My current read: If only I had told her

📖 Name of the Book: If only I had told her

📄 Plot: In the summer after graduation Autumn and Finny finally reconnect and are ready to be more than friends. But everything changes the night of August 8, where she is left to rely on all of her strength to get through this.

📖 Genre: young adult literature

📄 My Favorite Quotes: “Sweet Autumn”

💭 My Thoughts: This is a great book. While reading the first book I always wondered what was Finny thinking or what was Finny doing. This book covered most of that. It’s a very emotional book (or maybe I’m just very emotional, who knows). Although I’m only 50% done with the book, I can tell you that it’s an amazing book. There have been times where I have to put it down because I was physically hurting, that’s how great Nowlin’s writing is. I like that there is more than one perspective on this book because it helps you understand things from multiple points of view and helps you understand the reason for most things.

⭐ Star Rating: 5⭐️

#Lemon8Diary #currentlyreading #lemon8challenge #ifhehadbeenwithme #lauranowlin #ifonlyihadtoldher

2024/3/11 Edited to

... Read moreOkay, so if you've stumbled upon 'If Only I Had Told Her' and are wondering where to start, you're not alone! Many readers, myself included, discover Laura Nowlin's incredible work through this book. But here's a little secret: 'If Only I Had Told Her' is actually the companion novel to her first book, 'If He Had Been With Me'. While you can certainly enjoy 'If Only I Had Told Her' on its own, reading 'If He Had Been With Me' first really enhances the experience. It gives you Autumn's full story, and then 'If Only I Had Told Her' beautifully dives into Finny's perspective, offering a heart-wrenching look at the same events from his eyes. It’s like getting two sides of an incredibly emotional coin, and it truly makes you understand the depth of their connection and the tragedy that unfolds. Speaking of that tragedy, the plot, as hinted in my initial review, centers around Autumn and Finny, childhood friends who finally realize their feelings for each other right after graduation. But then August 8th changes everything. What unfolds is a truly poignant story about first love, loss, and the devastating impact of a single moment. Reading about Autumn and Finny, and seeing how their lives intertwine, felt incredibly real. Laura Nowlin masterfully crafts these characters, making you feel every pang of their joy and sorrow. You might find yourself wondering, just like I did, what Finny was thinking or feeling during crucial moments in 'If He Had Been With Me', and this book delivers those insights in a raw, honest way. Now, for a question many of you might have: 'Is If Only I Had Told Her spicy or smutty?' Given it's a young adult novel, I can tell you that while the romance is intense and deeply emotional, it focuses more on the emotional connection and the profound bond between Autumn and Finny rather than explicit scenes. It’s a powerful love story, but its 'spice' comes from the depth of feeling and the heartbreak, not from sexual content. This is a book that will make your heart ache in the best way possible, exploring themes of grief, regret, and the 'love arrives too late' trope that is just so beautifully tragic. The beauty of this book also lies in its exploration of themes like destiny and the different perspectives on a shared past. Seeing events through Finny's eyes, after experiencing them through Autumn's, adds so much richness and complexity. It’s a testament to Nowlin's writing that she can make you feel such profound empathy for both characters. If you found yourself caught up in phrases like "Sweet Autumn" or the raw emotion of their story, you know what I mean. If you loved the emotional depth of 'If Only I Had Told Her' and are searching for similar reads, I highly recommend exploring other powerful YA contemporary novels that tackle heavy themes and first loves. Books like 'They Both Die at the End' by Adam Silvera, 'The Fault in Our Stars' by John Green, or even 'Five Feet Apart' by Rachael Lippincott and Mikki Daughtry offer similar emotional journeys. These stories, much like Laura Nowlin's work, delve into the complexities of young love and loss, leaving a lasting impact. Getting to read about Finny's perspective was truly an experience I won't forget.

