Christmas Tradition: Cookie Exchange Part 3

Easy Grinch Cookies

Prep Time: 30 minutes

Cook Time: 12 minutes

Total Time: 42 minutes

Yield: 20 cookies

Ingredients

1 cup (226g) unsalted butter, at room temperature

1½ cups (285g) granulated sugar

2 large eggs

1 teaspoon (5ml) pure vanilla extract

½ teaspoon peppermint extract (optional)

3 1/2 cups (420g) all-purpose flour

½ teaspoon baking soda

½ teaspoon cream of tartar

½ teaspoon salt

Additional 1/2 cup granulated sugar for finishing

Electric Green Gel Color

Heart-shaped sprinkles

Instructions

Preheat the oven to 350° F. Line a large cookie sheet with parchment paper or a silicone baking mat.

Combine the butter with the sugar and beat on medium speed until well creamed together.

Add the eggs, vanilla extract, and green gel coloring. Mix until well combined.

In a separate bowl, combine the remaining dry ingredients. Slowly add into the dough and beat on medium-low speed until well combined and dough forms.

Use a large cookie scoop and portion the dough. Roll each ball of dough in granulated sugar and then place each one about 2 inches apart on a baking sheet.

Bake at 350° F for 12-15 minutes. Immediately when pulled from the oven, place a heart-shaped sprinkle on top.

Allow the cookies to cool on the baking sheet for several minutes and then transfer to a wire rack to cool completely.

2024/11/7 Edited to

... Read moreThe holiday season is the perfect time to indulge in sweet treats, and these Grinch cookies bring a fun twist to your Christmas celebrations. Inspired by the beloved character from Dr. Seuss' 'How the Grinch Stole Christmas,' these cookies not only look appealing but taste delightful too. With an easy-to-follow recipe, you’ll be able to prepare these vibrant green cookies adorned with heart-shaped sprinkles. The combination of unsalted butter, sugar, and vanilla extract creates a soft and chewy texture, while the optional peppermint extract adds a refreshing hint that embodies the essence of Christmas. Cookie exchanges are a wonderful way to celebrate the spirit of the season with friends and family. You can encourage creativity by sharing different variations of holiday cookies that participants can create. For a successful exchange, consider providing decorative boxes or bags to package the cookies, making it easy for guests to bring their tasty gifts home. Furthermore, pairing cookies with festive drinks like hot cocoa or cider can elevate your gathering. This festive cookie recipe can also serve as a great activity for children and adults alike. Get everyone involved in the baking process, from mixing ingredients to decorating the cookies. Not only does this create fun memories, but it also allows everyone to showcase their baking skills, making your holiday celebration even more special. Don't forget to share your creations on social media using popular hashtags like #CookieExchange and #GrinchCookies to inspire others during the holiday season!

Related posts

Christmas Tradition: Cookie Exchange
These hot chocolate cookies have all the flavors you love in a mug of hot chocolate, rolled up into one delicious baked good. Add these to your baking list this season—just don't forget the melty, gooey, roasted marshmallow topping. It's my favorite part! Prep Time: 20 minutes minsCook
HomesteadHeaven

HomesteadHeaven

23 likes

Christmas Tradition: Cookie Exchange
Cookie Monster Cookie Recipe PREP TIME: 10 minutes minutes COOK TIME: 12 minutes minutes SERVINGS: 24 cookies These Cookie Monster Cookies are perfectly blue cookies packed with white chocolate chips, chopped chips ahoy cookies and chopped Oreos. These soft and chewy monster cookies have
HomesteadHeaven

HomesteadHeaven

83 likes

A festive spread of numerous Christmas cookies, including chocolate, powdered sugar, and green-frosted varieties, arranged on white and silver platters on a table.
Two "Browned Butter Toffee Chocolate Chip" cookies on parchment paper, one broken open to reveal melted chocolate, with a glass of milk in the background.
A recipe card detailing ingredients and instructions for "Browned Butter Toffee Chocolate Chip Cookies," set against a red and white striped background with Christmas motifs.
Christmas Cookie Recipes - 90 Days Untill Christmas!
Here are a few more recipes for inspiration this coming holiday season. If you want a successful cookie exchange you need to start planning now! Let me know your favorite cookie recipe, even if I haven’t included it. #christmascookies #cookierecipe #christmascountdown2025 #christmas #holid
Chase’s Cozy Corner

