if only I had told her

if only I had told her

‼️‼️okay so after reading several comments, saying they wish they didn’t read them, THERE ARE SPOLIERS ‼️‼️ sorry 😭😂

#brokenhearted #books #bookrecommendations

2024/6/23 Edited to

... Read moreOkay, so let's talk about 'If Only I Had Told Her' because my mind is still reeling from it! Like that page eighty-four, with the poignant passage about footsteps, silence, and a mother's words—it truly hit me hard. It was one of those moments where you just feel a deep ache in your chest, instantly understanding why so many people are saying 'This whole heartedly broke me.' This isn't just another romance; it's an emotional journey that leaves a lasting imprint on your soul, definitely one for the #brokenhearted club. The story of Autumn and Finny? Absolutely captivating. Their connection felt so real, so raw, and that's what made the eventual heartbreak so profound. I found myself rooting for them every step of the way, feeling every high and every crushing low. It’s rare for a book to evoke such a powerful response in me, making me ponder their choices and the 'if onlys' long after I closed the cover. Their dynamic perfectly encapsulates what makes emotional romance books so compelling – the deep connection, the inevitable trials, and the sheer vulnerability of love. You can feel the weight of their unspoken words and hidden feelings, almost like a 'shhh don't let her find out' kind of secret that slowly unravels. What truly resonated with me were the subtle nuances and the way the author crafted moments of profound sadness. Those quiet instances, like the one mentioned in the OCR, where the weight of unspoken words or missed opportunities becomes almost unbearable. It reminded me that heartbreak isn't always a dramatic symphony; sometimes it's found in the delicate echoes of silence or the memory of a mother's gentle advice. This book truly explores the many facets of grief and love, making it incredibly sad and relatable. It’s not just about the grand gestures, but the small, everyday moments that weave together to form a truly tragic narrative. Comparing it to other emotional love story books I've devoured, 'If Only I Had Told Her' stands out for its raw honesty. It doesn't shy away from the pain, but rather embraces it, inviting you to feel every single emotion alongside the characters. It made me think about how some stories become 'locations' in our minds, symbolizing heartbreak literature itself—places we revisit mentally long after the final page. This book is definitely one of those. It’s a testament to how powerful a narrative can be when it delves deep into human connections and the consequences of our choices. I’ve read many books where heartbreak is a central theme, but this one truly hit different. It's not just about the ending, but the entire build-up, the characters' growth through those crucial chapters, and the way their fates intertwine. It makes you think about how our words and actions, or lack thereof, can shape our entire lives. For anyone who loves a good cry and a story that will stick with them, I honestly can't recommend 'If Only I Had Told Her' enough. Just be prepared for an emotional rollercoaster, because those quotes and moments will take you on a journey you won't soon forget, making you reflect on what it means to be truly brokenhearted.

103 comments

Alexis's images
Alexis

I literally JUST sat “if he had been with me” down 😭 the ending had me sobbing

See more(1)

See more comments

Related posts

A hand holds the book 'If Only I Had Told Her' by Laura Nowlin. The white cover features the title in black text and a prominent red rose. The author is noted as the #1 New York Times bestselling author of 'If He Had Been With Me'. The text 'my heart will break all over again..' is overlaid.
if only i had told her🥀
my first post here and i felt this was necessaryy! i preordered if only i had told her after i finished if he had been with me. the first book left me bawling my eyes out i could only imagine this one😅 #books #ifonlyihadtoldher #ifhehadbeenwithme
emmajade

emmajade

569 likes

A hand holds the book 'If Only I Had Told Her' by Laura Nowlin, featuring a red rose on the cover. Overlays include 'Book Review', 'His POV', 'Friends to lovers', and a three-star rating, all on a light-colored bedsheet background.
Book Review: If Only I Had Told Her
You guyssss! I randomly decided to read if he had been with me two weeks ago and zoomed through it in two days without knowing there was a second on the way! Obviously I had to grab it to read Finnys - I’m half way through and right now I’m preferring the first over this. Thoughts? 📖🥀 #Lemon8Di
MarySylvia Fain

