Pen Pal book review!

This book starts off simply: a grieving widow meets a handsome handyman. It feels too soon for Kayla to catch feelings after her husband’s death, but she can’t help it. She feels as though she already knows Aidan—almost like she already loves him. Then strange things start happening. She keeps seeing her dead husband out and about. A little boy also keeps appearing at her home, but he doesn’t seem to hear her. And then there’s the biggest issue: the letters from her new pen pal, Dante, who is apparently in prison and only wants one thing—her.

At this point in the book, things weren’t making a lot of sense to me. Honestly, I got really confused. While the story was good, I felt like a lot of things were happening that didn’t really seem connected. My advice for this book is to see it through. At one point, I considered stopping because it felt so random, but everything ties together beautifully in the end. I highly recommend this read! #bookreader #bookreviewer #bookstagramfeature #bookedandbusy #booktokbooks

2024/12/3 Edited to

... Read moreOkay, so I just have to talk more about J.T. Geissinger's 'Pen Pal' because my initial review only scratched the surface of how truly wild this book is. Like my friend mentioned earlier, I was genuinely confused for a good chunk of the story. You have Kayla, a grieving widow, and then Aidan, the handsome handyman. It felt almost too easy, too soon for her to fall for someone, and that's exactly where the author starts to mess with your head in the best way possible. What really kept me hooked through those confusing parts was the escalating mystery. You're constantly asking yourself: Is Aidan Dante? What's going on with her dead husband appearing? Who is this little boy? The letters from Dante are so unsettlingly possessive, yet you can't help but be drawn into the psychological game. Geissinger is a master at planting seeds of doubt and suspicion, making every interaction between Kayla, Aidan, and the unseen Dante feel charged with unspoken secrets. I loved how the book plays with your perceptions and expectations, making you question everything you thought you knew about the characters and their motives. It’s a compelling dance between romance and psychological thriller. And let's talk about the 'spicy' factor, because yes, it's definitely there! The romance between Kayla and Aidan is incredibly intense and passionate, adding another layer of complexity to the narrative. The spicy chapters aren't just for show; they deepen the connection and the emotional stakes, making the twists even more impactful. It's a steamy read that doesn't shy away from exploring desire and intimacy, which I think is crucial for the story's emotional depth and for understanding Kayla's journey of healing and rediscovery. It really elevates the stakes when you're emotionally invested in these characters. Before even diving into the pages, the book cover itself drew me in. The striking image featuring a tattooed man, combined with that poignant quote about love and loss, perfectly sets the tone for the intricate blend of romance, mystery, and emotional turmoil you're about to experience. It’s almost a clue in itself to the complexity within. Ultimately, for anyone who loves a psychological romance with jaw-dropping twists, this book is an absolute must-read. If you're looking for a story that keeps you guessing until the very last page and delivers a satisfying, albeit shocking, resolution, then 'Pen Pal' by J.T. Geissinger needs to be on your TBR list. Trust me, the payoff is worth every moment of confusion!

11 comments

HYRR's images
HYRR

I second your thoughts. I really did enjoy the book, and was happy with the way it ended. But I also thought the ending was rushed. That being said I plan to reread it. And am hoping the story flows better the second time. ^-^

Related posts

The book cover for J.T. Geissinger's 'Pen Pal,' featuring a tattooed man, with a 5/5 star rating and a chili pepper rating, indicating a dark romance novel.
A minimalist graphic for 'Pen Pal' by J.T. Geissinger, detailing its author, dark romance genre, 320 pages, and starring Aidan & Kayla, with a quote and scattered handwritten letters in the background.
A collage featuring handwritten letters, intertwined hands, a ring, and portraits of a woman (Kayla) and a tattooed man (Aidan), representing characters and themes from 'Pen Pal.'
Pen Pal Book Review!
WOW!!! This book was not what I expected! 🤯🤯🤯 What a twist!!! Absolutely loved it! Read it in a days time! Highly recommend reading it! It’s no where near what you think it will be AT ALL!!!!! 5/5⭐️ #penpal #bookrecommendations #BookReview #goodreads #darkromance
Squarebear

