Debut Diaries: Literary Magazine & Beta Feedback

Debut Diaries, except instead of being mysterious and glamorous, I was formatting a literary magazine submissions and reading feedback for The Star & The Saint like my life depended on it.

Tiny author milestones still count, even when they look like formatting, waiting, overthinking, and pretending to be normal about feedback.

#debutdiaries

#debutauthor

#literarymagazine

#betareader

#writingcommunity

3/12 Edited to

... Read moreEmbarking on my debut author journey, I've found that while the glamorous idea of publishing might be what many imagine, the everyday tasks like meticulously formatting literary magazine submissions and deeply engaging with beta reader feedback hold equal significance. Each step, no matter how administrative it seems, builds towards a polished and compelling final product. As I sift through feedback for my novel, The Star & The Saint, I am constantly reminded of the power of reader insights. Comments describing the story as 'powerful, unsettling, and impossible to ignore' or praising the 'magnetic and atmospheric' tension highlight how deeply narrative elements resonate. This authentic feedback not only validates my efforts but also guides revisions to enhance emotional impact and narrative clarity. The subtle art of balancing vulnerability and control in storytelling becomes apparent when considering phrases like 'a hypnotic psychological gothic steeped in power, vulnerability, and quiet menace.' These reviews emphasize the delicate dynamics between characters and the story's atmosphere, urging me to maintain that balance throughout revisions. Joining the writing community as a debut author means embracing these tiny but meaningful milestones—formatting, waiting anxiously for responses, overthinking every word, and normalizing the process of feedback reception. It’s a shared experience among #debutauthors and #betareaders, honing both craftsmanship and resilience. Incorporating this process into my routine has made me appreciate the patience and perseverance required for literary success. Whether it’s the thrill of a fresh submission or the challenge of refining a manuscript based on detailed critiques, each phase is a critical thread woven into the fabric of bringing a book to life. For anyone stepping into this arena, remember that every small task matters and contributes to your growth as a writer and storyteller.

1 comment

Reagan Westerly's images
Reagan WesterlyCreator

📖

Related posts

debut diaries — what I did this as a debut author
Debut Diaries — this week’s work as a debut author. I spent this week submitting a short story to a literary magazine, preparing a draft for beta readers, and finishing the final revision of my current work in progress. This part of the process is quiet but important — editing, proofreading,
Reagan Westerly

Reagan Westerly

5 likes

Strong literary women that don’t need to be fixed
☠️🔪😵🩸 Basically, these books are a masterclass in strong, complicated women. “Fixing” them? I don't think so. They're way too interesting for that! So I waltzed in here thinking I knew what was up, ready to play Cupid's little helper. Then I saw this bookshelf roundup and, let me
Meredith Jao

Meredith Jao

1033 likes

literary fiction books i want read pt. 1
any literary fiction recommendations? #literature #bookish #bookrecommendations #books
hannah

hannah

572 likes

literary/women’s fiction books i want to read 📖
lately i’ve been so tired of reading the same old genres that I always read! i want to switch it up a little bit and read some more general fiction/women’s fiction books. I love when you’re following a female main character and there is more going on in her life other than a romance. More of a roma
Alli Beachy 🤍

Alli Beachy 🤍

284 likes

A promotional image for 'Practical Magic' featuring Nicole Kidman and Sandra Bullock, with text overlay 'BOOKS FOR THE WOMEN OF PRACTICAL MAGIC + plus a special bonus'.
Sandra Bullock as Sally Owens, with a character description and five book covers including 'The Inheritance of Orquídea Divina' and 'A Ghost In The Throat', recommended for her personality.
Nicole Kidman as Gillian Owens, with a character description and four book covers including 'Three Women' and 'Acts of Desperation', recommended for her wild spirit.
practical magic but make it literary
A character study in the Owens family! For Antonia and Kylie, I used their themes from the Book of Magic moreso than the movie since we really see the depth of their characters in the sequel. Vincent is Frances and Jet’s brother, also from the series (the Rules of Magic specifically, which I cheeki
Inara