MarySylvia Fain

220 likes

The book cover for Laura Nowlin's 'If Only I Had Told Her' is displayed, featuring a minimalist design with a red rose. The cover is surrounded by a border of vibrant red roses and dark green leaves, with a Lemon8 watermark.
Tender Reads: If Only I Had Told Her 🕊️✨
I had finished Laura Nowlin’s If Only I Had Told Her back in August too and I’m still sitting with all the feelings. This was a 4.9 star read for me. ✨ Vibe: quiet, heart-aching romance ✨ Best for: fans of If He Had Been With Me or bittersweet YA love stories ✨ Perfect pairing: chamomile te
TheMalerieverse

TheMalerieverse

23 likes

this has SPOILERS from if only if I had told her!!
#sadbooks #crying #ifhehadbeenwithme YALL,when I say i was crying, i was NUMB...this book is so sad,I cried most in jacks pov.If he had been with me, damaged you..THEN BEWARE OF THIS BOOK. (P.S. This book was so good, and it's was sad but still so good) ⭐️Overall rating: 10000/10
batman

batman

142 likes

If only I had told her
#book #booktok #bookaesthetic #booksoflemon8 #bookstagram #bookwormsoflemon8 #travelwithme2024 #healthylifestyle2024
Sanita ✿

Sanita ✿

27 likes

A Kindle e-reader displays the title 'if only i had told her' by Laura Nowlin, resting on a gray blanket. The text 'MY FAVORITE QUOTES' is overlaid at the top.
A quote about a soul existing ecstatically in the universe is overlaid on a dark, cloudy sky with a partial solar eclipse visible.
A quote about loving someone for being funny, smart, and weird is overlaid on a vibrant pink liquid with bubbles, possibly a bath.
Best Quotes from If Only I Had Told Her
hey y’all! this book was so incredibly good and shocking and sad and i loved it so much, i thought id share my favorite quotes from it with you!! i highly reccomend this book and finished it so so fast! #bookquotes #ifonlyihadtoldher #education #lemon8bookclub #lemon8partner
Eli

Eli

25 likes

A copy of Laura Nowlin's book "If Only I Had Told Her" with a dark red rose on its cover rests on a light-colored surface. A pink fluffy blanket is next to it, with a remote, charging cable, and a pink animal cable protector in the background. A white heart sticker is overlaid.
If Only I had Told Her
#ifonlyihadtoldher #ifhehadbeenwithme #lauranowlin #book #books #booksoflemon8
Jassy

Jassy

8 likes

A book cover for 'If Only I Had Told Her' by Laura Nowlin, featuring a dark red rose and stem on a light background. Red text 'CURRENTLY READING' and white sparkle graphics are overlaid.
If Only I Had Told Her
Current read! And to say heartbreaking is an understatement for me 🥺 I read the first one and it was just so sad. Half way through this book. It’s definitely a 10/10 reccommended read. #currentlyreading #lemon8bookclub #ifonlyihadtoldher #if he had been with me
Mauricionaaa

Mauricionaaa

9 likes

IF ONLY I HAD TOLD HER
this book had me sobbing😭 what’s your currents reads? #recentread #current read 📚 #whatimreading
kennedy

kennedy

6 likes

If only I had told her - Laura nowlin
Page 147 line 8 “Whatever our souls are made of, hers and mine are the same” -I screamed literally screaming #ifonlyihadtoldher ⭐️Overall rating: 500/5 :saddest book ever especially after reading the first book ( #ifhehadbeenwithme ) and I love the writing style! edit: page 172 line 21
Tierra Morris

Tierra Morris

23 likes

A close-up of a book cover titled "if only i had told her" by Laura Nowlin, featuring a red rose with a stem and leaves. An overlay reads "My thought" and "lemon8 @lustunique", indicating a personal book review.
My Thoughts : “if only I had told her”
This book gives us everyone’s pov which is cool. I love how they brought in Jack. It is a pretty emotional story. (No crying, over here though 😂) The passion the characters have for each other is on par 🫶🏽. I’m sad how the main characters were oblivious😞. Because things could’ve took a different tu
neka lashay

neka lashay

9 likes

Currently reading- If Only I Had Told Her
Whew. After, “If He Had Been With Me”, I’m really not 100% sure I’m ready for the next book.. I’m kinda bitter against the author, it’s not entirely her fault that I fell so hard for their story that I cried like it was me in Autumns room on August 8th… it’s also not her fault that I imagined a h
🌸Leta💖