Squarebear

851 likes

The image displays the front cover of the psychological thriller novel "Behind Closed Doors" by B.A. Paris, featuring the title in red and a dark keyhole design. Overlay text indicates "BOOK REVIEW" and a "10/10" rating.
Book Review✨🖤 Psychological Thriller
Book Review 🪻🌾✨ Book name: Behind Closed Doors Author: B.A Paris Genre: Psychological Thriller My rating: honestly.. 10/10, I’m hoping to find this thrill in another book. My review: I had no idea going into this book exactly what I was getting into. The words and details used made me picture
RM

RM

639 likes

A hand holds the book 'PEN PAL' by J.T. Geissinger, featuring a shirtless, tattooed man on the cover. Overlay text reads 'It's time to Read'. The image includes a Lemon8 watermark and a barcode, with French text at the bottom right.
Pen Pal book review
I have not been surprised by a solid plot twist in I don't even know how long. This had me hooked from the very beginning and I couldn't put it down. I read this in a day. While it's not the greatest writing ever, I have such an appreciation for the story and how it all played out. I ab
Becks

Becks

15 likes

A book cover for 'PEN PAL' by J.T. Geissinger, featuring a tattooed man, is central. Text around it highlights themes like 'Intense,' 'Twisty,' 'Suspense,' and 'Spicy Romance,' with the phrase 'It all began with just one line...' The image also includes 'Lemon8 @niycki46'.
Pen Pal Book Review
Yallllll!! I was not prepared..why didn’t anyone warn me!?! again, I don’t read the synopsis of a book..I go strictly off of titles and covers lol. But this book right here threw me for a whole loop that I was NOT expecting! This book has the POV of Kayla, she lost her husband and she’s j
Haley Anderson

Haley Anderson

6 likes

Book review: PEN PAL
Loved this book from beginning to end just loved it, one of my new favorite reads #bookrecs #bookreview #penpal #booksoflemon8
Berenice A

Berenice A

45 likes

The image displays the book cover for "The Power of the Pussy" by Kara King, featuring a black cat silhouette. Overlaid text indicates a review, stating "I Finally Read It" and "Here's My Review," along with the Lemon8 handle.
This image presents a book review for "The Power of the Pussy," highlighting its benefits for women with low self-esteem and confidence. It includes a rating of 8.5/10 and testimonials, along with the book's ISBN.
The image shows an open book with text, overlaid with instructions to get a paper copy online or an Ebook off Amazon Kindle. A sticky note encourages followers for more reviews, recipes, life hacks, and DIY ideas.
MY BOOK REVIEW ON THE POWER OF THE 🐈‍⬛
I saw this book all over this app & decided to give it a read! This is my review & rating #books #BookReview #booksoflemon8 #bookshelf #reading #readingrecommendations #thoughts
ImTheLoveWitch777

ImTheLoveWitch777

1574 likes

A hand holds the book "Collide" by Pal Khabra, featuring an illustrated cover. The cover depicts a female character with a book and a male character in a varsity jacket with a hockey stick. The title "OFF THE ICE Collide" is prominent, with "Book Review Collide" overlaid.
Collide Review! 🏒📚
Omg I read this book in two days. Like no joke. I started it Sunday night and finished it Monday night. Since I’ve been snowed in literally one thing I’ve been doing. Also the book coming with a playlist was so cute. I’ve never had a book that’s had that. So this book is a good book. I love
Tor

Tor

7065 likes

A grid displaying 12 self-help book covers focused on improving communication skills, including "How to Win Friends & Influence People" by Dale Carnegie, "How to Talk to Anyone," and "Crucial Conversations." The image is titled "12 Books To Improve Your Communication Skills."
A hand holds the book "How to Win Friends & Influence People" by Dale Carnegie, featuring its white cover with red and black text, against a blurred background of green grass and autumn leaves. The text "Self-help book recommendations" is visible at the top.
An artistic image depicts an open, ornate wooden door revealing a dark, red-lit staircase leading downwards. Overlaid on the image is the quote: "BE HEARTY IN YOUR APPROBATION AND LAVISH IN YOUR PRAISE."
Book review you want to read
#selfhelpbooks #lemon8challenge #bookhealing #BookReview #healingjourney #healingvibes #bookwisdom #suchagoodbook #thewilltochoose #inspiration How To Win Friends & Influence People by Dale Carnegie This book was published in 1936 and has sold over 30 million copies.
vsinfleurs

vsinfleurs

663 likes

Mid Way Through Book Review 📚🩷
So here are my honest thoughts on the book so far: 📚The biggest win for the author is that she easly transitions well between timelines. Throughout the book she jumps timelines often giving us background information on each character she does this seamlessly! I’m also a squirrel and get confused
Deja Emani