11 comments

Captain Lemon8's images
Captain Lemon8

This is so cool! Welcome to the community✨ 💫

Related posts

Current Read: If Only I Had Told Her
#bookwormsoflemon8 #lemon8challenge I finished if only he had been with me not that long ago and after taking a few days to process my emotions (iykyk) I was so excited to jump right into if only I had told her. I’ll be honest, it’s a bit of a hard read since I ultimately know how the story
Amy Havens

Amy Havens

10 likes

A close-up of a book cover titled "if only i had told her" by Laura Nowlin, featuring a red rose with a stem and leaves. An overlay reads "My thought" and "lemon8 @lustunique", indicating a personal book review.
My Thoughts : “if only I had told her”
This book gives us everyone’s pov which is cool. I love how they brought in Jack. It is a pretty emotional story. (No crying, over here though 😂) The passion the characters have for each other is on par 🫶🏽. I’m sad how the main characters were oblivious😞. Because things could’ve took a different tu
neka lashay

neka lashay

9 likes

The book cover for Laura Nowlin's 'If Only I Had Told Her' is displayed, featuring a minimalist design with a red rose. The cover is surrounded by a border of vibrant red roses and dark green leaves, with a Lemon8 watermark.
Tender Reads: If Only I Had Told Her 🕊️✨
I had finished Laura Nowlin’s If Only I Had Told Her back in August too and I’m still sitting with all the feelings. This was a 4.9 star read for me. ✨ Vibe: quiet, heart-aching romance ✨ Best for: fans of If He Had Been With Me or bittersweet YA love stories ✨ Perfect pairing: chamomile te
TheMalerieverse

TheMalerieverse

23 likes

Currently reading- If Only I Had Told Her
Whew. After, “If He Had Been With Me”, I’m really not 100% sure I’m ready for the next book.. I’m kinda bitter against the author, it’s not entirely her fault that I fell so hard for their story that I cried like it was me in Autumns room on August 8th… it’s also not her fault that I imagined a h
🌸Leta💖

🌸Leta💖

6 likes

An open book displays page eighty-four with a poignant passage about footsteps, silence, and a mother's words. An overlay reads "This whole heartedly broke me.." with a broken heart emoji, reflecting the emotional impact of the text. A Lemon8 watermark is visible.
if only I had told her
if only I had told her ‼️‼️okay so after reading several comments, saying they wish they didn’t read them, THERE ARE SPOLIERS ‼️‼️ sorry 😭😂 #brokenhearted #books #bookrecommendations
20laurel04

20laurel04

715 likes

A book cover for 'If Only I Had Told Her' by Laura Nowlin, featuring a dark red rose and stem on a light background. Red text 'CURRENTLY READING' and white sparkle graphics are overlaid.
If Only I Had Told Her
Current read! And to say heartbreaking is an understatement for me 🥺 I read the first one and it was just so sad. Half way through this book. It’s definitely a 10/10 reccommended read. #currentlyreading #lemon8bookclub #ifonlyihadtoldher #if he had been with me
Mauricionaaa

Mauricionaaa

9 likes

A hand holds the book 'If Only I Had Told Her' by Laura Nowlin, featuring a red rose on its cover, against a white hexagonal bookshelf filled with books. The image has a large orange 'BOOK REVIEW' overlay.
A book review graphic for 'If Only I Had Told Her' by Laura Nowlin, showing the book cover, title, author, and a positive review highlighting multiple character perspectives and emotional depth.
A book rating guide with five rows of stars, each corresponding to a different level of reader engagement, from 'unfinished' to 'occupies my thoughts long after reading'.
If Only I Had Told Her | ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Synopsis: If Only I Had Told Her revisits the story of If He Had Been With Me, this time through multiple perspectives. The novel gives readers Finn’s point of view leading up to the tragedy, followed by Autumn’s and Jack’s perspectives in the aftermath. Through these voices, the story explores gri
cerisevape

cerisevape

22 likes

A hand holds the book 'If Only I Had Told Her' by Laura Nowlin, featuring a red rose on the cover. Overlays include 'Book Review', 'His POV', 'Friends to lovers', and a three-star rating, all on a light-colored bedsheet background.
Book Review: If Only I Had Told Her
You guyssss! I randomly decided to read if he had been with me two weeks ago and zoomed through it in two days without knowing there was a second on the way! Obviously I had to grab it to read Finnys - I’m half way through and right now I’m preferring the first over this. Thoughts? 📖🥀 #Lemon8Di
MarySylvia Fain