🌸Leta💖

6 likes

A bookshelf displays several books including 'King of Greed,' 'King of Pride,' 'King of Wrath,' 'if only i had told her,' 'if he had been with me,' and 'Fifty Shades' series. A flute-playing figurine and a turtle figurine are on top, with a 'fresh SUGAR' box nearby. The text overlay reads 'My current Reads'.
Three books by Laura Nowlin are arranged on a patterned blanket. An open copy of 'if only i had told her' is central, flanked by 'if he had been with me' and a red Barnes & Noble exclusive edition of 'if only i had told her.' The text overlay says 'Finny's perspective (#2)'.
An open book displays a page with highlighted quotes from 'if only i had told her,' including phrases like 'And you're so beautiful,' 'Sweet Autumn,' and 'Then everything is going to be okay. We're together now, right?'. Page number 115 is visible.
My current read: If only I had told her
📖 Name of the Book: If only I had told her 📄 Plot: In the summer after graduation Autumn and Finny finally reconnect and are ready to be more than friends. But everything changes the night of August 8, where she is left to rely on all of her strength to get through this. 📖 Genre: young adult lit
nvenus

nvenus

33 likes

if only I had told her
#booklemon8 #booklemon #bookreview #sadbooks #yabooks #Lemon8Diary #readingjournal
Christina 🫶📚

Christina 🫶📚

2 likes

Should I read ‘if only I had told her’?
#sad #ifonlyihadtoldher #if he had been with me #lauranowlin #books #comment #Lemon8 #lemon8bookclub #mustread #booksforlife📖
Di0R

Di0R

3 likes

Book Review If Only I Had Told Her
The number one lesson to take away from this book is to have the courage to speak your truth 🥺 If Only I Had Told Her ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ If you haven’t read If He Had Been With Me, I recommend reading that first as this is book is from a different characters POV. This book takes off with putting us r
Gaby

Gaby

4 likes

If Only I Had Told Her
Starting part 2, already cried my eyes out; not ready to sob #ifhehadbeenwithme #autumnandfinny #fyp
✨💫ShyanneRose📚📖

✨💫ShyanneRose📚📖

4 likes

A hand holds the red cover of the book "If Only I Had Told Her" by Laura Nowlin, featuring a rose illustration and a "Barnes & Noble Exclusive" sticker. Text overlays indicate "My Thoughts: If Only I Had Told Her" and "Rating: 5/5". Bookshelves filled with various books are in the background.
My Thoughts on If Only I Had Told Her 💔📝
My Thoughts on If Only I Had Told Her by Laura Nowlin💓📝 📖 Name of the Book: If Only I had Told Her 📖 Genre: Young Adult, Romance 📄 My Favorite Quotes: “Whatever our souls are made of, hers and mine are the same.” 💭 My Thoughts: I’d recommend this duo-logy to everyone (both the first boo
nicole

nicole

7 likes

i finished “if only i had told her”
i actually finished it a bit ago and forgot to post. ⚠️spoiler warning for first and second book⚠️ LOVE LOVE LOVE it was a bit sadder bc we could see finnys funeral, etc. it was super good tho. we saw autumn make a new friend and also get back to hanging out with angie. i’m glad the ending of t
ayla🫶🏻

ayla🫶🏻

3 likes

if he had been with me/if only I had told her
#brokensouls #stilltheone #lemon8bookclub #fyp #Lemon8Diary #if he had been with me #sadbooks #death #bestfriend My Current Read 📖 Name of the Book: If he had been with me 📄 Plot: childhood friends 📖 Genre: romance novel 💭 My Thoughts: amazing/sad ⭐ Star Rating: 4/5⭐
lala_luv<3

lala_luv<3

6 likes

The book cover for 'if only i had told her' by Laura Nowlin, featuring a red rose with a thorny stem, rests on a textured pink blanket. Light blue flower emojis are scattered around the image.
An open book, 'if only i had told her', displays highlighted passages in various colors. Text overlays indicate the book is better than the first and is rated highly.
Two stacked books, with 'if only i had told her' on top, are marked with numerous colorful sticky tabs. A light blue highlighter rests on the top book, with text stating it was loved more than the first.
If Only I Had Been Told Her🤎
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️✨THIS BOOK HAS MY HEARTTTT! i literally fell in love with the way she wrote out finny and jacks pov! THIS ACTUALLY MADE ME CRYYYY, simply because i related so much with his death because i have a cousin who died in the most uncanny similar way so i was sobbing soo badd. She really embodie
monai💕

monai💕

12 likes

If only I had told her! 🫶
My Current Read 📖 Name of the Book: if only I had told her 📖 Genre: romance 💭 My Thoughts: I cried at the end. It’s a good book! The first one is good too! ⭐ Star Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Scarlett💕🥰