Deja Emani

72 likes

A hand holds the front cover of the book "Tender Beasts" by Liselle Sambury, a YA thriller. The cover features two figures with a torn-paper effect, set against a dark green textured background. The image includes a "BOOK REVIEW" overlay.
Tender Beast Book Review 🐻🐾
Book Review : ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5 Stars Meet the mysterious Behre family, where secrets and tragedy seem to follow them around. Sunny who definitely lives up to her name is determined to “Take Care of Dom” and prove his innocence when he’s accused of murder. The author definitely keeps you guessing until
rickeashonte

rickeashonte

154 likes

🤯 BOOK REVIEW
So I had to take a break from my normal book readings lol, and pick me up a good thriller that I really enjoyed… I been eyeing this one all over KU but kept passing it by until today and it did not disappoint.. pretty much wish i read this sooner 🥴… A must read if you like suspense/ psychologica
💕✨TATIANA✨💕

💕✨TATIANA✨💕

155 likes

Pen Pal Book review
Go read it. Just do it! #booktok #bookrecommendations #darkromance #bookboyfriends
Chelsea Whorley

Chelsea Whorley

3 likes

A hand holds the book 'Moody Bitches' by Julie Holland, featuring its full title and a testimonial from Christiane Northrup, MD. Overlays like 'Thoughts' and 'Current Reads' suggest a book review or reading list on Lemon8.
Honest Book Review: “Moody B!tches” by Julie l
“Moody Bitches: The Truth About the Drugs You’re Taking, the Sleep You’re Missing, the Sex You’re Not Having, and What’s Really Making You Crazy" by Julie Holland is a bold and insightful look at the emotional and mental health of women. Dr. Holland, a psychiatrist, challenges the conventio
Goddess Luxure

Goddess Luxure

2437 likes

The book cover for Maya Angelou's 'The Heart of a Woman' features a woman's silhouette and red-orange flowers on a dark background, resting on a white fluffy surface. A quote from Kirkus Reviews is visible.
Book Review
This book is absolutely amazing. Maya Angelou’s early life was truly one worth writing about. She eloquently writes of the duality of women and the lives our grandmothers were forced to live. Having a child at 17, receiving the assistance of her mother and shortly after taking full custody. May
Marlesia

Marlesia

499 likes

BOOK Pen Pal by J.T. Geissinger
A dark romance novel with a major twist, initially marketed as a story about a woman, Kayla, who begins corresponding with a mysterious inmate named Dante after her husband's death, leading to an intense, intimate relationship that takes a dark turn when he appears at her door.
brandyhelm563

brandyhelm563

5 likes

A stack of romance novels by authors like Lucy Score and Elsie Silver, with arrows pointing to corresponding tropes such as 'small town romance,' 'enemies to lovers,' 'hockey romance,' and 'marriage of convenience.' Nail polish bottles and a floral painting are also visible.
Book review 🌸
#booksummary #lemon8challenge Twisted hate is one of my number ones but lmk if there is a book u want a review on and I will see if I have it
Ameliamarieisme

Ameliamarieisme

3247 likes

A person holds a coffee cup next to a laptop and saucer on a wooden table, with text overlay 'the sh*t they never taught you *an honest book review'.
The book 'the sh*t they never taught you' by Adam Jones & Adam Ashton is displayed on a yellow background, with a 4/5 star rating and a review comment.
An open book and cup are on a bed next to a lamp, illustrating 'Key takeaway #1: Mindset Matters' from the book.
The sh*t they never taught you (book review)
Okay, raise your hand if you ever felt like school totally ripped you off. 🙋‍♀️ Like, we learned about photosynthesis but not how to handle a breakup or file taxes. 🤦‍♀️ Adulting is HARD, and it feels like no one gave us the playbook. This book is not all-time cheat code imma be honest, though I
Meredith Jao

