4 years in, he says he’ll never marry

My man and I have been together 4 years. We split rent, share pets, do holidays with each other’s families. I thought we were just taking our time and not skipping marriage entirely. I’d bring it up gently now and then, but he’d say, “Not yet” or “It’s not everything.” Then last month, he said it clear that he’ll never want to marry but he loves me and wants our life. I told him I do want that someday, building a family, the whole thing with him. I care so much, but can I wait 5 more years for something he’ll never give? What would you do?

#letschat #asklemon8 #RelationshipDilemma #MarriageOrNot

2025/7/16 Edited to

... Read moreDeciding whether to stay in a relationship when your partner has clearly stated he will never marry can be emotionally challenging and requires deep reflection. Even after sharing four years of life—splitting rent, caring for pets together, and celebrating holidays with each other's families—the absence of a shared vision for marriage can create an underlying tension. The phrase "AMIWASTING TIME?" often echoes in the minds of those facing this dilemma. It's important to recognize that marriage means different things to different people. For some, it symbolizes legal commitment and societal recognition, while for others, it may feel like an unnecessary institution. Your partner may love you and show commitment in daily actions, yet his decision against marriage could stem from personal beliefs, past experiences, or concerns about legal complications. In these situations, communication is paramount. Expressing your desires clearly and honestly, as you’ve done, allows both partners to understand each other's perspectives without assumptions. It’s equally vital to listen empathetically to your partner’s feelings about marriage. Seeking counsel from a relationship therapist or counselor can provide a neutral space to explore these differing viewpoints and assess if your goals and values align enough to build a future together without marriage. Furthermore, consider your own timeline and what compromises you are willing to make, if any. Evaluating your needs for building a family and the role marriage plays in that vision is essential. Some couples create family structures without traditional marriage, but clarity on legal and social implications is needed. Ultimately, no one should feel they are "wasting time" in love. However, mutual respect for each other's aspirations is necessary to avoid eventual resentment. If waiting indefinitely is unbearable because the prospect of marriage or its equivalent is non-negotiable for you, it may be healthier to reconsider the relationship for your emotional well-being and future happiness. Remember, whether to marry or not is a personal life choice, but compatibility in core values and future plans is key to a lasting partnership.

61 comments

SadieMae's images
SadieMae

fun fact: you can be a family and not get married. but if you want to get married, you've wasted 4 years of your life. find someone else.

bboomer22's images
bboomer22

Get out now. You both have different visions of your future. And if he hasn't married you yet knowing how important it is to you he's never going to. Don't waste the remaining of your life with this man. Find someone who has the same values as you. There is someone out there who is perfect for you.

See more(1)

See more comments