Chase’s Cozy Corner

1696 likes

Christmas Cookie Reicpes - 93 days until Xmas!
Every year my friends and I do a massive Christmas cookie exchange (it’s our Super Bowl). Here’s a few recipes I’ll be making this year in anticipation! Let me know which is your favorite 🎅 #christmascountdown #christmascookies #holidaytreats #cookieexchange #LIVEIncentiveProgram
Chase’s Cozy Corner

Chase’s Cozy Corner

218 likes

Cookie Recipes to make your first holiday cookie box or impress at the cookie exchange
Most of these are super impressive but beginner friendly holiday cookie box ideas. Whether it’s your first time attending a cookie exchange or you’re just looking to shake things up, these will be a hit. The shortbread is my favorite - what is your favorite Christmas Cookie? #christmascookies #c
Chase’s Cozy Corner

Chase’s Cozy Corner

875 likes

The best Christmas tradition!
Save this to do this year! This is one of our favorite Christmas traditions that we started. It is budget friendly and you likely have most of what you need in your pantry. These are great keepsakes of your baby and toddlers feet to pull out every Christmas! I’ve heard people still having their
Danielle • Nurse & Mama

Danielle • Nurse & Mama

363 likes

This image displays handwritten nursing notes on "Perfusion & Oxygenation," detailing the flow of blood, the heart's function, and definitions of central perfusion, cardiac output, stroke volume, preload, contractility, and afterload.
This image presents handwritten nursing notes on heart rate, tissue perfusion, and age-related differences in cardiovascular function. It covers blood flow through arteries and capillaries, and how heart and blood vessel characteristics change from infancy to older adulthood.
This image contains handwritten nursing notes on "Oxygenation / Gas Exchange," defining the process, age-related differences in infants and older adults, and conditions affecting oxygenation. It also explains ventilation, transport, and perfusion related to gas exchange.
oxygenation/gas exchange notes 📝 ✨🤍
fundamentals of nursing 1st semester of nursing school oxygenation & gas exchanges #nursingcollege #nursingstudent #lemon8bookclub #oxygenation #fundamentalsofnursing
sydni g 🌷

sydni g 🌷

66 likes

A close-up of various Christmas cookies, including green Christmas trees with sprinkles, white stars with gold sprinkles, and red and white candy canes. The text 'Cookies I'm Making This Christmas' is overlaid.
An overhead view of assorted Christmas sugar cookies, including green Christmas trees, white snowflakes, white stars, and red and white candy canes, cooling on a wire rack. The text 'Sugar Cookies' is overlaid.
A recipe card titled 'Christmas Sugar Cookies' with ingredients and instructions listed, framed by a red and white striped border and featuring small reindeer and a Christmas tree graphic.
Christmas Cookie Recipe Dump
Perfect variety of cookies to make this year for any party or cookie exchange! #christmascookies #cookieexchange #christmasbaking #cookierecipe #holidaybaking
Chase’s Cozy Corner

Chase’s Cozy Corner

50 likes

A finished block of Sugar Cookie Christmas Fudge, topped with festive red and green sprinkles, rests on a wooden cutting board. The image has overlay text "Sugar Cookie Christmas Fudge SWIPE" with an arrow, indicating a recipe tutorial.
Ingredients for Sugar Cookie Christmas Fudge are laid out on a counter, including sweetened condensed milk, white chocolate chips, sugar cookie mix, butter, and festive sprinkles, alongside a glass baking dish. Overlay text lists the required quantities for each item.
Sweetened condensed milk is being heated and stirred in a silver saucepan on a stovetop with a pink spatula. The overlay text instructs to "Heat and stir the sweetened condensed milk until warmed."
Sugar Cookie Christmas Fudge
I saw this recipe on @Emerald.💗 page and had to try it! It was super quick and easy and turned out beautiful! A great addition to a cookie 🍪 exchange platter or to enjoy yourself (I’m using it for both 🤭). I feel like it’s not as sweet and rich as traditional fudge, and my kids absolutely l
Cassie | Mama Out West