Meredith Jao

951 likes

A hand holds the book 'If Only I Had Told Her' by Laura Nowlin, featuring a red rose on the cover. Overlays include 'Book Review', 'His POV', 'Friends to lovers', and a three-star rating, all on a light-colored bedsheet background.
Book Review: If Only I Had Told Her
You guyssss! I randomly decided to read if he had been with me two weeks ago and zoomed through it in two days without knowing there was a second on the way! Obviously I had to grab it to read Finnys - I’m half way through and right now I’m preferring the first over this. Thoughts? 📖🥀 #Lemon8Di
MarySylvia Fain

MarySylvia Fain

220 likes

A hand holds the book cover for "The Neighbor Favor" by Kristina Forest. The cover features an illustration of a man and woman on balconies, with the man handing a book to the woman, against a city skyline. The title is in large red letters, and a tagline reads "LOVE WAS CLOSER THAN THEY KNEW."
Book 6 📚
The Neighbor Favor was a good book and I really did enjoy reading it. I loved that this story centered around two book lovers, Lily and Nick, and showed how a connection can grow through words, trust, and vulnerability. The whole pen-pal/email part of the story was cute because it showed how som
Cam

Cam

38 likes

A hand holds the book 'Miss Pearly's Girls' by Award-Winning Author ReShonda Tate Billingsley, featuring four women on the cover. Overlays show 'Rating: 5/5' and 'BOOK REVIEW', with 'lemon8 @itsriahkristine'.
Black Girl Read: Book Review📚
Babe!! This was one of the BEST books I have read recently! I loved it. This book is about four sisters and how they differ but have more things in common than they realize. Black girl read FOR SURE! Plus a black author. Chefs kiss💋🤌🏽 #blackgirlbookreview #blackgirlsreadbooks #blackgirlsread
Mariah Kristine

Mariah Kristine

94 likes

A hand holds the book "Why Women Grow" by Alice Vincent, featuring a dark cover with vibrant floral illustrations. Overlaid text reads "My Honest BOOK REVIEW" and "Rating: 5/5," indicating a positive review of the gardening and empowerment book.
🌱 Book Review: Why Women Grow by Alice Vincent 📖🌸
Hey Lemon8 fam! 🌼 Just wrapped up "Why Women Grow" by Alice Vincent, and OMG, I am obsessed! 🌿✨ Alice takes us on this wild, wonderful journey through gardens and personal growth, showing how digging in the dirt is more than just a hobby—it's a whole vibe. 🌱💚 Her writing is this magi
Candyce

Candyce

222 likes

A person with pink nail polish holds the book 'Hurricane Summer' by Asha Bromfield. The cover features a woman with dark curly hair and a pink flower, against a blue and green rainy background. The tagline reads 'Sometimes the storm is inside of you.' A Lemon8 watermark is visible.
Book review ‼️
My mom got me this book a few days a go and I was hooked since I picked it up! You will laugh, you will cry it will make you frustrated and proud all at the same time. Definitely felt all the feels but over all the book is beautifully written and I think the target audience will definitely apprecia
Milan Brown

Milan Brown

119 likes

A copy of Marissa Meyer's book 'Cursed' lies on a gray blanket, featuring a dark castle and red moon on its cover. Text overlays highlight themes like ghost servants, demon court, monster queen, fake marriage to the Demon king, pregnant FMC, 'I want my wife back,' old gods, mythical creatures, and forbidden love, along with a 4/5 star rating.
Cursed Book Review
I loved this sequel! Fun end to a retelling of Rumplestiltskin. “Serilda and Gild attempt to break the curses that tether their spirits to Adalheid’s haunted castle before the Endless Moon, when the Erlking means to capture one of the seven gods and make a wish to return his lover, Perchta, from
Danielle

Danielle

239 likes

The book cover for "Men We Reaped: A Memoir" by Jesmyn Ward, featuring an old photograph of two young Black children, rests on a white fluffy surface. The cover includes a quote from The New York Times Book Review and the author's name. A Lemon8 watermark is visible at the bottom left.
Book Review 📚
If you are easily triggered, this may not be a book you would want to read. In order to go out into society and experience others without judgement, we have to know where they came from. The author perfectly illustrates the lives of four young, Black men who died very young. Their tragic deaths sho
Marlesia

Marlesia

265 likes

See more