Scarlett💕🥰

4 likes

if he had been with me ❣️
10/10🩷 I loved the book so much, even though it shattered my heart. I read the second book, I loved it so much, but I started crying, lol. And my friend was with me, and she was telling me, " It's a book. The characters are fake. " lmao. However, if you can't do sad books, then i
♡ Rebecca ♡

♡ Rebecca ♡

5 likes

🥀IF ONLY I HAD TOLD HER🥀 - laura nowlin
I’m sure most of you know about if he had been with me by laura nowlin And for those who have read it and loved it like me, my heart breaks with you. For those who have committed to the story of Finny and Autumn and bought the second book, in Finny’s perspective, I am so interested in your
Olivia Colette

Olivia Colette

8 likes

A collage featuring the book cover for 'If Only I Had Told Her' by Laura Nowlin, which shows a red rose and stem. The collage also includes romantic and melancholic imagery, such as couples kissing, red roses, a ghost figure, and the quote 'sometimes sad things are beautiful' by Laura Nowlin, reflecting the book's themes of love and loss. The bottom left corner includes the Lemon8 logo and username @brittsbook_shelf.
If Only I Had Told Her- Review
Book Review: If Only I Had Told Her ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5) This book was an emotional whirlwind from start to finish. After reading the first installment, I spent days mourning and processing what had happened, so I knew that diving into Finn’s perspective would be nothing short of devastating—and it was,
Little Crow 🐦‍⬛

Little Crow 🐦‍⬛

4 likes

A book review for 'If Only I Had Told Her' by Laura Nowlin, featuring a 3-star rating and the comment 'Cute but didn't need it.' The book cover with a red rose is shown, alongside quotes like 'We're just being close one last time' and 'If only I'd told her that I loved her years ago.'
If only I had told her..
I could have went without reading this part of the story. I like reading Finns chapters, but should have stopped there. Kind of feel like i wasted a coiple days reading. Overall ⭐️⭐️⭐️ If only l'd told her that I loved her years ago, then I wouldn't be here now. Finn has always loved Aut
💜Wendy Nicole💛

💜Wendy Nicole💛

1 like

SPOILERS FROM IF ONLY I HAD TOLD HER!!
#Lemon8Box
Sage Love

Sage Love

0 likes

Current Read: If Only I Had Told Her
#bookwormsoflemon8 #lemon8challenge I finished if only he had been with me not that long ago and after taking a few days to process my emotions (iykyk) I was so excited to jump right into if only I had told her. I’ll be honest, it’s a bit of a hard read since I ultimately know how the story
Amy Havens

Amy Havens

10 likes

The book cover for "If Only I Had Told Her" by Laura Nowlin, featuring a red background with a single red rose and its stem. A gold Barnes & Noble Exclusive sticker is visible, indicating special content. The author is noted as the #1 New York Times bestselling author of "If He Had Been With Me".
IF ONLY I HAD TOLD HER 🥀
📚 Title and Author: If Only I Had Told Her - By: Laura Nowlin 🌟 Genre: Romance, Fiction, Young Adult, Mental Health Key Point #1 : Jack was doing a little too much in my opinion. Like how could you even try to blame Autumn for Finny’s Death when all she tried to do was love him & be with
Muvalingling

Muvalingling

2 likes

The book cover for "if only i had told her" by Laura Nowlin, featuring a red rose with a broken stem on a light blue background, resting on a colorful patchwork quilt.
A page from the book "if only i had told her" describing a coffin being lowered into a grave, with page number 189 visible, partially on a patchwork quilt.
A page from the book "if only i had told her" detailing a burial scene where people throw dirt into a grave, and the narrator reflects on Finn's final resting place.
If only I had told her 🖤
#ifonlyihadtoldher #sadbooks #booktok #foryoupage
Ashlie 🕊🖤