MarySylvia Fain

220 likes

Should I read ‘if only I had told her’?
#sad #ifonlyihadtoldher #if he had been with me #lauranowlin #books #comment #Lemon8 #lemon8bookclub #mustread #booksforlife📖
Di0R

Di0R

3 likes

if he had been with me/if only I had told her
#brokensouls #stilltheone #lemon8bookclub #fyp #Lemon8Diary #if he had been with me #sadbooks #death #bestfriend My Current Read 📖 Name of the Book: If he had been with me 📄 Plot: childhood friends 📖 Genre: romance novel 💭 My Thoughts: amazing/sad ⭐ Star Rating: 4/5⭐
lala_luv<3

lala_luv<3

6 likes

A hand holds the red cover of the book "If Only I Had Told Her" by Laura Nowlin, featuring a rose illustration and a "Barnes & Noble Exclusive" sticker. Text overlays indicate "My Thoughts: If Only I Had Told Her" and "Rating: 5/5". Bookshelves filled with various books are in the background.
My Thoughts on If Only I Had Told Her 💔📝
My Thoughts on If Only I Had Told Her by Laura Nowlin💓📝 📖 Name of the Book: If Only I had Told Her 📖 Genre: Young Adult, Romance 📄 My Favorite Quotes: “Whatever our souls are made of, hers and mine are the same.” 💭 My Thoughts: I’d recommend this duo-logy to everyone (both the first boo
nicole

nicole

7 likes

If only I had told her! 🫶
My Current Read 📖 Name of the Book: if only I had told her 📖 Genre: romance 💭 My Thoughts: I cried at the end. It’s a good book! The first one is good too! ⭐ Star Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Scarlett💕🥰

Scarlett💕🥰

4 likes

Last Read vs Current Read
#currentread #tbr #bookclub #booklover
Christina

Christina

2 likes

Current read
#storytime #lemon8contest #ifonlyihadtoldher #current read 📚 #currentread #currentbooks #recentread #readingaesthetic #reading #summerreads
Grace 💙

Grace 💙

11 likes

🥀IF ONLY I HAD TOLD HER🥀 - laura nowlin
I’m sure most of you know about if he had been with me by laura nowlin And for those who have read it and loved it like me, my heart breaks with you. For those who have committed to the story of Finny and Autumn and bought the second book, in Finny’s perspective, I am so interested in your
Olivia Colette

Olivia Colette

8 likes

Current Read 📚
Since I've decided to finish series that I haven't finished yet, I figured I should read "If Only I Had Told Her" by Laura Nowlin. Had a job interview today and had to take my book with me! I think this space in my car was designed for us book girlies lol #ifonlyihadtoldher #laur
Meg💕

Meg💕

31 likes

My current read💌
Have any of you read this yet??? If so, without spoilers, what do you rate it? ❤️❤️😁😁 #lemon8challenge #currentlyreading
Kade Compton

Kade Compton

9 likes

Current read 😭
#currentread📚 I’ve already read “if he had been with me” and I didn’t think it could get anything worse but it did when I started reading “if only I had told her”. What are your thoughts and opinions!? Also what are you currently reading?
Munch

Munch

8 likes

Current read: Shields of Sparrows by Devney Perry
#lemon8bookclub #book #booktok #bookrecommendations #bookaesthetic
Sarah🌻

Sarah🌻

16 likes

A hand with dark red nail polish holds the book "If Only I Had Told Her" by Laura Nowlin, featuring a red rose on its cover. The book is displayed against a bookshelf filled with other books, with text overlays "My current Reads" and "Lemon8 @mikala.273".
My current Read
if only i had told her by Laura Nowlin I have been putting this book on hold for months now. I had read If He Had Been With Me about a year ago and in February I picked up this book. I finally feel like I can read it now and I cannot wait to see what heart break comes within this book!! #if he ha
mwaiwaiole7

mwaiwaiole7

5 likes

The front cover of the book "If Only I Had Told Her" by Laura Nowlin, featuring a dark red rose with a broken stem and scattered petals on a light, textured background. The author is identified as a #1 New York Times bestselling author.
The back cover of "If Only I Had Told Her," displaying the book's synopsis about Finn, Autumn, and Sylvie, and mentioning it's told from three perspectives. It includes a quote, ISBN, price, and publisher information.
An open page of the book showing the "author's note." The text describes the author's initial process of writing Finn's perspective for "If He Had Been with Me" before focusing on Autumn's story.
If only I had told her by Laura nowlin
I’m starting the second book again because I just finished the first and loved it and now I’ll understand this book better! What’s y’all thoughts 💭? Has anyone read this or are you going too? #booktok #book recommendations
Katie