Inara

424 likes

KB Magazine | A Faith-Based Digital Magazine
Discover KB Magazine – a Christian lifestyle digital magazine created for faith-filled women who love natural hair, self-care, and Kingdom entrepreneurship. Download our faith-based magazine for natural hair and self-care at karmasparadise.com #KBMagazine #karmasparadise #luxuryselfcare
Koach Kay Cole

Koach Kay Cole

3 likes

Debut Diaries: Literary Magazine Acceptance
Debut Diaries: Literary Magazine Acceptance & New Writing Projects This month: acceptance from fluorescentmagazine, collaboration with chaptore, and drafting a new gothic psychological short story. Documenting the publishing journey — literary magazines, creative partnerships, and buildin
Reagan Westerly

Reagan Westerly

4 likes

A grand library hall with ornate ceilings, long wooden tables, and numerous people reading and studying. The text overlay announces "Literary Lovers GUIDE TO New York City".
An ornate Victorian-era bar interior featuring a bronze statue holding a lamp, a marble bar, and patrons. Text highlights "Oscar Wilde" restaurant and "Pete's Tavern" as literary spots.
A cozy lounge with a lit fireplace, two red armchairs, and decorative artwork. An ornate chandelier hangs above. Text mentions Walt Whitman sites and the Chelsea Hotel, frequented by authors.
NYC guide for Literary lovers!
If you love literature, you’ll want to save these spots for your New York City trip! Oscar Wilde - this Victorian-era restaurant is themed after the Irish playwright! Pete's Tavern - historic pub where O Henry wrote Gift of the Magi The Hotel Chelsea - authors like Mark Twain,
Brooklyn Guide

Brooklyn Guide

190 likes

A bookstore display features numerous romance novels stacked on a table, with a prominent "Romance" sign. Bookshelves in the background are labeled "CLASSICS" and "Poetry, Drama, Literary Criticism," indicating a diverse literary selection.
A bookstore display showcases multiple copies of romance novels by Rachel Reid, including "COMMON GOAL" and "ROLE GAME." A canvas tote bag with "I Love Sports Romance" sits in front, with "YOUNG ADULT" shelves in the background.
A tall bookstore shelf displays various romance novels, organized "A-Z by Author." A sign at the top advertises a "MEMBERS EARN STAMPS" reward program, highlighting a wide selection of authors like Katee Robert and Rina Kent.
Dirty Thirty but make it literary. 📚🔥
Thirty books for turning thirty. Because what’s a milestone birthday without a dangerously large TBR? This is me romanticizing my life one bookstore trip at a time. Haul coming soon 👀 Happy Birthday to me. 🖤 #DirtyThirty #ThirtyBooksForThirty #BirthdayBookHaul #BookShoppingSpree
@PAGESANDPEACE96

@PAGESANDPEACE96

115 likes

How to Write a Book
Writing a book is a rewarding and challenging endeavor, and it can vary greatly depending on your goals and the genre you're working in. However, there are some general steps that can guide you through the process: 1. Define Your Purpose and Audience Purpose: Why are you writing the book? I
🤎JJ Howick🤎

🤎JJ Howick🤎

1350 likes

A bookshelf filled with old, dark-spined books. Overlay text reads "Ask your friends which literary genre you are" and "SWIPE". The Lemon8 logo and @stylingbykit handle are visible at the bottom.
A collage of nine images representing the 'Romance' genre, featuring couples, flowers, romantic text from a book, and a woman smiling while applying makeup. The word "Romance" is centered.
A collage of nine images representing the 'Fantasy' genre, including a dragon, castles, people in medieval attire, and enchanted forest scenes. The word "Fantasy" is centered.
ask your friends which literary genre you are 📚💕
which one are you? ❤️ -SAVE for reference and to send to your friends/family! @stylingbykit @Kit #books #booksoflemon8 #reading #aesthetic #stylingbykit
Kit