Cassie | Mama Out West

127 likes

A finished DIY Santa cookie plate with a handprint resembling a cookie, text "COOKIES F R SANTA 2025," and festive red and green dots. A gingerbread house plush and wicker basket are in the background.
A hand uses a black paint marker to write "COOKIES" and "SANTA" on a white plate, with text overlay instructing to use oven-safe plates and paint markers.
An adult's hand guides a child's hand onto a white plate to create a handprint, with text overlay instructing to use acrylic paint for the handprint.
Make your own Santa cookie plate! 🎅🍪
Making the sweetest Christmas keepsake ✨🎄 I used an oven-safe plate, paint pens + paint to make our DIY Santa cookie plate, and I love with how it turned out. Such an easy holiday craft to do with kids and something you can pull out every Christmas. Such a fun christmas tradition! @Lemon8P
Danielle • Nurse & Mama

Danielle • Nurse & Mama

14 likes

Anual cookie exchange
It’s great to be a part of a tradition that started before I was born. It’s the best feeling. #christmas #cookiedesings #cookieexchange #holidayseason
SANDRA | SAHM | WIFE 💎

SANDRA | SAHM | WIFE 💎

0 likes

A red gift box containing twelve miniature perfume bottles in various shapes and colors, arranged neatly on a red insert. The box has gold lettering on its lid.
An open black gift box revealing fifteen miniature perfume bottles, each with a black cap, arranged in three rows on a light-colored insert.
An orange gift box with a logo, next to an open white box containing four small perfume bottles with black caps and yellow or pink liquid.
Every girl should experience a perfume exchange pa
#perfume #lemon8bookclub #fyp #gift #perfumecollection 💵 Price:29$ 👍Pros :
Santa Claus for everyone

Santa Claus for everyone

829 likes

Christmas Cookie Display
Easy Christmas Cookie Bar Setup #christmascookies #holidayparty #cookieexchange Christmas Cookie Exchange Christmas Cookie Bar Ideas Christmas Cookie Display Holiday Cookies
Bridget

Bridget

517 likes

Stacked Candy Cane Christmas Cookies
Candy Cane Stacked Cookies 🎄 Press down on the bottom cookie just a bit and then center the character cookie on top. Bake them according to the package using the bottom cookies directions :) #lemon8partner #christmascookies #cookieexchange #baking #christmasparty
Taryn Camp

Taryn Camp

96 likes

Homemade exchange❤️
#lemon8christmas #lemon8contest had a little homemade exchange and let the kids do a cookie swap and make some ornaments❤️ everyone had so much fun
Rena H

Rena H

89 likes

CHRISTMAS TRADITIONS we’ll do with our kids❤️💚
These are the Christmas traditions we’ll be doing every year with our kids. When I was little, we always waited until midnight to open up all our presents (I’m Latina), but my husband is America and he likes the tradition of waiting until Christmas morning. So we open 1 gift on Christmas Eve
Dania Toddler Mom & UGC

Dania Toddler Mom & UGC

147 likes

Christmas Wedding Ideas: Part Two
Part two of my Christmas Wedding Ideas! 🎄 #christmas #christmaswedding #winterwedding #christmasbride #weddingideas
Syd 🌻

Syd 🌻

23 likes

Christmas Cookie Recipes
More cookies I’m making this holiday season. I can’t get enough and love to try new recipes. Do you have any absolute must try Christmas cookie recipes? #christmascookies #holidaybaking #christmas2025 #cookierecipe #cookieexchange
Chase’s Cozy Corner

Chase’s Cozy Corner

37 likes

Christmas Cookie Idea 🎅🏼
Looks like a cool cookie idea for your Christmas parties! #christmascookies #christmasrecipes #christmasfoodideas #holidaycookierecipe @LORAfied | HACKS Home & Life
Traveling Muse 🍃

Traveling Muse 🍃

731 likes

A recipe for homemade sugar Christmas cookies, featuring ingredients and step-by-step instructions. The image also shows three decorated cookies: a gingerbread man, a star, a Christmas tree, and a snowflake.
❤️ Making Christmas Memories One Cookie at a Time
Baking sugar cookies with my kids is one of our favorite Christmas traditions 🍪🎄 From rolling the dough to decorating with sprinkles, these are the moments that make the holidays extra special ❤️ If you’re looking for a simple, kid-friendly sugar cookie recipe, this one is perfect. ✨ Save this
Mrs.Jones

Mrs.Jones

190 likes

An outdoor table set up for a book exchange party, featuring stamps, ink pads, pens, and blank cards. A sign says 'Make your own'. A swing set is in the background, with a text overlay 'Book Exchange Party'.
A golden-framed chalkboard sign welcomes guests to 'The Great Exchange'. It instructs them to enjoy refreshments and browse, with Rachel guiding the swap time. Decorative chalk drawings are included.
An overhead view of a table set for a book-themed gathering. Books, teacups, plates, and bouquets of pink roses adorn the table. People are seated, some reading books like 'IF WE WERE VILLAINS'.
Book Exchange Party
#lemon8diarychallenge #books
Sugarjar