Ashlie 🕊🖤

2 likes

A book review graphic featuring the cover of "If Only I Had Told Her" by Laura Nowlin, which shows a red rose and stem. Text overlays read "MY HONEST", "Rating: 4/5", and "BOOK REVIEW", with a red background and white heart accents.
🍋Book Review🍋 If Only I Had Told Her
Short Summary: The sequel book to If He Had Been With Me starts at Finn's narrative three days before his death. He explores the progress of his unrequited love for best friend Autumn up until the day he finally expresses his feelings. Finn's story ends with his tragic death, which leaves h
Nancy Baten

Nancy Baten

6 likes

The front cover of the book "If Only I Had Told Her" by Laura Nowlin, featuring a dark red rose with a broken stem and scattered petals on a light, textured background. The author is identified as a #1 New York Times bestselling author.
The back cover of "If Only I Had Told Her," displaying the book's synopsis about Finn, Autumn, and Sylvie, and mentioning it's told from three perspectives. It includes a quote, ISBN, price, and publisher information.
An open page of the book showing the "author's note." The text describes the author's initial process of writing Finn's perspective for "If He Had Been with Me" before focusing on Autumn's story.
If only I had told her by Laura nowlin
I’m starting the second book again because I just finished the first and loved it and now I’ll understand this book better! What’s y’all thoughts 💭? Has anyone read this or are you going too? #booktok #book recommendations
Katie

Katie

5 likes

If only Reviewers
If he had been with me 3/5 It was a good book the ending was a bit sad but I think it shouldn’t have been so choppy like the past and present back to forth confused me a bit sometimes. If only I had told her 5/5 This book was amazing it wasn’t choppy like the first one, it does make you cry
Kaylene ❤️

Kaylene ❤️

1 like

A book review graphic for "If Only I Had Told Her" by Laura Nowlin, featuring the title in black text and a broken red rose. It includes a "Book Review: 10/10" rating and states "SUCH A GOOD/SAD READ".
If Only I Had Told Her💋
This book was most definitely a tear jerker🥲🥲 I absolutely love Finny as a character. I enjoyed this book a lot more than the first one. I highly recommend reading this one if you’ve read If He Had Been With Me. I most definitely cried through the whole book😭😭 I LOVE this series so much!
MattieGrace🩷🫶

MattieGrace🩷🫶

3 likes

The image displays the book cover for 'if only i had told her' by Laura Nowlin, author of 'if he had been with me'. The cover features a vibrant red rose with a stem and leaves against a light, textured background. A Lemon8 watermark is visible in the bottom left corner.
A book I had to DNF
I absolutely loved the first one but I cannot get through Finny’s POV. Can someone tell me if it’s worth to keep going or not? #dnfbook #ifonlyihadtoldher #if he had been with me #finnyspov #finnyautumn
Maddie🩷

Maddie🩷

25 likes

If only I had told her by Laura Nowlin
This one was for sure a fast read again like the first one was. It kept bringing me in all the time. I didn’t want to stop reading. I loved seeing the different perspective of difference characters. I also did enjoy seeing the development of some of the characters and how they had matured over the
Mariflor Flores

Mariflor Flores

2 likes

i finished if he had been with me…
oh my gosh this book broke me. i cried for so long afterwards i can’t even explain. i am reading the sequel and i would genuinely what happens as im reading until i got to the part. the sequel is just the story from finn and jacks point of view, we get to see alot more of the story ❤️ ⭐️Overall
ayla🫶🏻

ayla🫶🏻

4 likes

A person holds a red book slipcase titled "The BookTok sensations" featuring two books by Laura Nowlin: "if he had been with me" and "if only i had told her." Both book covers display red rose imagery.
If he had been with me & if only I told her
I finished if he had been with me and I absolutely loved it . I am currently reading if only I had told her .
Beautifulsunflower97

Beautifulsunflower97

5 likes

A book cover for "If Only I Had Told Her" by Laura Nowlin, featuring a red rose. Text overlays highlight themes of friends to lovers, grief, loss, depression, suicide, and romance. It is a #1 New York Times bestseller.
If I had only told her by Laura Nowlin
#lostlovepoetry #ifihadtoldher #booktok #booktok #book recommendations
Katie🦋