Kit

266 likes

A hand holds three books against a floral background, with text overlay "2024 literary fiction about siblings." The image highlights books focusing on sibling relationships for the year 2024.
A hand holds the pink book "Greta & Valdin" by Rebecca K Reilly. Text overlays indicate it "follows two messy siblings" and features "queer rep."
A hand holds the red book "Interesting Facts About Space" by Emily Austin. Text overlay states it's about "a woman connect[ing] with her half-siblings after her estranged father's death."
2024 sibling literary fiction
when I first made this post I was just going for 2024 literary fiction by women but then I realized they were all about sibling relationships! Bonus because G+V and Interesting Facts have queer rep ✨ These are all on my TBR but I’ve also heard good things so I’m excited to start them! #lemon8bo
bookrvws

bookrvws

84 likes

literary mysteries 🔎📚
I recently came across a funny/informative subreddit asking for "low-brow high-brow books", essentially meaning books that might otherwise qualify as literary fiction but contain a really compelling plot element that keeps you entertained while reading. I thought I would go one step further
bookrvws

bookrvws

67 likes

A person in a library, partially visible, with a collage of fantasy books like 'A Court of Thorns and Roses' and 'The Song of Achilles' around them, captioned 'I'm Mostly Her...'
A person at a desk looking at a laptop, with a collage of mystery and thriller books like 'Mexican Gothic' and 'Where the Crawdads Sing' around them, captioned 'and her...'
A person in a car reading a book, surrounded by a collage of romance and contemporary books such as 'Beach Read' and 'Funny Story', captioned 'Sometimes Even Her...'
My Literary DNA: Present and Past📚🧬
I'm mostly her, diving deep into fantasy, and all the epic worlds! But then there's also the her who gets completely lost in thrilling mysteries and historical sagas. And hey, sometimes I'm even her, curled up with a heartwarming romance or a poignant contemporary read! My shelves are a
✨️Morgan📚

✨️Morgan📚

50 likes

LITERARY FICTION YOU MUST READ
Literary fiction has quickly become one of my top fav genres!!! These 2 books are what I would say are my top 2 favorites so far 🩷 Big Swiss by Jen Beagin 🩷 Main character Greta works as a transcriber for a psychologist. She becomes infatuated with one of his patients and bumps into her in pub
KENNEDY ♡

KENNEDY ♡

65 likes

A magazine spread titled "This was one of my first Manhwa" features three manhwa covers: "The Color of Earth," "Chocolat," and "Uncomfortably Happily." The article discusses manhwa history, webtoons, and recommendations like "True Beauty" and "Bastard."
Manga Magazine
#manga #anime #manhwa #mangacollection #mangarecommendations
ElainaLovesManga

ElainaLovesManga

10 likes

Breaking Literary Boundaries
Breaking Literary Boundaries: A Creative Journey #breakingboundaries #creativity #storytelling #literature #culturedive
Trueluv’s Corner Ministry

Trueluv’s Corner Ministry

2 likes

A hand with red nail polish holds an open book, with pages blurred, against a white chunky knit blanket. Overlay text reads: "literary fiction lovers... this one is for you."
The front cover of Claire Lombardo's novel "Same As It Ever Was," featuring an illustration of houses, rests on a white knit blanket. Overlay text highlights themes like "betrayals" and "secrets."
The back cover of "Same As It Ever Was" by Claire Lombardo, showing the book's blurb and author photo, on a white knit blanket. Overlay text notes her other book was a "Reese Witherspoon Book Club Pick."
literary girlies — you need this book
Do you love Sally Rooney? Donna Tartt? Book club picks (especially Reese Witherspoon’s)? Family dramas? Character driven books? Then you need to mark your calendar for Claire Lombardo’s ‘Same As It Ever Was’   This book is THICK which always gets me excited. It tracks the potential disruption of
emmalouisebooks

emmalouisebooks

48 likes

An open book lies on a white bedsheet, with the text overlay "I can't wait Literary fiction to read in 2025." The bottom left corner shows "lemon8 @literature.and.lace."
The book cover for 'Gliff by Ali Smith' features a black horse-like creature on a green background. A plot summary describes an uncertain near-future with new boundaries, two children, and a horse.
The book cover for 'The Dream Hotel by Laila Lalami' is purple with an orange doorway. A plot summary details Sara being accused of a future crime based on dream data by the Risk Assessment Administration.
New Literary Fiction I ✨HAVE✨ to read this year 📚
You know it’s going to be a good reading year when there’s a new Ali Smith coming out. I actually didn’t read a ton of literary fiction in 2024, which was really out of the norm for me, but this year I’m ready to dive back in. Pub dates for all five books: 1. Gliff by Ali Smith is out 2/6 2. T
Laci Durham