Sugarjar

430 likes

Christmas Reads on my list. ✅
I picked these titles up from the library yesterday! My favorite holiday books are almost always from these authors. There are even recipes ! Joanne Fluke books are such comfort reads for me. I picked up Christmas Caramel Murder! The next book I checked out is A Catered Christmas Cookie Exchan
Brook

Brook

5 likes

🍪 Cookie Countdown to Christmas – Dec 13 🎄
Today’s featured treat is a holiday classic: Vanilla-Butter Sugar Cookies 🤍 Soft, buttery, and perfect for decorating—these cookies are a Christmas must-bake! Roll them out, cut your favorite shapes, and let the kids (or your inner kid 😉) go wild with frosting and sprinkles. ✨ Tip: Chill the
Aprealtormn

Aprealtormn

31 likes

Coffee shop/Cookie Exchange for the holidays🩵✨🍪🎅🏼
#cookieexchange #christmasparty #hosting #marthastewart #athomecoffeeshop
Lexie

Lexie

9 likes

Holiday cookie party!
a sweet holiday tradition: cookie decorating! #christmastradition #cookiedecorating #familytime #twodads
The vonBKs

The vonBKs

6 likes

Makeup Exchange ✨💄
Your sign to exchange gift with your friends!
Vanessa✨

Vanessa✨

354 likes

Cultural Exchange: Language Programs & Adventure
Hi there, lemon travel buddies!Traveling is more than just visiting new places; it's about immersing yourself in different cultures and experiences. One of the most powerful ways to enhance your travel is through language learning. Combining language programs with adventure activities allows yo
Travel Blog

Travel Blog

18 likes

Nursing Care for Altered Gas Exchange
Brain dump. Memory recall. #nursingstudent #nurseessentials #nursingschool #nursingstudenttips #nursingstudentessentials
Who? J. Jones

Who? J. Jones

6 likes

deautoexchange
Midday Auction Update! It's going to be a huge night at Delaware Auto Exchange! We're gearing up for one of the biggest weeks we ve had in months, and the lot is packed with amazing vehicles ready for auction! Check out these pictures of some of the standout cars hitting the block toni
Usa Public Auto Auctions

Usa Public Auto Auctions

7 likes

Holiday cookie recipe🎄🍪
These festive white chocolate-dipped peppermint sugar cookies are so quick and easy to make! They are perfect to take to your Christmas cookie exchange or give as gifts to friends and family. Crispy on the outside and perfectly chewy in the middle, these holiday sugar cookies with fun crushed peppe
Nikki🍋

Nikki🍋

43 likes

homemade candles for christmas gifts 🕯️❤️
#christmasgiftideas #GiftIdeas #homemade #christmas #DIY
brianna410berry

brianna410berry

94 likes

5 Christmas Cookies
‘Tis the season for holiday baking and I have 5 delicious, gluten-free cookie recipes that are must-makes before Christmas! 1. Sugar Cookies 2. Gingerbread Men 3. Red Velvet Crinkle Cookies 4. Paleo Thumbprint Cookies 5. Brown Butter Snickerdoodles Head to my blog for the full recipes! #
Ari Litrenta

Ari Litrenta

5 likes

2025 Christmas Cookie Tray 🍪✨
A year of baking & sweet traditions! This beautiful 2025 Christmas Cookie Tray is filled with all our family favorites — Peanut Butter Blossoms, Christmas Swirl Fudge, Mexican Wedding Cookies, Christmas Rice Krispie Squares, and Christmas Sugar Cookies. Buttery, chewy, chocolatey, and festive —
graceandgiggles.az

graceandgiggles.az

10 likes

Mug exchange 💕✨
#mugsnsips #valentines #mugcollector #valentinesday #valentinesideas
Alo 💕

Alo 💕

28 likes

I’ve decided to make this a tradition!
Although we don’t have kids yet, I baked Soft and Chewy Gingerbread Cookies and these Sour Cream Soft Sugar Cookies. I loved them so much that I believe I will make them every year. I discussed with my husband about when we have children, baking cookies each christmas time as a tradition, maybe eve
Brooklynn Shae