Katie

5 likes

Current read 📖
I have so many books on my tbr and I just started The Surgeon but I couldn’t wait to dive into this book! If you’ve read it lmk how many stars ⭐️ you gave it in the comments. #currentlyreading #lemon8bookclub #booksoflemon8 #ifonlyihadtoldher #lauranowlin #bookrecommendations #
AngelicaG

AngelicaG

11 likes

Book Review If Only I Had Told Her
The number one lesson to take away from this book is to have the courage to speak your truth 🥺 If Only I Had Told Her ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ If you haven’t read If He Had Been With Me, I recommend reading that first as this is book is from a different characters POV. This book takes off with putting us r
Gaby

Gaby

4 likes

My current read🫶🏻
#lemon8diarychallenge #perksofbeingawallflower #currentread #reading📖
Maddi Jane

Maddi Jane

11 likes

Last current next!💕
#lemon8diarychallenge #books 🫶🏼 #loves to read 📚 #reading📖 #if he had been with me #ifonlyihadtoldher #girlinpieces
🎀Lia🎀

🎀Lia🎀

340 likes

Current Read📚
Hola guys. So I am almost done with this book, ‘If Only I Had Told Her.’ It’s the second part to ‘If he had been with me’. I been seeing and reading a lot of reviews, and there are mixed feelings about this book. So far I really enjoying reading this book than the first. If you have not read the se
Steph🖤

Steph🖤

30 likes

A hand holds the front cover of "The Summer I Turned Pretty" by Jenny Han. The light green cover features seashells and daisies, with text indicating it's now an original streaming series. Overlay text says "my current read" with a butterfly.
An open copy of "The Summer I Turned Pretty" is held, displaying pages from chapter twenty-three. The text on the pages is visible. An overlay shows "Rating 5/5" with blue flower emojis.
A hand holds the back cover of "The Summer I Turned Pretty." The light green cover features seashells and daisies, along with a synopsis of the story and information about other books in the series.
My current read 🍋
I am not the type of person to read books ! But over the past couple of months I’ve been trying to read the summer I turned pretty. I love it it’s an easy read, I get excited for belly all the time . It just feels like I’m in the book ⭐️Overall rating: /5:5 #currentlyreading #lemon8challenge
Giselle

Giselle

9 likes

What is your current read?
Trying to make some friends on here 😊 What is everyone else reading???
Mikaylah| ✨📚

Mikaylah| ✨📚

270 likes

My current read 📚
📖 Name of the Book: If only I had told her 📄 Plot: bestfriends children fall in love and don’t realize until it’s too late. 📖 Genre: fiction/romance 📄 My Favorite Quotes:”I pause, trying to decide how to ask my first question, but then i laugh and say, “I love you, Autumn.” And somehow, she isn’
Vae

Vae

4 likes

My current 🌶️🥵🔥 read?
Current Read??? Haunting Adeline. NO SPOILERS. Pages - 605 Rating (So far) 5/5 -dark romance -if you touch her you d!3 (quite literally) -Short Chapters (appreciate that) -Spiciness 4.5/5 ( so far im on page 433 Chapter 30) Hello Everybody!!! So right now I’m currently read
Gigi