Laci Durham

22 likes

A wide shot of a book aisle at Walmart, featuring shelves filled with various books. A blue sign in the foreground advertises 'CHEAP BOOKS AT WALMART' for '$11.98', with a 'SWIPE' prompt.
A hand holds a red edition of 'THE BROTHERS GRIMM 101 FAIRY TALES'. The cover is adorned with words and phrases related to the stories, and the book features red sprayed edges.
A hand holds an orange edition of 'LITTLE WOMEN' by Louisa May Alcott. The cover is decorated with quotes and character names from the novel, and the book has purple sprayed edges.
These Literary Classics Are Only How much??!📚
All of these books are only 11.98 at Walmart right now! Im sorry about the sub par pictures😩 I had a group of teenage boys kicking balls down the isle into me. I was trying to hurry while also not giving them the attention they clearly so desperately needed. When my fiancé came back over to where
✨️Morgan📚

✨️Morgan📚

63 likes

A person with braided hair smiles, with text overlay "VAMPIRE book recs (that aren't twilight) part 2!!" and emojis of a blood drop and an open book.
A hand holds the book "Woman, Eating" by Claire Kohda, featuring a biracial vampire seeking connection. Text highlights it as an original vampire novel and a best book of the year.
A hand holds the book "A Long Time Dead" by Samara Breger, described as a sapphic tale of a plus-sized sex worker turned vampire and her found family.
even MORE literary vampire books 🤭🫶🏾
PART 2!!!! Definitely go back and look at my part 1 for some of my favorite adult vampire stories if you haven’t seen it yet. Here are two more I love! The writing in both of these stories is very literary and the authors explore deeper themes. Woman, Eating is my personal fave of these -
aubrei

aubrei

89 likes

Todays Vintage Magazine Companion
How long has spicy meant sexy in the literary world? I'm not sure but it dates back to at least 1934 when Spicy Detective was first published! Todays Vintage Magazine Companion is Spicy Detective Magazine from June of 1942 as published by Culture Publishing, owned and operated by Harry Donenf
Claire E Moss

Claire E Moss

2 likes

literary spring🌷
#cottagecorebook #springbooks #booktok #bookrec #literaryfiction
Rachel🫶🏻📚

Rachel🫶🏻📚

103 likes

A vintage black typewriter sits on a wooden desk below a bookshelf filled with books, many with Italian and Japanese themes. Overlay text reads 'Florence Literary Society LAUNCH PARTY FINDING COMMUNITY ITALY', highlighting the society's goal to unite writers.
Florence Literary Society
📚 Discovering the Florence Literary Society 🌍✍️ I attended a fascinating gathering hosted by the Florence Literary Society, and it felt like stepping into a dream for writers of all genres and levels. Whether you’re a poet, novelist, translator, or even just starting to dabble in writing, this g
thenomadicquill

thenomadicquill

3 likes

The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society
#xocinnamon💋 #onthisday October 9, 2021 REWIND The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society - Juliet Ashton #fyp #movie #tiktokviralvideo
TheOneRealCinnamon

TheOneRealCinnamon

1 like

A person in a brown tank top and beige corduroy pants holds the book "Big Swiss" by Jen Beagin. The cover features an upside-down woman with yellow text. The person has light pink nail polish and a ring on their left hand.
A close-up of a page from the book "Big Swiss" with highlighted text. Overlays explain the premise: a woman transcribes sex therapy sessions, falls for a patient she's never met, and the text emphasizes "this is not a drill."
The cover of the book "Big Swiss" by Jen Beagin, surrounded by descriptive phrases. These include "queer, messy, fascinating dynamics," "offbeat humor + emotional gut punches," "unreliable narrator energy," and "no traditional structure... and I loved that."
My ideal genre is weird girl literary chaos
alert: i’ve entered my ideal genre zone and it’s weird girl literary chaos Big Swiss by Jen Beagin 🧠💔 This book is in that sweet spot of “what did I just read” and “why do I relate?” It’s messy. It’s strange. It’s 100% character-driven. And honestly? That’s my ideal genre zone. The stor
Meredith Jao