Brooklynn Shae

6 likes

Christmas Cookie Plate Exchange?
What's a 🎄Christmas cookie 🍪 exchange called where you swap plates 🍽️ and no cookies? 🤔 #AskLemon8 #lemon8contest #AYA #christmascookieexchange #plateexchange
tarbs47

tarbs47

5 likes

"The Divine Exchange:
Good morning 🕊 🕊 🕊 The Divine Exchange: Why Giving Up Everything is Gaining Everything. Psalm 37:4 "Delight yourself in the Lord, and he will give you the desires of your heart" "Delight yourself in the Lord" sounds impossible when you've just surrendered the very th
Sophiasdaddio

Sophiasdaddio

14 likes

A collage showing finished melted snowman Oreo balls, ingredients like almond bark, Oreos, cream cheese, and the process of rolling Oreo balls, with text overlay 'Melted Snowman Oreo Balls'.
An overhead view of all the ingredients for melted snowman Oreo balls, including vanilla almond bark, regular and mini Oreo cookies, cream cheese, sprinkles, Rolo candies, and vanilla frosting.
A clear glass bowl filled with the dark, mixed Oreo, cream cheese, and frosting mixture, ready to be rolled into balls, with a wooden spoon nearby.
Melted Snowmen Christmas Oreo Balls
Melted Snowmen Christmas Oreo Balls 🌲🎅🏻🌲🎅🏻 Melted Snowman Oreo Balls is a super easy way to build edible snowmen out of Oreo cookies, cream cheese, vanilla frosting, almond bark, and candy instead of snow. These no-bake Christmas Oreo truffles create the cutest cold weather figures that celeb
Florida Travel

Florida Travel

50 likes

🍪✨ Cookie Countdown to Christmas – Day 3! ✨🍪
Today’s sweet treat: Dipped Gingersnaps — the perfect mix of warm spices, soft centers, and a festive white chocolate dip. These cookies smell like Christmas and taste even better! 🎄🤤 Whether you’re baking for a cookie exchange, holiday party, or just because… this recipe is a must-try. Grab yo
Aprealtormn

Aprealtormn

6 likes

A title slide with the text "Softening the Armor as Seasons Change" and "reflections for the equinox, where balance finds its way back" against a light background with subtle white smoke-like wisps.
A light-colored slide with the text "You landed here for a reason" followed by an explanation that the equinox signifies balance, where endings and beginnings coexist.
A light-colored slide with the text "The little ways we protect ourselves" describing how old patterns like keeping busy or pretending to be fine, once protective, can now feel heavy.
Sacred energy exchange
The equinox is a natural pause. 🌗 Day and night meet in balance, reminding you that you are allowed to soften, to release what feels heavy, and to welcome the balance already rising in your life. I have been noticing how the small ways we protect ourselves can also keep us from feeling steady.
Jess, EHP

Jess, EHP

1 like

A festive table covered with a red plaid tablecloth, laden with a wide variety of homemade Christmas cookies and treats. Assorted cookies, chocolate bark, cupcakes, and snack mixes are neatly arranged on plates and in containers, showcasing a bountiful holiday cookie exchange spread.
A close-up view of a holiday cookie exchange table, featuring a diverse array of homemade treats. Visible are chocolate crinkle cookies, M&M cookies, frosted cupcakes, and bar cookies, all arranged on plates and in containers on a red plaid tablecloth.
An overhead view of a large holiday cookie exchange spread on a red plaid tablecloth. The table is filled with numerous plates and bowls of homemade cookies, including peanut butter blossoms, chocolate truffles, M&M cookies, crinkle cookies, sugar cookies, and s'mores cookies.
Christmas Cookie exchange 2025 🎄
Our first year doing a cookie exchange! Some Cookies didn’t turn out as planned 😅 but soo excited to do this again next year! #holidayeats #lemon8challenge
Stardust

Stardust

6 likes

Christmas cookie exchange
Peppermint hot chocolate and turtle pecan. #bakedgoods #cookies #peppermint #hotchocolate #turtlecookies
Lacey Brzymialkiewicz

Lacey Brzymialkiewicz

8 likes

Your sign to have a cookie exchange party 🍪🎄
10/10✨ Everyone’s cookies were delicious! This is your sign to gather all your friends and family and have a cookie exchange 🍪✨ #holidaycookies #cookieparty #christmascookies #partyideas #girlsnight
✨Arely✨

✨Arely✨

11 likes

See more