Gigi

93 likes

The book cover for 'if only i had told her' by Laura Nowlin, featuring a red rose with a thorny stem, rests on a textured pink blanket. Light blue flower emojis are scattered around the image.
An open book, 'if only i had told her', displays highlighted passages in various colors. Text overlays indicate the book is better than the first and is rated highly.
Two stacked books, with 'if only i had told her' on top, are marked with numerous colorful sticky tabs. A light blue highlighter rests on the top book, with text stating it was loved more than the first.
If Only I Had Been Told Her🤎
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️✨THIS BOOK HAS MY HEARTTTT! i literally fell in love with the way she wrote out finny and jacks pov! THIS ACTUALLY MADE ME CRYYYY, simply because i related so much with his death because i have a cousin who died in the most uncanny similar way so i was sobbing soo badd. She really embodie
monai💕

monai💕

12 likes

A hand holds three books stacked vertically, labeled 'LAST', 'CURRENT', and 'NEXT' from top to bottom, representing the user's reading list.
A hand holds the book 'Don't Let Me Fall' by Kelsie Rae, a sweet romance about college students denying their true feelings for each other.
A hand holds the book 'The House Across the Lake' by Riley Sager, a fast-paced mystery where a woman uncovers secrets about her neighbors.
Last, Current, Next Read
My last, current, and next reads! LAST: 1. Don’t Let Me Go by Kelsey Rae I didn’t love this book…I would rate it maybe 3/5 stars. I am going to try and push through the rest of the series though! 2. The House Across the Lake by Riley Sager So far this book is so intriguing! I have some the
Khloemyers

Khloemyers

36 likes

If Only I Had Told Her book review.
I read the first book which was good. Had to read the second book, which was really hard for me to pick up. I had this book for a month now and almost DNF. I pushed through and finish. It was okay. Too slow for me. Did you read this book? What’s your opinion #booktok #BookReview #laurano
DenisexoBueno

DenisexoBueno

2 likes

IF ONLY I HAD TOLD HER
this book had me sobbing😭 what’s your currents reads? #recentread #current read 📚 #whatimreading
kennedy

kennedy

6 likes

A hand with yellow nail polish holds the book "The Help" by Kathryn Stockett, featuring a yellow cover with a purple title box. Overlay text reads "on my Thoughts Current Reads" and "#lemon8bookclub."
A hand with yellow nail polish holds an open copy of "The Help," displaying pages 220 and 221 of the novel. Overlay text says "Books to read this summer."
A hand with yellow and purple nail polish holds an open copy of "The Help," showing pages 338 and 339 of the book. Overlay text reads "My current Reads."
The help! My current read
This is the best book I have ever read! I’ve seen the movie also but the book is far far better ! Has anyone read this book before? What are your thoughts ? #bookwormsoflemon8 #lemon8challenge
EndlessKnots🧶Crochet

EndlessKnots🧶Crochet

5 likes

My Current Read 📖
I first heard about this book back in 2022, and I just recently got it a week ago at a local bookstore! So far I love it. It’s a mix of a biography, novel and historical fiction. It tells the life of Zelda, F Scott Fitzgerald’s wife, as had she might of told it. 🤍🤍 #reading📖 #recentbook #bo
Delaneyvon💓

Delaneyvon💓

5 likes

Already Read,Current Read,To Be Read
I love reading and wanted to share some of my reads so far of this year. I’m so excited to see how many I get read before the end of the year. What are some of your favorite thriller books that I should add to my TBR??? Any suggestions are appreciated thank you so much in advance💕 #bookworm
Ashley

Ashley

8 likes

Current read 🍋
Learn about the spirit realm & how everything is connected #matter #spiritrealm #reincarnation #God Allan Kardec New to Lemon8! Something I love:I love learning
Leanne🇵🇷🌻💕

Leanne🇵🇷🌻💕

702 likes

The book "FROM HERE TO THE GREAT UNKNOWN" by Lisa Marie Presley and Riley Keough, featuring a young girl and Elvis on the cover, rests on a blanket with a TV in the background.
A person holds open the memoir "FROM HERE TO THE GREAT UNKNOWN" to the preface, revealing a black and white photo of a woman and child, with a TV screen in the dark background.
A close-up of the book "FROM HERE TO THE GREAT UNKNOWN" shows the "PREFACE" text about Lisa Marie Presley's memoir and a black and white photo of a woman and child.
My current read ! Iconic
#lemon8bookclub #currentbooks #letschat
Sophiasbooknook

Sophiasbooknook

7 likes

See more