communication where both partners respect each other's limits. Discuss with your fiancé how to share childcare responsibilities fairly. Perhaps establish a schedule or explore alternative care options so that your time is valued. It’s also essential that your fiancé understands that while "this is what families do" might reflect a cultural norm, every relationship defines family differently. Mutual respect and understanding help foster a supportive environment where your identity isn’t overshadowed by imposed duties. Maintaining your autonomy ensures that you don't disappear in the relationship dynamic, preserving your sense of self while supporting your blended family. Ultimately, feeling conflicted about these situations is normal, but prioritizing honest dialogue and boundary-setting will strengthen your partnership and personal well-being.

463 comments

jessicasc2490's images
jessicasc2490

if you marry someone with a child you are literally signing on to be a parent. Period. Otherwise move along to someone without children.

See more(20)
Marisela's images
Marisela

He's your fiancé. You are engaged. If you said yes to being his soon to be wife, then his daughter is going to become your daughter too! Obviously at some point you are going to have to take responsibility of taking care of her also. That's the point of marriage what is one of yours becomes both of yours. And you're both going to have to share certain responsibilities regardless if you want to or not.

See more(17)

See more comments