Meredith Jao

21 likes

🐝 little literary lineup
-a moment to share a current read, cozy drink, & a simple bite- 📚 Great Big Beautiful Life [Emily Henry] 🫖 english breakfast tea 🥯 everything bagel ⭐️Overall rating: in progress/10 (TBD) ⭐️ What are you reading? #booksandfood #readwithme #homemaker #littleliterarylineup #m
The Gentle Bea

The Gentle Bea

11 likes

A hand holds a book in front of a bookshelf filled with various titles. An overlay asks, "want to violently sob?" with a crying emoji, suggesting a book that evokes strong emotions.
The front cover of the book "The Death of Vivek Oji" by Akwaeke Emezi, featuring abstract art. Text overlays describe it as "literary fiction" that "explores identity, love, and family."
The back cover of "The Death of Vivek Oji" by Akwaeke Emezi, displaying book reviews and author information. A quote about dying in the arms of a loved one, "wearing a skin that was true," is highlighted.
if you want a book that will crush your heart …
if you want to HURT, pick up the death of vivek oji by one of my favorite (if not my very favorite) authors, akwaeke emezi. it uses a non-linear timeline to follow the thread of young vivek’s life, watching him grow up and the grief that follows after his death. it’s absolutely beautiful.
Steph 📚💫

Steph 📚💫

105 likes

Another literary piece from my youth
#mypoems #poetry
Draksong

Draksong

10 likes

6 star literary reads
stunning. speechless. perfection. #booktok #literaryfiction #bookrecommendations
emmalouisebooks

emmalouisebooks

60 likes

A vibrant cityscape with colorful buildings lining a waterfront under a dramatic sky, likely Stockholm. Overlay text announces, "i JUST GOT PUBLISHED IN SWEDEN!!!" An arrow points right, with Lemon8 branding at the bottom.
I’m sooo excited to debut my writing in Sweden!
Stockholm University reached out this week asking if they could publish my poetry in their literary journal, Two Thirds North. 📚💛 This is the first time my work will be featured in Sweden so I’m excited!! They just emailed me the galley today to sign off on. AMA about the process of publish
The Quiet Alchemist Podcast

The Quiet Alchemist Podcast

31 likes

A flat lay of favorite items including book boxes (OwlCrate, Illumicrate), books by Rebecca Ross, a brown backpack, a beige crossbody bag, a tablet, pink lip products, an AirPods case, and Olipop. Text overlay reads 'my fave things as a literary homebody '23 edition'.
Literary Homebody-My Fave Things of 2023
✨My Favorite Things From 2023!✨ I discovered so many products last year (mostly thanks to being influenced by #lemon8 + bookstagram😂) Let’s go over my favorites! • Book subscription boxes! Im so grateful for the opportunity to have received many different subscription boxes. I recieved boxe
Kat 📚☕️🍰

Kat 📚☕️🍰

125 likes

Literary Fiction🫶
Some of my favorite literary fiction books❤️🫶🏻 #books 🫶🏼 #reading📖 #literaryfiction #bookrecommendations #bookaesthetic
Rachel🫶🏻📚

Rachel🫶🏻📚

8 likes

EyeCU Literary Experience Haul 📚
My book haul from EyeCU Literary Experience. #bookhaul #eyecureadingexperience #eyeculit #blackauthors #blackgirllemon8
KEEWEEZY

KEEWEEZY

23 likes

oh, you think you don’t like literary fiction?
guarantee these books will change your mind about literary fiction if you think you don’t like it #books #booktok #literaryficiton #bookrecs
emmalouisebooks

emmalouisebooks

34 likes

See more