Katie🦋

11 likes

Book Review : If he had been with me
Book Review Book name: if he had been with me Author: Laura Nowlin Genre: young adult My rating: 4.5 /5 💰Price: 10.99 at Barnes and Noble My review: What I think about this book it’s good in point of view of Autumn one of the main characters. The setting is high school drama . It’s a fr
Ashley

Ashley

7 likes

A flat lay image shows an e-reader displaying the book 'if he had been with me' by Laura Nowlin, with a 'BOOK REVIEW' overlay. A daisy and a Lemon8 BookClub ticket with a 4-star rating and notes 'will make you cry, but it's so sweet!!' are also visible on a textured brown background.
if he had been with me
#bookwormsoflemon8 #lemon8challenge this was my first read of 2025 and oh my GOSH was it a good one. I saw so so much of my younger self in the main girl, Autumn. reading it was like going into the past and giving teenage me a hug. obviously the plot strayed a little far from the issues tha
Amy Havens

Amy Havens

8 likes

i told Aaliyah your mother don't love you
your mother had something against you ever since you was 15 years old and this is what I told her 1998 I said Aaliyah you need to wake up and see the truth before it's too late for your soul your family is going to be your biggest downfall if you keep chasing behind them you can't save them
Aaliyah my wife loves me

Aaliyah my wife loves me

4 likes

Book Rating: If he had been with me
I sobbed
Kaitd

Kaitd

1 like

A woman applies mascara in a round, illuminated mirror, with the title 'Hygiene Tips Your mom may not have told you' overlaid. The image serves as the cover for an article on hygiene advice.
This image features a showerhead spraying water and a hand brushing wet hair, alongside text providing 'Shower/Body Care' tips, including exfoliation, soap usage, and loofah alternatives.
The image displays a person applying oil to their leg and another person from behind with a towel on their head, accompanying text on 'Shaving Tips' such as exfoliation, using shaving oil, and moisturizing.
Hygiene Tips Your Mom Never Told You 🧼🧼
Most of these I had to find out on my own just through life! Some of these topics can feel uncomfy to talk about (especially with your parents) but who else will you learn it from?! We have to de-stigmatize stuff like this because these conversations are really important for young girls and there’s
alaudano

alaudano

18.8K likes

A hand holds the book "if he had been with me" by Laura Nowlin. The dark cover features two lollipops, one red heart-shaped and one broken, with a 20% off sticker. The book is part of a series mentioned in the article.
If He Had Been With Me series by Laura Nowlin
Swipe to see the other book i have read, If Only I Had Told Her. I give both if these books a 8.5/10. I enjoyed these two reads. This one is sad and it's like a tragic love story. Usually if you're into these kind of stories, then you'll enjoy it, but if not, then you won't like
Alexis Hoke

Alexis Hoke

12 likes

A person holds a potted plant, partially visible behind a white overlay. The overlay displays the text: "ACCEPT PEOPLE AS THEY ARE, BUT PLACE THEM WHERE THEY BELONG." The Lemon8 logo, username @dangerouslysafe27, and hashtag #lynchlifehacks are also visible.
Had to put someone you love on the sidelines?
I’ll go first. I had a friend in my gaggle of gal pals who, for whatever reason, began to be mean and disrespectful to only me. I chose to continue to love her, but remove her from my social life. I told my friends to continue to do things with her, but if she was joining them, I would bow out. Eve
Cyna

Cyna

0 likes

A black collector's edition of "If He Had Been With Me" by Laura Nowlin stands upright, topped with a golden tiara. It rests on two other books, including "If Only I Had Told Her." The cover features red and white illustrations of windows, hearts, and books.
If He Had Been With me Book review ❤️
Author: Laura Nowlin Overall rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️- 4/5 Spice: 🌶️ Favorite Quote💭: “This book is a treasure; I did not suspect it would be so good when I picked it up, but now I can feel the printed words seeping through my skin and into my veins, rushing to my heart and marking it forever.” I p
Lily Tavares

Lily Tavares

32 likes

things i wish people had told me about college pt2
cause y’all seemed to really like the last one i wanted to share some more #collegediaries #collegestudent #collegelife #collegetips #college
Stephanie

Stephanie

35 likes

See more